Global Warming is a Lie

Mr. Downtown said:
----------------

You're right, lomotil. We should depend on those fucking Red Liberals who did absolutely sweet fuck all except desire power for 12+ years other than going to an Accord dance holiday in Japan at taxpayer's expense.

The Liberals are shit too, but are not beholden to Alberta, not their grassroots. A national energy policy is required now more than ever
as was brought in by Trudeau. There should be cheques and balances, that is why a minority government is sometimes good to effect balanced change.
ie reducing the GST, the Chretien Liberals lied about scrapping the GST, but Harper actually kept his promise.
 
lomotil said:
The Liberals are shit too, There should be cheques and balances, that is why a minority government is sometimes good to effect balanced change.
The Lieberals took care of the "cheques" all right. They padded their pockets with them.
 
pussylicker said:
Do you grow your own food? Produce your own electricity? Can you dispose of your own waste water?

Seems to me you rely too much on someone else to give you your so-called green footprint.

No more than anyone else. I assume people driving 45min a day to and from work also don't grow their own food, produce their own electricity, or dispose their own waste water.

What's your point? I didn't say I had zero footprint, I said I had relatively lower footprint than the average person.

Are you just saying that those things cost energy and create pollution? Thank you for telling me, everybody knows that. My footprint includes those things, but does not include driving 45min a day. Your footprint, if it includes driving 45min a day AND those things, is much higher.

Also note that my condo requires much less heat and electricity than the average home, so I have a win there. Transportation, though, is a big factor.

Are there other things we'd have to do to meet Kyoto targets? Yes. Plainly. Heavy industry needs to clean itself up too. We need more nuke power and less coal, etc., so I am not claiming this is the only story.

I personally think we should meet Kyoto targets but in the process we should slap tarriffs on any imported product that was produced using more greenhouse gas than we would have in Canada, so that the jobs don't just re-open in China as some have said. We can then say we've done our bit, without sacrificing our industries; we'll also be pressuring other nations to follow along, in order to evade our tarriffs.
 
fuji said:
I personally think we should meet Kyoto targets but in the process we should slap tarriffs on any imported product that was produced using more greenhouse gas than we would have in Canada, so that the jobs don't just re-open in China as some have said. We can then say we've done our bit, without sacrificing our industries; we'll also be pressuring other nations to follow along, in order to evade our tarriffs.

The only way that will ever work for Canada is if the USA enacts the same thing because otherwise we will be importing alot more things from Europe. :eek:

I'm also not sure if WTO would allow such a tariff structure as it is now.
 
fuji said:
I have a pretty green footprint. I live in a condo near my work, so I walk most days. IN fact, I hardly ever drive my car, I should sell the damn thing. My condo requires little heat/AC due to the shared walls. Except... I fly to europe or asia every other month for work and that blows my footprint out the window. My personal life, though, is pretty green until you add work travel.

Still, I don't see much benefit in the suburban driving lifestyle, I think quality of life is better when you can walk to the office. We could restructure our society so that more workplaces were nearer/in residential areas and wipe out a LOT of driving. Even for people who want to live in the suburbs--we could mix more office space in with the suburban areas to cut down commute times. I don't see any good reason why most people aren't living a 10-20min walk from where they work. Even with couples where both work, usually one has some j-random-job that could be anywhere, and the other has some specialized job--they could move near the specialized job and the other could get whatever j-random-job the area has to offer. A few people would have both specialized and maybe unable to both find work in the same area, but really most people could cut driving out most days if we set the cities up right.

We've set up our cities in a stupid way that causes a lot of excess driving. It's not really people's fault that they commute 45min to work right now given that the city plans, etc., pretty much force you to do that--that's our fault as a society as a whole. City planners should work towards getting everyone walking to work again. Every suburban residential area should have an associated business park in the middle, maybe including a school so dad can walk the kids to school on his way to work.

The way we have it now where the residential areas are all a 10-15min drive from the business parks, and the schools are someplace else, and the stores some other place again, it's just dumb, it forces people to spend half their free time driving around. Needing motorized transportation to leave your area should be something you do for special events or unusual shopping a couple times a week, not a couple times a day.

I honestly think these sorts of changes in our urban structure would IMPROVE everyone's quality of life all the while heavily cutting down on people's average environmental footprint. Not only that, if people got off their asses and walked more, like 20min each way to work every day, they'd be healthier, cutting down on healthcare bills, and again improving everyone's quality of life in another way.

