God's Law

Status
Not open for further replies.
The article goes on to become more interesting

Evans maintains an eponymous blog that draws thousands of highly engaged evangelical readers. She launched the site in 2008 to promote her first book, a sensitively written memoir that wrestled with faith and fundamentalism, and it now draws between 4,000 and 5,000 page views on a typical day, and significantly more when she pokes at a controversial topic. Christian publisher Thomas Nelson has purchased her book about the womanhood project, which will likely be in stores late next year. She's one of the rare prominent evangelical women who isn't primarily interested in parenthood; her blog takes on thorny theological questions, gender issues, and the future of the church. Evans speaks at Christian universities and conferences all over the country, and her writing frequently draws (mostly) respectful responses from prominent figures including Dr. R. Albert Mohler Jr., the powerful president of the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary.

The Bible includes hundreds of rules for women, both explicit and implied, Old Testament and New. Women should dress modestly (1 Peter), submit to their husbands (Ephesians), and remove themselves from their communities while menstruating (Leviticus). The project is often funny—growing her hair out all year, as suggested in 1 Corinthians, has clearly been driving Evans crazy—but it has a point: All Christians pick and choose the parts of the Bible that suit them. The believers who emphasize the verse in which Paul says, "Women should remain silent in the churches," tend to dismiss the verse just a few chapters away in which he writes that "every woman who prays or prophesies with her head uncovered dishonors her head" as culturally specific. As Evans points out, it's "Biblical" for a man to take multiple wives, or for a father to sell his daughter to pay off debts. When the term "Biblical" can mean anything, it means nothing. If Christians can acknowledge this, they may treat each other more lovingly and conduct themselves with more humility. . . .

But she's increasingly using her platform to challenge other evangelical leaders, especially those who have branded themselves as cool and sensitive—she's not aiming for easy targets like Pat Robertson. In July, she rightly called out prominent hipster pastor Mark Driscoll as a homophobic bully, launching a widespread conversation online and in the evangelical media. (World Magazine accused her of libel, but Driscoll admitted he'd been flippant.) Last month she caused another public kerfuffle by challenging best-selling author Donald Miller for writing that women are not the primary characters in their own "love stories"—in other words, that a woman's role is to chastely wait for a godly Prince Charming, the one in charge of "writing" the story of her life. Miller eventually deleted and apologized for the offending blog post. Evans is a vocal advocate of increasing the ranks of women within church leadership—another seriously controversial subject within a group that is in constant terror of being feminized. Though she doesn't like the word feminist because the term is so loaded within her community, she's a staunch egalitarian in a world in which there's an ongoing debate over whether husbands are the masters of their wives.

Evans has been writing about the womanhood project on her blog, but outside her own supportive commenters, the project has received criticism already. A piece on the website of the Council on Biblical Manhood and Womanhood, the leading proponent of "complementarian"—anti-egalitarian—gender roles in the church, accused her of a "mocking" attitude. Others have tut-tutted over her interpretation method, and called the project "dangerous." Evans told me a lot of people misunderstand her aims. "They fear that I'll make the Bible and those who love it look stupid, which would be hard because I read the Bible and love the Bible."

Her strongest critics within the church are conservatives who should be most sympathetic to the project's strictures: those who claim to follow the Bible literally themselves. "It's revealing that when I say, 'I'm going to actually do it,' they react," she said ruefully. "It goes to show at some level there's a fear of exposing what it means to follow the Bible literally." Evans is speaking to the church, but she's not preaching to the choir. And by doing that, she's helping her readers follow another Biblical instruction, this one from Paul's letter to the Romans: "Be transformed by the renewing of your mind."
 
Sisyphus... you are missing the point.
I am not missing the point at all. if you are going to offer a critique of orthodox Judaism then you should be upfront. I may not agree with Dr Laura but she did say clearly why she held the views she had. As it turns out what the rebuttal addressed was not Dr Laura's specific views but the views of orthodox jews. The vast majority of people have principles and judgements that are not always in agreement. If someone says I believe X and I believe X because I am a catholic. You can be critical of that persons position by arguing that Catholics don’t believe X. In such a case it would be appropriate to be critical of that someone. If however you accept that Catholics believe X your criticism is really with Catholicism.
You have wrongly identified my main objection with the OP. My major objection has more to do with it’s form rather then substance. The fact that there is no identifiable author I think is very relevant. I take issue with the straw manning of the bible passages cited. I take issue with how it attacks one orthodox Jew instead of attacking the principles of orthodox Jewish belief. It’s greatest sin is it simply is not funny nor witty. It is boring.
 
