Do you believe in free will?

Do you believe in free will?

  • Yes

    Votes: 6 66.7%
  • No

    Votes: 2 22.2%
  • Other

    Votes: 1 11.1%

  • Total voters
    9
  • Poll closed .

rhuarc29

Well-known member
Apr 15, 2009
9,905
1,738
113
Let me explain:

Yes - you believe in a soul or other intangible entity that allows you to make whatever decisions you 'feel' are right.

No - you believe that the decisions you make are based entirely on the neural connections in your brain formed through experience and/or genetics.

Other - please specify
 
Let me explain:

Yes - you believe in a soul or other intangible entity that allows you to make whatever decisions you 'feel' are right.

No - you believe that the decisions you make are based entirely on the neural connections in your brain formed through experience and/or genetics.

Other - please specify



Based on your definitions, i voted no. Normally i would've voted yes, but you outlined it differently.
 
Let me explain:

Yes - you believe in a soul or other intangible entity that allows you to make whatever decisions you 'feel' are right.

No - you believe that the decisions you make are based entirely on the neural connections in your brain formed through experience and/or genetics.

Other - please specify
You make choices based on free will. That free will is influenced by your experiences.

Your genetics will influence how you interpret your experiences.
 
Let me explain:

Yes - you believe in a soul or other intangible entity that allows you to make whatever decisions you 'feel' are right.

No - you believe that the decisions you make are based entirely on the neural connections in your brain formed through experience and/or genetics.

Other - please specify

Here is the problem I have. Belief is a function of the will. Without the free action of the will there can not be belief. Therefore I can believe that there is a free will but I can not believe there isn't a free will. If there isn’t freewill then there isn’t the phenomena of belief.