Does Fuji speak for you?

Does Fuji speak for you?

  • Fuji Speaks for me

    Votes: 16 50.0%
  • Fuji does not speak for me

    Votes: 16 50.0%

  • Total voters
    32
  • Poll closed .
I have a rifle, but that doesn't mean I'm not a civilian. Whether you are armed with a rock or a rifle doesn't matter. What matters is whether you go out and attack the enemy.

Someone sitting at home with a rock or a rifle isn't a combatant.

Then by your own definition, settlers are militants.
http://www.imemc.org/article/67472

Israeli forces continued to support settlement activities in the West Bank and Israeli settlers continued to attack Palestinian civilians and property.

On 30 March 2014, a 24-year-old civilian sustained a bullet wound to the left leg when a settler opened fire at him on "Yitzhar" bypass road.

Israel continued efforts to create a Jewish majority in the occupied East Jerusalem. Two civilians were obliged to demolish two residential barracks of their own.

A Palestinian sustained a bullet wound as a settler opened fire at him.

8 residential tents and 4 livestock barns were demolished.

18 civilian facilities in the Northern Jordan Valley were demolished, due to which 38 civilians, including 22 children, became homeless.

7 residential rooms, south of Hebron, were demolished, due to which 95 civilians became homeless.

Israeli attacks on non-violent demonstrations:

During the reporting period, Israeli soldiers used excessive force against peaceful demonstrations organised by Palestinian civilians, international and Israeli human rights defenders in protest at the construction of the annexation wall and settlement activities in the West Bank. As a result, a number of demonstrators suffered tear gas inhalation and others sustained bruises as they were beaten by Israeli soldiers.

In the same context, 6 Palestinian civilians, including 3 children, were wounded during other protests organized at the western entrance of Selwad village, northeast of Ramallah; Beit Ommar village, north of Hebron; and Kofur Qaddoum village, northeast of Qalqilia. Three women suffered tear gas inhalation during a demonstration at the southern entrance of al-Jalazone refugee camp, north of Ramallah, on 28 March 2014.

Following the Friday Prayer, 28 March 2014, dozens of Palestinian civilians and international and Israeli human rights defenders organised a peaceful demonstration in Bil’in, west of Ramallah, in protest at the construction of the annexation wall and settlement activities. Demonstrators took the streets raising the Palestinian flags and headed to the liberated territories near the annexation wall. Israeli forces had closed all the entrances of the village since the morning in order to prevent Palestinian and international activists and journalists from participating in the demonstration. Demonstrators marched adjacent to the cement wall and tried to cross the fence before Israeli forces that are stationed behind the wall, in the western area, and a large number of soldiers deployed along it, fired live bullets, tear gas canisters, rubber-coated steel bullets, sound bombs and skunk water at them and chased them into the olive fields. As a result, a number of demonstrators suffered tear gas inhalation and others sustained bruises as they were beaten by Israeli soldiers.

On the same day, dozens of Palestinian civilians organised a peaceful demonstration in the centre of Ni’lin village, west of Ramallah, in protest at the construction of the annexation wall and settlement activities. Demonstrators took the streets and headed to the annexation wall. Israeli forces closed the gates of the wall with barbed wire and prevented the demonstrators from crossing to the land behind it, before they responded by throwing stones. As a result, many civilians suffered tear gas inhalation and bruises as they were beaten by Israeli soldiers.

Around the same time, dozens of Palestinian civilians and Israeli and international human rights defenders organised a peaceful demonstration in Nabi Saleh village, southwest of Ramallah, in protest at the construction of the annexation wall and settlement activities. Demonstrators made their way in the streets raising the Palestinian flags and chanting slogans against the occupation and in support of the Palestinian unified resistance and, then, they headed to the lands that the settlers are trying to rob by force, near “Halamish” settlement. Israeli forces closed all the entrances of the village, since the morning, to prevent Palestinian and international activists and journalists from participating in the demonstration. When they arrived at the land, demonstrators were met by live bullets, tear gas canisters, rubber-coated steel bullets, sound bombs and skunk water, and were chased into the village. As a result, many civilians suffered tear gas inhalation and others sustained bruises due to being beaten by Israeli soldiers.

