So you are taking full responsibility for your misunderstanding . That is admirable.
At the end of the day a decision has to be made as to whether benefits are worth the costs. However, that has nothing to do with some imaginary “capitalist theory”
The point is if the only support they can give for their arguments is based on the beliefs of more primitive societies, I have not use for them. BTW, the fact is that successful religions change their values over time to reflect the societies they are in. If they did not, their religion would disappear. That is why most (all?) current religions ignore the parts of the bible mentioned in the first post of the thread. If they did not, they would have serious problems keeping members.
Economists rarely set policy. When it comes to advice, they can tell you that when you compare the HST to the old tax system, the HST can collect a given amount of revenue at lower cost to a typical taxpayer. One would hope informed voters would take than into account when voting in a referendum. Indeed, my personal opinion is that voters are idiots if they don’t take that into account. However, at the end of the day it is a personal opinion.
I am not sure there was an actual misunderstanding but we may have been talking at cross purposes.
Capitalist theory was my inelegant shorthand for the proposition that capitalism is the correct or best type of economy for a nation to follow. Many people think like this and it is a value judgement.
I think your characterization of what religions do is a little too simplistic. Particularly with the example you chose. The laws in question (the ones that we are talking about in the OT) were given to and for the people of the covenant as part of the covenant, and were not meant for all people. Thus many of the world's largest Christian denominations take the OT very seriously, but they actually read it and take it in context. Secondly most people who follow the NT are quite clear that Jesus' fulfilled the law and prophecy and replaced it with a new law based on his sacrifice. So no Christian religions that I know "ignore" the parts of the OT that were talked about earlier in the thread, they just understand them in a different context. It when these changes were being made, Chistians were being jailed or killed for refusing to pay homage to the emperor so it really doesn't seem like they did it to "keep members", when they had much worse problems on their hands.

