Global Warming is a Lie

fuji said:
How do you know that there is no benefit? How do you know that they would all re-open? This is an oft repeated statement, and it may be true, but I've never seen anything substantiate the claim that it makes no difference.

I do agree that the changes must occur at the consumption level, not just the production level. If North Americans *consume* less gas-producing goods and services then that would seem to force a reduction on producers no matter where they are located.

We could unilaterally impose an import tarriff on non-green goods as well.

Your first two questions are kind of tied together. As we increase our pollution controls the cost to manufacture goods in Canada goes up. At some point manufacturers can no longer compete with goods coming in from countries without pollution controls. At this point they will go out of business. Since our consumption of those products is not likely to go down to any great degree one or both of two things is likely to happen. 1) the companies in the non-controlled countries will increase production and/or 2) the owners of the defunct companies in Canada will move their companies to the non-controlled contries. Why do I believe this? How many people worry about whether their shoes and other goods are made with cheap overseas labour?

As to your tariff idea, IMO if Canada is going to persist in forcing tighter and tighter pollution controls on it's industry they will either have to do something like that, or face the destruction of our current standard of living.
 
Yup, he is saying the same thing I've been saying. We don't know what the heck is going on.
 
We do have an impact on our enviroment. Toxic emmisions, clear cutting old growth forests, excessive unbiodegradable waste, nuclear energy itself is quite toxic to our enviroment in ways that will outlive humanity.

I think we forget too easily how fragile our existance here on Earth really is.
 
Eli said:
We do have an impact on our enviroment. Toxic emmisions, clear cutting old growth forests, excessive unbiodegradable waste, nuclear energy itself is quite toxic to our enviroment in ways that will outlive humanity.

I think we forget too easily how fragile our existance here on Earth really is.

The question is how much effect does all that have on global warming. Global warming is inevitable given the history of our planet. Past interglacial periods (the warm time between the ice ages) have been warmer than this one.

Don't forget all those "green" energy sources come with environmental costs too. Solar panels and windmills all wear out at some point. Birds don't do well around windfarms either <grin>
 
Fact: There is a climatic warming trend
Fact: This warming trend is reaching higher average temps. than ever.
Fact: The human population is higher than its ever been.
Fact: This high population is consuming and using more rescorces and creating more waste than ever before.
Fact: "Global warming" is a normal trend in climatics.
Fact: Human influence has amplified the elements that create a warming trend.
Fact: Anyone who believes global warming is a lie is uninformed.
 
Moraff said:
The question is how much effect does all that have on global warming. Global warming is inevitable given the history of our planet. Past interglacial periods (the warm time between the ice ages) have been warmer than this one.

Don't forget all those "green" energy sources come with environmental costs too. Solar panels and windmills all wear out at some point. Birds don't do well around windfarms either <grin>

You always seem to have interesting points in your arguments although I must honestly say you are best at picking apart other's POV on improving our earth as a better place to live in by going green ( in general )

Once and for all, tell us , do you actually believe that we have a global warming crisis at present, or, there is not such a thing as global warming IYO ?

We are all ears.
 
Has anyone taken into account.

1. The sun's output over the ages

2. The planet's ability to self-regulate, it's own cycles and factors beyond man's reach

3. The fact that we only have semi-reliable readings for, at best, 100-150 years and only recently has the scientific equipment become sophisticated enough.

4. We've had ice ages and warmings before man, SUV's and Al Gore

5. Martian ice caps are melting due to solar output.
 
I agree with what you say generally but as an omnipitent godlike being hasn't Al Gore always been around?????:D
 
lonely guy said:
Has anyone taken into account.

1. The sun's output over the ages

2. The planet's ability to self-regulate, it's own cycles and factors beyond man's reach

3. The fact that we only have semi-reliable readings for, at best, 100-150 years and only recently has the scientific equipment become sophisticated enough.

4. We've had ice ages and warmings before man, SUV's and Al Gore

5. Martian ice caps are melting due to solar output.

Yes. That's all taken into account, and the analysis is overwhelmingly that we are causing global warming. By the way, while we have only had reliable thermometers for 100-150 years, there are lots and lots of geological and archeological ways of working out what the global temperature was in the past, so we have a much, much longer record than 100-150 years.
 
Berlin said:
You always seem to have interesting points in your arguments although I must honestly say you are best at picking apart other's POV on improving our earth as a better place to live in by going green ( in general )

Once and for all, tell us , do you actually believe that we have a global warming crisis at present, or, there is not such a thing as global warming IYO ?

We are all ears.