On Friday, 28 March 2014, dozens of children and young men gathered at the southern entrance of al-Jalazoun refugee camp, north of Ramallah. They were about 300 meters away from the fence of "Beit Eil" settlement. Israeli forces stationed in the area fired live ammunition, rubber-coated metal bullets, sound bombs and tear gas canisters. As a result, a number of civilians suffered tear gas inhalation. Of the wounded were three women: Amina Taleb Mohammed 'Attari (82); Sabrin Malek Mohammed Attari (25); and Majeda Issa Attiya Abu Aisha (54).

On the same day, dozens of young Palestinian men gathered at the western entrance of Selwad village, northeast of Ramallah, on the road between Selwad village and Yabrod village, near Street (60), to throw stones at the aforementioned street. In response, Israeli soldiers attempted to raid houses overlooking the area in which the clashes occurred, to turn them into military sites, but residents of the houses denied them access to their houses. As a result, two civilians were wounded and then taken to Palestine Medical Complex in Ramallah to receive the necessary medical treatment. The first 26-year-old male sustained a bullet wound to the left leg and the second 18-year-old male sustained a bullet wound to the right knee. Moreover, dozens of civilians suffered tear gas inhalation and others sustained bruises as they were beaten by Israeli soldiers. Israeli soldiers also stopped a vehicle driven by Mohammed Omar Hamed (20) and obliged him to step out. When they asked his brother Nabil (22), who is handicapped due to a previous injury in the spine by Israeli forces, to step out as well, they attacked him with their gun butts on his shoulder. Mohammed was taken to Ofer detention facility, but he was released at approximately 21:00.

At approximately 13:30, a peaceful demonstration was organized by dozens of Palestinians in Beit Ommar village, north of Hebron. They raised Palestinian flags and chanted patriot slogans. When they approached Asida area, about 300 meters away from the village's entrance, Israeli forces deployed and started firing sound bombs, tear gas canisters and rubber-coated metal bullets in response. As a result, a number of demonstrators suffered tear gas inhalation. In the meantime, military vehicles accompanied by a vehicle to spray wastewater moved into the village. The vehicle sprayed wastewater over stores at the entrance of the village. In addition, Israeli soldiers chased boys in al-Shaikh and al-Zahlaqan neighbourhoods and fired live ammunition indiscriminately. As a result, Qais Mohammed Kamel Abu Maria (11) sustained a bullet wound to the right thigh, as Israeli soldiers fired at him from a distance of 10 meters, while he was standing in front of his house. The child entered inside, but Israeli soldiers raided the house and abducted him. When his mother intervened, an Israeli soldier pushed her away and she lost consciousness. The child was taken to "Kfar Etzion" settlement. He was offered first aid and then delivered to a Palestinian ambulance that took him to Hebron Hospital. It was found that he sustained a deep wound. He was offered the necessary medical treatment and then discharged.

The child said to a PCHR fieldworker: "I am a 5th-grade student in Hettin school. Our house is about 300 meters away from the Israeli surveillance site at the entrance of the village. At approximately 17:00 on Sunday, 30 March 2014, I heard gunfire around the house. Other students at school told me it was the Land Day, so I realized clashes had erupted. I went out to see what was happening. I was standing on a high place about 10 meters away from the house. I saw students throwing stones at Israeli soldiers. The boys asked me to go away, so I approached the house door. I saw a soldier who took position and fired at me from a distance of about 10 meters. I felt something had hit my left thigh from the back. I ran towards the house, but the same soldier raided the house and pointed his gun at me, my mother Feryal (34) and uncle Sajed (38). He caught me from the back and pulled me to the outside. My mother tried to stop him but it vain. He took me to the military watchtower although I kept telling him that my leg was hurting. Another soldier pulled my hair and another one slapped me on the face and hit me by a gun butt to my back. The soldier pulled me from my hair to the watchtower and then forced me to get into a jeep. My mother hurried to help me, but a soldier pushed her away and she lost consciousness. They offered me first aid in the jeep. I stayed there for about 3 hours. A PRCS's ambulance arrived then and took me to Hebron Hospital."

