Global Warming for Dummies

The science debate behind climate change
Forecasting the future remains a contentious exercise
By Michael Coren
CNN






(CNN) -- Is global warming really a threat?

Absolutely, respond most scientists, but they have only recently been able to approach a basic agreement about our changing climate.

First, the Earth has gotten warmer. Since 1850, average global temperatures have risen about .6 degrees Celsius, the United Nations says. Greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide released by humans burning fossil fuels and clearing land are the likely culprits. Sea levels have also risen about 4 to 8 inches during the past century, according to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.

Second, the concentration of greenhouse gases (or GHG) in the atmosphere is near its highest point in recorded history. Since the Industrial Revolution, concentrations of carbon dioxide, a potent greenhouse gas, have risen 30 percent.

Based on studies of air bubbles trapped in ancient ice, today's levels are higher than any time in at least 420,000 years, said David King, chief science adviser for the British government. If GHG concentrations rise, as expected, concentrations could cross what some consider a "dangerous" threshold, although that designation is contentious.

Finally, almost every scientist agrees upon one thing: the future is highly uncertain. While most scientists support projections by the United Nation's Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change that temperatures will rise 1.4 degrees Celsius (2.5 degrees Fahrenheit) to 5.8 degrees Celsius (10.4 degrees Fahrenheit) by 2100, the scientific consensus shows cracks beyond this point. (Clues to climate's future)

John Christy, director of Earth System Science Center and critic of severe warming predictions, says forecasting the future "gets messy quickly."

"The Earth system has more unknowns that we are generally willing to acknowledge," he told CNN via e-mail. "It is very difficult for [scientists] to say, 'I don't have a clue.'...Our pronouncements often express more confidence than is warranted given the level of ignorance in which we presently operate."

Climate models inherit this uncertainty. The first crude models -- spinning aluminum dishpans in the 1950s -- have evolved into some of the world's most sophisticated computer simulations replicating the interaction between the atmosphere, oceans and continents. Yet the system's complexity -- a mathematical swamp of biological cycles, ocean circulation, geologic emissions and even solar activity -- injects guesswork into the science.

Despite the uncertainties, says Drew Shindell, a NASA climate modeler at the Goddard Institute for Space Studies in New York, climate models, at least in the short term, are good and "getting better."

"The results become steadily less reliable as you go out in time," Shindell said. "We can do a pretty good job 25 to 30 years out; we have a rough idea 50 years out. By the time you get into 100 years, there's a lot of things we can't really say."

The biggest questions in the climate equation are water vapor and airborne particles called aerosols. Water vapor acts like a huge sponge soaking up energy absorbed by greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide. It is a wild card for climate modelers because water vapor may also cool the planet by increasing cloud cover. Aerosols -- which can also cool or warm the planet -- may have other unknown effects.

But Shindell says dozens of climate models run by scientists around the world convincingly describe a world sweating under the influence of greenhouse gases which trap the sun's energy.

"I think we can say very clearly, with the same amount of energy going in and less going out, [the Earth] has to warm up," he said. "That's elementary physics."

This growing confidence is the result of progress being made with climate models and deciphering cryptic clues about ancient climate in tree rings, lake sediments and ice cores. Paleo-climate measurements, once unattainable, now offer a record of global temperatures stretching back 750,000 years.

"There is no doubt that humans are warming the planet. That's very clear now," says Jeffrey Severinghaus, a geoscience researcher at the Scripps Institute of Oceanography. "The data is beautiful. It's very strong. Humans are changing the climate, and we're expected to change it a lot more in the future."

Global warming 'alarmists'?
Scientists were not always so convinced.

As early as 1979, the U.S. National Academy of Sciences reported with "high confidence" that a 1.5 to 4.5 degree Celsius temperature increase was likely if carbon dioxide levels doubled. It was greeted by a chorus of skepticism.

However, the past two decades have also seen the retreat of once noisy critics. BP, a major energy company, says it is now taking "precautionary action" against climate change by cutting greenhouse emissions and investing in mitigation of greenhouse gases.