I have never said that there is no such thing as global warming. (Check my post #69 above for the most recent time I've said it). Global warming exists, just as ice ages exist. IMO we're luckier to be heading into a global warming instead of into an ice age.

Do I believe we are in a "crisis"? Not really. In the 70s the majority of scientists were claiming that we were headed into the next ice age and that by 2010 much of Canada would be unable to sustain itself due to the lack of any growing season. Didn't happen.

What I do believe is that if we are in a "crisis" there is nothing we can do to mitigate it's happening, mainly because we have no idea of what the results of our efforts would be.

I object to people grabbing onto scientific theories and computer models and hold them up as uncontrovertible evidence of things to come. Theories and models only suggest and their suggestions are only as good as the initial hypothesis that created them.

Current weather models did not and cannot fortell the El Nino effects that pop up every few years. El Ninos are huge weather influencers and our computer models cannot tell us when they will occur and how big their influence will be. And yet these same models are supposed to be able to predict the weather centuries ahead accurately?

Computer models cannot tell us whether or not the Earth's skies would contain more or less clouds as global warming progresses. More clouds -> more of the sun's heat reflected away -> global warming trend lessens.

I'm sorry that you think my best efforts lie in only wrecking people's POV on green earth efforts. I believe I try to confine my efforts to those making comments that I perceive as being flawed. Forcing polluting companies to close here, but then continue to buy the products once produced by those companies from companies located in countries w/o pollution controls is not an answer. Any policy that does not have the world's 100% compliance cannot be a global answer.

Too many people seem to feel that we could get rid of all non-green energy sources if everyone switched to solar panels, hydro-electric and wind power. Unfortunately the technology is not that far advanced yet.

It does not matter what direction we go in, there are costs yet the loudest proponents of green would have us follow them without considering the costs.

Closing down Ontario's coal fired generator plants before we have replaced the lost generating capacity with something that has a better cost/benefit ratio is nuts unless you enjoy rolling blackouts.

The costs of solar power are much higher in Canada than in more southern countries due to the lesser amount of sunlight we receive.

By all means let's go green, but in a sane and sustainable manner. The DriveClean program, even though it has some flaws, is an example of what I mean. Before the politicians warped it the intent of the program was to get people to switch to cleaner vehicles but also to give them some time to accomplish it. They could have said "any vehicle not meeting our standard is immediately banned from use." Which would have created a huge amount of havoc and hardship. Instead it was "if you don't pass you have to spend a max. of x$ to get a conditional pass". What should have happened was that the x$ should have gotten higher each year so that people would either fix their vehicles or get rid of them. And before the flames start, yes I know there are technical problems with the program too.

Hamilton's decision to go to a 3-bag/week garbage system is another good green decision. People will become accustomed to getting better and better at separating blue and green box-acceptable waste from their trash. Next step: reduce it to a 1-bag/week. Gradual improvement, but much less harsh than going from anything to 1 in 1 step.

So yes, I support green, but not at the expense of our standard of living.

Sorry if I've rambled on, I'm a bit tuckered from shoveling all this darn snow.
 
blackdog said:
Fact: There is a climatic warming trend

Agreed.

blackdog said:
Fact: This warming trend is reaching higher average temps. than ever.

False. The last four interglacial periods were all warmer than we currently trending to.


blackdog said:
Fact: The human population is higher than its ever been.
Fact: This high population is consuming and using more rescorces and creating more waste than ever before.

Agreed, but we are also doing more to try and alter our ways than ever before as well.

blackdog said:
Fact: "Global warming" is a normal trend in climatics.

Agreed.

blackdog said:
Fact: Human influence has amplified the elements that create a warming trend.

Agreed, but to what extent? If I hold my hand up vertically outside of a moving car's window I can state that I am increasing the car's drag, but how much affect am I really having?

blackdog said:
Fact: Anyone who believes global warming is a lie is uninformed.

Agreed.
 
fuji said:
Yes. That's all taken into account, and the analysis is overwhelmingly that we are causing global warming. By the way, while we have only had reliable thermometers for 100-150 years, there are lots and lots of geological and archeological ways of working out what the global temperature was in the past, so we have a much, much longer record than 100-150 years.

Causing? No way

Contributing? Yes, but I disagree that we have any idea on how much or what effect it will have.
 
