Denying climate change: a psychological problem?

Climate change is caused by human industry?

  • Yep, I believe the climate change scientists

    Votes: 14 14.0%
  • Nope, we're just in a natural cycle of warming

    Votes: 26 26.0%
  • Yep, I say Option 1 AND deniers are psychologically attached to consumerism

    Votes: 4 4.0%
  • Nope, it's Option 2 AND saying otherwise is bad science

    Votes: 4 4.0%
  • Yep, but powerful economic interests are misleading the public

    Votes: 28 28.0%
  • Nope, but idealistic and opportunistic economic interests are duping publics

    Votes: 24 24.0%

  • Total voters
    100
I don't know many scientist that use the term 'normal' on a regular basis.

As far as grape vines on Hadrians Wall, that basically a local anomaly. There are palm trees in the south of England. I wouldn't call the climate there comparable to the South Pacific.

The point of whether the grapes vines on Hadrians wall are a local anomoly is arguable. My point in posting the remark was there are not a lot of Vineyards in England at the moment . They were a regular part of the landscape during the medeival warm period. As was the existance of Argiculture in greenland, which also does not exist today.

There are other examples but those two will do for the present. The point is the climate was much warmer during this period than it is now.

Just as aduring the1700's it was much colder , ice fairs on the Thames in London were recorded as were he exploits of a number of American Revolutionary war heros who draged canon across frozen rivers that do not freeze at all now.

I can show you large arctic alpine meadows 1500 miles south of where they should be and they've been their since before I became aware of them 40 years go and evidence shows they go back further than that

Arctic meadows are an interesting thing but at the same time how can you say that they should not be " there"?

The temperature stated and the minimum/maximum are global numbers. Climate doesn't work that way. It's a combination of domino chains and feedback systems.

THe heart of the Climate change global warming argument is that tempuratures are rising at an unprecedented rate. The unprecedented rate change was driven by human activity through the collection of greenhouse gasses in the atmosphere.

The instrument of record to demonstrate that rate change is the work of Dr MAnn of the University of Pennsylvania. He calculated the rise in temperature based on tree ring data collected over time in a couple of locations.

That work led to the Hockey Stick graph and to the basis of the cuirrent dispute.

At present there is dispute over the science behind the work of Dr.Mann and the follow up work done by Dr Ammaan to verify the work following its dispute by Steve McItyre and Dr Mikitridge at the University of Guelph.

The argument lies in the way the data was collected and the way the computer models were constructed to show the data points on a graph.

The basis of that work is what the IPCC has used to formulate its position.

The release of the e-mails and data from the CRU whitch appear to confirm a number of the arguments that a fairly large number of scientists had made regarding the practices of the " core" group for lack of a better term of the climate change proponants have now cast doubt on the science of the issue.

The problem at present is that nobody actually knows what the science says anymore.

The lack of raw data and computer code for auditing by independant peer review as well as the lack of reproducability of the data have caused serious problems with the credibility of teh leaders of the CRU as well as the University of Pennsylvania's climate group. Both groups are beiong investigated by the parent institutions as we speak.

The US congress is starting aninvestigation into the actions of Nasa's Goddard center for the same reasons.
 
Good for The US government in their pre-emptive work into NASA. The scientist at UA who pulled this stunt have done themselves a tremendous hurt to themselves but also may have done something good in that now work will be under pressure to be more open and transparent to peer/government review. It still has to be somewhat behind closed doors for obvious reasons.

Something like their destroying the raw data, that now has to be recollected is probably their worst transgression and they will pay.
 
I see you're back to your talking points again, Landscaper.

So, once more, Mann's work has been verified by other studies using totally different methodologies. In the latest updates to the hockey stick data, his work is one of dozen's all proving the same temperature changes.

McIntyre's arguments over Mann's 1998 study are a decade old, and have been answered by the full release of the data. I believe I posted a link to that data.

That data is available and has been peer reviewed, it seems you are equating peer's with peer's of McIntyre, not climatologists. Is that correct?

The stolen emails prove only that there is healthy debate, that words such as 'trick' can be taken out of context and that climatologists have to spend way too much answering the same stupid questions from the same stupid people who won't listen to counter arguments. I'm sympathizing with them.
 
