free weights vs. resistance bands

simon482

internets icon
Feb 8, 2009
9,945
181
63
i started working out and shit about a month and a half ago. i got some free weights for when i am at home and resistance bands for traveling. when i am at home i use the free weights 30 mins each 3 times a day. when i am on the road i use the resistance bands 3 times a day 30 mins each. i find that after using the weight i can feel it more than when i use the resistance bands. i have lost 35 pounds in the last 2 months and feeling better.

was wondering from the guys here that do work out who uses what or what they prefer. i use the max and medium resistance bands at the same time and a 20 pound dumbbell when i am at home.
 
Both are good.

If you're building muscle yet losing weight I figure you're doing something else as well - eating less, a healthier diet or maybe walking more?
 
yeah. i try to eat a salad at least 2 times a week, sometimes i get 3 but i can't do more than that lol. i have been parking int he farthest back corners of the truck stops and walking the farthest route to the door. eating less as well, no more seconds on dinner. add that to the weight lifting and resistance bands and i am happy with the turn out thus far. got another 40 to go.
 
i started working out and shit about a month and a half ago. i got some free weights for when i am at home and resistance bands for traveling. when i am at home i use the free weights 30 mins each 3 times a day. when i am on the road i use the resistance bands 3 times a day 30 mins each. i find that after using the weight i can feel it more than when i use the resistance bands. i have lost 35 pounds in the last 2 months and feeling better.

was wondering from the guys here that do work out who uses what or what they prefer. i use the max and medium resistance bands at the same time and a 20 pound dumbbell when i am at home.

Free weights are way better than bands. Simply because you encounter the resistance from the moment you begin lifting them, whereas bands only begin to work at a certain point. Free weights are much better, but bands are still useful.
 
Like you I bought them for travel, but they have worked their way into my general exercise routines. They have not, however, completely replace free weights.

I think both have merit. I tend to use a mix. I often work out the smaller muscles with bands, because bands are a lot less likely to injure your joints. But I don't think bands are a good replacement for free weights for the heavy lifting like bench presses or squats. I find that at those levels, there is no comfortable way to use the bands--they dig into your sides, or you can't get a good leverage position. But they're great for things like bicep curls, overhead presses, etc.

I have some bands in my living room in a drawer and sometimes use them while sitting around, watching videos, or whatever. No way would my wife let me keep a set of free weights there. That means there are opportunities for me to do a couple of exercises with the bands where the free weight alternative is no exercise at all because they're not physically present where I am. (As with travelling too.)
 
i keep the bands in my truck. far easier for traveling with cuz they take up almost no room. great for tight quarters for sure. i looked it up online and websites were saying that resistance bands were better cuz you had resistance going up and down with it and in any position where free weights only gave you that resistance with gravity. i don't know but after doing a set with my weights my arms are lit up lol.
 
What I do now is I keep a set of bands in my home, and I go to the gym a couple of times a week to do the heavier lifting. So bench presses, squats, in the gym, where they have a full complete set of weights. But I do some exercises every day, the days I'm not in the gym I do the stuff that works well with bands at home. Means I don't have to spend a mint on a full set of weights at my home, which would also clutter the place up--but I also don't have to go the gym every single day.
 
What I do now is I keep a set of bands in my home, and I go to the gym a couple of times a week to do the heavier lifting. So bench presses, squats, in the gym, where they have a full complete set of weights. But I do some exercises every day, the days I'm not in the gym I do the stuff that works well with bands at home. Means I don't have to spend a mint on a full set of weights at my home, which would also clutter the place up--but I also don't have to go the gym every single day.

having a set up at home would be great for me but up until last week i been living out of a suitcase and hadn't been home for more than a day or 2 in a year and a half so it didn't make sense.
 
it's very difficult to get progression with resistance bands. sure, you could use stronger ones but weights allow you to add smaller increments. some lifting protocols are based on adding 2.5 or 5 lbs at specific intervals. try doing that with bands. but when nothing else is available, they work well enough. it all depends on your goals. while on the road, you're not probably training for strength. most likely you just want to keep what you can and build some more if you can. and they do provide a very strong eccentric. so my thoughts? a very good alternative when weights are not available.
 
Resistance bands do allow you to add small increments. You combine them , just like with weights. If you have a 2.5lb and a 20lb then attaching them both to the grips creates 22.5 lbs of resistance. It is normal to combine bands that way and works exactly the same as weights in that respect .

In fact if anything you should alternate using bands and weights as they work the muscle in slightly different ways, and variety is good.