Global Warming for Dummies

sparty86

Banned
Dec 19, 2005
173
0
0
Two Sides to Global Warming
Is it proven fact, or just conventional wisdom?
Ronald Bailey


During more than 15 years of reporting on climate change science and policy, I have watched climatology become increasingly politicized. Most headlines and publicized scientific reports confirm that humanity is heating up the planet by burning fossil fuels that load the atmosphere with heat-trapping carbon dioxide.

Take just two reports from the last week. The Arctic Climate Impact Assessment report from the Arctic Council found that Arctic warming is increasing twice as fast as elsewhere on the planet. This finding corresponds nicely with predictions made by various computer climate models that forecast that the poles should be warming faster than the rest of the planet.

Another new study from the journal Nature that seems to confirm this prediction finds that krill are declining in the frigid oceans around Antarctica. Why? Evidently because the sea ice is declining, and krill live on the algae that live and grow on the underside of the sea ice.

These reports are confirming what the majority of climate scientists have been saying—that man-made global warming is occurring at a rapid rate.

Well, maybe. Once a particular notion becomes conventional wisdom, evidence and stories confirming that conventional wisdom are easily accepted and published—and reported in the media. Those that contradict the prevailing views have a much harder time getting a hearing. Either global warming has hardened into conventional wisdom in the climatological community, or mounting scientific evidence shows that humanity is in fact warming the world at a dangerous pace.

Which is it and how can one tell?

To show how hard answering that question can be, let's take a little closer look at the two reports mentioned above. The Arctic Council report is based on the observations and deliberations of 300 scientists from eight countries and six groups of indigenous people over the past four years. They find that the Arctic region is warming at twice the rate of the rest of the world. They further find that the sea ice that covers the Arctic Ocean is thinning, and could almost disappear in the summer months by 2100.

But University of Alabama at Huntsville climatologist John Christy, a climate expert on whom I have relied for years, makes some interesting observations about the Arctic Council's report. "If you look at the long term records, the Arctic has been as warm or warmer than it is today," says Christy. He cites temperature data from the Hadley Centre in the UK showing that from 70 degrees north latitude to the pole, the warmest years on record in the Arctic were 1937 and 1938. This area is just slightly above the Arctic Circle.

Furthermore, those same records show that the Arctic warmed twice as fast between 1917 and 1937 as it has in the past 20 years. After 1940, the Arctic saw a big cool-down and climatologists noted sea ice expanding in the northern Atlantic. Christy argues that what he calls the Great Climate Shift occurred in the late 1970s and caused another sudden warming in the Arctic. Since the late 1970s there has not been much additional warming in the region at all. In fact, on page 23, the Arctic Council Assessment offers very similar data for Arctic temperature trends from 60 degrees north latitude—the area that includes most of Alaska and essentially all of Greenland, most of Norway and Sweden, and the bulk of Russia.

Interestingly, the recent increase in temperatures in Alaska and Siberia seem to have coincided almost simultaneously with a shift in the Pacific Decadal Oscillation (PDO) in the late 1970s. Could this be part of Christy's Great Climate Shift? Swings in the PDO occur on 30 to 40 year time frames, and the most recent one brought warmer currents flowing north to the coast of Alaska. The Assessment does note that "several important natural modes of variability that especially affect the Arctic have been identified, including the Arctic Oscillation, the Pacific Decadal Oscillation, and the North Atlantic Oscillation. Each of these can affect the regional patterns of such features as the intensity and tracks of storm systems, the direction of prevailing winds, the amount of snow, and the extent of sea ice."

The Arctic Council report states that satellite measurements find the area over which ice melts in the summer in Greenland increased 16 percent between 1979 and 2002. Should the ice cap in Greenland completely melt away, sea levels would rise seven meters or so, inundating Florida, New York City, London, and Bangladesh. Not an immediate worry, since this process even with extreme warming would take centuries.

But what to make of the report earlier this year in the scientific journal Climate Change by Petr Chylek and his colleagues from the Los Alamos Laboratory, which found that average temperatures in Greenland have been falling at the rather steep rate of 2.2 degrees Celsius since 1987?

In addition, the study found "summer temperatures, which are most relevant to Greenland ice sheet melting rates, do not show any persistent increase during the last fifty years." Strangely, when I searched the Assessment I could not find any reference to the Chylek team's study of Greenland temperature trends.