Right now I have this kind of life but it's a luxury I can afford that most people can't, because I can pay for a condo right next to the financial core where all the jobs are, and I don't have kids, so I don't need the suburban backyard where there's no work nearby. The whole idea of a financial core where all the jobs are, with no housing near it, or a residential area with no jobs near it, is questionable. We aren't environmental monsters because of our success or industrialization or prosperity or quality of life, but at least partly because of our stupid urban planning gone wrong.

Yes, you're not married, have no kids and you don't work in an industrial job. That's why you have the freedom to live wherever you want and don't really care much about: 1) the quality of public schools, 2) the proximity and amount of green space, 3) the availability of shopping and the time required to do it, 4) the cost of housing relative to all the expenses involved in raising children, 5) the safety of neighbourhoods for children (especially when unsupervised), etc. These are the things that drive people to the suburbs (pun intended).

Your model lifestyle requires high density housing and high density commercial and industrial space. There is insufficient proximate green space in that sort of development. High density always leads to identifiable problems - crime, temporary undersupply of goods and services, inflated property values, etc.

The market is smarter than any of us. There are good reasons why people prefer the suburbs.

Improving public transit is a much better idea than increasing planning density.
 
lomotil said:
There should be cheques and balances,

Isn't that the Liberal policy?;)
 
fuji said:
I personally think we should meet Kyoto targets but in the process we should slap tarriffs on any imported product that was produced using more greenhouse gas than we would have in Canada, so that the jobs don't just re-open in China as some have said. We can then say we've done our bit, without sacrificing our industries; we'll also be pressuring other nations to follow along, in order to evade our tarriffs.

Surely, you realize that the success of Canada depends on having a trade surplus! If we impose tariffs on incoming products, the affected countries will respond in kind. We have more to lose from that game than they do!

Let's not commit hari kari on the sword of environmentalism.
 
Bud Plug said:
Yes, you're not married, have no kids and you don't work in an industrial job.

2 out of 3. I am married, but no kids. On the other hand:

don't really care much about: 1) the quality of public schools

My whole point is that having the city set up this way is WRONG. There absolutely should be high quality public schools in areas where people work. That's my whole point. I agree we don't have that now, and I am saying that is wrong city planning that has caused that.


2) the proximity and amount of green space

Toronto Island doesn't count as green space?

At any rate if you go read what I wrote I am saying that we should have more business parks mixed in with residential suburban areas JUST SO people don't have to trade green space off against walking to work. It is wrong city planning that has resulted in having to choose between them.


3) the availability of shopping and the time required to do it

I bet there are more stores, and more variety of stores, within a 15 minute walk of my home than yours. Nevertheless, to the extent that there are none near where you live that is the result of wrong city planning. Everyone should live within walking distance of a basic shopping plaza where they can buy daily essentials. You should only have to travel to shop for infrequent purchases, like buying a new TV, or designer clothes might take a trip to a shopping area, but buying groceries should be something you can do by foot.

4) the cost of housing relative to all the expenses involved in raising children

Did you read where I was advocating having more jobs created in suburban areas? No?


5) the safety of neighbourhoods for children (especially when unsupervised), etc. These are the things that drive people to the suburbs (pun intended).

Absolutely. Which is why I said that it is the result of wrong city planning that there are no jobs within walking distance of those suburban homes.

Your model lifestyle requires high density housing and high density commercial and industrial space.

No it doesn't. It does today only because of wrong city planning. City planners allowed residential areas to be built far from work sites, and work sites to be built far form homes. I can easily imagine a business park sitting in the middle of every residential neighbourhood, within a few minutes walk of enough homes to provide most of the staff. People would then move to live near their work, or at least, near the work of one partner.


The market is smarter than any of us. There are good reasons why people prefer the suburbs.

I'm a free market booster, but in this case we are not talking about a free market. City planning is done by bureuacratic fiat. Perhaps a free market WOULD have created a mix of commercial/industrial/residential properties. The NON-free central planning done by city planners is what created the current separation between residential and commercial spaces.


Improving public transit is a much better idea than increasing planning density.

Who said anything about increasing density? I envision low-rise offices in business parks surrounded by houses.
 
Bud Plug said:
Surely, you realize that the success of Canada depends on having a trade surplus! If we impose tariffs on incoming products, the affected countries will respond in kind. We have more to lose from that game than they do!

Let's not commit hari kari on the sword of environmentalism.

If we impose tariffs based on the GREEN-NESS of incoming products, and affected countries respond in kind, we will have done everyone a favour.
 
fuji said:
No more than anyone else. I didn't say I had zero footprint, I said I had relatively lower footprint than the average person.

