Eight steps to immediately accelerate climate action

But it is war. Ukraine's moves against pro-Russian politicians, starting with the ousting of Yanukovych, would have raised suspicions about NATO/US involvement, if you see it from Putin's shoes.

There was not NATO movement, only Putin moving in.
NATO had nothing to do with Yanukovych being ousted, that was the people.
 
There was not NATO movement, only Putin moving in.
NATO had nothing to do with Yanukovych being ousted, that was the people.

Putin was at war with Ukraine though. NATO had nothing to do with Yanukovych's ousting, but from Putin's shoes, arresting pro-Russian politicians, is a red flag that Ukraine maybe moving closer to EU/NATO. So perhaps the buildup was pre-emptive.
 
Putin was at war with Ukraine though. NATO had nothing to do with Yanukovych's ousting, but from Putin's shoes, arresting pro-Russian politicians, is a red flag that Ukraine maybe moving closer to EU/NATO. So perhaps the buildup was pre-emptive.

That's much closer to reality.
Putin was pissed that Ukraine was ousting his guy.
So he built up around the borders and prepped his invasion to be all NATO's fault to Russians.
 
Emigrating to Britain and British citizenship are very different things. Also British India was not a British Protectorate.

The fact that there were immigration rules means they were NOT citizens. Every country allowed people to immigrate, UK wasn't special. Indians were subjects of the crown, and British India was a dominion. Indians were not citizens, couldn't vote in British elections etc., You said it yourself, they had to immigrate, claim residency and then apply for citizenship. So they were NOT citizens.

On the other hand, Russia did NOT annex those 14 current nations. They were part of the Russian Empire. The Empire was ended with the Russian Revolution and USSR was formed. When it collapsed the former SSRs, split into independent nations. So NO, they were NOT annexed.

You are just replying for the sake of replying and engaging in revisionism.

Again you are confused as to what the facts are. Canadians were British Subjects until 1947, even though Canada were granted their Independence in 1867:


With the British Subject Status one could travel freely to the UK and even live and work there. Now that applied to all British Subjects and India was no different. That is why a sizeable number of Indians left to migrate to England. Those with British Protected Passports had to apply to emigrate to the UK. I say migrate as most of them had not even step foot prior to that. When you are a British Subject then you have every right to travel to the UK without visas and live there indefinitely. What do you think happened to the Uganda Asians who were forced to leave Uganda in 1972. As all of them had their property and cash confiscated by the Uganda Government, all they ended up in the UK was with personal possessions and less than GBP 500. That is why they were then known as refugees and the British Government had to help put them in Army Shelters for a few months until they found their own accomodation. They all held British Subject Passports. Now the British Subject Passports were switched to British Overseas Citizenship in 1983. That is when the residential rights were curtailed, although this was long after all those countries were granted Independence. Very few citizens have this British Overseas Citizen status. Now if these British Subjects were residing in the UK, then they were allowed to vote in the elections. India was a Colony of the UK and the British laws applied during that time, just like the Soviet Union Laws in The Ukraine. Funny you mention elections, as there were no real elections in the Soviet Union. Just One Party Rule and that was it!!
 
Again you are confused as to what the facts are. Canadians were British Subjects until 1947, even though Canada were granted their Independence in 1867:


With the British Subject Status one could travel freely to the UK and even live and work there. Now that applied to all British Subjects and India was no different. That is why a sizeable number of Indians left to migrate to England. Those with British Protected Passports had to apply to emigrate to the UK. I say migrate as most of them had not even step foot prior to that. When you are a British Subject then you have every right to travel to the UK without visas and live there indefinitely. What do you think happened to the Uganda Asians who were forced to leave Uganda in 1972. As all of them had their property and cash confiscated by the Uganda Government, all they ended up in the UK was with personal possessions and less than GBP 500. That is why they were then known as refugees and the British Government had to help put them in Army Shelters for a few months until they found their own accomodation. They all held British Subject Passports. Now the British Subject Passports were switched to British Overseas Citizenship in 1983. That is when the residential rights were curtailed, although this was long after all those countries were granted Independence. Very few citizens have this British Overseas Citizen status. Now if these British Subjects were residing in the UK, then they were allowed to vote in the elections. India was a Colony of the UK and the British laws applied during that time, just like the Soviet Union Laws in The Ukraine. Funny you mention elections, as there were no real elections in the Soviet Union. Just One Party Rule and that was it!!