If someone says I believe X and I believe X because I am a catholic. You can be critical of that persons position by arguing that Catholics don’t believe X. In such a case it would be appropriate to be critical of that someone. If however you accept that Catholics believe X your criticism is really with Catholicism.
…
I take issue with how it attacks one orthodox Jew instead of attacking the principles of orthodox Jewish belief. It’s greatest sin is it simply is not funny nor witty. It is boring.
I think you’re making a silly distinction. If people were forced to be Catholics or orthodox Jews, you might have a point. However, in modern society, no one is forced to believe in nonsense. It is true that most people follow a given religion because they were indoctrinated with it as children. However, at some point, they have to take responsibility for their own beliefs. Excusing nonsensical beliefs because someone’s religion is made up of nonsensical beliefs is completely denying any role for individual responsibility.

BTW, I am not at all critical of Catholics when they don’t follow some of the dumber beliefs of their church (e.g. opposition to birth control). I would be more critical of them if they did blindly follow all the beliefs of their religion.
 
Bitch Laura is using the grand old american tactic of using the old testament ( or Tora she insists) as evidence to support her prejudice. Of course she will ignore the points of the sarcastic rebuttal whose teachings she may not wish to follow. She is not preaching to Orthodox Jews, she is trying to preserve the discrimination against gays that both orthodox jews and conservative christians ( and others, Muslims, etc.) cling to, as the world around them evolves.
 
She invokes Leviticus to justify her position. So it is a fair AND FUNNY question to turn around.
However, she not only has a right to do so, but also to say that she finds some passages more valid than others.

I get every bit if not more annoyed at the "you don't have a right to believe that" liberals, as I do at the "every jot and tittle was lowered on a string from Heaven" literalists.
 
I did not miss your point. You have no point. You, ironically, did exactly what Laura did. You selected a single passage that suited your purposes. YOU missed the point that one cannot select a passage out of a book and, because it supports your personal view, hold it up as some profound undeniable law of god and imply that it is obviously above criticism while then, conveniently ignoring the rest of god's laws that are ridiculous and laughable. You can suck and blow in the bedroom but not here. :)

For the record, god's laws were created by humankind. That is why, with greater knowledge, understanding and advances in society, we change them. The new and improved human-made laws very often replace god's ridiculous, flawed laws. That should tell you something.

Which of god's laws do you cling to? Which of god's laws do you ignore? How arrogant of you to imply, in your choices, to personally know the will of god.

It is amazing how people hold such pride in their beliefs and use their own ignorance as a shield to maintain their faith. Those people rarely, if ever, scrutinize and explore the foundations of their own beliefs.

They are cited as God's laws but does Jesus ever say those things in the New Testament (irrelevant to a Jew I know)? Are any of those "God's laws" mentioned in the 10 Commandments? If they were truly God's laws, then they wouldn't be flawed. They seem to be dated man-made laws, under the guise of God's laws.
 
However, she not only has a right to do so, but also to say that she finds some passages more valid than others.
In a country that allows free speech (which the US somewhat does) she certainly does have a right to express her opinion. However, if she would like for thinking and rational people to respect her opinion, she might consider trying an argument that is not both arbitrary and hypocritical. If she expects us to change our policy and belief based on some writings in the bible but to ignore other parts of the same book, she had better follow up with some pretty convincing explanation as to how she is able to distinguish which parts of the bible are the word of god and which parts are not. She has never even tried to justify her reasoning.

The truth, of course, is that the bible, like many other religious writings, is the work of men who reflected the moral and social attitudes of their culture at their time. It is not a surprise that the bible supports ritual sacrifice, slavery, death by stoning, subjugation of women, and persecution of gays as these were by far the prevailing attitudes of the day. However, standards have changed in the 3000+ years since the Torah was committed to paper and we no longer agree with many of the biblical societal norms. We don't condone slavery, we don't sacrifice bulls at the altar, and we recognize that sexual orientation is a personal matter for each person and not any business of the general public (at least most of us have evolved sufficiently).
 
