Hitler ordered Luftwaffe to spare Blackpool

fijiman said:
I recently read "The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich". Although it is long (1000 pages) it is an absolutely engrossing chronicle of Hitler's rise and fall.

Engrossing, yes. But it's also woefully out of date. It's what, 40 years old now?

There's been a HUGE amount of studies and analysis done since that book came out.

Some of the broad strokes may be true, but when you start delving more deeply there's a lot more to the story.
 
Rockslinger said:
...the Loony Liberal Left say that bombing Germany in WW II is a war crime. Did anybody expect them to say anything positive about the West?

You should do your homework. Most scholars will tell you the strategic bombing campaign late in the war was questionable. Was it a war crime? Arguably. And here I'm talking about late in the war when the race for Berlin was well under way.

As for the Loony Liberal Left, again, check your sources. By 1944-1945 even the American and British general public (and Eisenhower himself) were beginning to question the necessity of continued strategic bombing against Germany--especially against German cities that didn't have military or strategic value. By the end of the war the Americans and British were wiping out German cities as a show of strength and intimidation against the Soviets rather than for some strategic value against the Germans.

p.s., a little lesson for you. When people run around calling people "loony liberals" or "conservative racists" or whatever political bashing you want to use, it just makes you look ignorant and biased. Win your arguments with facts and reason. Calling someone a "loony liberal" just tells people to discredit whatever comes out of your mouth next.
 
Keebler Elf said:
Saying the non-Soviet Allies played no major role in WWII is just as inaccurate as saying the Americans or British "turned the tide" against Germany.

Although the Soviets did the heavy lifting, could they alone have defeated the Nazis (without the contributions from the U.S. and the Brits, however large or meager)? Let's use Waterloo as an example. Wellington was either barely winning or actually losing the battle at Waterloo when the Prussians finally made their appearance late in the day and "tip the scale" in favour of Wellington. At the very least, the U.S. and the Brits "tip the scale" and that allowed the Soviets to defeat the Nazis.
 
Rockslinger said:
Although the Soviets did the heavy lifting, could they alone have defeated the Nazis (without the contributions from the U.S. and the Brits, however large or meager)? Let's use Waterloo as an example. Wellington was either barely winning or actually losing the battle at Waterloo when the Prussians finally made their appearance late in the day and "tip the scale" in favour of Wellington. At the very least, the U.S. and the Brits "tip the scale" and that allowed the Soviets to defeat the Nazis.

The Russians had no chance in hell to beat the Germans alone. Only the Amreicans could have. Don't forget the Americans were quite busy in the Pacific as well.

The Russians succeeded only due to the harsh winter conditions and by sheer numbers. It's always easier to defend than attack. The Germans' Railway supply lines were constantly attacked by numerous Partisan groups. Never mind that the German forces were stretched across Europe and North Africa.

Had the Germans kept Russia as an ally when they originally attacked Poland, they could possibly have ruled the world or at least Europe and Asia. Scary....
 
Keebler Elf said:
True, though subsequent studies have shown that there might have been more to the German defeat than Soviet superiority. The northern German pincer made no progress at all but the southern pincer had broken through most of the Soviet defenses (granted, at enormous cost) and the German generals believed that a little more push would have won the day. However, Allied landings in Sicily at the same time diverted German forces and forced the Germans to end the battle.

The biggest mistake the Germans made was attacking a position where the Soviets knew they were coming and prepared accordingly. The Soviets packed so many mines and anti-tanks guns into such small areas that they were literally running out of room.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_kursk

The German generals said a bunch of things in their memoirs about how they "almost" won the war. In fact, the Soviets had massive reinforcements lined up and the southern pincer would never have broken through.

The Soviets were so superior at that point that they were launching offensives elsewhere along the front while holding the Germans back at Kursk.

The Germans probably attacked the Kursk salient because they had no other options for winning the war in 1943. The Soviets had attrited them down so badly in 41 and 42 that the Germans could no longer launch a wide front offensive as in former years. The Kursk salient was a bulge that was packed with Soviets troops and equipment and the thinking was that if the Germans cut off the bulge, they would finally wreck the Soviet army to the point it could no longer hold. The Wehrmacht had always succeeded in breaking through set defences in the past and the Germans arrogantly thought that they could do so again regardless of the Soviet preparations.
 