At approximately 16:00 on Saturday, 29 March 2014, Palestinian civilians and international activists organised a peaceful demonstration in the centre of Kufor Qaddoum village, northwest of Qalqilia, and headed towards the eastern entrance of the village to mark the Land Day. Clashes erupted between the demonstrators and Israeli forces that fired sound bombs and tear gas canisters. As a result, 3 civilians, including 2 children, were wounded and 2 others suffered tear gas inhalation. Khaled Morad Ishtaiwi (9) sustained a bullet wound to the right leg; a 17-year-old male sustained a bullet wound to the back and a 23-year-old male sustained a bullet wound to the right leg.

Israel arms and supports settler attacks on civilians.
 
Keep skating around the real issue yourself then, the fact that Palestinians want the complete destruction of the state of Israel. Keep talking about how Israel has to give up land it holds, when the Palestinians said no to the original deal which would have seem them have their own country along side Israel, they said no because they didn't want Israel to exist and thought that the coming war would wipe them off the map...oops, they fucked that one up huh. If you actually read the geneva conventions in regards to colonization you would actually see that Israel is not in violation of it and the settlers are armed because they are attacked. I abhor any violations against innocent civilians, be it if Israel does it or the Palestinians, the difference between you and I is you blame Israel for everything and don't denounce the atrocities committed by the Palestinians, instead you justify it.

First of all, the Saudi plan which recognized Israel existing beside Palestine was rejected not because Palestinians want Israel destroyed, but because it did not include the Palestinian right of return. You're creating false causation.

If YOU actually read the Geneva Convention you'd realize settlers are EXACTLY in violation of it and this is recognized by EVERY SINGLE STATE IN THE WORLD EXCEPT FOR ISRAEL. Even Israel's best allies recognize the settlements as against Geneva Conventions, against international law, and that colonization is a war crime. Making the colonizers war criminals. Settlers that are attacked should pick up their bags and stop committing the great moral atrocity of colonization. Palestinians are the victims.

The fact that you dare to claim that settlers don't violate international law shows you're willing to lie through your teeth for your beloved country. Why don't you try being a real patriot by fixing your country's problems, instead of denying them.

The reason I don't denounce "atrocities" committed by Palestinians in the same breath as I denounce Israeli war crimes is because it creates a parallel or dichotomy where there is none. The number of innocent children killed is incomparable. Palestinian children as young as five are tried in Israeli Military Court, there's no comparable Israeli complaint. Palestinians cannot control access to their own water, there's no comparable Israeli complaint. Palestinians cannot move freely, there is no comparable Israeli complaint. Palestinians cannot rebuild their own home without Israeli permission, there is no comparable Israeli complaint. Palestinians are beaten at checkpoints and go through arbitrary 5 hour waits, there's no comparable Israeli complaint. But Israel complains about Palestinian terrorism, where even in that arena, Israel has killed exponentially more civilians and reigned far more terror.

Palestinians are victims and when their land is being raped and pillaged by a government whose only claim to the land is that God gave it to them, they have a right to defend themselves. But the ones defending the territory that is being ILLEGALY occupied are terrorist and the ones dropping bombs on 360 km2 populated by 1.8 million people are the ones trying to spare civilians? You have a funny way of looking at things.

Another thing that's funny is that you're angry I justify Palestinian "atrocities" (as if they are at all on the same scale) but you haven't at all denounce Israeli war crimes, like putting Gazans on a calorie count while under seige, denying them access to water or medication, or displacing Palestinians from their land to build Jewish-only cities.

I agree with Noam Chomsky. The Palestinians are being CRUSHED by the Israeli government, military and settlers and they very much have a right to defend themselves. I don't agree with it, but what I'm saying is that if you're going to call them terrorists, then the Israeli military is the mother of all terrorists when you look at damage caused.