Nonetheless, a minority of scientists reject what they call "alarmist" global warming on scientific grounds. They raise three major objections, which most researchers agree remain troublesome.


Natural climate variability is not well understood and may be greater than once thought.


Computer models are oversimplifications that cannot simulate the complexities of the real climate.


Temperature extrapolations of the past are not precise enough to make dire conclusions about "normal" warming.

Richard Lindzen, a respected meteorologist from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, says in light of these uncertainties, pronouncements about climate change are both self-serving and unscientific.

"Scientists make meaningless or ambiguous statements. Advocates and media translate statements into alarmist declarations. Politicians respond to alarm by feeding scientists more money," said Lindzen at a scientific conference this January. He added that the accepted evidence is "entirely consistent with there being virtually no problem at all."

This sentiment is in the extreme minority of the scientific community, said Richard Sommerville, meteorologist at the Scripps Institution of Oceanography, who drew a parallel with proposing that HIV does not cause AIDS.

"[Lindzen] is taken seriously because he's capable of excellent science," Sommerville said. "[But] most of the scientific community thinks he's mistaken... People are given a fair hearing and then we move on."

New research
Plenty of questionable scientific claims muddy the discussion on climate change. Extreme weather events such as last year's hurricane season in the Atlantic are not conclusively linked to global warming, say scientists at NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center. It is exceedingly difficult to establishing a causal link between global warming and these events.

Even melting glaciers, such as the rapidly receding ice cap on Africa's Mount Kilimanjaro or the collapse of an Antarctic ice shelf, while consistent with climate change, cannot be decisively linked to the phenomenon.

But major studies released this year appear to buttress the the belief the Earth is undergoing significant warming and will continue to do so.

Tim Barnett, a researcher with the Scripps Institute of Oceanography, told the American Association for the Advancement of Science in February that the world's oceans are heating up from the top down. Barnett found the world's six ocean basins show a .5 degree Celsius increase since the 1940s in a pattern that could only be explained by human-induced warming.

An Oxford University report, published in the journal Nature, used computers networked over the Internet to conduct one of the most powerful computer climate simulations ever attempted. It appeared to confirm that predictions of warming of at least 2 degrees Celsius -- and perhaps as high as 11 degrees Celsius -- were possible.

Ultimately, scientists who believe global warming is underway say uncertainties do not undermine the significance of the research.

"When you go to your doctor, and she says you're due for a heart attack, you don't turn around and say medicine is imperfect even if she can't predict the date of your heart attack," Sommerville said. "You take it seriously. I think climate science is in that
 
Esco! said:
Funny thing is I just got back from Montreal last month and they're saying the same thing there.
There was almost no snow on the ground, highly unusual for the month of December, and their winters are becoming much milder the last 20 years.
According to the radio, today was the warmest new years since 1979; not quite 20 years.
 
basketcase said:
According to the radio, today was the warmest new years since 1979; not quite 20 years.
But you have to agree that Toronto winters have become noticably warmer (and drier) over
the past 20 to 30 years, no????
 
papasmerf said:
maybe you should quit trying to imply you know more then others and admit you know only what you are told.

Does that help???

It helps to understand your so-called question but the question itself makes no sense. Finding information and then sharing it does not imply that I know more about certain topics than others. Nobody knows everything. I am the first to admit that I don't know a lot about climatology. Which is why I did a quick check on the scientist whose research claims formed the basis of the article that started this thread. If you have a problem with that, please put me on ignore.
 