What about the report on the Antarctic krill? The shrimp-like krill are the foundation of the food chain in the oceans around Antarctica, being dined upon by whales, seals, fish, and penguins. The report finds that krill populations off the Antarctic Peninsula have declined by 80 to 90 percent in recent years. The study in Nature notes that the extent of winter sea ice has been declining near the Antarctic Peninsula, where temperatures have increased by 2.5 degrees Celsius over the past 50 years.

But again, the picture is complicated. Overall winter sea ice around Antarctica has been increasing since 1979. However, Antarctica experienced a very rapid decline in winter sea ice in the early 1970s and the area covered today is not quite as large as it was before the decline in the 1970s.

But the average temperatures for most of Antarctica outside of the Antarctic Peninsula have been declining since the mid-1960s. So is this evidence that the amount of warming predicted by computer climate models is wrong? Not so fast, say even some climatologists who report on the Antarctic cooling. They insist that their data do not overturn predictions of rapid global warming. Richard Lindzen, a climatologist from MIT and a global warming skeptic, points out, "the Antarctic is not warming and there is nothing in the models that distinguish the temperature trends they predict in the Arctic from those in the Antarctic." Climate is messy.

With so many researchers in the climatological community apparently convinced of the reality of dangerously rapid man-made climate change, why do I continue to rely so much on the skeptical Christy? Christy is the climatologist who has put together the highly accurate atmospheric temperature data from satellites since 1978. And confidence in his data is bolstered by the fact that they correlate nicely with temperature data from radiosondes, which are a completely independent measure of temperature. Christy's data show that since 1978 the planet is warming up at a rate of 0.08 degrees Celsius per decade. The Arctic, according to Christy's data, is indeed warming faster than the rest of the planet, at a rate of 0.39 per decade. But the Antarctic is cooling by 0.12 degrees Celsius per decade.

For the nationalistic, Christy's satellite data find that the lower 48 states of the U.S. are warming at a rate of 0.07 degrees per decade. If temperatures continue to increase by 0.08 degrees Celsius per decade, the planet will warm by 0.8 degrees Celsius by the end of the century. That compares to an increase of 0.6 degrees Celsius during the 20th century. Not much of a crisis. Richard Lindzen says he's willing to take bets that global average temperatures in 20 years will in fact be lower than they are now.

So is dangerous rapid global warming merely the new conventional wisdom—or a credible forecast of our climatic future? There's plenty of evidence for both positions, and I'll keep reporting the data and the controversy.

Ronald Bailey is Reason's science correspondent. His new book, Liberation Biology: A Moral and Scientific Defense of the Biotech Revolution will be published in early 2005.

http://www.reason.com/rb/rb111004.shtml
 
Its only going down to plus 3 degrees Celsius tonight, tomorrow its going up to plus 7.
Obviously this is global warming!!!

When my parents moved here in the 70's they said every winter the snow would be waist high and many days were -20C, whens the last time Toronto got weather like that??????
 
As these the same climatologist that predicted the most horrific hurricane season for 2007???????

Maybe these folks could explain what happened to the ICE AGE before that predict the future.
 
It was very interesting to actually read a balanced article from someone who is knowledgeable and has access to data but still isn't sure what to believe.
 
Esco! said:
Its only going down to plus 3 degrees Celsius tonight, tomorrow its going up to plus 7.
Obviously this is global warming!!!

??????

Tell that to the people in Denver.
 
shack said:
It was very interesting to actually read a balanced article from someone who is knowledgeable and has access to data but still isn't sure what to believe.
Agree. Thanks for posting the article sparty86.
 
Esco! said:
Just because they had one week of snow doesnt prove the Global warming theory wrong
From the guy who claims two weeks weather is proof of the warming.
 
global warming speaks louder then words

waiting for a melting pot ?

A giant ice shelf the size of 11,000 football fields has snapped free from Canada's Arctic, scientists said.That has been in place for 3000 years .


Even 10 years ago scientists assumed that when global warming changes occur that it would happen gradually so that perhaps we expected these ice shelves just to melt away quite slowly, but the big surprise is that for one they are going, but secondly that when they do go, they just go suddenly, it's all at once, in a span of an hour."

"This is a dramatic and disturbing event. It shows that we are losing remarkable features of the Canadian North that have been in place for many thousands of years. We are crossing climate thresholds, and these may signal the onset of accelerated change ahead," Vincent said Thursday.


http://www.cnn.com/2006/TECH/science/12/29/canada.arctic.ap/index.html
 
sparty86 said:
Two Sides to Global Warming
Is it proven fact, or just conventional wisdom?
Ronald Bailey


During more than 15 years of reporting on climate change science and policy, I have watched climatology become increasingly politicized. Most headlines and publicized scientific reports confirm that humanity is heating up the planet by burning fossil fuels that load the atmosphere with heat-trapping carbon dioxide.