Well, the Soviets DID beat the GErmans alone without the Allies. Kursk took place in summer 1943. From that time onwards, the GErmans were fucked and the Soviets beat them every time they fought. By early fall, the Soviets were at the Dneiper - a huge advance. They liberated Kiev in November IIRC. By the following March, they were at the Romanian border. The Germans were taking shit-kicking after shit-kicking and could no longer launch their own offensives.

The Allies tied down 2 German armies in Italy during this time. The Allies did not invade in Normandy until June 44. The Soviets were clerly superior in the East at this point and the Germans were already in a hopeless position. In July 44, the Soviets destroyed - as in DESTROYED - 2 German army groups - that is groups of several GErman armies. By September 1944, the Germans were fighting in mid Poland and around Budapest.
 
Keebler Elf said:
Not really, if at all.

Overall, German armour was superior to the Soviets. The Soviets had some standouts such as the T-34 and its later heavy and super heavy assault guns, but overall German armour was technically superior. The Soviets had no tanks that could stand up to the Tigers and King Tigers. Yes, they had some assault guns later in the war with super heavy frontal armour and large caliber guns, but the Germans still destroyed them at a much higher kill ratio.

The T-34 is always brought up as an example of excellent Soviet tank design, which is true but the Germans quickly copied many of the T-34 design elements (widely spaced tracks and sloped armour being the most significant) and the Panther, Tiger, and King Tiger easily outclassed the T-34. When the T-34 was upgraded to the T-34/85 it became more of a threat but by that time the T-34 was nothing more than cannon fodder. In short, the T-34 was rapidly outclassed by subsequent German tank designs.

Assault guns (aka self-propelled anti-tank guns) weren't really tanks per se though they were similar. Throughout much of the war German assault guns (usually built on captured Allied tank chassis' or outdated German tank chassis') were superior to Soviet assault guns. Only at the end of the war did the Soviets have super heavy assault guns that required Tigers and King Tigers (or the German "jagr"/hunter assault gun equivalents) to take out.

Bottom line, if someone tells you Soviet armour was superior to the Germans overall, they don't know what they're talking about. In certain instances that may have been true (e.g., in 1941 when the T-34 first made its appearance on the road to Moscow), but overall German armoured forces decimated Soviet armour. What made the Soviets ultimately successful wasn't quality, it was quantity. When you can absorb a kill ratio of 10:1 or even as high as 20:1 in some instances, the saying "quantity has a quality all its own" holds very true. Which is typical of most analysis between German and Soviet armed forces during WWII. The major fault of German armour wasn't killing power, armour, or mobility but other factors such as being rushed into service, over designed, lack of tank recovery vehicles, being used in inappropriate roles (i.e., as defensive weapons rather than offensive), etc. But their core function performance was second to none.

All that being said, Soviet armour was still far superior to anything the Americans and Brits had (e.g., the Sherman was a joke and even the Firefly variant was extremely vulnerable to destruction at even long range; British armour design was a mess throughout the war).

If you're looking for an excellent resource on German Tiger tanks, get this book. Lots of statistics, including some shocking kill ratio data. It's an unbiased, academic study of the Tiger tank and sheds some light on the strengths and weaknesses of German armoured warfare: http://www.amazon.ca/Sledgehammers-...=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1235538292&sr=8-2

See attached link for correction.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IS-2_heavy_tank

Like the Sherman, the T-34 constituted a choice to make a simple, reasonable quality tank in large numbers. The Germans chose to make smaller numbers of very, large powerful tanks...... and look what happened in the end.

There's a story about a parade in occupied Germany in late 45. A GErman mother is standing with her small son watching a parade of Shermans down what was left of a main street in the Us occupied zone. Standing next to them is a GI (who must have know some German, I guess). The kid pipes up "German tanks are bigger and better."