I see you're back to your talking points again, Landscaper.

So, once more, Mann's work has been verified by other studies using totally different methodologies. In the latest updates to the hockey stick data, his work is one of dozen's all proving the same temperature changes.

McIntyre's arguments over Mann's 1998 study are a decade old, and have been answered by the full release of the data. I believe I posted a link to that data.

That data is available and has been peer reviewed, it seems you are equating peer's with peer's of McIntyre, not climatologists. Is that correct?

The stolen emails prove only that there is healthy debate, that words such as 'trick' can be taken out of context and that climatologists have to spend way too much answering the same stupid questions from the same stupid people who won't listen to counter arguments. I'm sympathizing with them.

http://www.americanthinker.com/2009/12/understanding_climategates_hid.html

why don't you try some light reading it might get you past the dogma
 
Let's start with what the IPCC actually does say.

http://www.ipcc.ch/pdf/presentations/20th Anniversary BFM/pres-wg-1-ipcc.pdf

Then let's look at an oversimplification of what it means when someone uses those terms:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statistics

In the IPCC analyses, there is no "distribution" over which a CI may be applied. The terminology used by the IPCC is completely incorrect and has no basis in fact.

I see, you looked at the executive summary and didn't find references to CI, therefore the IPCC has no idea how statistics work.

Here's the section from the full report, not the executive summary with how they deal with uncertainty. I apologize for the poor formatting, but if it doesn't look good enough for you just go to page 5 of the full IPCC report.

The IPCC uncertainty guidance note1 defines a framework for the treatment of uncertainties across all WGs and in this Synthesis Report. This framework is broad because the WGs assess material from different disciplines and cover a diversity of approaches to the treatment of uncertainty drawn from the literature. The nature of data, indicators and analyses used in the natural sciences is generally different from that used in assessing technology development or the social sciences. WG I focuses on the former, WG III on the latter, and WG II covers aspects of both.
Three different approaches are used to describe uncertainties each with a distinct form of language. Choices among and within these three approaches depend on both the nature of the information available and the authors’ expert judgment of the correctness and completeness of current scientific understanding.
Where uncertainty is assessed qualitatively, it is characterised by providing a relative sense of the amount and quality of evidence (that is, information from theory, observations or models indicating whether a belief or proposition is true or valid) and the degree of agreement (that is, the level of concurrence in the literature on a particular finding). This approach is used by WG III through a series of self-explanatory terms such as: high agreement, much evidence; high agreement, medium evidence; medium agreement, medium evidence; etc.
Where uncertainty is assessed more quantitatively using expert judgement of the correctness of underlying data, models or analyses, then the following scale of confidence levels is used to express the assessed chance of a finding being correct: very high confidence at least 9 out of 10; high confidence about 8 out of 10; medium confidence about 5 out of 10; low confidence about 2 out of 10; and very low confidence less than 1 out of 10.
Where uncertainty in specific outcomes is assessed using expert judgment and statistical analysis of a body of evidence (e.g. observations or model results), then the following likelihood ranges are used to express the assessed probability of occurrence: virtually certain >99%; extremely likely >95%; very likely >90%; likely >66%; more likely than not > 50%; about as likely as not 33% to 66%; unlikely <33%; very unlikely <10%; extremely unlikely <5%; exceptionally unlikely <1%.
WG II has used a combination of confidence and likelihood assessments and WG I has predominantly used likelihood assessments.
This Synthesis Report follows the uncertainty assessment of the underlying WGs. Where synthesised findings are based on information from more than one WG, the description of uncertainty used is consistent with that for the components drawn from the respective WG reports.
Unless otherwise stated, numerical ranges given in square brackets in this report indicate 90% uncertainty intervals (i.e. there is an estimated 5% likelihood that the value could be above the range given in square brackets and 5% likelihood that the value could be below that range). Uncertainty intervals are not necessarily symmetric around the best estimate.
 
Again, no.


Do you deny that we now have 387 ppm of CO2 in the atmosphere?
No but why is that a problem ? How do you know that is not the normal state of affairs?

