Does Fuji speak for you?

Does Fuji speak for you?

  • Fuji Speaks for me

    Votes: 16 50.0%
  • Fuji does not speak for me

    Votes: 16 50.0%

  • Total voters
    32
  • Poll closed .
Yes, it looks like you like to change the topic. I don't blame you. The number of a Palestinian children killed on a continual basis is obscene.

Okay, you don't want to talk about Palestinians or Syrians killed in the Syrian conflict.

How about the 731 Israeli civilians killed during the 2nd Intifada? That amounts to 1 Israeli civilian killed every 2 days.
 
Okay, you don't want to talk about Palestinians or Syrians killed in the Syrian conflict.

How about the 731 Israeli civilians killed during the 2nd Intifada? That amounts to 1 Israeli civilian killed every 2 days.

I'd love to compare that to the number of Palestinians killed by Israel during the same period. Can you provide us with those numbers and let everyone draw their own conclusions?
 
I'd love to compare that to the number of Palestinians killed by Israel during the same period. Can you provide us with those numbers and let everyone draw their own conclusions?

Israel has gotten pretty good at preventing Palestinians from succeeding at killing civilians. Is that the conclusion you were thinking of?

You are trying to blame Israel for not losing the war. You think it is unfair that Palestinians can't kill more people.
 
Israel has gotten pretty good at preventing Palestinians from succeeding at killing civilians. Is that the conclusion you were thinking of?

You are trying to blame Israel for not losing the war. You think it is unfair that Palestinians can't kill more people.

I'd like to see the facts, wouldn't you? Are you afraid of the facts? Then everyone can draw their own conclusions.
 
I'd like to see the facts, wouldn't you? Are you afraid of the facts? Then everyone can draw their own conclusions.
I think fuji acknowledged more Pals have died than Israelis.

Therefore fuji's conclusion sounds right. He neglected to say those results came to be even though the pals make more attempts on Israeli civilians.
 
I don't think that ALL Canadians reject violence and war crime since many of them seem to support U.S. and Israeli aggression and war crimes;however, I do know that I personally reject war crime (especially when they are committed by nations such as the U.S. who regularly castigate others who commit them) and I oppose the use of violence to coerce others into accepting one's views on anything or achieving some kind of political objective.

That said it is sometimes necessary to use violence when threatened by injustices committed through the use of violence and oppression and leaving no effective peaceful means to address the circumstances such as in the case of the Palestinians oppression by Israel. As MLK said "those who make peaceful change impossible ... make violent change inevitable" and the results of violent change usually only please those who are the most willing and able to to inflict violence ... i.e. thugs, bullies, psychopaths and criminals

If anyone objects to my comments then I suggest they read "Goliath" by Max Blumenthal as well "Allies for Armageddon by Victoria Clark before hurling the usual Right Wing Israeli propaganda or US neo-con drivel at me ... I've heard all that stuff but I'll bet you haven't been exposed to much info from the other side of the issue.
 
...

That said it is sometimes necessary to use violence when threatened by injustices committed through the use of violence and oppression and leaving no effective peaceful means to address the circumstances such as in the case of the Palestinians oppression by Israel. ...
This is where I'd disagree with your analysis of the situation. There have been many opportunities for a peaceful solution. Considering one of the Palestinian governments is outright opposed to peace with Israel and the other recently stated that a two state peace will only be a temporary peace, it seems to me that it is a conscious choice amongst the Palestinian leadership to avoid the opportunities for peace.
 
I'd love to compare that to the number of Palestinians killed by Israel during the same period. Can you provide us with those numbers and let everyone draw their own conclusions?

Considering you criticize consider all Israelis valid targets because they are Jews/Isarelis and don't see Palestinians as valid targets even when they are engaged in attacks, is it really worth having that discussion?
 
I don't think that ALL Canadians reject violence and war crime since many of them seem to support U.S. and Israeli aggression and war crimes

Let's leave the US aside because that's a topic in its own right, or at least, that should be a separate thread.