The GI smiles and says "Kid, if German tanks were so much bigger and better, why the hell aren't they the ones doing the parade?"
 
james t kirk said:
Yup.

Kursk made D-day look like a Tea Party (no disrespect intended).

A million Russians squared off against a million Germans. Neither side took prisoners.

At the end of the day a few thousand Russians were still standing.

The Western Allies let the Russians and Germans duke it out and wear each other down. Stalin was screaming for a second front but he only got it when it looked like the Russians might march clear across Europe to the English channel.



I'll accept the no disrepect qualifier, but from the few anecdotes Dad related of that early morning beach trip in June, Normandy was no "picnic" by any stretch. The Day itself was brutal , but was only a precursor to the carnage to come as once inland the standard mortality tables ( Hobbes i think they were) that the Army used for combat modelling needed a never before used Double Intense rating. The life expectancy of an ordinary rifleman dropped to one week.


Also don't forget that for a relatively small pop base Britain was more than a smidge occupied with fighting the japs on the sub-continent. Of the main combattants at play of the european Jap and yanks, Great Britain had the smallest population.


Lets also not forget the countless thousands of naval crew from the RN and RCN that lost their lives on the horrible convoy runs taking supplies to the Russians.


.
 
Rockslinger said:
Although the Soviets did the heavy lifting, could they alone have defeated the Nazis (without the contributions from the U.S. and the Brits, however large or meager)? Let's use Waterloo as an example. Wellington was either barely winning or actually losing the battle at Waterloo when the Prussians finally made their appearance late in the day and "tip the scale" in favour of Wellington. At the very least, the U.S. and the Brits "tip the scale" and that allowed the Soviets to defeat the Nazis.

The Waterloo example isn't a good one and you make incorrect assumptions.

Germany was fighting a war on 2 fronts without the manpower or resources to sustain it. Because they failed to take Stalingrad (or the Soviet Union) their fate was sealed.

You may not consider the western campaign as heavy lifting but those still alive who survived Normandy may disagree with you. Also, Other countries aside form the U.S. and G.B. palyed a significant role on the western front, Canada being one of them.

It is often incorrectly assumed that the Soviets beat the Germans back with pithforks and antiquated equipment and that they won battles strictly because of their numbers. New Soviet tanks with sloped armour and wide tracks were better equipped and designed for the environment. Also, Soviet tanks and planes were designed to be easily maintained on the battlefield (unlike their German counterparts). Factor in the numbers being produced and Germany was doomed.

Therefore, it can be concluded that a major contributing factor to the Soviet's success was the fact they out-engineered the Germans. As strange as that may sound.
 
Keebler Elf said:
Bottom line, if someone tells you Soviet armour was superior to the Germans overall, they don't know what they're talking about. In certain instances that may have been true (e.g., in 1941 when the T-34 first made its appearance on the road to Moscow), but overall German armoured forces decimated Soviet armour. What made the Soviets ultimately successful wasn't quality, it was quantity. When you can absorb a kill ratio of 10:1 or even as high as 20:1 in some instances, the saying "quantity has a quality all its own" holds very true. Which is typical of most analysis between German and Soviet armed forces during WWII. The major fault of German armour wasn't killing power, armour, or mobility but other factors such as being rushed into service, over designed, lack of tank recovery vehicles, being used in inappropriate roles (i.e., as defensive weapons rather than offensive), etc. But their core function performance was second to none.

German equipment was better built but not necessarily better engineered (at least not for the environment on the eastern front).

The genius of Soviet design was in it's simplicity. Yes, they had a 10:1 quantity ratio but if you factor in ease of maintenance and repair, it gave the Soviets even more of an advantage (for example, it took German maintenance crews a full day to change a tank's tracks where the Soviets could do the same in an hour or two). This committment to design by interchangability and ease of maintenance carried right through into the design of the Mig-29.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
German equipment was better built but not necessarily better engineered (at least not for the environment on the eastern front).

The genius of Soviet design was in it's simplicity. Yes, they had a 10:1 quantity ratio but if you factor in ease of maintenance and repair, it gave the Soviets even more of an advantage (for example, it took German maintenance crews a full day to change a tank's tracks where the Soviets could do the same in an hour or two). This committment to design by interchangability and ease of maintenance carried right through into the design of the Mig-29.