There is no use in calculating exactly how much we have contributed to global warming. There is a great deal of value in just admitting that we are part of the warming trend then, take steps to change our ways. It does not help to turn the issue into a polarized political argument that is nothing more than left vs.right wing mastribation. If you stick a cupped hand out of a Lotus at 260kms per hour it will make a measurable amount of drag. If you do the same in a cube van at 60kms per hour the difference would be nominal. But, this is not theory, its real. So poeple should shut the fuck up and try to solve the problem.
P.S. The interglaciel periods had warmer spikes, but the average temp was never at this level, and never climbing so quickly. The cycles are natural, but we are making them more extreme. Im gonna call a hooker now.
 
blackdog said:
There is no use in calculating exactly how much we have contributed to global warming. There is a great deal of value in just admitting that we are part of the warming trend then, take steps to change our ways. It does not help to turn the issue into a polarized political argument that is nothing more than left vs.right wing mastribation. If you stick a cupped hand out of a Lotus at 260kms per hour it will make a measurable amount of drag. If you do the same in a cube van at 60kms per hour the difference would be nominal. But, this is not theory, its real. So poeple should shut the fuck up and try to solve the problem.
P.S. The interglaciel periods had warmer spikes, but the average temp was never at this level, and never climbing so quickly. The cycles are natural, but we are making them more extreme. Im gonna call a hooker now.

Holy Crap



You should see a physic
 
Moraff said:
I have never said that there is no such thing as global warming. (Check my post #69 above for the most recent time I've said it). Global warming exists, just as ice ages exist. IMO we're luckier to be heading into a global warming instead of into an ice age.

Do I believe we are in a "crisis"? Not really. In the 70s the majority of scientists were claiming that we were headed into the next ice age and that by 2010 much of Canada would be unable to sustain itself due to the lack of any growing season. Didn't happen.

What I do believe is that if we are in a "crisis" there is nothing we can do to mitigate it's happening, mainly because we have no idea of what the results of our efforts would be.

I object to people grabbing onto scientific theories and computer models and hold them up as uncontrovertible evidence of things to come. Theories and models only suggest and their suggestions are only as good as the initial hypothesis that created them.

Current weather models did not and cannot fortell the El Nino effects that pop up every few years. El Ninos are huge weather influencers and our computer models cannot tell us when they will occur and how big their influence will be. And yet these same models are supposed to be able to predict the weather centuries ahead accurately?

Computer models cannot tell us whether or not the Earth's skies would contain more or less clouds as global warming progresses. More clouds -> more of the sun's heat reflected away -> global warming trend lessens.

I'm sorry that you think my best efforts lie in only wrecking people's POV on green earth efforts. I believe I try to confine my efforts to those making comments that I perceive as being flawed. Forcing polluting companies to close here, but then continue to buy the products once produced by those companies from companies located in countries w/o pollution controls is not an answer. Any policy that does not have the world's 100% compliance cannot be a global answer.

Too many people seem to feel that we could get rid of all non-green energy sources if everyone switched to solar panels, hydro-electric and wind power. Unfortunately the technology is not that far advanced yet.

It does not matter what direction we go in, there are costs yet the loudest proponents of green would have us follow them without considering the costs.

Closing down Ontario's coal fired generator plants before we have replaced the lost generating capacity with something that has a better cost/benefit ratio is nuts unless you enjoy rolling blackouts.

The costs of solar power are much higher in Canada than in more southern countries due to the lesser amount of sunlight we receive.

By all means let's go green, but in a sane and sustainable manner. The DriveClean program, even though it has some flaws, is an example of what I mean. Before the politicians warped it the intent of the program was to get people to switch to cleaner vehicles but also to give them some time to accomplish it. They could have said "any vehicle not meeting our standard is immediately banned from use." Which would have created a huge amount of havoc and hardship. Instead it was "if you don't pass you have to spend a max. of x$ to get a conditional pass". What should have happened was that the x$ should have gotten higher each year so that people would either fix their vehicles or get rid of them. And before the flames start, yes I know there are technical problems with the program too.

Hamilton's decision to go to a 3-bag/week garbage system is another good green decision. People will become accustomed to getting better and better at separating blue and green box-acceptable waste from their trash. Next step: reduce it to a 1-bag/week. Gradual improvement, but much less harsh than going from anything to 1 in 1 step.

So yes, I support green, but not at the expense of our standard of living.

Sorry if I've rambled on, I'm a bit tuckered from shoveling all this darn snow.



So would it be fair to say that you support green but will not change the way that you have been living all along ?

At the expense of standard of living ? How can you be so sure that the way we have been living, consuming, is the proper one ?

You see, the problem I see in your argument is that you don't , as you stated, see that there is a global crisis there, where as most others see it . It's like folks who believed the earth is flat arguing with the round globe believers, ain't going any where.

Anyway, as I said, you brought up interesting perspectives, but are they relevant ? I'll let others judge for themselves.
 
Why should I see a "physic"? On the other hand i've always wanted to meet Kreskin.