As for your comment on Israel, let's make a few things crystal clear so we aren't dancing around it: Not all accusations of wrongdoing are equal. Israel does not attack civilians, and Israel has never started a war. Israel has been the victim of aggression in every war it has been involved in, and Israel has made peace with every nation in the region that was willing to make peace -- either formally, or informally. The only nations and groups in the region that Israel is at war with are recognized as terrorists and state sponsors of terrorists around the world, the worst of the worst: Iran, Syria, Hamas, Hezbollah. With all other groups Israel has achieved either a full formal peace, as with Jordan or Egypt, or a long-term understanding that has eliminated armed conflict from the relationship, as in the case of Saudi Arabia, etc.

What Israel is accused of are comparatively minor things--disputes over the locations of borders and such. That is something that can and should be discussed, but it is in no way similar to or equivalent to the horrendous atrocities perpetrated on Israel by the aggressors it is at war with -- attacks on civilian homes, bombings of civilian establishment, the ambush and murder of civilian families, etc., there are no more serious crimes than that. You cannot compare a property dispute to murder with a straight face.

That said it is sometimes necessary to use violence when threatened by injustices committed through the use of violence and oppression and leaving no effective peaceful means to address the circumstances

I agree with that, and I think pretty much all civilized peoples agree with that -- war is sometimes necessary.

However, let's be clear that war is not the same thing as war crime. We accept that it sometimes necessary to go and fight against foreign nations and their armed forces. We DO NOT accept that this justifies war crime and atrocity: We do not accept attacks on civilians. This is encoded into the Geneva Conventions, and a number of other treaties, which almost all nations around the world have wholeheartedly endorsed. Civilized people accept the need for war in some circumstances, but not the need for war crime. You attack the other guy's army, not innocent civilians living within his territory.
 
Considering you criticize consider all Israelis valid targets because they are Jews/Isarelis and don't see Palestinians as valid targets even when they are engaged in attacks, is it really worth having that discussion?

More capitulation. Are you afraid of providing the facts? Tell us the number of Palestinians killed in the same period. Educate everybody. Maybe Palestinians killed Israeli's at a far greater number. If that's the case, I'll gladly concede they kill more than Israeli's. Will you have the courage to do the same?
 
More capitulation. Are you afraid of providing the facts? Tell us the number of Palestinians killed in the same period. Educate everybody. Maybe Palestinians killed Israeli's at a far greater number. If that's the case, I'll gladly concede they kill more than Israeli's. Will you have the courage to do the same?

Do you have the figures or are you just expecting others to do the work for you?

As for your second, your posting history would clearly show you just lied through your teeth, again.
 
More capitulation. Are you afraid of providing the facts? Tell us the number of Palestinians killed in the same period. Educate everybody. Maybe Palestinians killed Israeli's at a far greater number. If that's the case, I'll gladly concede they kill more than Israeli's. Will you have the courage to do the same?

Let's restrict the analysis to attacks targeting civilians in contravention of the laws of war.
 
Let's restrict the analysis to attacks targeting civilians in contravention of the laws of war.

My, my....b,case has gone AWOL. Do you think that means he knows the number will embarrass him?
 
My, my....b,case has gone AWOL. Do you think that means he knows the number will embarrass him?

Glad you agree that we will be talking about civilians targeted for attack. Israel has targeted zero. How many have the Palestinians targeted?
 
Let's restrict the analysis to attacks targeting civilians in contravention of the laws of war.

The use of the word 'targeting' is just to deflect blame.
You should be concerned with attacks killing civilians. Full stop.
 
The use of the word 'targeting' is just to deflect blame.
You should be concerned with attacks killing civilians. Full stop.

Aren't we interested in which side is committing war crimes? In that case we must use the legal standard.
 
Why should he give a shit about civilians being killed in attacks when you don't? Difference is, the Israeli military targets terrorists and civilians are killed because they are used as human shields, whereas the Palis target civilians directly. See the difference? No, you probably don't.
 
I have provided the Israeli number: zero civilians targeted by Israel. Where is the Palestinian number?

But you're not Israel, although it would appear you think you are one in the same. I'm looking for facts coming from independent sources, such as B'Tselem, not your personal tin foil hat theories.

But, it is odd that b'case is still AWOL.