The REAL issue here, the real issue of this conflict is where Israel has a right to exist. I argue that it is within the only legal borders Israel has. Israel argues it has a right to exist in over 90% of historical Palestine, even though it's legally entitled to 49%.

I blame Israel because Israel is the one violating 77 international laws and conventions and resolutions. I blame Israel because Israel is the one daily committing the moral atrocity of colonization, and Israel is the one painting the retaliating victims of colonization as terrorists looking for jihad. I think I have pretty good reason to blame Israel.
 
Amy you are going to have to stop the hate speech about settlers not being civilians. No civilized person will take anything you say seriously while you promote hatred and atrocity that openly.
 
Some sellers being militants doesn't make all settlers militants. Just like some Palestinians being militants doesn't make all Palestinians militants.
No but ALL SETTLERS are actively participating in the war crime of colonization.
 
Amy you are going to have to stop the hate speech about settlers not being civilians. No civilized person will take anything you say seriously while you promote hated and atrocity that openly.

It's not hate speech to say settlers aren't civilians. Civilians are people that have nothing to do with government action. A settler in a settlement by their existence acts as an aggressor, they are living on occupied land that is being violently stripped from the aboriginals before their eyes. Israelis can live within Israel. By choosing to live in a settlement instead, the Israeli stops becoming an Israeli civilian and becomes and Israeli settler. The Israeli settlers existence in Palestine is a war crime, and its not hate speech to say that someone actively stealing land with the support of an armed military is not a civilian.
 
No but ALL SETTLERS are actively participating in the war crime of colonization.

Not so. A five year old child, for example, is guilty of nothing whatsoever.

More to the point, the law you are citing makes the POLICY of population transfer Illegal (not "colonization", there is no such crime). The only ones accused are those in government who authorize the policy.

The transferred population itself is not even accused.

You have listened to very biased, partisan sources which gloss over the details of the law in order to justify their own war crimes and atrocities.

The correct legal remedy is compensation for those who have suffered losses. By analogy, the natives in Caledon do not have a right to murder the families of home owners there, even though the homes are built on land subject to a native land claim.
 
First of all, the Saudi plan which recognized Israel existing beside Palestine was rejected not because Palestinians want Israel destroyed, but because it did not include the Palestinian right of return. You're creating false causation. You can't be serious? First off, Israel has a law of return for Jews, had the Palestinians accepted a deal and became a nation of their own, then they could have implanted their own law of return.
 
It's not hate speech to say settlers are civilians. Civilians are people that have nothing to do with government action. A settler in a settlement by their existence acts as an aggressor, they are living on occupied land that is being violently stripped from the aboriginals before their eyes. Israelis can live within Israel. By choosing to live in a settlement instead, the Israeli stops becoming an Israeli civilian and becomes and Israeli settler. The Israeli settlers existence in Palestine is a war crime, and its not hate speech to say that someone actively stealing land with the support of an armed military is not a civilian.

There is no basis in law and no basis in morality for your claims. Living in a settlement is not in and of itself a violent act, that is empty rhetoric you use to justify atrocity against those civilians.

This article very well refutes your claim:

http://m.hrw.org/reports/2002/isrl-pa/ISRAELPA1002-04.htm

It is NOT a war crime "to be a settler", moreover you can't commit war crimes against someone just because they themselves did, even if it were.

For example, it is a war crime to encourage your children to participate in hostilities, such as stone throwing, but that does not justify targeting all parents of Palestinian child soldiers, even though they are war criminals.
 
Not so. A five year old child, for example, is guilty of nothing whatsoever.

More to the point, the law you are citing makes the POLICY of population transfer Illegal (not "colonization", there is no such crime). The only ones accused are those in government who authorize the policy.

The transferred population itself is not even accused.

You have listened to very biased, partisan sources which gloss over the details of the law in order to justify their own war crimes and atrocities.

The correct legal remedy is compensation for those who have suffered losses. By analogy, the natives in Caledon do not have a right to murder the families of home owners there, even though the homes are built on land subject to a native land claim.


