Does Fuji speak for you?

Does Fuji speak for you?

  • Fuji Speaks for me

    Votes: 16 50.0%
  • Fuji does not speak for me

    Votes: 16 50.0%

  • Total voters
    32
  • Poll closed .
Every human rights organization on earth reports Israel's open season on Palestinian civilians.. Claiming Israel doesn't target civilians is delusional.

Settlers are not civilians. Settlers are Israelis living outside of Israels borders on Palestinian land with the sole intention of colonization. Settlers are armed, religious colonizers, who very very very openly wage aggressive assaults on nearby Palestinian villages in the hopes of terrorizing the Palestinians off of the land the settlers would like to take (the only goal of Settlements).

Settlers are illegal colonizers actively and knowingly violating the Geneva Conventions. This is INCOMPARABLE to the Palestinian civilians, who are actually just poverty - ridden aboriginals living off of their own land while being colonized from the north, the south, the east and the West.

Settlers are no civilians. They are violent land thieves.
 
Every human rights organization on earth reports Israel's open season on Palestinian civilians.. Claiming Israel doesn't target civilians is delusional.

Settlers are not civilians. Settlers are Israelis living outside of Israels borders on Palestinian land with the sole intention of colonization. Settlers are armed, religious colonizers, who very very very openly wage aggressive assaults on nearby Palestinian villages in the hopes of terrorizing the Palestinians off of the land the settlers would like to take (the only goal of Settlements).

Settlers are illegal colonizers actively and knowingly violating the Geneva Conventions. This is INCOMPARABLE to the Palestinian civilians, who are actually just poverty - ridden aboriginals living off of their own land while being colonized from the north, the south, the east and the West.

Settlers are no civilians. They are violent land thieves.

So you prescribe to the notion that all Israeli civilians are soldiers, since they were, are, or will be active in the military?
 
My problem with human rights organizations that are claiming what you claim is that they ignore the Palestinian abuses. They ignore the fact that they launch deliberate attacks on civilians, in Israel. That they torture journalist and their own people. Having been there, having served there, I know for a fact that no orders are ever given to directly target civilians and in fact that things are called off when there is a high probability of it. Civilian casualties will happen as collateral damage, especially when they are used willingly or not, as human shields for Hamas and the other lovely groups who don't just want the territories but the complete destruction of Israel.
 
Your question is completely unrelated to whether settlers are civilians or not.

A soldier on duty is a soldier.
A soldier off duty is a civilian.
A civilian that was once a soldier is a civilian.

A settler is not a soldier, but a different form of aggression employed by the Israeli government. There is no on duty or off duty settler. A settler is an armed citizen of Israel choosing to live their life outside of their own country's legal borders, participating in internationally recognized war crimes by living in a home built with the sole intention of land theft. That is what a settlement is. It is a colony built upon stolen land from aboriginals. Colonizers are not civilians, colonizers are illegal and their presence constitutes a war crime under the Geneva Convention.

Palestinians that attack settlers are not attacking innocents, they are attacking war criminals.
 
Your question is completely unrelated to whether settlers are civilians or not.

A soldier on duty is a soldier.
A soldier off duty is a civilian.
A civilian that was once a soldier is a civilian.

A settler is not a soldier, but a different form of aggression employed by the Israeli government. There is no on duty or off duty settler. A settler is an armed citizen of Israel choosing to live their life outside of their own country's legal borders, participating in internationally recognized war crimes by living in a home built with the sole intention of land theft. That is what a settlement is. It is a colony built upon stolen land from aboriginals. Colonizers are not civilians, colonizers are illegal and their presence constitutes a war crime under the Geneva Convention.

Palestinians that attack settlers are not attacking innocents, they are attacking war criminals.

How are settlers considered war criminals?
 
Your question is completely unrelated to whether settlers are civilians or not.

A soldier on duty is a soldier.
A soldier off duty is a civilian.
A civilian that was once a soldier is a civilian.

A settler is not a soldier, but a different form of aggression employed by the Israeli government. There is no on duty or off duty settler. A settler is an armed citizen of Israel choosing to live their life outside of their own country's legal borders, participating in internationally recognized war crimes by living in a home built with the sole intention of land theft. That is what a settlement is. It is a colony built upon stolen land from aboriginals. Colonizers are not civilians, colonizers are illegal and their presence constitutes a war crime under the Geneva Convention.

Palestinians that attack settlers are not attacking innocents, they are attacking war criminals.

Except that Palestinians not only attack settlers, including murdering an infant while she slept, but they also attack innocent civilians inside of Israel...you know, like bombing a bus, a school, a tourist on a beach, etc.
 
If you'd like me to copy/paste the Geneva Convention, I will. Colonization is a war crime. Please don't make a fool of yourself and attempt any dispute of this. If colonization is a war crime, those colonizing would be the war criminals. Settlers actively build the colonies they colonize, they are not just war criminals by presence, but through actions.
 