Are you just saying that those things cost energy and create pollution? My footprint includes those things, but does not include driving 45min a day.

Also note that my condo requires much less heat and electricity than the average home, so I have a win there. Transportation, though, is a big factor.
Hats off to you for trying to have a Green footprint. I'm not knocking you, it's just that the Greeners will never be satisfied until we all die and quit creating GHGs. They are hypocrites. Plain and simple.

But, 48% of GHGs in Toronto come from buildings. Just because you are in a condo complex, doesn't mean it is more efficient than an urban home. That would depend when it was built, and on your cubic footage. There are more dead spaces in a condo tower that may not be directly heated, but are still warmer than the outside air. There is a lot of lost heat as you go higher in the air from wind wicking warmth away from the building, than a bungalow. It's a known fact that there is a micro climate in downtown TO, so it is consistantly windier than out in the country. I'm not certain, but a lot of apartment buildings I've seen, don't have energy efficient windows either. If the "heat" is included in the cost of the rent, people won't change their habits and turn the thermostat down.

Unless we all build into a hillside, and face south, there is going to be heatloss.
 
lomotil said:
The only Canadians who deny global warming are fucking redneck Albertans, I wonder why? The Harper Conservatives are not really going green and are not so serious about global warming and the Kyoto Accord, Alberta is their grassroots, birth of the Reform Party. The day when there is a horrendous hew and cry from Alberta regarding constraints on the oil sector perpetrated by Ottawa is the day, that you will know that Harper is serious about the environment. Not likely to ever happen is it?

Actually, I don't buy into Global Warming either.

1. The scientists are all just jumping on the bandwagon.

2. Our society really doesn't value scientists or engineers, we take them for granted and pay them shit money really for their level of education. This gives them some sort of spot light.

3. It's a great excuse to have climate change conferences all over the world like Rio, Copenhagen, Kyoto. Bet there isn't an escort to be had that week.

4. There is absolutely no empirical proof that the climate is doing anything abnormal. It's a computer model full of assumptions.

5. We have only been keeping climate records for about 150 years. The earth is billions of years old. Hardly enough data to draw any accurate conclusions from.

6. The same scientists who are now proclaiming that we are all going to boil in our own juices were previously screaming about the impending ice age.

7. Mount Pinatubo erupted in 1991 ejecting more Greenhouse Gases into the atmosphere in one shot than all of man kind has since the industrial revolution.

8. This winter has been a bitch for the last 2 months.
 
Meister said:
I find it funny that everybody loves the new buzz "green". However, nobody is willing to do shit about it and just blame big factories and industry in general.

- Are do-gooder celebrities giving up their 3 mansions, 4 cars, jets....
- Do you see anybody taking their bicycle to work?
- Do you see anybody investing thousands at home to convert to energy efficiency? Replace all toilets, throw out old dryer, fridge, washer, replace old windows, only keep one car....
- Willing to pay higher utility prices. Extra money would go to investing in green technology

Consumers will think twice about Kyoto when it starts directly affecting their lifestyle. We got enough armchair critics. If you want to tell others what to do lead by example.

Well put.

The celebrity hipocrits like Al Gore, and George Clooney and the rest of them are well known private jet users.

George Clooney for example regularly flies to his luxury villa in Italy on a private plane. With the fuel that he consumes to fly his singular ass to Italy, he could drive his Toyota Prius to the moon.

READ THIS:

http://www.tmz.com/2006/10/18/celebs-who-claim-theyre-green-but-guzzle-gas

The only celeb that I am aware of that flies coach is Leonardo DiCaprio, believe it or not.

As far as my house goes, I have installed a high efficiency furnace, new windows, a set back thermostat, and low flow toilets already. Oh, and R-44 insulation in the attic where you lose 75% of your heat. My NDP friends have done none of the above (they all live in old shitty houses in the City btw) I live in a very old house too in High Park, but I've upgraded everything. New wiring, plumbing, walls, insulation, mechanical, HVAC, everything. All done myself btw. My NPD friends (blow hards all) all think that industry is the bad guy, that the gov't should step in to regulate industry to death. They all look at me like I have 2 heads when I tell them that it's individuals who are responsible for the majority of greenhouse gas emissions and that they are more to blame than exxon. Every single one of them (mostly teachers) talk the talk, but do not walk the walk. Their houses are not properly built, or maintained, they tend to drive shitty old cars (Jettas and Volvos) that spew crap into the environment rather than subscribe to the bourgeous notion of "buying a new car". Instead, they find ways around the emissions test because they want to use the money to travel to Costa Ricca, or Thailand in order to enrich their spirit (i.e. have a good time and get laid alot by strangers)
 
fuji said:
If we impose tariffs based on the GREEN-NESS of incoming products, and affected countries respond in kind, we will have done everyone a favour.