While obviously killing children in any case is morally unjustifiable, the parents of that child are equally to blame. They exercised extremely poor moral and parental judgements by choosing to raise their child in a conflict region, in one of the very colonies causing the longest middle eastern conflict in history. The goal of Settlements is land theft and re population of land with Jews only, and its the parents of those children that chose to use their kids as pawns in a crazy religious war crime.

I'm a criminology and law major, I've taken years of international law both here and in Palestine, and I highly doubt years of coursework left me with a glossed over idea of what the law is.

By definition, colonization INCLUDES and is not even limited to population transfer. When you say that colonization isn't mentioned, it's because the legislators did not want to use narrow terminology.

Settlers have mayors and those mayors adopt policies, like more funding to enlarge the settlement, like asking for and building more roads to cut apart Palestinian billages, etc. And the mayor is elected by a population whose very existence proves they support ethnic cleansing. I don't know where you stop passing the buck, all I know is that colonization and "transfer of civilian population" wouldn't be possible if it weren't for the hundreds of thousands of settlers participating in the war crime.
 
There is no basis in law and no basis in morality for your claims. Living in a settlement is not in and of itself a violent act, that is empty rhetoric you use to justify atrocity against those civilians.

This article very well refutes your claim:

http://m.hrw.org/reports/2002/isrl-pa/ISRAELPA1002-04.htm

It is NOT a war crime "to be a settler", moreover you can't commit war crimes against someone just because they themselves did, even if it were.

For example, it is a war crime to encourage your children to participate in hostilities, such as stone throwing, but that does not justify targeting all parents of Palestinian child soldiers, even though they are war criminals.

Lol. It's not a war crime to throw a stone. You're funny.

And see below where I discuss where the buck stops.
 
First of all, the Saudi plan which recognized Israel existing beside Palestine was rejected not because Palestinians want Israel destroyed, but because it did not include the Palestinian right of return. You're creating false causation. You can't be serious? First off, Israel has a law of return for Jews, had the Palestinians accepted a deal and became a nation of their own, then they could have implanted their own law of return.

You only know enough to think you know things, but you sound foolish to me. If Palestinians had a state, of course they could implement the right of return. That wasn't the issue with the Saudi plan. The Saudi plan did not account for the 2 million+ Palestinian refugees that have a right to return to their home in ISRAEL. That was why it was rejected. Again, not because Palestinians want the destruction of Israel. False causation with no basis, considering no where in the poll is it asked "does your idea of a peace plan include the total destruction of Israel?"
 
Keep telling yourself that. Why don't you go read the charter of Hamas? Do you understand the quote, "from the river to the sea"? They do not want Israel to exist, they want one state, an arabic state.
 
While obviously killing children in any case is morally unjustifiable, the parents of that child are equally to blame.

No, they are not even remotely to blame. They are civilian victims of the murder of their child. Blame is ENTIRELY on the shoulders of those who chose to attack the civilian settlers.

They exercised extremely poor moral and parental judgements by choosing to raise their child in a conflict region

The same could be said of anyone else living in Palestine, whether Jew or Arab. Choosing to raise a family there does not mean you are legally or morally to blame for an attack targeting your family.

That is called blaming the victim.

I'm a criminology and law major, I've taken years of international law both here and in Palestine, and I highly doubt years of coursework left me with a glossed over idea of what the law is.

Then shame on you for not knowing the law, and shame on you again for advocating for horrendously illegal atrocity and war crime.

Here is some homework, scroll down to the discussion of settlers as legitimate targets:

http://m.hrw.org/reports/2002/isrl-pa/ISRAELPA1002-04.htm

By definition, colonization INCLUDES and is not even limited to population transfer.

Your definition. It is not from international law. The settlements are alleged to contravene the sections making a policy of population transfer illegal.

Settlers have mayors and those mayors adopt policies, like more funding to enlarge the settlement, like asking for and building more roads to cut apart Palestinian billages, etc.

Sure, to the extent that the mayor is not just providing for the population, but encouraging transfer, you could bring charges against the mayor. The mayor, even if convicted, would remain a civilian protected by the Geneva Conventions. Being guilty of a crime does not remove protected status under the convention.


