greatest overall baseball player all time

Taken from an article by Brian Gjurgevich .....

I love "greatest ever" arguments -- like any other great debate, everyone has their opinion, but nobody has the answer, because the answer doesn't really exist.

Bonds hit his 661st career home run the other night, surpassing legend and fellow "greatest ever" candidate Willie Mays for third on the all-time list. Bonds now looks up at baseball immortals Babe Ruth and Hank Aaron in his quest to be the all-time home run king -- arguably (like everything else) the greatest title in all of sports.

Now, the man's resume should read nicely when his playing days are over -- at least six MVPs (he should have at least eight), at least eight gold gloves and the title of the most dominant offensive force of his generation.

But does that make him the best ever?

Well, if you equate dominance with greatness, then sure.

But, to me, domination and overall greatness are two different birds. he is definitely the most feared presence in the game today, often raising the question, "why in the hell would you pitch to him?"

When the man is dialed in, as he so often is, he has the ability to hit any pitch that goes over the plate 500 feet in the opposite direction.

Yes, that makes him macho as hell, but "the greatest ever?"

Hold the phone.

I wouldn't even say that Barry Bonds is the greatest player playing today.

He is certainly up there, but I would venture to say that a guy like Alex Rodriguez or even Ichiro Suzuki is a better all-around ballplayer.

Then again, greatness is not measured in skills, tools, or reputation.

To me, greatness is found in how one fits into the game and the era they play in, and most importantly, whether or not they transcend that game and that era.

Bonds' numbers are staggering, yes, but looking through the scope of the game as it is today, they are not all that remarkable.

Throughout baseball history, there have been three men (now four) that have hit over 600 home runs. An impressive feat.

But, if you take a closer look, there are currently a dozen players who could reach 600 in the next decade, if they continue to put up numbers on par with their career averages.

You can venture a guess as to why this has happened (steroids, bad pitching, expansion, smaller ballparks) but the fact is, getting to 600, even 700, is not the accomplishment it had formally been.

Just like hitting 30 or 40 or 50 or 60 home runs in a season isn't the mark of excellence it once was.

Will Gary Sheffield be considered one of the greatest when he gets to 600? How about Rafael Palmiero? Or Frank Thomas? Or Juan Gonzalez, Manny Ramirez, Ken Griffey Jr. or Jim Thome?

All great ballplayers, even Hall of Famers, in their own right, but among the greatest? Not necessarily.

Times have changed, and so has the game of baseball.
 
Yeah, excellent post.

As for the "why would you pitch to him at all" argument, I remember Bill James once running a statistical study looking at Babe Ruth in his finest year (even juiced up a little bit) surrounded by the pansiest hitting position players you can imagine. He ran two seasons - in one, Ruth was walked EVERY TIME UP. In the other, he was pitched to in a more "normal" fashion - still walked plenty, obviously. The results? Not even close - walking Ruth every time up was a bad strategy for the defense.
The conclusion? You should pitch to Bonds. ..... Most of the time. ;)

Anyway, cross-era comparisons are perfectly fine in baseball - you just have to adjust for the numbers average players are putting up (and for park factors, as always). So, no, homerun totals from this season can't be compared, without adjustment, with homerun totals from the 70's.

That having been said, there are lots of truly great players playing baseball right now, lots of players *among the greatest of all time* at their positions. Even, perhaps, the greatest ever. Arguably.

But, yes, that's why these arguments are fun.
 
Don't you mean "Mulliniorg"? Surely, the greatest two-headed player I've ever seen!
:)
 
My Dream Team (league listed when not MLB)

C- Josh Gibson (Negro League)
1B- Gehrig
2B- Hornsby
SS- Ripken
3B- Schmidt
OF- Bonds
OF- S. Oh (Japan)
OF- Mays
DH- Ruth

RHP- Paige(Negro), Ryan
LHP- Koufax, Spahn

Pen- Fingers, Eck, Gossage

Manager- Casey Stengal
 
Ranger68 said:
Don't you mean "Mulliniorg"? Surely, the greatest two-headed player I've ever seen!
:)

LOL.....one of 2 two-headed players the Jays had.
The other was BuckWhitt.
Remember him??
 
lists! i love lists!

Alright lets see....
According to batting order and some stats....my dream team

Batting first....

