the proponents of climate change . . . like to put down everybody who don't subscribe to their views
You really are a dumbass
What were you saying?
There is no mathematical basis whatsoever for claiming "90% probability", based on the evidence presented. And yes, I have read the full report . . .The authors made this claim because they felt an emotional connection to the idea of what they think "90% probability" means to them, without any factual basis to their usage of the terminology.
You really read the report? You saw them define very likey as 90% confidence and, for instance, 95% as extremely likely, and so forth. That's not emotion, that's characterizing statistical significance in laymens terms.
Also, you read the technical reports, right, not just the policy documents? You read them describing how the 90% figure was a computation, not a guesstimation? First, the used actually collected weather data over more than 100 years. They fed that into a model and calibrated that model to accurately replicate the observed trends over many decades (stretching back in time). Then they reran that simulation without anthropogenic emissions (they simulated no industrial age). This allowed for a comparison of the world we know (which is industrial) with a hypothetical world (minus an industrial age). The 90% figure is thus a computed figure, based on a simulation. It's not emotion.
I admit, of course, that science involving models is complex and prone to debate. But it's not 'emotion', is what I am saying.
When there's money to be made, and there is a shitload of money to be made on global warming, the "experts" have lots to protect. For me, the tipping point for when I question is when the idea cannot tolerant and begins to demonize any opposition.
You mean, for instance, when climate change scientists, holding out their hand to Governments for meager funds to do research, are battered in public by scientists living off the very large coffes of big oil companies? Or, when a climate change scientist is said to be some cazy tree hugger trying to take your first born, when they say the world is getting warmer because of human industry? You might want to step back a bit and see who is slinging the most mud.
decades ago, cigarette companies trotted out scientists and doctors and any conceivable "expert" to say that smoking is not harmful instead it's healthy . . . What I'm getting at is that just because it's a popular belief does not mean that it is always correct, facts can be hidden and statistics can be manipulated.
You're exactly right, in each case. But look, I really want you to seriously consider this following point. Honestly.
Big Tobacco denied that smoking was harmful. They slandered doctors who said it was harmful, mostly in newspapers. Significantly, they funded research aimed purely at debunking the health hazard claims, as opposed to funding epidemilogical studies to find out if there was a risk. To me, that is what is the big kicker in the tobacco controversy. Big Tobacco spent money debunking without spendning money investigating.
Today, it is Big Oil doing the slandering. It is Big Oil pouring funds, through supposed not-for-profit charities, into advocacy groups to poke holes in climate change science. Big oil is real good at it, too.
What's very significant about the analogy between tobacco and oil is that, in each case, industrial and corporate interests were opposed to large scale changes that would directly affect their bottom line. Do you honestly think the greenie cause or the personal cheque-book of some geek scientists outweights the money on the line for big oil and industrial interests?