I like it how everyone is so concerned about global warming...while driving their V6/V8 SUVs/pick-up/muscle cars/German/American high performance vehicles and flying (ever thought about how much fuel a person/mile uses?) all over the place for "business" or on "vacation", and commuting from the 'burbs an average of 45 min. each and every day (wonder why no one takes the train, or why we don't build more of them?).
The truth is that eventually, we will have an impact...probabaly not in out lifetimes but eventually. All this Global Warming crap is not such an immediate threat as the Environmental Community would have you believe, what we do with our garbage and sewage is much more immediate. Unfortunately, no one would listen to a message that simply says "do all that you can to decrease your environmental footprint"...
We should alll drive 2-4 cylinder cars, ban large trucks (18 wheelers and the like), invest in and promote rail for the movement of both goods and people, live close to work and schools. create neighborhoods and villages NOT suburbs, refuse to buy overpackaged products, ride bicycles, etc.
This real issue is that we need to live on this great earth with much more respect than we have been.
Global warming may or may not be real, but our wasteful, selfish and self centered ways are.
We need industry, commerce, consumergoods and farmland on a grand sacle to support proseperous productive societies, what we don't need is waste and fear mongering.
Global Warming...maybe,
but wasteful nearsighted, closeminded, planning and spending...FOR SURE!
 
LOL

Like Kerry owning 6 SUVs and Gore flying in private jets. A lot of people wanting to talk the talk (Canada included) but not many wanting to walk the walk.

OTB
 
DonQuixote said:
PLEASE, OTB.

After the trash that Bush has thrown into the atmosphere
in Iraq your references to Kerry and Gore are pathetic.

Try a different approach.

$200Million a week for a debacle in Iraq is tragic.
I'd keep references to your Democratic opponents
in check until you clean up your Republican house.

LOL, you're becoming the single note TOVPekkkr.....

OTB
 
DonQuixote said:
NOT. I'm fed up with this continuing divisive
rhetoric. The electorate voted against this
innane divisive mentality. Go write for Rush.
I've had it with this tactic of character
attacks that was spawned by Gingrich and
DeLay. Go piss up a rope. Americans can
do better, and must.

LOL

You've had it with character attacks..... that's a good one. Talk about global warming..... not Bush.

What a laugh.

OTB
 
DonQuixote said:
Bush is POTUS. He pushed for the invasion of Iraq.
I'm not attacking his character, I'm challenging the
insanity of his decisions.

He's the force behind $200million/week in Iraq.
Can you justify that?

Stay on topic, there have only been 2,000 threads on that topic......

Again, a one (off pitch) note tune........

OTB
 
DonQuixote said:
I suggest you stay on topic.
Take your own advice.

You try to turn a global warming thread into yet another anti-war thread and then lecture me on changing topics - Kerry, Gore and DQ.....

OTB
 
DonQuixote said:
A bit paranoid, I'd say.

You brought up Kerry and Gore.
I respond with Bush and you're
guilty mind set turns it into an
anti-War protest.

No. Bush's policies have harmed
the global environment. Wars do
do that, OTB. Recall nuclear warheads.

Not good for the environment. All
weapons and the aircraft that deliver
them are a great threat to the environs
we live in.

Think about it for a moment, OTB.
There are environmental issues in war.

It's personal choice (and economic growth) that's causing global warming, not a war in Iraq (or Afghanistan). We have hundreds of ships plowing through oceans, thousands of jets flying missions..... with or without a war in Iraq.

I don't remember anyone popping off a nuclear warhead in the last few decades - except the French.....

OTB
 
DonQuixote said:
You've got to be yanking my chain or you're totally
naieve. Then again, you never served in combat.

There are many sources of pollution. Some can be
argued as necessary like raising cattle and driving
cars, trains and planes.

There are sources that are necessary for economic
growth.

Where's the economic benefit of war, unless I get really
sarcastic and start talking about controlling oil fields.


Yeah, we all need the 4.8 lt V8 that gets 16 miles a gallon. That's not an economic necessity, it was my choice. If you drive anything that gets less than 30 miles a gallon (unless you're in construction) then you're creating excess pollution by personal choice. Been on a bus recently......

I've not read a single argument that a single war has an impact on global warming - you must be kidding. What's the economic impact of keeping 200,000 troops in Germany, 100,000 in Asia and 500 ships on the high seas....

OTB
 
DonQuixote said:
Our coal plants spew more pollution than cars.

Industry creates most of the pollution.

There's huge profits for those than can
reduce that waist in the air and water.
Mobile-Exxon and GE are spending billions
on alternative energy....

