Does J.P. know what he is doing?

Primetime21

Well-known member
Nov 27, 2001
1,459
3,052
113
internet
With the official signing of BJ Ryan supposed to be at 1 pm today, one must wonder if JP knows what he is doing. He has had some good and some bad moves during his tenure, but this signing could be his make or break move. It is obvious he had overpaid for a closer that has only been full-time for 1 full season. I know there will be other moves, to come. But if this turns into a bust the other moves may turn out to be irrelevant. If this guy is a flash in the pan, the jays are screwed if they deal Batista. JP isn't at the top of my list for gm's, but this move is very interesting. I know he has to overpay to get players to come to Toronto, but this is the extreme. I really don't agree with his philosophy of getting players with a high on-base %. He should be more interested in getting players that actually get rbi's. The jays were terrible batting with runners in scoring position last year, if they were able to get a few more rbi's they would have had a better record. I do hope this turns out for the best, but for the amount he paid, it is more likely to blow up in his face.
 
Give JP a chance for now.

JP has had the team for only a short time. Give him another 2 seasons. This year's free agent market is definatly a seller's market due the weak number of people out there. If we get a guy in our lineup like a Brian Giles or a Lyle Overbay who both got a large number of RBI's considering the teams they were on and have done so through their career, we should go and get them. Especially since San Diego balked at Giles' $8 mil a year request. We could get him at a bargain!

The Jays' problem last year wasn't getting on base, it was getting those guys on base in. Their next priority should be an rbi man like the aforementioned or a Kevin Mench who are proven run providors.

And hey, if some team is stupid enough to take Batista, then we can applaud JP for getting someone in return. If that someone in return produces some great numbers, we can hail him as a genius!
 
I am on record in another thread stating there was no way Ryan would come to the Jays. I was wrong. The amount of money they're paying him is obscene. The guy had a good year last year closing, and has been an effective reliever the last 5 - 6 years, but a situational lefty until the last 2. The happiest man in baseball today must be Billy Wagner, cuz if Ryan got this deal, Wagners price just went waaaaaaay up!
 
I think this signing does 2 things. It gives the team a much needed solid closer as well as show other free agents that Toronto is serious.

A pitcher like Burnett who the Jays would like to have will now look more seriously at the Jays. He knows now that if he gets into the 8th inning a top notch closer can come on and preserve the win.

A first baseman with some pop along with a pitcher like Burnett would move the Jays up to the next level.

They can either, now trade Batista or put him into the starting rotation where he could be a solid #4 or #5 starter.
 
Let's face it with the Yankees and the Red Sox in the same division we need a minor miracle to make the play-offs.
 
JohnC said:
Let's face it with the Yankees and the Red Sox in the same division we need a minor miracle to make the play-offs.
The Yanks and BoSox are both getting a little long in the tooth.

If a team comes together and peaks at the right time they can suprise even themselves.
 
A-ROD said:
The Yanks and BoSox are both getting a little long in the tooth.

If a team comes together and peaks at the right time they can suprise even themselves.

I dunno who's gonna be on either the Yanks or Sox., The Sox would seem to be trying to get younger, while addressing their issues. The Yanks have not yet begun, but you know the Boss is gonna do something big. The Yanks may not get younger, they'll sure as hell get pricier.:rolleyes: You have to know both will do whatever it takes to try stay at the top.
 
bigdik said:
I The Sox would seem to be trying to get younger, while addressing their issues. The Yanks have not yet begun, but you know the Boss is gonna do something big. The Yanks may not get younger, they'll sure as hell get pricier.:rolleyes: You have to know both will do whatever it takes to try stay at the top.
There, in a nutshell, is the problem for the BJ's.
 
bigdik said:
I dunno who's gonna be on either the Yanks or Sox., The Sox would seem to be trying to get younger, while addressing their issues. The Yanks have not yet begun, but you know the Boss is gonna do something big. The Yanks may not get younger, they'll sure as hell get pricier.:rolleyes: You have to know both will do whatever it takes to try stay at the top.
But this doesn't always work, especially in baseball.

When they spend the way they do they always seem to forget one of the most important factors......"Team Chemistry"
 
Anybody see the size of that guy (BJ Ryan)... 6'6" 270 lbs

I saw a clip of him sitting beside Riccardi.. He is huge.

The Argos should have signed him not the BJ's
 
I think the hope is that Ryan continues to do well for at least 2 seasons, and that a home-grown pitcher steps into the closer role and the Jays can unload Ryan. Reason being, his contract is structured to pay $2 million in 2006, rising to $5 million in 2007 and $10 million in the final three years of his deal, according to bluejays.com.
If they can find a taker for him before the big money kicks in and a Brandon league or another kid can come in, this could be a great deal. If Ryan flounders however, the Jays will be very hard pressed to find a taker for his remaining $30 million over the final three years.
I think this also signals Riccardi realizing the honeymoon is over. He doesn't have the lack of money excuse anymore, so he has to show results now, no more "building for the future", otherwise he might not be part of it.
 
BlahBlah said:
I think the hope is that Ryan continues to do well for at least 2 seasons, and that a home-grown pitcher steps into the closer role and the Jays can unload Ryan. Reason being, his contract is structured to pay $2 million in 2006, rising to $5 million in 2007 and $10 million in the final three years of his deal, according to bluejays.com.
If they can find a taker for him before the big money kicks in and a Brandon league or another kid can come in, this could be a great deal. If Ryan flounders however, the Jays will be very hard pressed to find a taker for his remaining $30 million over the final three years.
I think this also signals Riccardi realizing the honeymoon is over. He doesn't have the lack of money excuse anymore, so he has to show results now, no more "building for the future", otherwise he might not be part of it.
Very good... this makes a lot of sense.
 
A-ROD said:
But this doesn't always work, especially in baseball.

When they spend the way they do they always seem to forget one of the most important factors......"Team Chemistry"

Yankees forget chemistry, In the last couple of years, the Sox don't.
I think I hear Ranger coming.............:rolleyes:
 
Seriously though, Ryan is a good acquisition,he addresses 2 needs. A closer, and whatever they do with Batista. This is definitely a case of overpaying though, even if BlahBlah's prediction comes true. They also have to pay him$10M in bonus, so the first 2 years are still $17M. They'd better give him a lot of save situations.;)
 
I like this signing. Not only for the benefits of having a top notch closer, but I think it also sends a message to the league and other free agents. The BJ's are serious about fielding a competitive team again :)
 
I still hope they dont get Burnett, over-rated, the stats simply dont lie. I remember hearing something about the Jays inquiring about Zito, but that was a while back.

As for Overbay, they dont need him either. The team is stacked with 1B/DH's...
 
A lucrative 5 year deal to a semi proven 29 year old isn't good business sense.

The problem, however, is that Toronto HAS to overpay to successfully land free agents here....until, of course, they are winning again.
 
actually Wagner's deal topped his. And Ryan cant be classified as a 'top player'. He's been a closer for ONE season. If he gets off to a bad start, it will be boo bird city.