God's Law

Status
Not open for further replies.
So you are taking full responsibility for your misunderstanding . That is admirable.

At the end of the day a decision has to be made as to whether benefits are worth the costs. However, that has nothing to do with some imaginary “capitalist theory”

The point is if the only support they can give for their arguments is based on the beliefs of more primitive societies, I have not use for them. BTW, the fact is that successful religions change their values over time to reflect the societies they are in. If they did not, their religion would disappear. That is why most (all?) current religions ignore the parts of the bible mentioned in the first post of the thread. If they did not, they would have serious problems keeping members.

Economists rarely set policy. When it comes to advice, they can tell you that when you compare the HST to the old tax system, the HST can collect a given amount of revenue at lower cost to a typical taxpayer. One would hope informed voters would take than into account when voting in a referendum. Indeed, my personal opinion is that voters are idiots if they don’t take that into account. However, at the end of the day it is a personal opinion.

I am not sure there was an actual misunderstanding but we may have been talking at cross purposes.

Capitalist theory was my inelegant shorthand for the proposition that capitalism is the correct or best type of economy for a nation to follow. Many people think like this and it is a value judgement.

I think your characterization of what religions do is a little too simplistic. Particularly with the example you chose. The laws in question (the ones that we are talking about in the OT) were given to and for the people of the covenant as part of the covenant, and were not meant for all people. Thus many of the world's largest Christian denominations take the OT very seriously, but they actually read it and take it in context. Secondly most people who follow the NT are quite clear that Jesus' fulfilled the law and prophecy and replaced it with a new law based on his sacrifice. So no Christian religions that I know "ignore" the parts of the OT that were talked about earlier in the thread, they just understand them in a different context. It when these changes were being made, Chistians were being jailed or killed for refusing to pay homage to the emperor so it really doesn't seem like they did it to "keep members", when they had much worse problems on their hands.
 
I am not sure there was an actual misunderstanding but we may have been talking at cross purposes.

Capitalist theory was my inelegant shorthand for the proposition that capitalism is the correct or best type of economy for a nation to follow. Many people think like this and it is a value judgement.
It is a value judgement. However, the main reason so many people think like this is that it is provides higher standards of living than other systems. But, yes, it is a value judgement to say higher standard of living for more people is a good thing.
I think your characterization of what religions do is a little too simplistic. Particularly with the example you chose. The laws in question (the ones that we are talking about in the OT) were given to and for the people of the covenant as part of the covenant, and were not meant for all people. Thus many of the world's largest Christian denominations take the OT very seriously, but they actually read it and take it in context. Secondly most people who follow the NT are quite clear that Jesus' fulfilled the law and prophecy and replaced it with a new law based on his sacrifice. So no Christian religions that I know "ignore" the parts of the OT that were talked about earlier in the thread, they just understand them in a different context. It when these changes were being made, Chistians were being jailed or killed for refusing to pay homage to the emperor so it really doesn't seem like they did it to "keep members", when they had much worse problems on their hands.
All organizations adapt or die out. One of the advantages of a market economy is that it allows less efficient organizations (i.e. firms) to die quicker and be replaced by others. With regard to religions, major Christian denominations have proven to be pretty flexible. Islam less so. A problem Christian denominations will face over time is taht as they increasing pick and choose what parts of their bible to believe, there will be less to set them apart from secular society. Hence, less reason for people to maintain memberships. This could well lead to a slow death by attrition in places like Europe and Canada (perhaps not “death” but very decreased membership). The fewer families who go to church, the fewer children who end up having any serious religious beliefs. Despite by personal opinion of Southern Baptists and similar American fundamentalist religious organizations, they don’t face the same problem (but in time may face the opposite problem as beliefs like creationism become harder for people to accept). Islam could also face the opposite problem if they cannot adjust to modern society. These are interesting times for the scientific study of religion.
 
In Ontario since 2001 municipalities are required by legislation to have a property tax rebate program from charities with varying amounts available.
Interesting in that in both the U.K. and the U.S.A. Religious, Educational, and Eleemosynary Institutions have 'always' been exempt from property tax.
 
It is a value judgement. However, the main reason so many people think like this is that it is provides higher standards of living than other systems. But, yes, it is a value judgement to say higher standard of living for more people is a good thing.