BA slg% H HR RBI
2B - Roger Hornsby .358 .577 2930 301 1584
SS - Honus Wagner .327 .466 3415 101 1732
CF - Hank Arron .305 .555 3771 755 2297
RF - Babe Ruth .342 .690 2873 714 2213
1B - Lou Gehrig .340 .632 2721 493 1995
LF - Ted Williams .344 .632 2654 521 1839
3B - Mike Schmidt .267 .527 2234 548 1595
C - Johnny Bench .267 .476 2048 389 1376

on the bench - Frank Robinson 2B / OF, Stan Musial 1B / OF and Cal Ripken SS/ 3B / DH (i like Ripken and Robinson as starters, but; in this line up Wagners ability to get on base overrides both Ripkens power from the left and Robinsons speed IMHO)

My pitchers....
W-L ERA CG SO BB
Denton "CY" Young 511-316 2.63 749 2803 1217
Walter Johnson 417-279 2.17 531 3509 1363
Christy Mathewson 373-188 2.13 434 2502 844
Pack "Bob" Gibson 251-174 2.91 255 3117 1336
Warren Spahn (L) 363-245 3.09 382 2583 1434

My bullpen......

mid reliever right - Grover Cleveland Alexander
373-208 2.56 437 2198 951
dominant shut down pitcher...wicked curve and devastating slider- hardly ever walked batters amazing control.
mid relif lefty - Robert Moses "lefty" Grove
300-141 3.06 298 2266 1187
hard throwing lefty....elusive control- killer cuve to both sides of the plate
closer.....
Dennis Lee Eckersley 197-171 390 SV 3.50 100 2401 738
with the game on the line - nobody was better....ever

I'm a big Ryan Express fan, but; he had lousy control at times and had a propensity for beaning batters.lol

But if I could have 2 more pitchers....Ryan and the "Rocket"
 
They say that Walter Johnson threw the hardest of all of them.
He basically competed with just 1 pitch, his fastball.
No curve, slider or changeups.

I think its amazing these guys can throw so hard, my fastball was once clocked at a whopping 70 MPH.
And the only way I could get the ball to curve is through gravity.
 
The skinny on Johnson being a one ball fast ball pitcher was true.

But....he had excellent command of that one pich - high low...in out. Unlike Ryan he didn't bean too many guys in the process.
Thats why on the list...I had him starting on the second spot in the rotation.lol.
 
Good lineup healer. A couple of points.

I think it's hard to leave Sandy Koufax out as a starter. He was the most dominating pitcher, for sure for his era and arguably of all time. Granted he doesn't have the lifetime stats of many others such as Cy Young due to an injury-shortened career, but he was more dominant than Gibson during their common era. He was virtually unhittable. He had 3 or 4 of the best years in history of any pitcher in terms of W-L, ERA and strikeouts with very, very few walks. It's sort of like putting Bourque and Coffey ahead of Orr because they have better lifetime stats.

Also, as much as I don't really like him and unless all his stats are asterisked for steroids you've probably got to find room for Bonds. He's not even finished compiling his stats and I suspect he was better defensively than either Aaron or Williams (# of Gold Gloves) and probably stole more bases as well (I haven't checked any stats book). As such I'd probably put him ahead of Williams. He's obviously better than Ruth was in those areas as well, but Ruth's offensive numbers were so incredibly far ahead of anyone else of his era, he has to be considered the best outfielder of all time.
 
I'll go for Willie Mays. If we could somehow extract votes from all of these posts and add them up, it would appear that he would win.
 
johnnyhandsome said:
Iorg had blinding speed, could hit towering homeruns, had massive biceps and always hit over .300.
A shoe-in for the hall of fame if I've ever seen one.

yeah but he was no lloyd mosely
 
Ken Griffey.

The pre-trade Ken Griffey. For almost 10 years in Seattle, Ken Griffey looked like the best player in baseball.
Since the trade to Cincinnati, he doesn't even look like their best centre fielder. :(
 
I'm not sure if there is such a thing as the "greatest overall baseball player of all time" because the game has changed so much. Back when Ruth played, as has been pointed out, there was no West Coast travel, night games, relief specialists, or most importantly, black players. Today, you have pitching diluted by expansion, better conditioning and equipment, and of course, performance enhancing drugs. I think the best you can do is pick a greatest player from each era.

For me, they would be:

Pre-1947 - Babe Ruth
1948-1977 - Willie Mays
1977-present - Barry Bonds

Supposedly, back during WWII, Japanese soldiers would try to insult American soldiers by saying "Fuck Babe Ruth". Whether or not that is true, it does have a ring of plausibility to it. Do you think it would remotely plausible that Iraqi soldiers would be saying "Fuck Barry Bonds"?

And red, it was Lloyd Moseby. If you're going to make a joke, at least get the freaking name right.
 
Excellent points, homonger. As much as Sabrmetrics allows for cross-era comparisons, there are some things it's just hard to allow for. And I think I'd agree with all your picks. Lemme think about Willie Mays, though. ;)