Elderly Drivers.

Celticman

Into Ties and Tail
Aug 13, 2009
8,903
99
63
Durham & Toronto
I was at work a couple of weeks before Christmas, car parked in the undeground parking garage. Around mid morning I realised that I had left my phone in the car. I went down to the car, opened the drivers side door and leaned in. I heard a squeal of tires then an almighty series of bangs. A driver had floored his car in reverse, and perpendicular to my car, crashed into me (first) and then two cars parked next to me.

I was thrown into the frame of the door opening, slight concussion and a broken collar bone. As you can see from the pics, there was quite a bit of damage to my car, as well as the other two.

Here are the disturbing parts. If anyone had been standing at the back of their car, they would have been crippled or killed. The driver of the runaway Escalade? A very frail and infirm gentleman of 89. When the police arrived, they told me that they were in some kind of traffic unit that looks after crash incidents. They were great by the way. The cop in charge told me that the vast majority of serious events invariably fall into one of two groups. Kids or the (infirm) elderly.

It makes me wonder if testing for older drivers is anywhere near stringent enough. Regardless of any status, the authorities have a responsibility to ensure that drivers are capabale of safe driving. And it seems to me, based on chatting with the cop and the tow truck driver, that this infirm elderly driver problem is a known, glaring issue. The government sure reacted and legislated to some young driver issues a few years ago (correctly). Now some folk on the board know that I myself am older than the Ancient Mariner, so feel free to insert puns and funs in this tiny reserved space " " :D

Apart from the hassle of hospital, getting the car fixed etc, courtesy of the collar bone I was restricted in my hobbying activities to massage only. Requires less participation from me. I know, life is tough, but I did see my first SP in some time this morning with a visit to Praline. I now have to get organised to see a "mystery" SP that has informed a certain respected photoghrapher that she should act as an intermediary and setup a blind date session with me. apparently this mystery woman has a preconceived notion of me from my posts. Fooled her :) !! My midle names are gullible and game, so what the heck, I love surprises. and BTW photo person, I have guessed that your friend has the same initials as me. Good guess?

vcxov5.jpg


yf0bt.jpg
 
OMG!!!

FIRST - I am so sorry for you. That is terrible. I am glad to hear you are on the mend.

Second - wonderful captures. LOL ;)

Third - I love that you love surprises!!!!

And lastly - yes I do believe that there should be something done about better testing on the elderly for driving.


 
Ouch, sorry about your car (and collar bone). Glad it wasn't more serious; could easily have been. Guess I got off easy two weeks ago when that elderly lady almost hit me head on because she mistakenly was driving in the wrong lane and even in the face of oncoming traffic decided the appropriate action was to keep plowing ahead!

Ironically, that very same day I was having some work done on my vehicle and there was an older man (89) and and slightly younger woman at the shop having a discussion that eventually got around to him still driving at his age. According to him, once you hit 80, you have to renew your license every two years. This involves a vision test, a lecture, and a written test.

I have several problems with this:

1) Eighty seems like a high minimum for this type of action.
2) No test to gauge reaction time?
3) No actual road test to test ability?
4) In both my case and OP's case, it seems the cause of the dangerous situation was that something wasn't clicking right in the driver's head. I don't think a vision test or written test on road signs addresses that.
 
Ouch, sorry about your car (and collar bone). Glad it wasn't more serious; could easily have been. Guess I got off easy two weeks ago when that elderly lady almost hit me head on because she mistakenly was driving in the wrong lane and even in the face of oncoming traffic decided the appropriate action was to keep plowing ahead!

Ironically, that very same day I was having some work done on my vehicle and there was an older man (89) and and slightly younger woman at the shop having a discussion that eventually got around to him still driving at his age. According to him, once you hit 80, you have to renew your license every two years. This involves a vision test, a lecture, and a written test.

I have several problems with this:

1) Eighty seems like a high minimum for this type of action.
2) No test to gauge reaction time?
3) No actual road test to test ability?
4) In both my case and OP's case, it seems the cause of the dangerous situation was that something wasn't clicking right in the driver's head. I don't think a vision test or written test on road signs addresses that.

I completely agree. WOW - I can not believe it is 80. That does seem really old.

I would also agree that reaction testing and especially a road test would be done, so I am in total shock about that.

I guess I can see it being a cost and time issue. That could be a lot of money for people at that age if they needed to be testing every 2 years. However sadly, at that age - how many renewals do they have?
 
I am very sorry for your pain and troubles as the innocent victim Celticman, and very glad they were no worse when they might easily have been, but I'd be surprised if the topic had even crossed your mind before the crash.

As an aging driver—just like every other driver on the road—I have a couple of thoughts. As much as they can, politicians make laws that don't upset people and get them re-elected. Most pols are close to being elderly drivers themselves, and do most of their talking, fund-raising and riding association work among other almost-elderly folk. And they vote more reliably than younger voters. How many extra votes would a sensible measure like biennial road-testing get anyone who proposed it? What would it cost in support? That's why we don't have such a law.

