Denying Holocaust Will be Illegal

Status
Not open for further replies.
No, the hockey stick was a proven fabrication.


No, 99% of scientists do not back the IPCC findings.

Scientists who are not quacks and are not in agreement with currrent hysteria have spoken:


Ross Mckitrick is a moron.
Total quack.
Paid to make nonsense graphs for scientifically illiterate idiots who don't notice he's funded by the oil industry.
You're smarter than that, aren't you?
 
We don't NEED to pronounce a verdict (backed by law) on everything. Freedom is always stolen on the basis of some temporary (and usually bogus) call to safety

99% of scientists.
Even when Exxon hired scientists they came up with the same numbers.
When Shell hired their own team, same thing.

99% of scientists.
 
No, we debate EVERYTHING.

Sure, let someone debate Pearl Harbour! If there are Civil War Deniers, lol, let them talk all they want.
What's your problem with that?
But those things are never debated, because they are accepted as fact.

And if they were debated they have nothing to do with attempted destruction of a race that has hated and persecuted and there are many people who'd like to see it happen again. People who want to supposedly debate do nothing more than encourage and embolden those people. The only motivation for denial is anti-Semitism, pure and simple. It has nothing to do with any doubts or vagaries of history because there are none. The Holocaust happened just as sure as the sun came up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jsanchez
But those things are never debated, because they are accepted as fact.

And if they were debated they have nothing to do with attempted destruction of a race that has hated and persecuted and there are many people who'd like to see it happen again. People who want to supposedly debate do nothing more than encourage and embolden those people. The only motivation for denial is anti-Semitism, pure and simple. It has nothing to do with any doubts or vagaries of history because there are none. The Holocaust happened just as sure as the sun came up.
Better question is: should antisemitism be outlawed? I'm of the opinion that hate should be kept in the open and in the spotlight.
 
Why does the Holocaust get such special status? Is it illegal to deny black slavery existed? Is it illegal to deny native children were abused?
The idea of controlling speech about such topics gets problematic in a hurry as soon as you get into any details. With respect to the holocaust:

1. Can you dispute the number of people killed in the Holocaust? What if you assert the numbers were actually higher than generally accepted?
2. Can you blame any additional groups or persons apart from Nazis for what happened?
3. Can you question the timeline asserted for the Holocaust, or pertaining to any particular concentration camp or group that was held in such a camp, or political direction given to camp administrators?

Nothing helpful is ever accomplished by closing the door to further study and to challenging generally accepted views about history (or about any subject at all). We only learned about what happened in these camps because people challenged the propaganda that had been generally accepted.
 
Last edited:
Moreover why is antisemitism equated to questioning history instead of speaking hatred? Why is questioning history anywhere near the same ballpark as uttering death threats or declaring people subhuman, etc?

I would think that 99% of holocaust denial or downplaying is actually predicate on people recognizing such an event is wrong. Wouldn't hatred of Jews lead people to celebrate it rather than downplay it?

Is this about people hating Jewish people or about Jewish people's entitlement to a group victim social status?
 
  • Like
Reactions: jacksparrow
The idea of controlling speech about such topics gets problematic in a hurry as soon as you get into any details. With respect to the holocaust:

1. Can you dispute the number of people killed in the Holocaust? What if you assert the numbers were actually higher than generally accepted?
2. Can you blame any additional groups or persons apart from Nazis for what happened?
3. Can you question the timeline asserted for the Holocaust, or pertaining to any particular concentration camp or group that was held in such a camp, or political direction given to camp administrators?

Nothing helpful is ever accomplished by closing the door to further study and to challenging generally accepted views about history (or about any subject at all). We only learned about what happened in these camps because people challenged the propaganda that had been generally accepted.
To this day the Holocaust remains a controversial subject in many places. I remember the explosion of self righteousness in Central Europe, especially in Poland, after the fall of communism when the honest assessment of history was again allowed and the pain it caused on all sides. But, in the end, an honest conversation brought not only truth, but much reconciliation and a dramatic change in attitudes toward the past and present. Only an open and free conversation can achieve meaningful results.
 
Better question is: should antisemitism be outlawed? I'm of the opinion that hate should be kept in the open and in the spotlight.
It's obviously impossible to ban hatred. You can ban discrimination (when provable) and certain statements but the bigots will always find new ways to try and disguise their hatred. For example, the "soft on crime" and 'nuclear family" lines are simply just a less obvious way for people to denigrate blacks.
 
Why does the Holocaust get such special status? Is it illegal to deny black slavery existed? Is it illegal to deny native children were abused?
Is there any racist movement denying either of those things? I know parts of the US are trying to pass bills making it illegal to suggest slavery was bad but those are attacks on free speech in the ahistorical direction.
 
The idea of controlling speech about such topics gets problematic in a hurry as soon as you get into any details. With respect to the holocaust:

1. Can you dispute the number of people killed in the Holocaust? What if you assert the numbers were actually higher than generally accepted?
2. Can you blame any additional groups or persons apart from Nazis for what happened?
3. Can you question the timeline asserted for the Holocaust, or pertaining to any particular concentration camp or group that was held in such a camp, or political direction given to camp administrators?

Nothing helpful is ever accomplished by closing the door to further study and to challenging generally accepted views about history (or about any subject at all). We only learned about what happened in these camps because people challenged the propaganda that had been generally accepted.
Yes, yes, and yes. Unless you are transparently making shit up to promote hatred.

There is nothing wrong with examining the exact number. Trying to pretend it was tens of thousands is completely false based on the facts. Trying to claim it was 100 million would be just as farcical. And more importantly, this kind of academic discussion should be done by academics, not on twitter, You know, a place where people have some level of standards and rigor to actually give evidence.

There are many documented cases of non-German people complicit in the Holocaust. There are also many documented cases of Germans who worked to prevent killings. Trying to pretend that it wasn't an organized plan by the Nazis to kill people based on ethnicity is patently false.

There are also quite a lot of study on the progression of the Holocaust from work camps, and expulsions to outright murder camps. Very few historians actually believe that the original intent was to run execution camps. To deny that can only be motivated by hatred.


The door isn't closed, at least to anyone willing to investigate using rigor. Most of the Holocaust deniers though don't do this and simply claims the evidence was simply fabricated as part of the very Jewish conspiracy the Nazis believed in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Valcazar
Is there any racist movement denying either of those things? I know parts of the US are trying to pass bills making it illegal to suggest slavery was bad but those are attacks on free speech in the ahistorical direction.

The IHRA definition of antisemitism is similar as it attempts to stop debate and criticism of Israel instead of targeting racism.
Of course if you were really against racism you'd be against all racism, including Islamaphobia and racist policies like apartheid.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jolly_Penguin
The door isn't closed, at least to anyone willing to investigate using rigor. Most of the Holocaust deniers though don't do this and simply claims the evidence was simply fabricated as part of the very Jewish conspiracy the Nazis believed in.
You’re not in charge of deciding which studies merit serious consideration. We ALL are. Which is why speech has to come first, and review and debate later. There is no way to evaluate a study before It is communicated in public.
 
The IHRA definition of antisemitism is similar as it attempts to stop debate and criticism of Israel instead of targeting racism.
...
It explicitly says criticism of Israel is not necessarily anti-Semitic but thanks to your pre-existing bias, you still claim otherwise as part of the double standard quoted in Canada's definition.


And pathetic again, instead of talking about the overtly racist Holocaust denial, you simply want to bitch about Israel. The IHRA definition was adopted by Canada (but I'm sure I can guess your interpretation of Canada acted that way).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.