No one is forcing you to be an observant Orthodox Jew. if you wish to be smug, I would not be critical of the smugness of others.

On the contrary, that is exactly what Dr Laura Schlesinger is saying when she tells us that under no circumstances can we condone homosexuality because it violates Leviticus 18:22.
 
On the contrary, that is exactly what Dr Laura Schlesinger is saying when she tells us that under no circumstances can we condone homosexuality because it violates Leviticus 18:22.

geez are you that thick? That is exactly what YOU are engaging in. Perhaps Dr. Laura was being smug perhaps she was not. That really is immaterial. What I take issue with is how YOU are being smug. If your rebuttal to the smugness is your smugness it really seems to me to be rather shrill and insignificant.:frusty:
 
On the contrary, that is exactly what Dr Laura Schlesinger is saying. . . .
In fairness it is what she said almost 11 years ago and publicly changed her mind about eight years ago.


May I also point out that the argument can certainly be made to the opposite of yours above that what you are attempting to do is to force someone not to be an observant Orthodox Jew.
 
the point is that if you are using the authority of God's word regarding homosexualty, then you must also honour that authority on the other issues as mentioned in the rebuttal- if it is true because it is god's word, then all of god's word must be true. The obvious fact is some of these "divine words" are either idiotic because they were created by humans, or God is an idiot. In either case, Laura is shown to be irrational, wrong, and both intellectually and spiritually corrupt. What are the defenders of orthodox Judaism doing on Terb, anyway? (but welcome to the debate)
 
Dr Keith Ablow who was on The Howard Stern Show has spoken out against Chaz Bono being on DWTS, and links sexual orientation with pedophilia.

 
In fairness it is what she said almost 11 years ago and publicly changed her mind about eight years ago.

May I also point out that the argument can certainly be made to the opposite of yours above that what you are attempting to do is to force someone not to be an observant Orthodox Jew.

I would suggest that someone who positions herself as a moral authority and espouses said convictions in a public forum has to live up to her alleged beliefs. This is a woman with a pattern of behaviour that would make one question anything she has to say when it comes to matters of morality or enlightenment. Worse yet, she was apparently a dilettante who dropped her Orthodox Jewish faith when she felt it no longer suited her needs. That doesn't say much for her spirituality or beliefs and doesn't give her much credence within her community or among others.

I would suggest that most people here are just sick of people trotting out their religion when they feel like it in an effort to push an agenda on a specific topic, rather than living a truly spiritual and observant life full-time. I'd say that's called hypocrisy.

Further, most people want to see a separation of Church and State when it comes to laws and day-to-day life. There is a lot to be learned and carried over into 21st century life from the old spiritual books, but there is just as much that is either pure fiction or a part of a time and place that has no business in our world today. People like Schlessinger do not add a great deal to the discussion with her hypocrisy, inconsistency and at times, amorality.
 
The last time Dr Ablow was on THSS, he said he was going to get Artie Lange clean and sober - that worked out well.

 
This is a woman with a pattern of behaviour that would make one question anything she has to say
Back many posts ago I believe I mentioned that she is not a particularly likeable person, however, I would criticize her far more for her constantly inflexible rules, there are no shades of grey just black and white, rather than her own behaviour.

Further, most people want to see a separation of Church and State when it comes to laws and day-to-day life.
So much depends upon how you mean the above statement. Certainly from a U.S. Constitutional perspective the wall is to protect religion from government, not to block people of faith from being involved in or influencing government.

That doesn't mean we can't disagree with her perspective as it was then, but it does mean that you can't force her synagogue to marry people it doesn't want to, or to stop saying that it finds TERB immoral.
 
Back many posts ago I believe I mentioned that she is not a particularly likeable person, however, I would criticize her far more for her constantly inflexible rules, there are no shades of grey just black and white, rather than her own behaviour.
To me, it is a combination of both. I find the inconsistency in what she chooses to be black and white about ridiculous. And I also find her personal behaviour - for a public persona who claims to be a moral authority - abhorrent.

Aardvark154 said:
So much depends upon how you mean the above statement. Certainly from a U.S. Constitutional perspective the wall is to protect religion from government, not to block people of faith from being involved in or influencing government.
While I understand the US Constitutional definition, I think many people would like to see the church & state separation extend both ways.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.