greatest overall baseball player all time

I've read tons about Shoeless Joe, and it's my opinion (well, not only mine, but I agree with it) that he was CERTAINLY in collusion. Perhaps he didn't go in to the extent that others did, but he was definitely in on the fix. You don't get into the Hall just on batting average, but by numbers, ignoring off-field activities, he belongs in the Hall certainly. This doesn't make him the best player of all time - not even close.

And, I think those two should stay out of the Hall. Period.
 
Bonds all round for sure

Can run, hit (average & power) and good defensively.

I know the knock against him is the 'Roid issue but that is baseball's problem not his. It ain't cheating if it ain't against the rules or if you don't get caught.

Besides even if you used the CCES(Canadian Centre for Ethics in Sport) guidelines, the Babe, Rose and Mick could have both tested positive for a number of sitimulates.
 
You guys can say that Ruth was the greatest hitter alltime which may be true but the thread's question was "who was/is the greates OVERALL player". Willie Mays could run circles around Ruth and Babe Ruth was never considered an excellent fielder as strong as his throwing arm was.

My vote has to go to Mays.
 
Have to wonder what the Babe could have accomplished if he had made even the slightest effort at conditioning.
Playing hung over, existing on beer, hot dogs and cigars?
How about the Babe hitting the weight room, running a few miles a day in the off season, eating a low fat diet and drinking in moderation.
 
Greatest baseball player of all time

Pat Borders
 
I thought the question was who was the greatest ALL AROUND player. This being the case you have to make room for Robbie Alomar. Even though I lost complete repect for him after he left T.O. and spit in the umps face, from a baseball point of view he hit really well, fielded as good or better than any player before or after him, heck he understood the game so well he used to pick off signs and give them to his pitcher. Lets also mention he stole bases and ran the bases with the best of them.
 
johnnyhandsome said:
You guys can say that Ruth was the greatest hitter alltime which may be true but the thread's question was "who was/is the greates OVERALL player". Willie Mays could run circles around Ruth and Babe Ruth was never considered an excellent fielder as strong as his throwing arm was.

My vote has to go to Mays.

Okay, what do you mean by "greatest overall player"?
'Cause, if it's the player who meant the most to his team, who contributed the most to his team's success, it's Ruth.
If it's something else, what is that?
 
luv2fress said:
I thought the question was who was the greatest ALL AROUND player. This being the case you have to make room for Robbie Alomar. Even though I lost complete repect for him after he left T.O. and spit in the umps face, from a baseball point of view he hit really well, fielded as good or better than any player before or after him, heck he understood the game so well he used to pick off signs and give them to his pitcher. Lets also mention he stole bases and ran the bases with the best of them.

ACK! Alomar was (is) very overrated defensively. I think there's very little to back up your statement about his defensive prowess. He might not even make the list of 10 best second basemen in history, overall.
 
Ranger68 said:
Okay, what do you mean by "greatest overall player"?
'Cause, if it's the player who meant the most to his team, who contributed the most to his team's success, it's Ruth.
If it's something else, what is that?

When people judge ballplayers they look at 5 different tools:

1. Throwing arm strenght
2. Running speed
3. Hit for power
4. Hit for average
5. Defensive abilities (range, positioning, least errors...etc..etc)

Willie Mays was among the best in ALL 5 categories.

Babe Ruth didnt have his speed
Pete Rose couldnt hit homeruns
 
Best basebal player?
That would be the kid in park who plays because he likes to play and has fun.
All of these so called "professionals" are nothing but crybabies who whine about making their 45 Million a year and not getting that Pepsi endorsement.
 
1) Ted Williams. He missed three or four seasons in his prime. He was 6'5" but was skinny at 185lbs. He was the last one to have a 400 avg. and he hit over 500 homers when it was hard to do. If you put him on steroids and HGH like today’s baseball players with his eyesight and eye-hand coordination he would probably have the best OBP ever (because he was so disciplined and would be so feared) and I bet he could knock more than 72 homers in a season. Realistically those production numbers are the most important stats for a baseball player b/c they help your team win the most and they influence the other numbers (i.e. RBI's, runs) which win ballgames. Ted Williams was a very good fielder and was fast.


2) Barry Bonds. His numbers speak for themselves and in his prime he was a damn good fielder too. One can only imagine what his numbers would be like if he was juiced for his whole career.
 
I have to say we should give consideration to Hank Aaron!

.305 Career Batting Average

All-time home run leader: 755.
All-time games played: 3,298.
All-time at-bats leader: 12,364.
All-time RBI leader: 2,297.
All-time total bases leader: 6,856.
All-time extra-base hits leader: 1,477
 
johnnyhandsome said:
When people judge ballplayers they look at 5 different tools:

1. Throwing arm strenght
2. Running speed
3. Hit for power
4. Hit for average
5. Defensive abilities (range, positioning, least errors...etc..etc)

Willie Mays was among the best in ALL 5 categories.

Babe Ruth didnt have his speed
Pete Rose couldnt hit homeruns

Actually, no, johnny - those are *scouting* tools, not tools for guys who are comparing the usefulness / importance of players. I'll take the guys who hit for power over ALL of those things, if I'm building a team - it's drastically more important than any of them.

So, if we're just talking about five tool talents, it becomes a different discussion ...
 
OK, here goes.

Here's my dream team.

C Johnny Bench
1B Lou Gehrig
2B Joe Morgan
3B Mike Schmidt
SS Honus Wagner
LF Ted Williams
CF Willie Mays
RF Babe Ruth

RHP Bob Gibson, Walter Johnson
LHP Sandy Koufax, Warren Spahn

LPH Gates Brown,
RPH Matty Alou
Relief Rollie Fingers

Manager Sparky Anderson
 
Sparky Anderson! BLECH! LOL
You had a pretty damn fine team up until that one.
;)
Well, to each his own.
 
With out a doubt it's Ty Cobb, he might have been the biggest asswhole but he was one hell of a ball player. Just cause someone hit a lot of Home runs that dosn't make a great all around player, There are other aspects to the game and Ty Cobb had it all.
 
Someone who hits a lot of homeruns is worth more to his team than someone who fields well, runs well, throws well - or ALL of those things.

Just an FYI.

The thread was titled "greatest overall baseball player" not "all-around". There's a difference.
 
slademan said:
With out a doubt it's Ty Cobb, he might have been the biggest asswhole but he was one hell of a ball player. Just cause someone hit a lot of Home runs that dosn't make a great all around player, There are other aspects to the game and Ty Cobb had it all.

Plus he had that retarded grip on the bat. A cool movie about him was made, also.
They attributed his assholeness to the fact that he watched a family member get shot. That theory went out the window when it was discovered he was a major asshole BEFORE that tragic event, also.
LOL