You can't be serious! You really think that China or the U.S. will base their tariffs on "green-ness", just because we have?!

We're not exactly rulers of the world, you know!
 
fuji said:
There absolutely should be high quality public schools in areas where people work. That's my whole point. I agree we don't have that now, and I am saying that is wrong city planning that has caused that.

It's high density and too much diversity in the educational background of school parents that leads to poor quality schools. You can't implement your vision of lower density Toronto without higher density in the suburbs. (law of conservation of mass and energy, and all that stuff....)

fuji said:
Toronto Island doesn't count as green space?

At any rate if you go read what I wrote I am saying that we should have more business parks mixed in with residential suburban areas JUST SO people don't have to trade green space off against walking to work. It is wrong city planning that has resulted in having to choose between them.

First of all, if you think Toronto island is "green space" (forgetting about the fact that you have to take a ferry to get to it), its been too long since you've been out of the city. My local green spaces don't have amusement parks, identifiable gay beaches, an airport, or housing.

Again, you can't decrease Toronto density without increasing the density of suburbs.

fuji said:
I bet there are more stores, and more variety of stores, within a 15 minute walk of my home than yours.

Right, within a 15 minute walk. Wrong, within a 15 minute trip, and thats what matters in terms of quality of life - how long it takes you to do your chores. I used to live downtown within walking distance of Kensington Market for my shopping. Great food. Lots of fun. However, grocery shopping was a half-day event instead of the one hour job it is now (by car).

fuji said:
Did you read where I was advocating having more jobs created in suburban areas? No?

There's an existing logic to the current locations of businesses. Could you explain your superior ideas about this? Seems like you might be biting off more than you can chew.

fuji said:
I'm a free market booster, but in this case we are not talking about a free market. City planning is done by bureuacratic fiat. Perhaps a free market WOULD have created a mix of commercial/industrial/residential properties. The NON-free central planning done by city planners is what created the current separation between residential and commercial spaces.

City planning is the separate responsibility of each municipality. As such, they compete for businesses and residents to locate within their taxable jurisdiction. Toronto did not plan for people to move out of the city. The surrounding cities simply offered more attractive planning to residents, and to a growing degree, businesses.


fuji said:
Who said anything about increasing density? I envision low-rise offices in business parks surrounded by houses.

Sorry, only possible in Sim City, not the real world.
 
Bud Plug said:
You can't be serious! You really think that China or the U.S. will base their tariffs on "green-ness", just because we have?!

We're not exactly rulers of the world, you know!

I think we matter more to them than they matter to us.
 
Bud Plug said:
It's high density and too much diversity in the educational background of school parents that leads to poor quality schools. You can't implement your vision of lower density Toronto without higher density in the suburbs. (law of conservation of mass and energy, and all that stuff....)

I think you're misunderstanding me. I've said two different things here. First I've said that we could be doing a better job downtown, which would still be high density, but we could have more schools and support than we do. Second I've said that the low density areas could mix business and residential buildings together better than they do now.

We seem to be mixing up those two things a little, you seem to think I expect downtown to become low density--I don't. What I want is to bring the walk-to-work potential to the low density areas by changing the mix of business and residential space.

Right, within a 15 minute walk. Wrong, within a 15 minute trip

Doubt that. A 15 minute trip for me covers anything you could imagine.

I used to live downtown within walking distance of Kensington Market for my shopping. Great food. Lots of fun. However, grocery shopping was a half-day event instead of the one hour job it is now (by car).

I just walk over to the grocery store that's 10 minutes from where I live, buy a few things I want for dinner that day, and walk home. I'm home with the groceries 30min after walking out of the office. All on foot. I'm probably home with the groceries before you're even home from work.

Oh yeah, and I can eat my lunch at home if I want to as well, nice if you have a family. I don't, but a bunch of my neighbours do--they like to visit their kids at lunch.

There's an existing logic to the current locations of businesses. Could you explain your superior ideas about this? Seems like you might be biting off more than you can chew.

The existing logic is that gas is cheap and everyone drives so rather than optimizing fuel and driving by having deliveries into local areas, we force the consumer to use fuel and automobiles to drive to the distribution point. Were we to set gas prices reasonably, say $3-4/litre, it would make more sense to optimize out the driving by having groceries shipped in once to a store many consumers can walk, rather than drive to.