Granted that it's the age groups at the incoming and outgoing edges of the accident bell-curve that cause most trouble, is that any reason not to retest every driver periodically? The guy who t-boned me when he ran a red-light with his whole family aboard was as middle-aged as could be, but clearly operating in a 'nobody's gonna check on me' mindset. The number of folks we've all noticed who never signal, have no lane consciousness, roll through stops and so on suggest he has lots of company. No need to worry about cost of such a program, it could be entirely user-pay. But no one wants it.

Re-testing is a great theory, but it will only be a popular prposal after some horrific crash, or crashes, generating public demand no politician can ignore. When ordinary people stop to think about it, it's always the other guy who should be tested. And even then, they've got other stuff they want to see at the top of the TDL, like getting streetcars replaced by subways so they can drive a quarter kph faster. If you think about it, stuff like realistically assessing who's qualified to drive is the sort of thing you hire experts to do, and to ponder how to do better. But we've spent the last few decades of public life damning public servants as greedy, lazy and incompetent, and electing pols devoted to reducing their numbers and reducing their wages. There's no one on the payroll thinking about retesting and how to do it. Nor have the penny-mad pols or the company they outsourced driver testing to given evidence they want to make the system better at all.

We do get what we ask for; when we look around we can figure out who asked the loudest.
 
Celticman, I'm sorry to hear about the collision, and I hope your recovery will be speedy and complete.

It's a tough thing to do to take away a driver's license from an older person. From their perspective, they are dealing with declining ability, and a DL very much affects their independence. When my late father was in his 70s we, his family, were concerned about his declining driving ability in terms of his reaction, vision and judgement. We had several discussions about how to approach him on this when he went into the hospital with one of the many ailments he had later in his life. A week or so after he got out of the hospital he received a letter notifying him that his DL had been revoked. Apparently his family doctor was required to report the ailment that he was hospitalized for, which was sufficient cause to revoke his license. He gradually adjusted to, and even began to enjoy, being a passenger instead of a driver.
 
more to the problem

Years ago we tried to get my mother-in-law out from behind the wheel since her increasing dimentia was making it dangerous for her and those around her on the roads. She was getting lost, leaving her car running and locking herself out. We contacted her insurance agent and insurance company, explained the circumstances and offerred to support them if they could somehow pull her insurance or at least make it too expensive to continue:(. They would not help. Neither would the family doctor, who we suggested could pull her licence.

From our experience I have concluded that the insurers and the government have decided to just let the insurance premiums cover over the problems rather than antagonize potential voters and customers.

I figure there will come a day for all of us when we should not be driving a car. We should plan for that day and not assume a driver's license is some kind of right to the point oters are being injured or killed.
 
Celtic man. So glad to see you are better. I've been there as a pedestrian myself so am in complete sympathy for you.....
I noticed your posts didn't drop off.....can I assume you've had a lot of experience with one handed typing........:)
 
I am very sorry for your pain and troubles as the innocent victim Celticman, and very glad they were no worse when they might easily have been, but I'd be surprised if the topic had even crossed your mind before the crash.

Au contraire! I ride a pretty high powered motorbike. Have been mbiking for 50 years. One of the mbiking driving habits that I employ is to anticipate the early signs of inattentive driving or a circumstance that might precipitate a sudden lane change. Bikers lose all arguments with cars. There is no right and wrong involved at the time, just survival. When I have to avoid these situations, I often have time to glance at the driver. Two of the bigger offenders are cell phone users and elderly drivers. In fact most motorbikes have OEM horns that sound like a fart in a thunderstorm. I had mine replaced with a truck type horn. It certainly causes drivers to stop wandering across lanes. They jump back into a proper lane position. I would too if I thought an 18 wheeler was bearing down on me.

So I have been keenly aware of elder driver issues for many years. The only thing that has changed is the added dimension of frequency explained to me by a police officer in a specialised unit that sees this all the time. This copper, who is closer to it than we will ever be is adamant that at 80 you should have a road test accompanied by some form of medical certificate from your doc declaring that you are fit for the purpose of taking the test.

Celtic man. So glad to see you are better. I've been there as a pedestrian myself so am in complete sympathy for you.....
I noticed your posts didn't drop off.....can I assume you've had a lot of experience with one handed typing........:)

I chuckled when I read this. In the last ten years I have had rotator cuff surgery on each shoulder; a broken arm and a broken hand. I have had plenty of practice to enable me to deal with a broken collar bone! Interestingly, I was prescribed a painkiller for the first rotator cuff surgery that required the surgeon to report it to the ministry, and my license was suspended. I had not expected this, did not fill the perscription, returned it to the surgeon and he immediately had the ministry restore my license. If elderly drivers are not physically able to drive in a safe and competent manner, how is this different to my pain killer experience? It is not.
 
