Finally justice - This is Canada

FUji: just how stupid are you? Really, have you ever heard of a thing called the RIDE PROGRAM

Oh wait, isn't that where they STOP ALL CARS whether you've been drinking or not?
 
Yes and no...

iluvquarks said:
How does a handful of women wanting to wear a niqab while they vote automatically amount to "attempting to push their way of life on us"?

You're also making the assumption that Canadian law is perfect as it is and are implying that if someone was not born in this country, they should just shut up and take it even if it conflicts with their religious beliefs. While I understand that your main point is immigrants should be more open to assimilation and embrace Canadian laws and culture, the "leave if you don't agree" argument sounds like you are telling a large portion of the population that their opinion only matters if they agree. Otherwise they should "shut up and go home because you should be thankful they're here".
*****************************

"leave if you don't agree" argument sounds like you are telling a large portion of the population that their opinion only matters if they agree.

That is not what was posted. Kindly take it exactly as it was written.

That said you made an excellent point. "assimilation and embrace Canadian laws and culture". This I feel is one of our main problems. There should be more assimilation. The country is too fractured. Melting pot, as our American friends used to call their country, does not exist in North America.

There will be debate after debate but we have, in effect is, adopted multi countries with in one country and it won't work.

All multi-cultural is is a nice way of saying religions. Look at the fighting that is going on around this word in the name of religion.

The sooner the line is drawn the better Canada will be.
 
Well, David, in a way, there's a valid point in it.
A lot of people come here expecting help and then cheating the government at the same time (health care, taxes, etc).
Then on top of that, some will want the rules to bend according to them?
Sorry...back you go...
 
tboy said:
FUji: just how stupid are you? Really, have you ever heard of a thing called the RIDE PROGRAM

Oh wait, isn't that where they STOP ALL CARS whether you've been drinking or not?

Gee, do you think you might be DRIVING A CAR when that happens? Go read my post again. When you are driving a car on a public highway the police are entitled to ask you for proof that you are licensed to do so.

Learn just a LITTLE about the country you live in before you start talking about whether other people have this or that right, ok?

If you walk past a RIDE program they cannot force you to stop or identify yourself unless they arrest you. To arrest you they must have cause. They can ASK, of course, just as any other citizen can ask you who you are. You don't have to answer. You can just keep walking.

You have rights in Canada. You owe it to yourself to learn what they are.
 
Cobster said:
Well gee, if you walk away, and they tell you to stop and you keep going...
What do you think will happen next?
They'll have suspicion then.
Which in turn will give them a reason to stop you and ask you ?'s.

Nope. Not grounds for arrest. They have to have reason to believe you have committed some OFFENSE. Walking away from the police is not an offense.

But what constitutes suspicion from one person to another varies.

However, the police are trained on what constitutes suspicion, and it's written into law and case law.


But if they ask you to stop and you keep moving because as you say, you can do so - since they don't have a right to stop you....see how confusing that can be?

If they arrest you then you have to stop. If they're in the wrong, you take that up with a judge. If they wrongly arrest you, you have legal recourse later with a judge. In principle you could resist a wrongful arrest, but you'd better be damn sure, and you're also likely to get shot.
 
zuzi said:
...

The niqab is a cloth that along with the hijab covers the womens face(from the eyes down). it is NOT OBLIGATORY on muslim women and is TOTALLY VOLUNTARY!
...

Religious obligations are always open to interpretation. While the majority of Muslim women choose not to wear a niqab, (or it isn't a cultural obligation for them) there are some groups where it is expected behaviour. A simple example would be to look at Afghanistan under the Taliban.

My school experience also saw the Muslim guys play a significant role in the attire of the girls. My grade 12 year, the group of more religious Muslim guys left and the year after, all except one of the girls dressed in the (wonderfully revealing) Western styles. Obviously, there was some pressure put on them by the guys. I think that the idea of "forced to" is a strange one due to it's definitions. Most youth and children don't really have free will or decision making abilities. If your family gives you a set of expectations (whether religious or social), you choose to either follow them or set yourself up for conflict. For many people, the decision making power of the parents continues as adults, some meet a new person to control them (spouse or friends), and some really make their own decisions. I am sure that Muslim women fit into each of these categories so saying women are forced to does apply in some cases.

