tboy said:
Maybe you should have been the sheriff instead of the deputy because everytime I have voted I've had to show picture ID. EVERYTIME.
Just because they check your photo id when they canvass for the voter's list what's to stop someone from just showing up and stating whatever name and voting 20 or 30 times? Your way: NOTHING. All one had to do was write down the list of names on a 200 unit apartment building intercom and then go to the polling station and vote for every one of them.
Sorry, but in Ontario you have to show photo id and what good is photo ID if your face is covered?
…edit.
I can't speak for your experience
tboy. I do know what the Elections Manual says and what I was trained to do. There is no requirement to produce a photo ID; all you have to do is satisfy the DRO that you are the person on the list. And even if challenged, your right to vote can be established w/o photo ID. You may think it's full of holes, but the law says every Canadian citizen over eighteen resident in the riding may vote. No mention of photo ID. Or how anyone should dress for that matter.
We're so used to being asked for photo ID that we sometimes think we've been asked for it when we've only been asked to identify ourselves. Many voters simply hand you the Voter's Card—which could be picked up by the dozen in that apartment lobby you mentioned*—and we're supposed to tell them, "I'm sorry, the card is not ID". If they then produce a photo ID, so be it, but all they actually have to do is state their name and address so we can verify they are on the list. In fact, even if photo ID's handed over from the top, we're still supposed to ask them to state their name and address.
You may recall a hoorah last federal election when a student in Montreal claimed to have voted though he was not qualified—can't recall whether he claimed to have voted twice, or got on the list improperly and voted—and self-righteously alerted the media to "expose this security hole". The real point was that he had committed a serious fraud (for which the penalties are properly severe) against a system which deliberately does
not treat us like suspected criminals and terrorists who must first prove they're OK to suspicious functionaries.
Election Day is one of the very few instances in this age when a person's word actually means something, and when their identity can be established by the word of their fellow citizens who know them. Just like Greeks and Romans. Considering that the Health card is the most reliable photo ID used in Ontario—although it's not legal to use it for any purpose other than health—and there are hundreds of thousands of known false cards out there, I'd go for the Elections Act version.
BTW, if your contracting schedule's got any room come the next election, you might drop in at your riding's Returning Office and apply. The Day itself is a bit of a grind; you're stuck at that table for twelve hours and hafta brown bag it. After that The Count; nobody leaves until every single ballot's been accounted for and all totals balanced. And before that, the Training Day, which is mercifully short, and hopefully efficient. You meet nice folks, some of your neighbours, and get an unbeatable view of the machinery of democracy clanking and grinding. And they pay you up to $200 for the privilege.
*About your hypothetical election fraud: In my riding, your list of 20 or 30 names copied from the lobby panel would include a great many non-citizens as well as voters. If you show up using the non-citizen's name, you WILL have to produce photo ID, including proof of citizenship to get on the list. You'd also have to find out where all the voters have been told to vote, because it's the only place they can vote, and when you got there you'd find that all of your twenty or thirty phony voters have to walk up to the same guy at the same table and state (no peeking) who they are and where they live. The polls I was responsible for had about 60% turnout from a list of 300-400 names. I may not be the brightest bulb, but I think I'd catch on when you showed up the second time. Interestingly, one of the standard pieces of paper they give you is an Arrest Warrant. Please don't do it.