Au contraire! I ride a pretty high powered motorbike. Have been mbiking for 50 years. One of the mbiking driving habits that I employ is to anticipate the early signs of inattentive driving or a circumstance that might precipitate a sudden lane change. Bikers lose all arguments with cars. There is no right and wrong involved at the time, just survival. When I have to avoid these situations, I often have time to glance at the driver. Two of the bigger offenders are cell phone users and elderly drivers. In fact most motorbikes have OEM horns that sound like a fart in a thunderstorm. I had mine replaced with a truck type horn. It certainly causes drivers to stop wandering across lanes. They jump back into a proper lane position. I would too if I thought an 18 wheeler was bearing down on me.

FYI...You do realize that if the object of your "blast on the Horn" was distracted or surprised enough by your horn and caused / created an accident that you could/would have been charged with creating an Audible distraction..
So I have been keenly aware of elder driver issues for many years. The only thing that has changed is the added dimension of frequency explained to me by a police officer in a specialised unit that sees this all the time. This copper, who is closer to it than we will ever be is adamant that at 80 you should have a road test accompanied by some form of medical certificate from your doc declaring that you are fit for the purpose of taking the test.



I chuckled when I read this. In the last ten years I have had rotator cuff surgery on each shoulder; a broken arm and a broken hand. I have had plenty of practice to enable me to deal with a broken collar bone! Interestingly, I was prescribed a painkiller for the first rotator cuff surgery that required the surgeon to report it to the ministry, and my license was suspended. I had not expected this, did not fill the perscription, returned it to the surgeon and he immediately had the ministry restore my license. If elderly drivers are not physically able to drive in a safe and competent manner, how is this different to my pain killer experience? It is not.

As far as testing of the elderly..well there are some 20..30..40 year olds who couldnt pass the drivers test NOW.....people have a tendancy to develope bad driving habits.....and those habits will not allow you to pass the testing now a days.....
My job allows me to see the good..bad ..and ugly out there on the highways and being an octagenarian by no means..means you are incompetant to drive a motor vehicle.I have seen plenty of 70..80 Y/O who could still handle a NASCAR ride.....but I have also see 20..and 30..Y/O who shouldnt be allowed behind the wheel of a fucking bumper car!
 
As far as testing of the elderly..well there are some 20..30..40 year olds who couldnt pass the drivers test NOW.....people have a tendancy to develope bad driving habits.....and those habits will not allow you to pass the testing now a days.....
My job allows me to see the good..bad ..and ugly out there on the highways and being an octagenarian by no means..means you are incompetant to drive a motor vehicle.I have seen plenty of 70..80 Y/O who could still handle a NASCAR ride.....but I have also see 20..and 30..Y/O who shouldnt be allowed behind the wheel of a fucking bumper car!

Think about what I said in my post. Drivers wandering out of their lane etc is a legitimate reason to use a horn. Simple stuff.
 
Think about what I said in my post. Drivers wandering out of their lane etc is a legitimate reason to use a horn. Simple stuff.

Uh NO not really....defensive driving teaches you to slow down...allow the drifter to drift over...keep your distance ....and move away from the drifting car.....DO NOT distract them.......you dont know what the other driver is going to do.....AS MC Riders ..... we have to always be on the defensive when it comes to other drivers....driving a car should be no different...

SIMPLE STUFF!!!!
 
Uh NO not really....defensive driving teaches you to slow down...allow the drifter to drift over...keep your distance ....and move away from the drifting car.....DO NOT distract them.......you dont know what the other driver is going to do.....AS MC Riders ..... we have to always be on the defensive when it comes to other drivers....driving a car should be no different...

SIMPLE STUFF!!!!

15wgf2s.jpg
 
Hmmmm....not getting the reference there Celticman...but if its to infer that I'm blowing smoke up your ass(possible ..but I dont see your ass in the picture) I suggest you might wanna take an advanced rider refresher course and see what the instructors would say about your scenario....Since I was an instructor...and still do from time to time...I know what their answer would be.!
you say you've been riding for 50 years?...so...I'd say that puts you in the mid to late sixties...
I expected more from you sir..but....no worries

Cheers
 
I remember a friend of mine getting a call once where my friend's spouse drove through the front of a store. I thought an incident like that should have required some re-testing for this elderly person but nothing came of it. Hell my ex is one of those people that should not be driving...she is very dangerous at times but after nearly 20 years of trying to get a licence, they gave her one (probably to stop her of coming back).
Not everyone is born with good driving instincts and I'm not so sure they can be learned by everyone...
 
I remember a friend of mine getting a call once where my friend's spouse drove through the front of a store. I thought an incident like that should have required some re-testing for this elderly person but nothing came of it. Hell my ex is one of those people that should not be driving...she is very dangerous at times but after nearly 20 years of trying to get a licence, they gave her one (probably to stop her of coming back).
Not everyone is born with good driving instincts and I'm not so sure they can be learned by everyone...

Or retained for that matter.
I would say 40% of the licenced drivers on the road today...would FAIL their drivers test if they took it today....thats either the written ..OR..practical
 
When I was in Florida there was so many elderly drivers that they all looked about 75 and older.

They were either driving way below the speed limit or not making proper lane changes or going through stop signs.

I couldn't believe how crazy it was driving there. My grandmother drove til she was 86 and she hit a few cars in her last year of driving.