Go ahead, pull it up and I can shove it in your face how the Palis keep abusing it by attacking innocent civilians within the country of Israel.
 
My problem with human rights organizations that are claiming what you claim is that they ignore the Palestinian abuses. They ignore the fact that they launch deliberate attacks on civilians, in Israel. That they torture journalist and their own people. Having been there, having served there, I know for a fact that no orders are ever given to directly target civilians and in fact that things are called off when there is a high probability of it. Civilian casualties will happen as collateral damage, especially when they are used willingly or not, as human shields for Hamas and the other lovely groups who don't just want the territories but the complete destruction of Israel.

It's funny that you mention Hamas's human shields... could you be a doll and link me to any international reports of Hamas using human shields?

Would you like me, instead, to link you to instances of Israeli soldiers tying Palestinian children to the front of their tanks and using them as shields.

If you've served in Israel, you know what a liar you are. If you've served in the occupied territories, you bullied, harassed, degraded, humiliated and psychologically tortured Palestinian children. I don't know how you live with yourself, let alone come on this forum and defend such racist and discriminatory actions. It disgusts me.

What Palestinians want is for Israel to go back to its legitimate legal borders and to end it's occupation. Stop talking about what Hamas wants, as if that represents what Palestinians want. Even within Hamas, not every leader calls for the destruction of Israel. Palestinians want peace and the best way to achieve peace would be for Israel to start following some of the 77 international conventions and resolutions it's breaking. But when that means that Israel has to reduce its land hold from over 90% (95%?) if historical Palestine, down to its legal 49%, why in the world would Israel be looking for peace? It's looking for land (thus, daily building of settlements).

For anyone interested in what other Israeli soldiers have to say about the occupation, check this out:

http://www.breakingthesilence.org.il

It's kinda hard to accuse Breaking the Silence of the same biases that you accused reputable international human rights organizations of.
 
Go ahead, pull it up and I can shove it in your face how the Palis keep abusing it by attacking innocent civilians within the country of Israel.

Right, but the issue at hand was whether settlers are war criminals ... which you just skated over. There is no rebuttal because I am right, so now turn to the bus bombings ..... which 99% occurred in Jerusalem .... which is ILLEGALY OCCUPIED.

maybe if Israel wasn't a war criminal, the people its committing war crimes against wouldn't be staging attacks?
 
Keep skating around the real issue yourself then, the fact that Palestinians want the complete destruction of the state of Israel. Keep talking about how Israel has to give up land it holds, when the Palestinians said no to the original deal which would have seem them have their own country along side Israel, they said no because they didn't want Israel to exist and thought that the coming war would wipe them off the map...oops, they fucked that one up huh. If you actually read the geneva conventions in regards to colonization you would actually see that Israel is not in violation of it and the settlers are armed because they are attacked. I abhor any violations against innocent civilians, be it if Israel does it or the Palestinians, the difference between you and I is you blame Israel for everything and don't denounce the atrocities committed by the Palestinians, instead you justify it.
 
Keep talking about how Israel has to give up land it holds, .... I abhor any violations against innocent civilians, be it if Israel does it or the Palestinians,


Except for land stealing and ethnic cleansing.
That you seem to be supporting as long as Israel gets some new land and settlements.
 
I don't recall when I have ever stated I support the settlements? And like I have said in the past, I welcome the creation of a country for the Palestinians, however, they will first have to give up on their dream of Israel being wiped off the map.
 
...

What Palestinians want is for Israel to go back to its legitimate legal borders and to end it's occupation. ...

Maybe you've been living with realistic Palestinians but significant numbers of them want Israel destroyed, not a Palestinian state bedside Israel.


From recent Palestinian polling (Dec. 2013)
43) According to the Saudi plan, Israel will retreat from all territories occupied in 1967 including Gaza the West Bank, Jerusalem and the Golan Heights, and a Palestinian state will be established. The refugees problem will be resolved through negotiation in a just and agreed upon manner and in accordance with UN resolution 194 which allows return of refugees to Israel and compensation. In return, all Arab states will recognize Israel and its right to secure borders, will sign peace treaties with her and establish normal diplomatic relations. Do you agree or disagree to this plan?

Certainly agree - 4.3%
agree - 43.1%
disagree - 35.9%
certainly disagree - 14.1%

48) If the US under president Obama decides to pressure the Palestinians and the Israeli sides to accept and implement this compromise permanent settlement as outlined above listed items, do you think the Palestinian side should accept or reject this American intervention?

Accept - 36.8%
Reject - 60.2%

51) If in addition to the above items in the card, Israel agreed to accept the Arab peace initiative and in return all Arab countries supported this peace treaty, would you support or oppose it?

Accept - 18.4%
Reject - 76.7%

52) If in addition to the above items in the card, Israel acknowledged its responsibility for the creation of the refugee problem, would you support or oppose it?

Accept - 25.3%
Reject - 71.8%

53) If in addition to the above, the Palestinian state received 30 to 50 $billion dollars to help in settling those refugees wishing to live in the Palestinian state and compensating them, would you support or oppose it?