All organizations adapt or die out. One of the advantages of a market economy is that it allows less efficient organizations (i.e. firms) to die quicker and be replaced by others. With regard to religions, major Christian denominations have proven to be pretty flexible. Islam less so. A problem Christian denominations will face over time is taht as they increasing pick and choose what parts of their bible to believe, there will be less to set them apart from secular society. Hence, less reason for people to maintain memberships. This could well lead to a slow death by attrition in places like Europe and Canada (perhaps not “death” but very decreased membership). The fewer families who go to church, the fewer children who end up having any serious religious beliefs. Despite by personal opinion of Southern Baptists and similar American fundamentalist religious organizations, they don’t face the same problem (but in time may face the opposite problem as beliefs like creationism become harder for people to accept). Islam could also face the opposite problem if they cannot adjust to modern society. These are interesting times for the scientific study of religion.

Lots of organisms stop adopting and continue to live once they reach a certain state. Your position clearly overstated Darwinian evolution as we now understand it. Plus that kind of evolutionary theory cannot be applied to organizations, culture or ideas. The forces of evolution in those realms are really driven by Lamarkian forces not Darwinian ones.

In addition, your suggestion about Islam being less flexible doesn't mesh with your theory either. Islam is the fastest growing religion in the world, and thus either your theory is wrong or your understanding of Islam is wrong.

With certain notable exceptions, religions have not chosen to "ignore" parts of the bible or even pick and choose what parts to believe. This shows a remarkable lack of understanding of the theology of any of the major streams of Christianity. As I noted above most of them place the OT in conext in one of the ways that has been unchanged for almost 200 years, and all of them use virtually the same bible.

All of the scientific study of religion that I have read has indicated that levels of participation and to a lesser extent belief, has gone down when societies, or individuals, become very affluent and people don't feel that they need help with their daily lives becomes things are okay. But they also tend to turn quickly back to religion when severe challenges occur (some good work coming out on the Japan earthquakes on this).

And it is a pity that market economies no longer really work in the way you describe.
 
Lots of organisms stop adopting and continue to live once they reach a certain state. Your position clearly overstated Darwinian evolution as we now understand it. Plus that kind of evolutionary theory cannot be applied to organizations, culture or ideas. The forces of evolution in those realms are really driven by Lamarkian forces not Darwinian ones.
It has nothing to do with Darwinian evolution. Clearly my post went over your head.
In addition, your suggestion about Islam being less flexible doesn't mesh with your theory either. Islam is the fastest growing religion in the world, and thus either your theory is wrong or your understanding of Islam is wrong.
You should look at where it is growing and why.

With certain notable exceptions, religions have not chosen to "ignore" parts of the bible or even pick and choose what parts to believe. This shows a remarkable lack of understanding of the theology of any of the major streams of Christianity. As I noted above most of them place the OT in conext in one of the ways that has been unchanged for almost 200 years, and all of them use virtually the same bible.
Here you a just plain wrong.

All of the scientific study of religion that I have read has indicated that levels of participation and to a lesser extent belief, has gone down when societies, or individuals, become very affluent and people don't feel that they need help with their daily lives becomes things are okay. But they also tend to turn quickly back to religion when severe challenges occur (some good work coming out on the Japan earthquakes on this).
Clearly you have "all" of your reading is extremely limited. Otherwise you would know that this has been a major topic for the latst 20 years. You are repeating what is called the secularization hypothesis which was more or less uncontested 100 years ago. If you had read any of the literature, you would know that is no longer the case. Personally, I think it may be possible to salvage the secularization hypothesis. However, it is only possible to salvage it by being aware of the problems it faces both in terms of theory and empirical evidence, both which you are clearly unaware of.


Indeed, you have just stated your ignorance more clearly here than in any of you other posts.

And it is a pity that market economies no longer really work in the way you describe.
Given that you clearly don’ t know the first thing about either economics or the scientific study of religion, your statement is based on total ignorance.
 
It has nothing to do with Darwinian evolution. Clearly my post went over your head.

You should look at where it is growing and why.

No, you make a comment about organisms adapting or dying why would someone think that had anything to do with Darwinian evolution...?

You said flexibility was necc. for a religion to flourish. Then you suggested Islam was less flexible than other religions. We put this together with the fact that Islam is the fastest growing religion. If you can't see the flaw there maybe you should consider some liberal arts studies?



Here you a just plain wrong.

Prove it. Find me a large denomination that does not deal with the OT and just ignores it.


Clearly you have "all" of your reading is extremely limited. Otherwise you would know that this has been a major topic for the latst 20 years. You are repeating what is called the secularization hypothesis which was more or less uncontested 100 years ago. If you had read any of the literature, you would know that is no longer the case. Personally, I think it may be possible to salvage the secularization hypothesis. However, it is only possible to salvage it by being aware of the problems it faces both in terms of theory and empirical evidence, both which you are clearly unaware of.