Same with automatic weapons. The hun machine pistols and infantry autos were perfectly made things of beauty, but they didn't like mud and cold.


Our Sten gun was a mass produced stamped piece of crap by comparison , but its simple action worked and was easily serviced. The style survived to become the SMG that so many of us enjoyed in the '60's.



.
 
Balderdash, World War 2 started on December 7, 1941 after which America fought alone in a titanic struggle against Hitler who controlled the entire World except the Arsenal of Democracy and Little Britain.

EU
 
The Houdini said:
The Germans' Railway supply lines were constantly attacked by numerous Partisan groups.

The Germans didn't realize until they were actually in Russia that German railcars were incompatible with Russian railtracks because they were a different size. Also, Russian dirt roads were straight out of the 18th century (no modern paved highways) and became a muddy mess in rainy conditions.
 
The Houdini said:
The Russians had no chance in hell to beat the Germans alone. Only the Amreicans could have. Don't forget the Americans were quite busy in the Pacific as well.

That's quite ignorant of the facts.

I'll leave it at that.
 
Rockslinger said:
Although the Soviets did the heavy lifting, could they alone have defeated the Nazis (without the contributions from the U.S. and the Brits, however large or meager)?

We'll never know for sure but quite probably. They beat 85% of the German armed forces. Would an additional 15% have tipped the balance? Maybe. Or maybe it just would have extended the war another year.
 
oagre said:

Correction to your correction.

Inferior to the German heavy tanks for one simple reason: it took too damn long to load the two-piece ammunition. They'd be blown apart long before they could reload for a second shot.

On the whole, German tanks were superior. As I have already indicated.

The masses of Soviet tanks were not IS-2's. Just like the masses of German tanks were not King Tigers.
 
Keebler Elf said:
That's quite ignorant of the facts.

I'll leave it at that.

The Russians had dick on a stick. They rationed bullets to soldiers. In fact half the soldiers didn't even have guns, they had to wait for some comrade to die on the battlefield to grab his weapon.

They survived by sheer numbers and the knowledge that if they deserted the'd be executed. Their tanks sucked, their planes sucked. At the end the Germans literally ran out of supplies and spare parts to fix their equipment. And slowly lost tens of thousands of men to the brutal cold.

I guess that's all ignorant.
 
The Houdini said:
They survived by sheer numbers and the knowledge that if they deserted the'd be executed. Their tanks sucked, their planes sucked.

Not so sure this is entirely true. Towards the latter stages of the war, the Red Army attacked the Japanese Imperial Army in Manchuria and literally annihilated them.

We keep talking about the "quantity" of Russian manpower. Just how many men (and women) in uniform did they have? Surely, they did not have unlimited manpower. Wasn't the population of Russia only twice that of Germany at the begging of the war?
 
Rockslinger said:
Not so sure this is entirely true. Towards the latter stages of the war, the Red Army attacked the Japanese Imperial Army in Manchuria and literally annihilated them.

We keep talking about the "quantity" of Russian manpower. Just how many men (and women) in uniform did they have? Surely, they did not have unlimited manpower. Wasn't the population of Russia only twice that of Germany at the begging of the war?

Russia was and still is the largest country in the world. They lost more soldiers than any other country in WW2. They lost half a million soldiers and civilians (mostly soldiers) in Stalingrad alone. There were over a million Russian soldiers fighting the German 6th army by the time the Germans capitulated in 1943.
 
The Houdini said:
The Russians had dick on a stick. They rationed bullets to soldiers. In fact half the soldiers didn't even have guns, they had to wait for some comrade to die on the battlefield to grab his weapon.

They survived by sheer numbers and the knowledge that if they deserted the'd be executed. Their tanks sucked, their planes sucked. At the end the Germans literally ran out of supplies and spare parts to fix their equipment. And slowly lost tens of thousands of men to the brutal cold.

I guess that's all ignorant.

Call of Duty isn't a history lesson.

(This is a joke...)