India was a colony, yes. Being able to travel freely, does NOT equal citizenship. Citizenry comes with certain rights and responsibilities. Those did NOT apply to Indians. Regardless of whether or not India was a colony, India was COLONIZED by the British. It was a foreign land, with foreign people, with a foreign culture and the UK took it over.

On the other hand, Ukraine as we know it today, was a part of the Russian Empire - like Ontario is a part of Canada. When the USSR was formed, Ukraine stayed on. Only with the collapse of the Soviet Union did Ukraine become a free nation.

So the situation in India and Ukraine are entirely different and are not comparable.

You are just going around in circles and making convoluted statements. It doesn't add anything to the discussion.
 
That's much closer to reality.
Putin was pissed that Ukraine was ousting his guy.
So he built up around the borders and prepped his invasion to be all NATO's fault to Russians.

Its possible that is what he did. However it doesn't take away from the underlying reason that Ukraine was moving away from Russia and towards EU/NATO. That in and of itself is seen as a threat by Russia, and justifiably so. Because the next step would be economic and most importantly military cooperation.
 
India was a colony, yes. Being able to travel freely, does NOT equal citizenship. Citizenry comes with certain rights and responsibilities. Those did NOT apply to Indians. Regardless of whether or not India was a colony, India was COLONIZED by the British. It was a foreign land, with foreign people, with a foreign culture and the UK took it over.

On the other hand, Ukraine as we know it today, was a part of the Russian Empire - like Ontario is a part of Canada. When the USSR was formed, Ukraine stayed on. Only with the collapse of the Soviet Union did Ukraine become a free nation.

So the situation in India and Ukraine are entirely different and are not comparable.

You are just going around in circles and making convoluted statements. It doesn't add anything to the discussion.

They applied to Indians Citizens withe the British Subject Passports. India was part of the British Empire as well. Indians with British Subjects Passport could travel freely. Not the case with British Protected Citizens. There was NO INDIAN CITIZENSHIP during the British Rule.

But there was far worse travel restrictions within the Soviet Union:

Freedom of movement[edit]

January 10, 1973. Jewish refuseniksdemonstrate in front of the Ministry of Internal Affairs for the right to emigrate to Israel.
Main article: Passport system in the Soviet Union
Emigration and any travel abroad were not allowed without an explicit permission from the government. People who were not allowed to leave the country and campaigned for their right to leave in the 1970s were known as "refuseniks". According to the Soviet Criminal Code, a refusal to return from abroad was treason, punishable by imprisonment for a term of 10–15 years, or death with confiscation of property.[19]

The passport system in the Soviet Union restricted migration of citizens within the country through the "propiska" (residential permit/registration system) and the use of internal passports. For a long period of Soviet history, peasants did not have internal passports, and could not move into towns without permission. Many former inmates received "wolf tickets" and were only allowed to live a minimum of 101 km away from city borders. Travel to closed cities and to the regions near USSR state borders was strongly restricted. An attempt to illegally escape abroad was punishable by imprisonment for 1–3 years.[19]

 
Its possible that is what he did. However it doesn't take away from the underlying reason that Ukraine was moving away from Russia and towards EU/NATO. That in and of itself is seen as a threat by Russia, and justifiably so. Because the next step would be economic and most importantly military cooperation.

So?

Its not a threat to Russia because Ukraine isn't part of Russia. They are allowed to do what they want.
Would you say the same if the US invaded Mexico because they started aligning with China more?
 
So?

Its not a threat to Russia because Ukraine isn't part of Russia. They are allowed to do what they want.
Would you say the same if the US invaded Mexico because they started aligning with China more?

The US did that (well not invade -, but atleast threatened war), during the Cuban Missile Crisis. They also try to orchestrate Bay of Pigs to topple the Castro regime which is a great example of foreign interference against a neighbouring country that was considered an ally of the enemy.
 
The US did that (well not invade -, but atleast threatened war), during the Cuban Missile Crisis. They also try to orchestrate Bay of Pigs to topple the Castro regime which is a great example of foreign interference against a neighbouring country that was considered an ally of the enemy.

Sure, but does that mean you think the Bay of Pigs was as justified as Ukraine?
Would you apply that to Iraq and Afghanistan or any other American 'intervention'?
 
Sure, but does that mean you think the Bay of Pigs was as justified as Ukraine?
Would you apply that to Iraq and Afghanistan or any other American 'intervention'?