I've attached a link to a few articles related to Exxon's disinformation tactics and funding for global warming contrarians, junk science initiatives etc. Exxon may be doing research on lowering carbon emissions but they're also making sure the average American is misinformed about the science associated with global warming.

http://abcnews.go.com/Technology/story?id=2767979&page=1

Report: Big Money Confusing Public on Global Warming
ExxonMobil Tactics Similar to Tobacco Industry, Group Found

By CLAYTON SANDELL

"Jan. 3, 2007 — A new report details what it calls an "enormously successful" disinformation campaign by ExxonMobil that used tobacco-industry tactics to fund groups who cast doubts and deceive the public on the scientific consensus regarding global warming.

The report was released today by the Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS), a nonprofit environmental advocacy group based in Massachusetts.

ExxonMobil spokesman Dave Gardner, in an e-mail to reporters, initially called the report an "an attempt to smear our name and confuse the discussion of the serious issue of [carbon dioxide] emissions and global climate change."

Gardner later deleted that portion of the statement about the report, but reiterated that "many of the conclusions are inaccurate."

The UCS report found that between 1998 and 2005, ExxonMobil has funnelled about $16 million to 43 advocacy groups and 16 individuals in an effort to "manufacture uncertainty" and ultimately stall government action that would require a mandatory cut in greenhouse gasses such as carbon dioxide. The group said the figures in the report were compiled from ExxonMobil corporate reports.

"ExxonMobil has, in a cynical and manipulative strategy, helped create a kind of echo chamber to amplify the views of a carefully selected group of spokespeople whose work has been largely discredited by the scientific community," said Seth Schulman, the report's primary author, in a conference call today with reporters.

The strategy is built on the notion, the report found, that "public opinion can be easily manipulated because science is complex, because people tend not to notice where their information comes from, and because the effects of global warming are just beginning to become visible."

The report compared the company's efforts to the strategy used by tobacco companies to downplay the effects of smoking.

The vast majority of the world's climate scientists agree that human activities, such as the burning of fossil fuels, are contributing to a greenhouse gas effect that has warmed the globe at an unprecedented rate.

ExxonMobil has acknowledged as much.

"Even with many scientific uncertainties, the risk that greenhouse gas emissions may have serious impacts justifies taking action," Gardner said. "What is clear today is that greenhouse gas emissions are one of the factors that contribute to climate change, and that the use of fossil fuels is a major source of these emissions."

The UCS report, however, calls the financial connections between ExxonMobil and a number of organizations — including the Competitive Enterprise Institute, the George C. Marshall Institute, Heritage Foundation and the Media Research Center— part of an effort to obscure the scientific evidence on global warming.

ExxonMobil has said it is reviewing the organizations the company funds and has noted in the past that the Competitive Enterprise Institute did not receive any Exxon money this year."...

http://abcnews.go.com/Technology/story?id=2612021&page=1

http://abcnews.go.com/images/exxon_report.pdf
 
A few interesting facts I thought, can't vouch for the source, this is my first visit (on the first Google page for US adoption of clean coal).

OTB

November 30, 2006
Is Clean Coal Possible?

I dislike coal. Besides CO2, it produces pollutants that kill forests and blacken buildings & lungs. But coal is the fuel of the future. Coal consumption will nearly double by 2030, with 81% of that increase coming from developing countries like China & India, and supply 27% of the world’s energy. Ignore coal and our world goes to hell. That is why President Bush’s clean coal initiative is so important.

The locus of world environmental decision making is shifting from Europe and the U.S. to developing countries such as China & India. Coal consumption in China and India is expected to increase by 3.6 billion tons in the next 30 years. Already the air in many Chinese cities is well neigh unbreathable and Chinese pollution darkens snow in Washington and British Columbia. Everything we do short of addressing this problem is like rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic while ignoring the oncoming iceberg.

Renewable energy and nuclear power may well be the fuels of the more distant future, but we have to face the fact that coal will be a big part of our energy mix for the rest of our lifetimes.