City planning is the separate responsibility of each municipality. As such, they compete for businesses and residents to locate within their taxable jurisdiction.

That's a HUGE stretch. City planning is plainly central planning and planning isn't a free market by ANY stretch of the imagination. It's a process dominated by the special interests of the incumbents and insiders, and by the senselessness of bureuacracy.

You might as well claim that communism was a free market because Poland competed with the Ukraine. At that level of competition there's very little selection pressure--no matter how retarded a decision a city planner makes, the city planner still has a job for life at taxpayer expense. Maybe over 1000 year time horizons this sort of competition amounts to something, but by then we're all dead.

We'd better not wait for the free market to sort this out, because the market just plainly isn't free. It's centrally planned by any definition of central planning.

Toronto did not plan for people to move out of the city.

Actually Toronto planned for increased density, and has been growing rapidly. I'm not sure why you think people have moved out. The city has added massive numbers of residents over the last 10-15 years with an absolutely hectic pace of home building that's showing no signs of letting up.

Sorry, only possible in Sim City, not the real world.

Until the central planners got their hands into things and decided that there was some arbitrary never really explained value in outlawing businesses from locating near residential areas we had EXACTLY what I'm asking for, so it plainly has, can, and could again exist.

Before the environment became an issue nobody saw a problem with masses of people driving hours every day. We could easily structure our spacious, green suburbs so that people living there had places to work near their homes.
 
alienencounters said:
"Since 1974, a total of 13,500 square kilometers (about half the size of New Jersey) of ice shelves have disintegrated—a phenomenon linked to global warming, as temperatures have risen faster in Antarctica than anywhere else in world."

Moraff either you are right or that article is right.
Your analogy of global warming leading to lower sea levels would only work if the earth had an open system, and not a closed system.
Case in point: The ocean evaporates and the vapour goes out into space.
Which would mean we are really f*cked because our oxygen would do the same!


Don't know what source(s) the article you quote used, but here's mine....

"From 1986 to 2000 central Antartic valleys cooled .7degC/decade with serious ecosystem damage from cold."

Comiso,J.C., 2000 "Variability and trends in Antartic surface temps from in situ & satellite measurements," Journal of Climate 13

"Both satellite and ground station data show slight cooling over the last 20 years."

Joughin.I., and Turlaczyk, S., 2002 "Positive mass balance of the Ross Ice Streams, W. Antarctica," Science 295

"Side-looking radar measurements show West Antartic ice is increasing at 26.8 gigatons/yr. Reversing the melting trend of the last 6000 years."

Thompson, D.W.J., and Solomon, S., 2002, "Interpretation of recent Southern Hemisphere climate change,: Science 296

"Antartic peninsula has warmed several degrees while interior has cooled somewhat. Ice shelves have retreated but sea ice has increased"

Petit, J.R., et al 1999 "Climate and atmospheric history of the past 420,000 years from the Vostok ice core, Antarctica" Nature 399

"Less Antarctic ice has melted today than occurred during the last interglacial."

Liu, J., et al 2004 "Interpretation of recent Antarctic sea ice variability," Geophysical Research Letters 31


Speaking to the article's comment on the melting of the ice shelves.

Antartica is 14.2 million km^2 in the summer ( and doubles in size in the winter due to the formation of sea ice but I'll use the summer figure).

New Jersey is 20,168 km^2. Half of that is 10,084 km^2.

So this means that slightly more than 0.07% of Antartica's ice volume has melted. Yes something the size of half of New Jersey seems very large to you and I, but to Antartica is is pretty piddly. We get fooled because Antartica looks so small on our maps, but it really is the fifth largest continent.


As for my analogy of lower sea levels. I was not assuming the water evaporating would head out into space. I was theorizing that it would be in the air (warmer overall therefore capable of holding more moisture) and bound up in snow on land or in surface/underground water making it's way back to the sea since it snows more readily near freezing than way below it.

My point is not that I deny global warming. Global warming/ice ages cycles are a proven fact of our planet's history. I strongly disbelieve that we have a) any understanding of what's driving it and what the results would be and b) any understanding of exactly what humankind is contributing to it. For us to monkey around with it in an attempt to control the world's weather is sheer lunacy. We couldn't protect New Orleans from one hurricane, how are we going to affect the globe?

There are good points to cutting down on our pollution and consumption of non-renewable resources to improve our local air/water/land qualities. But they have to be made sensibly, not just because "we have to do something, anything"