Actually I read almost all the most up to date studies on the subject. The secularization hypothesis is what you are advancing. More recent studies tie wealth and crisis to the issue. Lots of good data to work with. Such as this one: http://news.illinois.edu/news/11/0808happiness_EdDiener.html


Given that you clearly don’ t know the first thing about either economics or the scientific study of religion, your statement is based on total ignorance.

Another non-substantive response. No surprise.
 
Actually I read almost all the most up to date studies on the subject. The secularization hypothesis is what you are advancing. More recent studies tie wealth and crisis to the issue. Lots of good data to work with. Such as this one: http://news.illinois.edu/news/11/0808happiness_EdDiener.html
I will start here as you are clearly either lying when you say you have read the most up-to-date studies or you just have no idea what they are. If you want to learn about the studies, go to google scholar and google names like Finke, Stark, Bainbridge, and Iannacone. I have lot’s of problems with their work. Indeed, all of my own work in the area takes issue with their approach. However, unless you know what the key people have done, you are in no position to make dumb posts stating: “I read almost all the most up to date studies on the subject”, which clearly you have not. BTW, the data available is actually not very good or the issue would have been conclusively by now.
QUOTE=rld;3693827]
Another non-substantive response. No surprise.[/QUOTE]
Your last post backs up the truth of my statement here.
 
I will start here as you are clearly either lying when you say you have read the most up-to-date studies or you just have no idea what they are. If you want to learn about the studies, go to google scholar and google names like Finke, Stark, Bainbridge, and Iannacone. I have lot’s of problems with their work. Indeed, all of my own work in the area takes issue with their approach. However, unless you know what the key people have done, you are in no position to make dumb posts stating: “I read almost all the most up to date studies on the subject”, which clearly you have not. BTW, the data available is actually not very good or the issue would have been conclusively by now.
QUOTE=rld;3693827]
Another non-substantive response. No surprise.
Your last post backs up the truth of my statement here.[/QUOTE]

It's funny I don't see you posting your complete reading bibliography in each post...
 
Your last post backs up the truth of my statement here.

It's funny I don't see you posting your complete reading bibliography in each post...[/QUOTE]
I have given you the “big names” that anyone who has “ read almost all the most up to date studies on the subject” would know. Your posts indicate that you have never heard of them. However, if you do want to learn about the debate in the area, you are free to google them. Afterwards, I can even tell you who their leading critics are to further expand your education.
 
It's funny I don't see you posting your complete reading bibliography in each post...
I have given you the “big names” that anyone who has “ read almost all the most up to date studies on the subject” would know. Your posts indicate that you have never heard of them. However, if you do want to learn about the debate in the area, you are free to google them. Afterwards, I can even tell you who their leading critics are to further expand your education.[/QUOTE]

You ability to divine that I have not read those folks is rather impressive...perhaps you are a prophet?
 
You ability to divine that I have not read those folks is rather impressive...perhaps you are a prophet?
Actually all I had to do was read your posts. Getting basic about the literature wrong while claiming to have read "read almost all the most up to date studies on the subject” gave you away. That is a mistake that Aardvark154 would not have made. He would have just cited something to support his position without claiming to be an expert.
 
Actually all I had to do was read your posts. Getting basic about the literature wrong while claiming to have read "read almost all the most up to date studies on the subject” gave you away. That is a mistake that Aardvark154 would not have made.

You mean like that classic moment when you suggested that Christian religions chose to ignore the OT in order to keep members which showed you understand neither the history or theology behind the relationship between the OT and the NT?

Or the part where you were unaware that in Ontario all charities get property tax rebates?

I may not have time to craft perfectly elegant prose when I post on terb, but I do know the essentials on what I am talking about.

And since I did not mention any literature, I have no idea how you think you can conclude that I "Getting basic about the literature wrong".

But I will concede Aardvark154 is a bright chap.
 
You mean like that classic moment when you suggested that Christian religions chose to ignore the OT in order to keep members which showed you understand neither the history or theology behind the relationship between the OT and the NT?
Once again, you are demonstrating your ignorance. The fact that you dislike the facts does not change the facts. I have given you references to start you off if you want to learn more. Much of it is not mathematical so even a liberal arts students should be able to read it.
And since I did not mention any literature, I have no idea how you think you can conclude that I "Getting basic about the literature wrong".
I know that because of the nonsense you posted about the literature. Post #100 is an obvious example.
 