Should immigrants be expected to assimilate? Many are quite happy to and see it as a cost that is balanced by the new opportunities they receive here. When it comes down to it though, as long as their rights don't interfere with the rights of others. This voting issue is a divisive political issue because of it's strangeness but I don't think allowing it really has a negative affect on anyone else. If there was evidence that this was being used to abuse the system, then something should be done.
 
fuji said:
The police have NO RIGHT to arbitrarily stop you, question you, detain you, or force you to identify yourself.
Thus far true.

fuji said:
In order to arrest you they have to have reasonable grounds to believe that you have committed an offense, or that you will commit an offense. They can't just make this up. There are standards that those reasonable grounds have to meet. They have to be able to explain it convincingly to a judge why they suspect you might have committed an offense.
However, it doesn't take much to meet this standard. A great way to escalate a situation that was originally going to end with a verbal warning to "keep the noise down" or "don't spit on the sidewalk" instead ends up with you being arrested and spending the night in jail because by God that Constable wasn't going to make you do whatever.
Then it depends on the Judge or J.P. you see: bleeding heart - oh you poor boy (unlikely), not quite so bleeding heart - it's your own stupid fault should I fine you or is the night in jail enough to have gotten your head into a wiser place.
 
Originally Posted by Meister
Interesting story.

A German woman judge has refused a Moroccan-born woman permission to file for divorce by interpreting the Koran as allowing husbands to beat their wives.

I wonder if anybody knows where in the Koran it allows husbands to beat their wives?

scouser1 said:
I am sure Cinema Face will be quick here to enlighten us with his extensive knowledge of Islam and the Koran :D

on a side note even the Muslim organizations in Germany are freaking out about this lunatic judge


Thanx Scouser

Actually Tabari makes it pretty damn clear where Islam stands on women's rights.

Tabari IX:113 "Allah permits you to shut them in separate rooms and to beat them, but not severely. If they abstain, they have the right to food and clothing. Treat women well for they are like domestic animals and they possess nothing themselves. Allah has made the enjoyment of their bodies lawful in his Qur'an."
 
dollastove said:
this move made sense; when in Rome, do what Romans do!
Can I move to Norway and refuse to learn Norwegian? Insist that any demands or expectations that I conform to Norwegian norms of behaviour are anti-whatever? Demand that Norwegians should instead conform to my beliefs?
 
fuji said:
Can't the introduction of a new social/cultural group in Canada have an impact on what those standards are?
That sounds fairly black and white. So the choices are: Imigrants come to Canada but aren't expected to conform to Canadian standards and values. Imigrants come to Canada, everyone else is expected to change to make the Imigrants feel like home.
 
fuji said:
Nope. Not grounds for arrest. They have to have reason to believe you have committed some OFFENSE. Walking away from the police is not an offense.



However, the police are trained on what constitutes suspicion, and it's written into law and case law.




If they arrest you then you have to stop. If they're in the wrong, you take that up with a judge. If they wrongly arrest you, you have legal recourse later with a judge. In principle you could resist a wrongful arrest, but you'd better be damn sure, and you're also likely to get shot.

(1) Walking away from a Police officer when he orders you to stop is called failing to abide by the orders of a police officer and is an arrestable offence.

(2) LOL if they arrest you you have to stop? What drugs are you ON dude. They have to stop you before they can arrest you. From what you're saying as long as you keep moving then they can't arrest you therefore you don't have to stop. Talk about circular logic....

Dude, really, stop. You're killing me, lol, at least one thing: your posts make me laugh harder than adam sandler (tho that's not saying much). BTW: in your post you didn't say the police can't stop you while you are anything. You said they "can't stop you" period.....

Here's the link to the police services guidebook. Fuji is correct when he states that literally "you do not have to identify yourself to a police offiicer" but it also says in the guidebook that to fail to do so could arouse suspicion and cause the police to want to investigate further which can be interpreted as meaning arresting you, detaining you, questioning you further and at length, etc and the book simply states why you SHOULD identify yourself to the police officer.

Anyhow, read away. It is pretty interesting.

http://www.torontopolice.on.ca/communitymobilization/newcomer/guides/tps_guide_eng.pdf
 
Ok let's get back to the topic at hand: Whether or not one's religious beliefs supercede those of the country they are living in or emigrating to.

So basically we're talking about where to draw the line. Obviously Fuji doesn't want any lines drawn because that would impact one's right to practise their beliefs. So, with that being said I guess we should allow the following:

1) There are cultures in Africa that still practice female circumsision whereby they scrape away the vulva and clitoris with a sharp edged object while others hold her down without the benefit of an anesthetic.

