Global Warming for Dummies

May 3, 2006?!?!
You may want to keep up with current events.
As in, cabinet shuffles? What those might mean?
Here, I'll break it down - AMBROSE HAS BEEN RELIEVED BY HER OWN PM.
Sheesh.
LOL
But, no, by all means. Keep believing that we're not altering the earth's climate. That seems the reasonable course of action.
:rolleyes:
 
and:

In adopting Kyoto, the previous Liberal government pledged that Canada would reduce its greenhouse gas emissions by six per cent below 1990 levels by the five-year commitment period of 2008 to 2012. Canada’s 2002 climate change plan committed the country to cut greenhouse gas emissions by 240 million tonnes a year by the end of 2012. It proposes a three-stage strategy to achieve that goal through a combination of incentives, regulations and tax measures.

On March 31, 2006, environment minister Rona Ambrose told a Vancouver audience that since ratifying Kyoto, Canada's "greenhouse gas emissions are up by 24 per cent – a far cry from the previous government's commitment to meet a target six per cent below the 1990 levels."

http://www.cbc.ca/news/background/kyoto/timeline.html

OTB
 
By the terms of Kyoto, countries are permitted to NOT meet those emissions levels, by means of credits - contributions to other, mostly poorer nations to help them.
As I said, reading lessons are obviously required. Have you even read the treaty, or are you talking out the hole in your ass?
Again, quoting AMBROSE who has been fired, essentially, does NOTHING to support your argument. Nor does posting articles from almost a year ago.
Anything else?
 
Ranger68 said:
May 3, 2006?!?!
You may want to keep up with current events.
As in, cabinet shuffles? What those might mean?
Here, I'll break it down - AMBROSE HAS BEEN RELIEVED BY HER OWN PM.
Sheesh.
LOL
But, no, by all means. Keep believing that we're not altering the earth's climate. That seems the reasonable course of action.
:rolleyes:

I've not said we're not altering the earth's climate, I've just said you can't walk out your door and make that determination because there is no snow on the ground in NY. You also can't sign treaties and do nothing, and then lecture your neighbor - that doesn't seem to be working either.

I think it's pretty clear that we're changing the environment (how much and how fast is probably up to debate) and we lack the political will to change that fact.

And it's going to get a fair bit worse. Take rapidly growing (and dirty) China for instance:

China has 16 of 20 most polluted cities

Deforestation has turned a quarter of the country into desert

With a tenth of the cars Beijing pumps out as much carbon monoxide as LA & Tokyo combined.

Why would anyone try and solve this problem without China on board.

OTB
 
Ranger68 said:
By the terms of Kyoto, countries are permitted to NOT meet those emissions levels, by means of credits - contributions to other, mostly poorer nations to help them.
As I said, reading lessons are obviously required. Have you even read the treaty, or are you talking out the hole in your ass?
Again, quoting AMBROSE who has been fired, essentially, does NOTHING to support your argument. Nor does posting articles from almost a year ago.
Anything else?

Like this better?

http://www.davidsuzuki.org/Climate_Change/Kyoto/Canadian_Emissions.asp

You're attacking the sources, not the facts.

OTB

P.S. I do like this one: http://climatechange.gc.ca/default.asp
 
onthebottom said:
I've not said we're not altering the earth's climate, I've just said you can't walk out your door and make that determination because there is no snow on the ground in NY. You also can't sign treaties and do nothing, and then lecture your neighbor - that doesn't seem to be working either.
Canada isn't doing nothing. To say so is just argumentum ad hominem, nothing more, nothing less. The US hasn't even SIGNED Kyoto. THAT'S how much they care. Period. Canada remains committed to fulfilling its treaty obligations one way or the other.

onthebottom said:
I think it's pretty clear that we're changing the environment (how much and how fast is probably up to debate) and we lack the political will to change that fact.
Clearly, the US lacks the political will.

onthebottom said:
And it's going to get a fair bit worse. Take rapidly growing (and dirty) China for instance:

China has 16 of 20 most polluted cities

Deforestation has turned a quarter of the country into desert

With a tenth of the cars Beijing pumps out as much carbon monoxide as LA & Tokyo combined.

Why would anyone try and solve this problem without China on board.

OTB
Fuck, man, again, you REALLY need to read the treaty.
The treaty accommodates, specifically, China and India, and indicates that they are to be "on board" in the next round of negotiations. The treaty, as is, is admittedly a first step. One the US has yet to take.
But, I can understand why they haven't - what with their economy on the edge of a precipice, and spending as much as most of the rest of the world on the military - I mean, I can see why they don't want to spend any money to make a difference with regards to the environment.
It's really pretty clear.
 
onthebottom said:
Like this better?

http://www.davidsuzuki.org/Climate_Change/Kyoto/Canadian_Emissions.asp

You're attacking the sources, not the facts.

OTB

P.S. I do like this one: http://climatechange.gc.ca/default.asp

Yeah, I DO like that.
From Suzuki:
"Despite our high consumption, research shows that Canadians are eager to adopt clean, renewable energy technologies. The good news is that these technologies are available now, and are becoming more affordable each year. Many Canadians also realizing that cutting energy use can mean substantial savings."
May want to read more carefully next time. ;) But, that doesn't seem to be your strong point.

Dude, you REALLY need to read the treaty. How can you even pretend to have an intelligent discussion about it without having done so?
Stop surfing Google for arguments that you think back up your position, and give it some thought.
Let me know when you've done so.
 
Ranger68 said:
Yeah, I DO like that.
From Suzuki:
"Despite our high consumption, research shows that Canadians are eager to adopt clean, renewable energy technologies. The good news is that these technologies are available now, and are becoming more affordable each year. Many Canadians also realizing that cutting energy use can mean substantial savings."
May want to read more carefully next time. ;) But, that doesn't seem to be your strong point.