And the mayor is elected by a population whose very existence proves they support ethnic cleansing.

Their existence does not prove they support ethnic cleansing, you are sliding back into dehumanizing hate speech.

And if you are trying to suggest that a population becomes a legitimate target because of who they voted for, you are waaaay out of line. Consider that Palestinians voted for Hamas: this does not make all Palestinians legitimate targets, not even only those who voted.
 
Keep telling yourself that. Why don't you go read the charter of Hamas? Do you understand the quote, "from the river to the sea"? They do not want Israel to exist, they want one state, an arabic state.

Again, Hamas does not represent all Palestinians. Fatah is the ruling party in the West Bank and it is in the West Bank that Israel builds illegal settlements. Even in Gaza, where Hamas was elected, it was elected by a majority, not unanimously. On an even more micro level, even within Hamas, not every leader calls for the total destruction of Israel.

So to say that the Saudi plan was rejected by Palestinians because of a sentence in the charter of Hamas is just plain ignorant. Especially not when the actual reason is completely legitimate and is being stated and restated.
 
Here's the problem with that, they do represent all Palestinians as they are a governing body. The charter states that "our struggle against the Jews is very great and very serious" and calls for the eventual creation of an Islamic state in Palestine, in place of Israel and the Palestinian Territories,[2] and the obliteration or dissolution of Israel.[3][4] The charter also states that Hamas is humanistic, and tolerant of other religions as long as they do not block Hamas's efforts.[5] The Charter adds that "renouncing any part of Palestine means renouncing part of the religion" of Islam.[1] Sounds pretty much like they don't want Israel to exist...
 
Lol. It's not a war crime to throw a stone.

No, it isn't a war crime, it is assault with a weapon.


If the target of the stone throwing is a legitimate military target, like a soldier, then it isn't a war crime, but it is a belligerent act. The stone thrower ceases to be a bystander and becomes a combatant, and they lose their Geneva Convention protection as civilian by becoming combatants.

Where the stone thrower is a child who was incited by an adult, the adult is a war criminal under the child soldier provisions.
 
The same could be said of anyone else living in Palestine, whether Jew or Arab. Choosing to raise a family there does not mean you are legally or morally to blame for an attack targeting your family.

That is called blaming the victim.

I knew you were going to say something ignorant like this. I knew you were going to say that the exact same could be said about Palestinian parents. That's another false dichotomy. Palestinians dont have freedom of movement and Palestinians are unable to relocate to other countries because other countries don't want them claiming refugee status. Palestinians are denied visas everywhere. This is not at all comparable to the Israeli citizen who can live within the borders of Israel. A Palestinian living in Palestine borders has no choice but to face the colonizers.
 
Here's the problem with that, they do represent all Palestinians as they are a governing body. The charter states that "our struggle against the Jews is very great and very serious" and calls for the eventual creation of an Islamic state in Palestine, in place of Israel and the Palestinian Territories,[2] and the obliteration or dissolution of Israel.[3][4] The charter also states that Hamas is humanistic, and tolerant of other religions as long as they do not block Hamas's efforts.[5] The Charter adds that "renouncing any part of Palestine means renouncing part of the religion" of Islam.[1] Sounds pretty much like they don't want Israel to exist...

Not sure how quoting Hamas's charter helps your argument when I already laid out why it's ignorant to say that this principle of Hamas is why the Saudi plan was rejected. You need to stick to actual arguments made instead of irrelevant point scoring
 
I knew you were going to say something ignorant like this. I knew you were going to say that the exact same could be said about Palestinian parents. That's another false dichotomy. Palestinians dont have freedom of movement and Palestinians are unable to relocate to other countries because other countries don't want them claiming refugee status. Palestinians are denied visas everywhere. This is not at all comparable to the Israeli citizen who can live within the borders of Israel. A Palestinian living in Palestine borders has no choice but to face the colonizers.

Palestinians can leave Palestine, many have. The decision not to leave would not and does not justify attacks targeting non combatant Palestinians.

The point here is that you cannot claim settlers are to blame for atrocity committed against them. Targeting non combatant civilians is always criminal.