Do you deny that we are in a period of warming?

Yes actually I do, the temperature is lower now than it was in the medival warm period , Grape Vines were growing on HAdrians wall them, In the mid to late 1700's temperatures were far colder than they are now. So what is warm what is cold what is normal?

Do you deny that glaciers the world are thawing?
Do you deny that the north pole is losing permament ice?

The ice measurements are have been taken using a baseline from the late 1960's when there was a massive ice buildup in glaciers and the poles. In point of fact I expect that if you actually researched the issue you would find the average amount of ice in the caps and glaciers is pretty much the same.

Regardless, what is normal? can you tell me that 27'C is the normal temperature? or did you ahve a different number in mind.

Really now, Landscaper, you could have better then that.
CO2 levels have been tracked for at least 400,000 years and the only times that level has breached 300ppm, the temperature of the planet has been drastically higher.

And once again, you seem to be confusing local climate with global climate in your references to the medival warm period. The studies show that these were local phenomena, not global.

There are photo records of glaciers readily available on the web that go back about 100 years. The differences are pretty obvious.

Of course there is variability in the climate and it changes over time. We're just pushing it in a way that's probably not going to work for us. Check out the drought in Australia, for instance.
 
Hey, I checked out the article, Landscaper.

So they still have a beef with Mann, big deal.
This is from the IPCC summary you linked to before:

2007 Report: 987 pages, 152 lead authors and 400 contributing authors from 40 countries and 600 reviewers 113 countries at final plenary

One beef does not discount the work of a thousand people. 600 reviewers from across the globe looked at this work, that's called peer review. Ask McIntyre and Sheppard to post their articles in a peer reviewed format, where they are liable to answer to criticisms. One article in a right wing paper does not prove them right, only when they can publish in a forum where they have to answer to the same criticisms that Mann et al have can you suggest that their work is valid.
 
Hmmmmm, I smell a union guy.

Division of labour has been around long before that. Try in excess of 1.5 million years.

First time I've been accused of a union guy. Ironic since I believe most unionists blindly follow their "leadership". My post is to highlight the money factor in the climate change debate. No one seems to want to talk about the cash, cash, cash that is behind all the climate change studies.

As for division of labour being around 1.5 million years, that's nice. Too bad homo sapiens have only been around for a few hundred thousand years.
 
O.K. just checking, the fact that the information in that article is lifted directly form the information provided by the ICPP and the CRU et has no meaning for you?

That data was what teh CRU and Mann provided to teh ICPP, its their data along with the adjustments made to imprtove their results.

So nothing in that bothers you?

One beef does not discount the work of a thousand people. 600 reviewers from across the globe looked at this work, that's called peer review. Ask McIntyre and Sheppard to post their articles in a peer reviewed format, where they are liable to answer to criticisms. One article in a right wing paper does not prove them right, only when they can publish in a forum where they have to answer to the same criticisms that Mann et al have can you suggest that their work is valid.

The work of Mcyinrite et al has been reviewed by several much tougher audiences than the peer review that the Mann Jones work has done.

Manns original work was discredited the subsequent work that was done to validate the work was done with data sets that were cherry picked to provide the results wanted add in a computer model that adjusts the end result to conform to the required result and you have a problem.

Your problem seems to be that you can not look beyond the result that you want. Somebody disagrees with your required result and you dismiss them out of hand as deniers, not properly vetted a right wing paper.

It would seem to me that you don't want any answer beyond the one that you ahve determined to be correct.

If the science was properly done do you think there would be this uproar?

If properly done the science would have been peer reviewed and the results duplicated independantly. That in spite of your insistance has not been done. The raw datas has with one exception not been released nor has the computer code that the model was designed with been released and audited.

The raw data has been " lost" so now we are required to simply say OK with a controversial issue?

The Royal Society required the raw data and to be released before the article was published , that is the way it is supposed to work, independant scientists can then work to replicate the results. In this case the reveiwers dicovered some problems, notabley an unacceptable small sample size , in one case a single tree. Other samples were rejected because they did not produce the result required. The data was then adjusted using a computer model that is still understood only by the people who wrote it to adjust the end result, notably to hide the temperature decrease in the tail end of the twentieth century. The rejection and marginalization of other sources of data has also occured when that data did not conform.