I think American reasoning for their actions during the Cuban Missile crisis with the naval blockade etc, was justified. Similarly, reasons for Russian actions invading Ukraine are also justified.

But it is a bit of a moral quandary as although the reasons are justifiable, the actions are not.

BTW the American intervention in Iraq, Afghanistan and Bay of Pigs were not justified as it was about regime change, not guarding American sovereignty.
 
I think American reasoning for their actions during the Cuban Missile crisis with the naval blockade etc, was justified. Similarly, reasons for Russian actions invading Ukraine are also justified.

But it is a bit of a moral quandary as although the reasons are justifiable, the actions are not.

BTW the American intervention in Iraq, Afghanistan and Bay of Pigs were not justified as it was about regime change, not guarding American sovereignty.

Ukraine was about regime change.
Putin had a puppet government all set to go.
 
Ukraine was about regime change.
Putin had a puppet government all set to go.
Sure, as a consequence. But primarily it was about national security and sovereignty.

For the US it was more about economics and foreign policy.
 
Sure, as a consequence. But primarily it was about national security and sovereignty.

For the US it was more about economics and foreign policy.

I don't think that's accurate.
Putin had a 3 day plan to take out Zelenskyy and his government and replace it with puppets.
That's regime change.

As for security, he now does have a NATO neighbour in Finland.
 
I don't think that's accurate.
Putin had a 3 day plan to take out Zelenskyy and his government and replace it with puppets.
That's regime change.

As for security, he now does have a NATO neighbour in Finland.

Finland not yet though. But it is indeed a checkmate to Putin.

Also regime change is the consequence of an invasion, but the invasion itself was because of fears of Ukraine joining NATO. The US on the other hand invaded Iraq which is neither a security threat nor a neighbour, solely to institute regime change, oust Saddam and steal its oil.
 
Finland not yet though. But it is indeed a checkmate to Putin.

Also regime change is the consequence of an invasion, but the invasion itself was because of fears of Ukraine joining NATO. The US on the other hand invaded Iraq which is neither a security threat nor a neighbour, solely to institute regime change, oust Saddam and steal its oil.

You're back to this idea that Putin was afraid so he spent a year building up forces around Ukraine, then gave NATO the ultimatum and then invaded with the goal regime change.
Putin invaded because he thought it would be an easy win. 3 days.
 
You're back to this idea that Putin was afraid so he spent a year building up forces around Ukraine, then gave NATO the ultimatum and then invaded with the goal regime change.
Putin invaded because he thought it would be an easy win. 3 days.

He did think it will be easy. But I am talking more about the actual reason for the invasion in the first place. Why would he wanna invade Ukraine even if it was easy? Because of NATO (and also because he wants to secure that region as Russia's sphere of influence).
 
He did think it will be easy. But I am talking more about the actual reason for the invasion in the first place. Why would he wanna invade Ukraine even if it was easy? Because of NATO (and also because he wants to secure that region as Russia's sphere of influence).

That story just doesn't hold water. Ukraine was the buffer between Putin and NATO. Taking out the buffer would have only meant that NATO definitely was on his border.
 
All that had to happen was for the west and NATO to compromise on Russia's demands.

Russia rejected all compromise and negotiation, though.

Russia demanded that the US and NATO enter into a legally binding arrangement preventing Ukraine from ever joining NATO. Since the west is so concerned about Ukraine, they should have done that. Ukraine at the very least should have given assurances to Russia. None of that happened.

So where was the compromise offered?
Russia - according to you - said that NATO had to change its charter to invalidate the part that says any country can apply. (Applying does not guarantee acceptance.)
NATO said it wouldn't do that but was willing to discuss the security situation in Europe.
Remember that Russia said it was not going to invade and that the US saying it was intending to invade was the US lying.
So Russia said "we want Ukraine frozen out of NATO, but we aren't going to invade Ukraine". The US and NATO both say "we aren't going to change the NATO charter, but on the rest of your list there are things we can negotiate - but don't invade Ukraine."
Russia says "You refuse to give us the thing we want, but how dare you accuse us of intending to invade Ukraine".

Then Russia invades Ukraine.
 
That is hyperbole and dont put words in my mouth. Ukraine and NATO providing a legally binding agreement that Ukraine will never join an enemy military alliance does not prevent Ukraine form acting independently in other ways.

And providing such an agreement would have 100% prevented war.

What one Earth possibly would make you say something as ridiculous as that 100% promise?