2) As stated above Muslim men treat their women like domestic animals

3) Is it the seventh day adventists that don't allow blood transfusions? (sorry, I forget which religion that is)

4) Sikhs wish to wear their ceremonial daggers in public

5) Sikhs don't have to wear hardhats on construction sites

6) Everyone should stop eating cows because Hindu's worship them

7) No one should eat pork because according to many religions they are "unclean" animals

8) Thaiwanese and many other asian cultures embrace child protitution. So we should allow them to practice that here?

9) Many african cultures embrace ethnic cleansing. So, if they don't want any christians around we MUST allow them to practice their beliefs

I could go on but I think you get my point. There are many religious practices that don't go against our laws or societal standards but should we allow those that do for, as Fuji says, to allow them to integrate them into our society? Sorry, a line has to be drawn somewhere and one was drawn. Whether we agree or not is irrelevant.

My thought is if you want to allow ALL ethnic or religious practises might I suggest you run for government office on that platform that you think we should allow the above. I bet you don't get 1 vote.
 
There's some validity here...but...

dollastove said:
this move made sense; when in Rome, do what Romans do!

like how asians can't eat cats/dogs here in North America :D
*******************
A British/Canadian friend of mine is a cat lover. (He normally has the patience of Joeb) He has two cats. One morning the oldest wasn't home from normal overnight adventures. He looks out his kitchen window and his cat is being lured into an ***** families home.

Now at 6'2 and 275 LBS it's amazing how he went over that 6' fence. After a brief question period on what was going on it was found out that one individual could fly. Back into his house propelled by one massive fist.

Point:- This is Canada. Some citizens are not that easy going to unusual food ways. No, I do not condone violence!!!

True story.
 
Aardvark154 said:
Can I move to Norway and refuse to learn Norwegian? Insist that any demands or expectations that I conform to Norwegian norms of behaviour are anti-whatever? Demand that Norwegians should instead conform to my beliefs?
Yes. And they have bigots there too, who will demand you do as they do or leave. But the rest of them will be polite enough to try to speak english.

Where were you when those earlier lousy immigrants were forcing their evil ways on us? Now I actually like sushi, have my own capuccino machine, can't go a week w/o pizza, or pakoras. And don't even mention pasta, paella or perogies. Or apple strudel. I love phad thai, was brought up on egg rolls, go to German, Italian and Russian opera, and I am completely pissed off because 90% of the music on the radio and most of the programs on TV are 'immigrant' products, that don't reflect our Canadian ways. Like building outdated cars that even the Americans who own the factories won't drive. You shoulda protected me from good cars, now that I'm addicted to my immigrant Nissan.

Where were you when you shoulda been preventing immigrant ghettos with their different languages on signs, like Kensington Market, Little Portugal, Corso Italia, Gerrard India Bazaar, KoreaTowns I and II, not to mention ChinaTowns beyond counting? Not to mention the most prevalent immigrant culture that ignores ours: Where were you when the Americans were tking over? Probably watching a CFL game at the time were you? You wouldn't have been skiing I'm sure—that would be a foreign way of enduring winter, against our snowshoeing ways. But you can do it to your hearts content in Norway.

Goodbye, and au revoir which I can say because it's Canadian. We immigrant squareheads imposed our ways on the canadiens by force of arms long ago so now we can treat them like the immigrants. Neat trick, eh?
 
BTW: where is that turd zuzi? He's supposed to give me a where and when so he can slap me.....

I'm waiting punk.......
 
A little culture for you to read!

FOR YOUR INFO

Those coverings are called debutta, They wear these covers for respect of there family and husbins. To them it is about respect! you respect yourself and your family. By not covering you are choiceing to show your face and by covering your choice is to be respected. But we dont study enough about other cultures so that is why we are closed minded as a soicity. Bad on you for being so rude.... This is culture respect it and they will respect you.... dosent mean you have to wear it , just understand another point of view instead...

Live your life but understanding is most important..!!!!:)
 
OH i will get flamed for this but:

,,,but understanding is most important?? Well, I could barely understand your post due to all the grammatical errors and misspelled words. If you want our understanding use spell check! :)
 
toughb said:
*******************
A British/Canadian friend of mine is a cat lover. (He normally has the patience of Joeb) He has two cats. One morning the oldest wasn't home from normal overnight adventures. He looks out his kitchen window and his cat is being lured into an ***** families home.

Now at 6'2 and 275 LBS it's amazing how he went over that 6' fence. After a brief question period on what was going on it was found out that one individual could fly. Back into his house propelled by one massive fist.

Point:- This is Canada. Some citizens are not that easy going to unusual food ways. No, I do not condone violence!!!

True story.
Pointless. Details please, otherwise it's a story of a bully leaping to conclusions faster than over fences. If there's any truth to it at all.