Accept - 21.6%
Reject - 76.1%

54) If in addition to the above items in the card, the state of Palestine was offered by Europe to join the
European Union, would you support or oppose it?

Accept - 20.6%
Reject - 75.2%


http://www.pcpsr.org/survey/polls/2013/p50e.pdf


Seems pretty clear that even the Arab League plan won't get Palestinian support, pretty overwhelmingly against accepting the plan.




p.s. One of their standard questions
65) Concerning armed attacks against Israeli civilians inside Israel, (note for amy - not in the West Bank) I....
Support - 42.9%
Oppose - 54.9%
 
I don't recall when I have ever stated I support the settlements? And like I have said in the past, I welcome the creation of a country for the Palestinians, however, they will first have to give up on their dream of Israel being wiped off the map.

Keep talking about how Israel has to give up land it holds.

That sounds like support for settlements.
If you think Israel should end all illegal settlements say so.

Otherwise you sound like just another racist zionist trying to squeeze Palestinians into bantustans and apartheid rule.
 
Claiming Israel doesn't target civilians is delusional.

It is actually the truth, whether or not you have the moral honesty to admit it.

Settlers are not civilians.

They clearly are civilians, again, whether you have the moral honesty to admit it or not.

Settlers are Israelis living outside of Israels borders on Palestinian land with the sole intention of colonization.

Which has nothing to do with whether or not they are civilians.

Settlers are armed, religious colonizers

Sorry but that is just prejudiced. Saying that no settler is a civilian because a few settlers are armed is ludicrous hate speech.

It is like saying every single Palestinian is a terrorist because some belong to Hamas. Nonsense. Civilized people reject hate speech like that.

Settlers are illegal colonizers actively and knowingly violating the Geneva Conventions.

This is not the case. The settlers are not accused of violating the conventions, the Israeli State is. There is a fairly important difference!


This is INCOMPARABLE to the Palestinian civilians, who are actually just poverty - ridden aboriginals living off of their own land while being colonized from the north, the south, the east and the West.

Oh please spare us the revisionist lying.

Jews are also indigenous, Middle Eastern Jews are genetically indistinguishable from Middle Eastern Arabs. Once upon a time one brother converted to Islam and the other brother remained Jewish.

And stop apologizing for war crime and atrocity. There is no need to downplay the evil of groups like Islamic Jihad just because you have some issues with Israel.

Settlers are no civilians. They are violent land thieves.

Reread your statement and contemplate how depraved it is. You are attempting to strip people of fundamental human rights because of their race. You are attempting to dehumanize them, to justify their violent ethnic cleansing.

Ethnic cleansing the settlements is a barbaric, savage concept. Any reasonable person does not believe two wrongs make a right.

Seeking compensation for all who lost property to the conflict, and equitable land swaps, is reasonable.

Justifying atrocity, demanding ethnic cleansing, and promoting terrorism is just reprehensible.
 
Your question is completely unrelated to whether settlers are civilians or not.

A soldier on duty is a soldier.
A soldier off duty is a civilian.
A civilian that was once a soldier is a civilian.

A settler is not a soldier, but a different form of aggression employed by the Israeli government. There is no on duty or off duty settler. A settler is an armed citizen of Israel choosing to live their life outside of their own country's legal borders, participating in internationally recognized war crimes by living in a home built with the sole intention of land theft. That is what a settlement is. It is a colony built upon stolen land from aboriginals. Colonizers are not civilians, colonizers are illegal and their presence constitutes a war crime under the Geneva Convention.

Palestinians that attack settlers are not attacking innocents, they are attacking war criminals.

The ICRC, HRW, etc, vehemently disagrees with you.

http://m.hrw.org/reports/2002/isrl-pa/ISRAELPA1002-04.htm

"The illegal status of settlements under international humanitarian law does not negate the rights of the civilians living there. The fact that a person lives in a settlement, whether legal or not, does not make him or her a legitimate military target. Under international humanitarian law, intentional attacks on civilians, or attacks that do not distinguish between military targets and civilians, are prohibited under all circumstances. Israeli civilians living in the settlements, so long as they do not take up arms and take an active part in hostilities, are noncombatants.**"
 
They clearly are civilians, again, whether you have the moral honesty to admit it or not.
.

Speaking of moral honesty, a man who argues a child with a rock is a militant while a man with an army supplied rifle or machine gun is not, clearly has no idea about moral honesty.
By what logic do you call kids with rocks militants and settlers with guns civilians?
 
Speaking of moral honesty, a man who argues a child with a rock is a militant while a man with an army supplied rifle or machine gun is not, clearly has no idea about moral honesty.
By what logic do you call kids with rocks militants and settlers with guns civilians?

I have a rifle, but that doesn't mean I'm not a civilian. Whether you are armed with a rock or a rifle doesn't matter. What matters is whether you go out and attack the enemy.

Someone sitting at home with a rock or a rifle isn't a combatant.