Eight steps to immediately accelerate climate action

Russia rejected all compromise and negotiation, though.

So where was the compromise offered?
Russia - according to you - said that NATO had to change its charter to invalidate the part that says any country can apply. (Applying does not guarantee acceptance.)
NATO said it wouldn't do that but was willing to discuss the security situation in Europe.
Remember that Russia said it was not going to invade and that the US saying it was intending to invade was the US lying.
So Russia said "we want Ukraine frozen out of NATO, but we aren't going to invade Ukraine". The US and NATO both say "we aren't going to change the NATO charter, but on the rest of your list there are things we can negotiate - but don't invade Ukraine."
Russia says "You refuse to give us the thing we want, but how dare you accuse us of intending to invade Ukraine".

Then Russia invades Ukraine.

What compromise could they offer when talking about a possible rival military alliance at their borders? NATO may have a charter but they could have made an exception to say that Ukraine will never be accepted into NATO.
 
What one Earth possibly would make you say something as ridiculous as that 100% promise?

Because that would have made sure Ukraine remained neutral.
 
The US did that (well not invade -, but atleast threatened war), during the Cuban Missile Crisis.

When did the US threaten war during the Cuban Missle Crisis?
They actually rejected the "bomb and invade again" plan. They put up a naval restriction, and then entered negotiations, in which they agreed not to invade Cuba and took their missiles out of Turkey.
(Since putting the missiles in Turkey provoked the USSR making the deal to put missiles in Cuba.)

Kind of hard to make a good parallel to the Ukraine situation here.

They also try to orchestrate Bay of Pigs to topple the Castro regime which is a great example of foreign interference against a neighbouring country that was considered an ally of the enemy.

Yes.
And everyone agrees it was immoral and wrong to do that.

"The US did an immoral act. This means that Russia cannot do anything immoral" is a pretty weird argument to be making.
 
Its possible that is what he did. However it doesn't take away from the underlying reason that Ukraine was moving away from Russia and towards EU/NATO. That in and of itself is seen as a threat by Russia, and justifiably so. Because the next step would be economic and most importantly military cooperation.

So anything that doesn't go Russia's way is a justified reason to wage war according to you?
 
That story just doesn't hold water. Ukraine was the buffer between Putin and NATO. Taking out the buffer would have only meant that NATO definitely was on his border.

Look.
NATO on his border is intolerable.
Therefore he had no choice but to invade and force NATO to be on his border.

All very logical.

Actually, by this logic, NATO should feel threatened and so therefore is justified in invading Russia at this point, according to the logic here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
That story just doesn't hold water. Ukraine was the buffer between Putin and NATO. Taking out the buffer would have only meant that NATO definitely was on his border.
That would be true if he annexed Ukraine and made it a part of Russia. Wouldn't be the case if the invasion led to an agreement that Ukraine wouldn't join NATO (like in Georgia in 2008).
 
When did the US threaten war during the Cuban Missle Crisis?
They actually rejected the "bomb and invade again" plan. They put up a naval restriction, and then entered negotiations, in which they agreed not to invade Cuba and took their missiles out of Turkey.
(Since putting the missiles in Turkey provoked the USSR making the deal to put missiles in Cuba.)

Kind of hard to make a good parallel to the Ukraine situation here.

A naval blockade is a show of force. Yes it did not lead to war, but could possibly have. People at the time were afraid there was going to be a nuclear holocaust.

But why would that have 100% prevented an invasion?
What on earth would make you say something like that?

That was the demand from Russia. If Ukraine wouldn't join NATO, what reason does Russia have to invade?

So anything that doesn't go Russia's way is a justified reason to wage war according to you?

Thats a strawman. I said military cooperation with a foreign rival military alliance is a threat to Russia, which it is.
 
That would be true if he annexed Ukraine and made it a part of Russia. Wouldn't be the case if the invasion led to an agreement that Ukraine wouldn't join NATO (like in Georgia in 2008).

That's your weirdest claim yet.
You think Putin invaded Ukraine not to install the puppet government he had waiting but just to sign an agreement on their behalf and then leave?

That was the demand from Russia. If Ukraine wouldn't join NATO, what reason does Russia have to invade?

To fulfill Putin's dreams of an expanded Russian empire.
That's so much more believable a story than saying he wanted to invade, putting NATO on his borders, in order to avoid having NATO on his borders.
 
A naval blockade is a show of force. Yes it did not lead to war, but could possibly have. People at the time were afraid there was going to be a nuclear holocaust.

Of course they were.
It's still a bad comparison in the end, given how it played out.

That was the demand from Russia. If Ukraine wouldn't join NATO, what reason does Russia have to invade?
That wasn't Russia's only demand and it wasn't even what they cited when they actually did invade.
There is very little reason to believe that Ukraine promising to not join NATO would stop an invasion.
What happens when Ukraine decides to make other defensive alliances against Russia?
(An Alliance of Baltic states, perhaps.)

Most countries don't agree with "if you make an alliance we disagree with, we will invade" as a legitimate invasion reason.
I get it that you and I disagree on this point.

Thats a strawman. I said military cooperation with a foreign rival military alliance is a threat to Russia, which it is.

And that justifies invasion for you, yes.

We just have very very different ideas of what is a justified invasion.

"You cannot join a military alliance that will protect you from invasion by us or we will invade you" isn't convincing to me. Sorry.
 
We just have very very different ideas of what is a justified invasion.

"You cannot join a military alliance that will protect you from invasion by us or we will invade you" isn't convincing to me. Sorry.

It is more like - "You cannot join a military alliance that threatens my sovereignty, because that makes you my enemy".
 
That's your weirdest claim yet.
You think Putin invaded Ukraine not to install the puppet government he had waiting but just to sign an agreement on their behalf and then leave?



To fulfill Putin's dreams of an expanded Russian empire.
That's so much more believable a story than saying he wanted to invade, putting NATO on his borders, in order to avoid having NATO on his borders.

All of this, while I agree is plausible, still amounts to speculation in an argument.
 
Yes so that further justifies it, no?

No, its just hard to say, 'ok, I know we've been at war for 8 years, but you talking to those guys over there really pissed me off so now its regime change'.
Its still less speculation than claiming that had Ukraine signed yet another treaty then Putin really would have sent all the forces he amassed back home.