Taken from an article by Brian Gjurgevich .....
I love "greatest ever" arguments -- like any other great debate, everyone has their opinion, but nobody has the answer, because the answer doesn't really exist.
Bonds hit his 661st career home run the other night, surpassing legend and fellow "greatest ever" candidate Willie Mays for third on the all-time list. Bonds now looks up at baseball immortals Babe Ruth and Hank Aaron in his quest to be the all-time home run king -- arguably (like everything else) the greatest title in all of sports.
Now, the man's resume should read nicely when his playing days are over -- at least six MVPs (he should have at least eight), at least eight gold gloves and the title of the most dominant offensive force of his generation.
But does that make him the best ever?
Well, if you equate dominance with greatness, then sure.
But, to me, domination and overall greatness are two different birds. he is definitely the most feared presence in the game today, often raising the question, "why in the hell would you pitch to him?"
When the man is dialed in, as he so often is, he has the ability to hit any pitch that goes over the plate 500 feet in the opposite direction.
Yes, that makes him macho as hell, but "the greatest ever?"
Hold the phone.
I wouldn't even say that Barry Bonds is the greatest player playing today.
He is certainly up there, but I would venture to say that a guy like Alex Rodriguez or even Ichiro Suzuki is a better all-around ballplayer.
Then again, greatness is not measured in skills, tools, or reputation.
To me, greatness is found in how one fits into the game and the era they play in, and most importantly, whether or not they transcend that game and that era.
Bonds' numbers are staggering, yes, but looking through the scope of the game as it is today, they are not all that remarkable.
Throughout baseball history, there have been three men (now four) that have hit over 600 home runs. An impressive feat.
But, if you take a closer look, there are currently a dozen players who could reach 600 in the next decade, if they continue to put up numbers on par with their career averages.
You can venture a guess as to why this has happened (steroids, bad pitching, expansion, smaller ballparks) but the fact is, getting to 600, even 700, is not the accomplishment it had formally been.
Just like hitting 30 or 40 or 50 or 60 home runs in a season isn't the mark of excellence it once was.
Will Gary Sheffield be considered one of the greatest when he gets to 600? How about Rafael Palmiero? Or Frank Thomas? Or Juan Gonzalez, Manny Ramirez, Ken Griffey Jr. or Jim Thome?
All great ballplayers, even Hall of Famers, in their own right, but among the greatest? Not necessarily.
Times have changed, and so has the game of baseball.
I love "greatest ever" arguments -- like any other great debate, everyone has their opinion, but nobody has the answer, because the answer doesn't really exist.
Bonds hit his 661st career home run the other night, surpassing legend and fellow "greatest ever" candidate Willie Mays for third on the all-time list. Bonds now looks up at baseball immortals Babe Ruth and Hank Aaron in his quest to be the all-time home run king -- arguably (like everything else) the greatest title in all of sports.
Now, the man's resume should read nicely when his playing days are over -- at least six MVPs (he should have at least eight), at least eight gold gloves and the title of the most dominant offensive force of his generation.
But does that make him the best ever?
Well, if you equate dominance with greatness, then sure.
But, to me, domination and overall greatness are two different birds. he is definitely the most feared presence in the game today, often raising the question, "why in the hell would you pitch to him?"
When the man is dialed in, as he so often is, he has the ability to hit any pitch that goes over the plate 500 feet in the opposite direction.
Yes, that makes him macho as hell, but "the greatest ever?"
Hold the phone.
I wouldn't even say that Barry Bonds is the greatest player playing today.
He is certainly up there, but I would venture to say that a guy like Alex Rodriguez or even Ichiro Suzuki is a better all-around ballplayer.
Then again, greatness is not measured in skills, tools, or reputation.
To me, greatness is found in how one fits into the game and the era they play in, and most importantly, whether or not they transcend that game and that era.
Bonds' numbers are staggering, yes, but looking through the scope of the game as it is today, they are not all that remarkable.
Throughout baseball history, there have been three men (now four) that have hit over 600 home runs. An impressive feat.
But, if you take a closer look, there are currently a dozen players who could reach 600 in the next decade, if they continue to put up numbers on par with their career averages.
You can venture a guess as to why this has happened (steroids, bad pitching, expansion, smaller ballparks) but the fact is, getting to 600, even 700, is not the accomplishment it had formally been.
Just like hitting 30 or 40 or 50 or 60 home runs in a season isn't the mark of excellence it once was.
Will Gary Sheffield be considered one of the greatest when he gets to 600? How about Rafael Palmiero? Or Frank Thomas? Or Juan Gonzalez, Manny Ramirez, Ken Griffey Jr. or Jim Thome?
All great ballplayers, even Hall of Famers, in their own right, but among the greatest? Not necessarily.
Times have changed, and so has the game of baseball.