That is just one case, this issue is so very important to everybody involved there can be no room for question. The issue has to be settled. And before you say it is settled perhaps you can explain why

Given the bulk of the greenhouse gass emmissions occured from 1945 on the temperature was rising before that from the late 1800's. If greenhouse gasses were or are responsible for the temperature increases why the increases occured following the temperature increases?

If the greenhouse gasses were responsible would they not have to be present prior to the temperature rising ?

Minor little questions like this are the reason the results of Mann, Jones, Amman, Bradley and Schmidt are questioned. Their actions in hiding data, adjusting data to meet predetermined results and demonizing opposition voices just adds to the questions.
 
First time I've been accused of a union guy. Ironic since I believe most unionists blindly follow their "leadership". My post is to highlight the money factor in the climate change debate. No one seems to want to talk about the cash, cash, cash that is behind all the climate change studies.

As for division of labour being around 1.5 million years, that's nice. Too bad homo sapiens have only been around for a few hundred thousand years.

I only said you sounded like a union man. I sure do miss Mr Big1949 and his chorts. They gave you so much material to work with.

As far as the division of labour comment, your right about H sapien being relatively new, but the reference goes back to H. erectus/H. ergaster, or more commonly known as Turkano boy.
 
Landscaper, its quite hard to follow your arguments. Your spelling and grammar need some work. And it is IPCC, not ICPP, no wonder you can't find the facts.

Ok, here we go again.

What review has McIntyre been subjected to that is tougher than 600 scientists from 40 different countries? Please state.

And Mann's work has not been discredited, if you read the IPCC reports its been verified, updated and passed by the IPCC and included in recent reports. The only people on the planet who seem to think otherwise are you, McIntyre and Sheppard.

The raw data was not lost, its posted on the web. The only data that Mann ever refused to publish was data he was not allowed to post due to freedom of information agreements he signed with host countries. And those agreements have been updated to allow him to post the information. And I linked you to that information. To continue to say that the info is not public is wrong. Stop it unless you can prove that its not there.

Human kind has been releasing CO2 into the atmoshere for a while now. Whale oil, trees (see deforested england), coal and for the last hundred years oil products. If you look at the charts you see a correlation between CO2 and temperature. Its there, look.

Is your only argument still relient on one person's argument with one decade old study?
That's lame.
 
Oh, and Landscaper, here's the latest update on the Mann/McIntyre debate, courtesy of the IPCC 2009 report:


Knowledge of climate during past centuries can help us to understand natural climate change and put modern climate change into context. There have been a number of studies to reconstruct trends in global and hemispheric surface temperature over the last millennium (e.g. Mann et al. 1998; Esper et al. 2002; Moberg et al. 2005), all of which show recent Northern Hemisphere warmth to be anomalous in the context of at least the past millennium, and likely longer (Jansen et al. 2007). The first of these reconstructions has come to be known as the ‘hockey stick’ reconstruction (Mann et al. 1998, 1999). Some aspects of the hockey stick reconstruction were subsequently questioned, e.g. whether the 20th century was the warmest
at a hemispheric average scale (Soon and Baliunas 2003), and whether the reconstruction is reproducible, or verifiable (McIntyre and McKitrick 2003), or might be sensitive to the
method used to extract information from tree ring records (McIntyre and McKitrick 2005a,b). Whilst these criticisms have been rejected in subsequent work (e.g. Rutherford et al. 2005; Wahl and Ammann 2006, 2007; Jansen et al. 2007) the US National Research Council convened a committee to examine the state of the science of reconstructing the climate of the past millennium. The NRC report published in 2006 largely supported the original findings of Mann et al. (1998, 1999) and recommended a path toward continued progress in this area (NRC, 2006).
Mann et al. (2008) addressed the recommendations of the NRC report by reconstructing surface temperature at a hemispheric and global scale for much of the last 2,000 years using a greatly expanded data set for decadal-to-centennial climate changes, along with recently updated instrumental data and complementary methods that have been thoroughly tested and