Dude, you REALLY need to read the treaty. How can you even pretend to have an intelligent discussion about it without having done so?
Stop surfing Google for arguments that you think back up your position, and give it some thought.
Let me know when you've done so.


Ah, so all you have to be is eager.....

LOL

Action optional.

So, you've not bothered to dispute a single fact. Educate me, the government site isn't going to..... I don't read treaties.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
Ah, so all you have to be is eager.....

LOL

Action optional.

Again, the same old tired straw man.
Fact is, Canada has committed to Kyoto and is going to work to implement its obligations. That's a fact.
And the US is doing ..... ? Fuck all? Yeah, I thought so.

onthebottom said:
So, you've not bothered to dispute a single fact. Educate me, the government site isn't going to..... I don't read treaties.
OTB
You haven't posted any facts. Just links to web sites that aren't relevant or don't support your position.

It's really simple. You're arguing against Kyoto, which you haven't even read. I've tried to educate you. You're unwilling to learn. Doesn't that smack of being an idiot to you?

You're, plain and simple, one of those fools who refuses to accept the obvious until EVERY DISSENTING OPINION is silenced. You're not going to accept the MAJORITY of the science on the position, because you can find some supporters of the other side, and that let's you live your life more comfortably, while attacking those trying to do something about it. You have no evidence that Canada is failing to meet its treaty obligations, other than outdated statements from a minister who's just been fired. lol That's pretty poor. I've given you an opportunity to present any shred of a fact or argument, and you've failed to do so. Which means, you have nothing else.
So, I'll say good night.
Let me know when you've educated yourself by reading the treaty,then we can talk about it's good and bad points. Until then, you're just another Google genius.
 
Ranger68 said:
Again, the same old tired straw man.
Fact is, Canada has committed to Kyoto and is going to work to implement its obligations. That's a fact.
And the US is doing ..... ? Fuck all? Yeah, I thought so.

I think there is doubt about if Canada will meet it's obligations, it's certainly not on the path to doing so. There are even reports of the US making more progress outside of Kyoto, but that would conflict with your "Fuck all" .


Ranger68 said:
You haven't posted any facts. Just links to web sites that aren't relevant or don't support your position.

It's really simple. You're arguing against Kyoto, which you haven't even read. I've tried to educate you. You're unwilling to learn. Doesn't that smack of being an idiot to you?

You're, plain and simple, one of those fools who refuses to accept the obvious until EVERY DISSENTING OPINION is silenced. You're not going to accept the MAJORITY of the science on the position, because you can find some supporters of the other side, and that let's you live your life more comfortably, while attacking those trying to do something about it. You have no evidence that Canada is failing to meet its treaty obligations, other than outdated statements from a minister who's just been fired. lol That's pretty poor. I've given you an opportunity to present any shred of a fact or argument, and you've failed to do so. Which means, you have nothing else.
So, I'll say good night.
Let me know when you've educated yourself by reading the treaty,then we can talk about it's good and bad points. Until then, you're just another Google genius.

I've not argued that Global Warming isn't happening. I've argued that anecdotal evidence is silly. I've argued that the world lacks real (as opposed to show) resolve to address the issue.

What would reading the treaty alone do, it would tell me what Canada is suppose to do (reduce green house gases to below 1990 levels) not what it's actually done or even more importantly what it's likely to do to achieve it's results.

You have offered no contrary view, just insults and the single argument that I've not read the treaty - which is silly.

OTB
 
Ah, okay, so now there are "doubts" about Canada meeting its commitments? LOL So, perhaps we'd best wait and see, hmm? ;)

I'm sorry that you think the argument that you haven't read the treaty you're supposedly debating is "silly".

P.S. Perhaps you should read some of those links you posted a bit more closely - Suzuki's comes to mind. LOL
 
Ranger68 said:
Fuck, man, again, you REALLY need to read the treaty.
The treaty accommodates, specifically, China and India, and indicates that they are to be "on board" in the next round of negotiations. The treaty, as is, is admittedly a first step.

Rather than reading you should take a trip to China. I have. They don't give a crap about the environment. It is total and utter environmental and infrastructure chaos, NOW. Nevermind Greenhouse gases, the rivers are so bad that it is a crisis.

Just imagine what happens in the next 5 years when the average Chinese people are just burning to upgrade their lifestyle ie.: cars, TVs, air conditioning, washing machine, clothes dryer..... Multiplied times a few 100 million makes the greenhouse gases in NA seem like nothing.
This is not something you can fix in 5 or 10 years.

China will give lip service to Kyoto, but will not adhere to it. It is unfortunate, but China just does what they want. Just like they do with their currency or copying anything and everything with total disregard to patents....
 
Last edited:
Meister said:
Rather than reading you should take a trip to China. I have. They don't give a crap about the environment. It is total and utter environmental and infrastructure chaos, NOW. Nevermind Greenhouse gases, the rivers are so bad that it is a crisis.

Just imagine what happens in the next 5 years when the average Chinese people are just burning to upgrade their lifestyle ie.: cars, TVs, air conditioning, washing machine, clothes dryer..... Multiplied times a few 100 million makes the greenhouse gases in NA seem like nothing.
This is not something you can't fix in 5 or 10 years.

China will give lip service to Kyoto, but will not adhere to it. It is unfortunate, but China just does what they want. Just like they do with their currency or copying anything and everything with total disregard to patents....

I just read that China is now estimated to surpass the US in emissions by 2009, ten years earlier than recently thought...... I'd say you're spot on.

OTB