Take just two reports from the last week. The Arctic Climate Impact Assessment report from the Arctic Council found that Arctic warming is increasing twice as fast as elsewhere on the planet. This finding corresponds nicely with predictions made by various computer climate models that forecast that the poles should be warming faster than the rest of the planet.

Another new study from the journal Nature that seems to confirm this prediction finds that krill are declining in the frigid oceans around Antarctica. Why? Evidently because the sea ice is declining, and krill live on the algae that live and grow on the underside of the sea ice......
http://www.reason.com/rb/rb111004.shtml


The dissenting climatologist in that article, John Christy, seems to have slowly backtracked from his earlier position on climate change. He is a maverick whose interpretations of satellite date have been called questionable or even discredited:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Christy

Dr. John Christy is a climate scientist whose chief interests are Global Climate Change, Satellite Sensing of Global Climate, and Paleoclimate. He is best known, jointly with Dr. Roy Spencer, for his version of the satellite temperature record. He is a professor of atmospheric science and director of the Earth System Science Center at the University of Alabama in Huntsville (UAH). He was a key contributor to several IPCC reports, participating with lead authors in the drafting sessions, and in the detailed review of the scientific text. He was appointed Alabama's State Climatologist in 2000.

Christy is generally considered a contrarian on some global warming and related issues, although he helped draft and signed the American Geophysical Union statement on climate change [1].


More recently, in an interview with National Public Radio about the new AGU statement, he said:

"It is scientifically inconceivable that after changing forests into cities, turning millions of acres into farmland, putting massive quantities of soot and dust into the atmosphere and sending quantities of greenhouse gases into the air, that the natural course of climate change hasn't been increased in the past century." [2]
Christy has also said that while he supports the AGU declaration, and is convinced that human activities are a cause of the global warming that has been measured, he is "still a strong critic of scientists who make catastrophic predictions of huge increases in global temperatures and tremendous rises in sea levels."...
Christy became famous as early as 1993 for claiming the global temperature was actually decreasing based on the "more accurate" satellite data. But others over the years have shown errors in his interpretation of the data which has slowly and consistently increased his results. This is in addition to the improving accuracy of the short data set [4] (it begins in December 1978). In 1997 his testimony to the Committee on Environment and Public Works pointed out that his (and Dr. Roy Spencer's) data indicated a decrease in global temperature. Before the same committee in 2001, he stated it was at an increase that was "a rate less than a third that observed at the surface" at 0.045 C/decade and it showed "remarkable consistency between independent measurements [by radiosonde] of these upper air temperatures". In 2003 before the U.S. House Committee on Resources he stated his data was "less than half of the warming observed at the surface." In 2004 his published results showed a 0.08 C/decade increase. A new error in his interpretation of the data found in 2005 has now increased his results by 60% in only a year to 0.13 C/decade but he still claims "all radiosonde comparisons have been rerun and the agreement is still exceptionally good" [5] as was claimed in 2001 when his results were 1/3 as high as now.
 
slowpoke said:
The dissenting climatologist in that article, John Christy, seems to have slowly backtracked from his earlier position on climate change. He is a maverick whose interpretations of satellite date have been called questionable or even discredited:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Christy

Dr. John Christy is a climate scientist whose chief interests are Global Climate Change, Satellite Sensing of Global Climate, and Paleoclimate. He is best known, jointly with Dr. Roy Spencer, for his version of the satellite temperature record. He is a professor of atmospheric science and director of the Earth System Science Center at the University of Alabama in Huntsville (UAH). He was a key contributor to several IPCC reports, participating with lead authors in the drafting sessions, and in the detailed review of the scientific text. He was appointed Alabama's State Climatologist in 2000.

Christy is generally considered a contrarian on some global warming and related issues, although he helped draft and signed the American Geophysical Union statement on climate change [1].