Once again, you are demonstrating your ignorance. The fact that you dislike the facts does not change the facts. I have given you references to start you off if you want to learn more. Much of it is not mathematical so even a liberal arts students should be able to read it.

I know that because of the nonsense you posted about the literature. Post #100 is an obvious example.

Ah but my student days are long behind me. I can tell you are not in a decision making position, you simply dodge the harder questions and points by ignoring them or with empty rhetoric.

Feel free to carry on.
 
Ah but my student days are long behind me. I can tell you are not in a decision making position, you simply dodge the harder questions and points by ignoring them or with empty rhetoric.

Feel free to carry on.
Look, I have already demonstrated that you lied when you said you had "read almost all the most up to date studies on the subject”. I realize that you have committed yourself so far that you’re not going to admit you were wrong here. However, you could still take the time and read some of the literature without telling anyone. It never hurts to try to learn from your mistakes.
 
Look, I have already demonstrated that you lied when you said you had "read almost all the most up to date studies on the subject”. I realize that you have committed yourself so far that you’re not going to admit you were wrong here. However, you could still take the time and read some of the literature without telling anyone. It never hurts to try to learn from your mistakes.

You have demonstrated no such "lie."

Nor have you answered any of the tough questions posed of you.
 
You have demonstrated no such "lie."

Nor have you answered any of the tough questions posed of you.
You don’t know when to stop digging yourself in.

First you made the following post.
All of the scientific study of religion that I have read has indicated that levels of participation and to a lesser extent belief, has gone down when societies, or individuals, become very affluent and people don't feel that they need help with their daily lives becomes things are okay. But they also tend to turn quickly back to religion when severe challenges occur (some good work coming out on the Japan earthquakes on this).
If your reading in the area was very limited, I might just assume you had read a couple of papers that gave you a misrepresentation of the literature. However, you then went on to make the following statement.
Actually I read almost all the most up to date studies on the subject.
Clearly this statement is a lie as you would know if you had read much of the literature. No one unaware of the most important debates in the area in the last 20 years could possibility have written the previous passage.

I will even start in on the road to actually learning something about the debates.. This is only one of many paper I could cite and I do not necessarily one I agree with it. Indeed, I think Stark announces the complete death of the secularization hypothesis prematurely. However, unlike you, he has read the literature and knows about the debate. It will get you started with the literature. http://socrel.oxfordjournals.org/content/60/3/249.short


The following statement as also especially funny for someone who claims to have read almost all the literature.
Lots of good data to work with.
I don’t even know where to start with someone who claims there is “lots of good data. Lots of data, sure. Good is another matter. I don't think anyone who has read "almost all" the literature could possibly make that statement. Never mind the technical estimation problems.

Nor have you answered any of the tough questions posed of you.
The problem is that my responses clearly went over your head. Actually, perhaps you did read “almost all the most up to date studies” but just did not comprehend any of it.
 
You don’t know when to stop digging yourself in.

First you made the following post.

If your reading in the area was very limited, I might just assume you had read a couple of papers that gave you a misrepresentation of the literature. However, you then went on to make the following statement.

Clearly this statement is a lie as you would know if you had read much of the literature. No one unaware of the most important debates in the area in the last 20 years could possibility have written the previous passage.

I will even start in on the road to actually learning something about the debates.. This is only one of many paper I could cite and I do not necessarily one I agree with it. Indeed, I think Stark announces the complete death of the secularization hypothesis prematurely. However, unlike you, he has read the literature and knows about the debate. Nonetheless, it will get you started with the literature. http://socrel.oxfordjournals.org/content/60/3/249.short


The following statement as also especially funny for someone who claims to have read almost all the literature.

I don’t even know where to start with someone who claims there is “lots of good data. Lots of data, sure. Good is another matter. I don't think anyone who has read "almost all" the literature could possibly make that statement. Never mind the technical estimation problems.


The problem is that my responses clearly went over your head. Actually, perhaps you did read “almost all the most up to date studies” but just did not comprehend any of it.

Repeating your lie will not make it any more real.

1999 is old news, although I happily admit I have not read that article. If you are talking Oxford you really should be talking Barret and Trigg, the people doing the cutting edge research shouldn't you? Are you suggesting that their data and the Pew data is not good data?

And you still cannot name a denomination that "ignores" the OT in the way you describe. You have missed the basic foundations of theology and history of that whole issue. Even if you don't accept it, you should try to understand it.
 
Seems to work for those who KNOW their is a God!

Know is a tricky word. For clarity I think the right term should be "believe."

On the other hand the ones who suggest they can prove there is a God, in the traditional sense, they are the ones you have to keep a close eye one...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.