thE CoPEnhAgEn DiAgnosis > 45
validated with climate model simulations. Their results extend previous studies and conclude that recent Northern Hemisphere surface temperature increases are likely anomalous in a long-term context (Figure 19).
Kaufman et al. (2009) independently concluded that recent Arctic warming is without precedent in at least 2000 years (Figure 20) reversing a long-term millennial-scale cooling trend caused by astronomical forcing (i.e. orbital cycles). Warmth during the peak of the “Medieval Climate Anomaly” of roughly AD 900-1100 may have rivalled modern warmth for certain regions such as the western tropical Pacific (Oppo et al. 2009), and some regions neighbouring the North Atlantic (Mann et al. in-press). However, such regional warming appears to reflect a redistribution of warmth by changes in atmospheric circulation, and is generally offset by cooling elsewhere (e.g. the eastern and central tropical Pacific) to yield hemispheric and global temperatures that are lower than those of recent decades.
 
SImplify

The loss of the polar ice caps will drastically effect normal weather patterns. The polar ice caps act to stabilize weather. When they are gone, look out.

The warmer periods of medieval history were NOT accompanied by NO polar ice.

Scientific consensus seems to be that there will be rapidly increasing desertification, widespread famine causing displacement of large numbers of people into more temperate areas where other people are already living. Potential for wars as southern populations move northward.

The Russians are already making a show of force in the Canadian arctic. The developed nations know there will be open seas in the arctic, opening up vast areas for mineral and oil exploration. Strong potential for political conflict and environmental disaster. US, Canada and Russia all agree this is a done deal - no more polar ice in the very near future.

There will be very big changes as a result of this, and no amount of military force
will be able to combat this problem.

We need more and better science, and yes, a lot more green technology to help us
through this.
 
Dinasaurs lived in a really warm time too..... Guess they all drove SUVs......

:)

Sorry to tell you TM, but you're wrong, on both counts. Oh that was your attempt at humour. Not really that funny, but keep trying. you're much more skilled at hyperbole.

The group of dinosaurs that lived in the Arctic lived there when the temperature was quite moderate, some might temperate, average 10°C. That's windbreaker or long sleeved shirt temperature for me. The evidence shows temperatures did occasionally go below zero, especially in the area of 70° North latitude. This begins to kick the teeth in on the argument that the dinos were strictly cold blooded.
 
the proponents of climate change . . . like to put down everybody who don't subscribe to their views

You really are a dumbass

What were you saying?

There is no mathematical basis whatsoever for claiming "90% probability", based on the evidence presented. And yes, I have read the full report . . .The authors made this claim because they felt an emotional connection to the idea of what they think "90% probability" means to them, without any factual basis to their usage of the terminology.

You really read the report? You saw them define very likey as 90% confidence and, for instance, 95% as extremely likely, and so forth. That's not emotion, that's characterizing statistical significance in laymens terms.

Also, you read the technical reports, right, not just the policy documents? You read them describing how the 90% figure was a computation, not a guesstimation? First, the used actually collected weather data over more than 100 years. They fed that into a model and calibrated that model to accurately replicate the observed trends over many decades (stretching back in time). Then they reran that simulation without anthropogenic emissions (they simulated no industrial age). This allowed for a comparison of the world we know (which is industrial) with a hypothetical world (minus an industrial age). The 90% figure is thus a computed figure, based on a simulation. It's not emotion.

I admit, of course, that science involving models is complex and prone to debate. But it's not 'emotion', is what I am saying.

When there's money to be made, and there is a shitload of money to be made on global warming, the "experts" have lots to protect. For me, the tipping point for when I question is when the idea cannot tolerant and begins to demonize any opposition.

You mean, for instance, when climate change scientists, holding out their hand to Governments for meager funds to do research, are battered in public by scientists living off the very large coffes of big oil companies? Or, when a climate change scientist is said to be some cazy tree hugger trying to take your first born, when they say the world is getting warmer because of human industry? You might want to step back a bit and see who is slinging the most mud.

decades ago, cigarette companies trotted out scientists and doctors and any conceivable "expert" to say that smoking is not harmful instead it's healthy . . . What I'm getting at is that just because it's a popular belief does not mean that it is always correct, facts can be hidden and statistics can be manipulated.