More recently, in an interview with National Public Radio about the new AGU statement, he said:

"It is scientifically inconceivable that after changing forests into cities, turning millions of acres into farmland, putting massive quantities of soot and dust into the atmosphere and sending quantities of greenhouse gases into the air, that the natural course of climate change hasn't been increased in the past century." [2]
Christy has also said that while he supports the AGU declaration, and is convinced that human activities are a cause of the global warming that has been measured, he is "still a strong critic of scientists who make catastrophic predictions of huge increases in global temperatures and tremendous rises in sea levels."...
Christy became famous as early as 1993 for claiming the global temperature was actually decreasing based on the "more accurate" satellite data. But others over the years have shown errors in his interpretation of the data which has slowly and consistently increased his results. This is in addition to the improving accuracy of the short data set [4] (it begins in December 1978). In 1997 his testimony to the Committee on Environment and Public Works pointed out that his (and Dr. Roy Spencer's) data indicated a decrease in global temperature. Before the same committee in 2001, he stated it was at an increase that was "a rate less than a third that observed at the surface" at 0.045 C/decade and it showed "remarkable consistency between independent measurements [by radiosonde] of these upper air temperatures". In 2003 before the U.S. House Committee on Resources he stated his data was "less than half of the warming observed at the surface." In 2004 his published results showed a 0.08 C/decade increase. A new error in his interpretation of the data found in 2005 has now increased his results by 60% in only a year to 0.13 C/decade but he still claims "all radiosonde comparisons have been rerun and the agreement is still exceptionally good" [5] as was claimed in 2001 when his results were 1/3 as high as now.



so as the title of this thread implies you agree?
 
Esco! said:
Its only going down to plus 3 degrees Celsius tonight, tomorrow its going up to plus 7.
Obviously this is global warming!!!

When my parents moved here in the 70's they said every winter the snow would be waist high and many days were -20C, whens the last time Toronto got weather like that??????

Don't know exactly what part of the City your parents lived in but I lived in Toronto in the 70s and don't recall waist high snow and many days that were -20c. Yea, there were the winters of 76/77 and 77/78......the so-called experts were saying it was the start of another Ice Age. 1982 was a winter similar to this years.

I think the answer is somewhere in the middle. What's gonna happen when China goes from under 1% of the population using vehicles to 25 or 50%......
I like the term "Climate Change" as opposed to "Global Warming".

Being a bit of a weather buff, alot of what the original poster has mentioned makes sense.
 
Macator2003 said:
Don't know exactly what part of the City your parents lived in but I lived in Toronto in the 70s and don't recall waist high snow and many days that were -20c. Yea, there were the winters of 76/77 and 77/78......the so-called experts were saying it was the start of another Ice Age. 1982 was a winter similar to this years.

I think the answer is somewhere in the middle. What's gonna happen when China goes from under 1% of the population using vehicles to 25 or 50%......
I like the term "Climate Change" as opposed to "Global Warming".

Being a bit of a weather buff, alot of what the original poster has mentioned makes sense.
Snow was up to his hips at 36 inches tall. We hold our memories but not the reality
 
papasmerf said:
so as the title of this thread implies you agree?

The title of this thread is "Global Warming for Dummies". I don't see anything in that title that implies anything at all about me agreeing with whatever it is you're talking about. Maybe try your question again in English.
 
slowpoke said:
The title of this thread is "Global Warming for Dummies". I don't see anything in that title that implies anything at all about me agreeing with whatever it is you're talking about. Maybe try your question again in English.

maybe you should quit trying to imply you know more then others and admit you know only what you are told.

Does that help???
 
Macator2003 said:
Don't know exactly what part of the City your parents lived in but I lived in Toronto in the 70s and don't recall waist high snow and many days that were -20c. Yea, there were the winters of 76/77 and 77/78......the so-called experts were saying it was the start of another Ice Age. 1982 was a winter similar to this years.
Funny thing is I just got back from Montreal last month and they're saying the same thing there.
There was almost no snow on the ground, highly unusual for the month of December, and their winters are becoming much milder the last 20 years.
 
Esco! said:
Funny thing is I just got back from Montreal last month and they're saying the same thing there.
There was almost no snow on the ground, highly unusual for the month of December, and their winters are becoming much milder the last 20 years.

GOTS to love EL NINIA!!!!!!!!

But don't tell the PNW that
 
What is the big deal??

I will be dead long before the prairie becomes desert & the great lakes become the Great Ponds

My parents, grandparents, great grandparents and so on never worried about it, nor will I. They contributed to it and I feel it is my right to contribute to global warming as well.

btw.. I do not bother recycling either.. everything goes in the trash!

Just wait until the economies in China and India pick up and really start contributing to greenhouse gas emissions!!