Most Americans probably have not heard of the Asia Pacific Partnership. President Bush announced it less than a year ago but it holds promise as an excellent multilateral way to address energy and environmental issue and help the inevitable economic development to be cleaner and better. I wrote about our relationship with India and last week the Senate overwhelmingly supported the Indian nuclear deal. Nuclear power will mitigate the need for coal, but will not eliminate it. Renewables (including my personal favorite cellulos ethanol), conservation and nuclear power are good options but not sufficient.

After all this, I still do not like coal, but I see that we WILL use more coal, both in the U.S. and especially in developing countries. We need to ensure that we have the best and most efficient technologies available.

Today the Department of Energy announced that it will grant $1 billion in tax credits to clean coal projects. These are working toward a zero emission power plant. I personally do not think a zero emission power plant is possible. All energy production entails risks and costs. But working toward this goal will certainly be better than pretending we can find some magic formula. And we can share technological imporvements with developing countries that will use more coal, cleaning their air and ours.

Sometime in the future, I believe most of the world's energy will come from renewables, but that day is a long ways off. The optimistic scenario is for renewable energy to make up 25% of our energy mix by 2025. With reasonable economic growth, that remaining 75% will be MORE energy than we use today in total. Let's try to generate that energy in a way that is sustainable for our environment.

http://www.watchblog.com/republicans/archives/004533.html
 
basketcase said:
According to the radio, today was the warmest new years since 1979; not quite 20 years.
Yes, I remember it rained New Years Eve '79.

I like watching the weather forecast for the whole country, where they show +3 or 4 for Whitehorse, and -20 for Yellowknife. This has happened several times a winter over the past few years, but in '76, they didn't have any ice on the Yukon river to have their dogsled race

onthebottom said:
Yeah, we all need the 4.8 lt V8 that gets 16 miles a gallon. That's not an economic necessity, it was my choice. If you drive anything that gets less than 30 miles a gallon (unless you're in construction) then you're creating excess pollution by personal choice. Been on a bus recently......OTB
I can't count the number of times I've driven by a bus, TTC or otherwise with 1 or 2 people on board. Kind of defeats the purpose. They should be the ones walking or riding a bike.

muscle lover said:
All this Global Warming crap is not such an immediate threat as the Environmental Community would have you believe, what we do with our garbage and sewage is much more immediate. Unfortunately, no one would listen to a message that simply says "do all that you can to decrease your environmental footprint"...
I don't see very many people complaining about what gets flushed down the drain, that they end up drinking later, or what's in the ground water the farmer uses to water his crops they eat, or leaching garbage dumps polluting underground springs.
 
It just hit 54 degrees right now in Buffalo NY, the "snow/blizzard capital" of NY State!
Yesterday at this same time it was 53 degrees here......
pops is usually ice fishing about now...hell who knows he still may be.....:D
NY City hit 61 degees earlier today!

What is amazing it that Rush Limbaugh, that OxyContinized drug addict of the far Reich wing of the GOP, still babbles on how Global Warming is a myth created by tree-hugging libs who just want to harm the greedy, self centered, self serving bastards and 'special interests' that own El Rushbloe, lock, stock and barrel.
Makes you wonder if all those apologists that bleat on like El Rushbloe and are in denial about Global Warming, are all on OxyContin and need to spend some time in the Betty Ford Center for some rehab!
 
63 in Dayton OH today, I guess there is an upside to global warming.

I have to say, as a kid, at least 1 of 3 Christmases in Minnesota was without snow and I remember running the air conditioning at Easter.....

So, if the Germans blame global warming for Katrina, does the absence of a strong hurricane this season negate the theory or does it just work one way.

Perhaps isolated anecdotes are of marginal value - as apparently are agreements like Canada signed (and didn't live up to) and we didn't.

OTB
 
What agreement has Canada signed and not lived up to? Kyoto??
LOL
Next.
Nice try.
Reading assignments all 'round!

The only thing most of the dummies around here need to know about global warming is that we're in the process of fucking the planet. Any other notion is idiocy.

'Night.