You're exactly right, in each case. But look, I really want you to seriously consider this following point. Honestly.

Big Tobacco denied that smoking was harmful. They slandered doctors who said it was harmful, mostly in newspapers. Significantly, they funded research aimed purely at debunking the health hazard claims, as opposed to funding epidemilogical studies to find out if there was a risk. To me, that is what is the big kicker in the tobacco controversy. Big Tobacco spent money debunking without spendning money investigating.

Today, it is Big Oil doing the slandering. It is Big Oil pouring funds, through supposed not-for-profit charities, into advocacy groups to poke holes in climate change science. Big oil is real good at it, too.

What's very significant about the analogy between tobacco and oil is that, in each case, industrial and corporate interests were opposed to large scale changes that would directly affect their bottom line. Do you honestly think the greenie cause or the personal cheque-book of some geek scientists outweights the money on the line for big oil and industrial interests?
 
What were you saying?



You really read the report? You saw them define very likey as 90% confidence and, for instance, 95% as extremely likely, and so forth. That's not emotion, that's characterizing statistical significance in laymens terms.

Also, you read the technical reports, right, not just the policy documents? You read them describing how the 90% figure was a computation, not a guesstimation? First, the used actually collected weather data over more than 100 years. They fed that into a model and calibrated that model to accurately replicate the observed trends over many decades (stretching back in time). Then they reran that simulation without anthropogenic emissions (they simulated no industrial age). This allowed for a comparison of the world we know (which is industrial) with a hypothetical world (minus an industrial age). The 90% figure is thus a computed figure, based on a simulation. It's not emotion.

I admit, of course, that science involving models is complex and prone to debate. But it's not 'emotion', is what I am saying.



You mean, for instance, when climate change scientists, holding out their hand to Governments for meager funds to do research, are battered in public by scientists living off the very large coffes of big oil companies? Or, when a climate change scientist is said to be some cazy tree hugger trying to take your first born, when they say the world is getting warmer because of human industry? You might want to step back a bit and see who is slinging the most mud.



You're exactly right, in each case. But look, I really want you to seriously consider this following point. Honestly.

Big Tobacco denied that smoking was harmful. They slandered doctors who said it was harmful, mostly in newspapers. Significantly, they funded research aimed purely at debunking the health hazard claims, as opposed to funding epidemilogical studies to find out if there was a risk. To me, that is what is the big kicker in the tobacco controversy. Big Tobacco spent money debunking without spendning money investigating.

Today, it is Big Oil doing the slandering. It is Big Oil pouring funds, through supposed not-for-profit charities, into advocacy groups to poke holes in climate change science. Big oil is real good at it, too.

What's very significant about the analogy between tobacco and oil is that, in each case, industrial and corporate interests were opposed to large scale changes that would directly affect their bottom line. Do you honestly think the greenie cause or the personal cheque-book of some geek scientists outweights the money on the line for big oil and industrial interests?
It's sad to see what passes for education these days.

Truly sad.
 
I'm not positive, but I suspect that Anynym is still trying to suggest that since there is no CI quoted in the stats number that the IPCC work is useless. And that Anynym, with his superior education, is the only one smart enough to call them on it.
 
Oh, yesterday Landscaper referenced an article by one Noel Sheppard. There's a nice little sarcastic write up on him on Whiskey Fire.

I quote:
Pravda says that we're soon in for an Ice Age, not global warming. An Ice Age! Gracious! Best grab a scarf! Brrrrr!
Top wingnut scientist and noted fucknosed prissy shitbooger Noel Sheppard speculates, scientifically, based on scientific information from the Glenn Beck show, that Vladimir Putin knew all about this scientific Pravda science revelation, and is using it to cleverly manipulate the world oil market. This is not only possible, but probable. Because once something is published in Pravda, it automatically attains what is called by disinterested scientists Automatic Unquestioned Scientific Legitimacy.

Theres more there, and a good laugh or two as well.

http://whiskeyfire.typepad.com/whiskey_fire/2009/01/i-am-a-scientist.html