Denying climate change: a psychological problem?

Climate change is caused by human industry?

  • Yep, I believe the climate change scientists

    Votes: 14 14.0%
  • Nope, we're just in a natural cycle of warming

    Votes: 26 26.0%
  • Yep, I say Option 1 AND deniers are psychologically attached to consumerism

    Votes: 4 4.0%
  • Nope, it's Option 2 AND saying otherwise is bad science

    Votes: 4 4.0%
  • Yep, but powerful economic interests are misleading the public

    Votes: 28 28.0%
  • Nope, but idealistic and opportunistic economic interests are duping publics

    Votes: 24 24.0%

  • Total voters
    100

nolabel

Wherever u go, there u r
Jan 7, 2009
607
0
0
A newspaper article, on why many in the public do not believe man-made causes are driving climate change, reports the suggestion that a psychological attachment to consumerist lifestyles is at fault. Is this you? Thoughts?

Cold comfort: the psychology of climate denial

If the evidence is overwhelming that man-made climate change is already upon us and set to wreak planetary havoc, why do so many people refuse to believe it?

The UN's panel of climate scientists, in a landmark report, described the proof of global warming as "unequivocal".

That was two years ago, and since then hundreds of other studies have pointed to an ever-bleaker future, with a potential loss of life numbering in the tens of millions, if not more.

Yet survey after survey from around world reveals deep-seated doubt among the public.

A poll published in Britain on November 14, to cite but one example, found that only 41 per cent of respondents accepted as an established fact that human activity was largely responsible for current global warming.

The majority said the link was not proven, that green propaganda was to blame or the world was not heating up at all.

Last week, a private exchange of emails among climate scientists stoked a firestorm of scepticism after it was hacked and posted on the web.

The memos expressed frustration at the scientists' inability to explain what they described as a temporary slowdown in warming, and discussed ways to counter the campaigns of climate naysayers.

Experts see several explanations for the eagerness with which so many dismiss climate change as overblown or a hoax.

"There is the individual reluctance to give up our comfortable lifestyles - to travel less, consume less," said Anthony Grayling, a philosophy professor at the University of London and a bestselling author in Britain.

While deeply anchored in the West, this resistance also extends to emerging economies such as China, India and Brazil where a burgeoning middle class is only today tasting the fruits of a lifestyle they have waited so long and worked so hard to obtain.

For Tim Kasser, a professor of psychology at Knox University in Galesburg, Illinois, the reality of climate change impinges on core aspects of our identity.

"We are told a thousand times a day, notably through advertising, that the way to a happy, successful and meaningful life is through consumption," he said.

"But now scientists and environmentalists come along and say part of the problem is that we are consuming too much or in the wrong way."

Yet there may also be a darker explanation. It is the human instinct to shut out or modify a terrifying truth: that the world as we know it is heading for a smash.

"It's a paradox: when it comes to disasters, people do not allow themselves to believe what they know," explained Jean-Pierre Dupuy, a professor of social philosophy at the Ecole Polytechnique in Paris.

"Because everybody is in denial - or would like to be in denial - and would prefer to not shoulder too much of the responsibility for dealing with the problem, you have a kind of disconnect here," Grayling said.

Even scientists reluctantly pushed by their growing sense of alarm into launching public appeals for action have trouble coping.

When Clive Hamilton, a professor of public ethics at Australian National University, attended a September climate conference at Oxford tasked with imagining a world warmed by 4 degrees Celsius, he was struck by how researchers spoke among themselves.

"It was very revealing. As they relaxed somewhat, they began to speak about their fears, about losing sleep, not wanting to think about the implications of what they do," he recalled.

Under such circumstances, people are resourceful in finding ways to reassure themselves or turn their backs on the threat posed by climate change.

Some applaud their own environmental virtue: "Changing to compact fluorescent bulbs makes people feel good - 'I've done my bit for today,'" said Kasser, describing a common attitude in the United States.

"Blaming China and India is another great psychological defence mechanism."

A more sophisticated variant is to conclude, with a sigh of resignation. that individual action isn't enough.

"Even if all of us were at our most maximally green, it probably wouldn't make much more than about a 0.5 per cent difference," said Grayling in characterising this mentality.

At some point, however, reality may bite.

Hamilton, who is running for Parliament in Australia, said more and more people he meets are having what he calls an "Oh shit!" moment.

"It's that moment when you really get it, when you understand not just intellectually but emotionally that climate change is really happening. I think we will see a rush of that over the next couple of years," he said.

It may take one or more terrible shocks - national bankruptcies, a major environmental disaster in a vulnerable country like Bangladesh - for that to happen, said Grayling.

Once it does, "it will be impossible to look back over your shoulder and think, 'it's not true,' or 'there will be a scientific fix, it will all go away'."
 
Apart from the factual bias revealed in the poll (such as the debate whether Global Warming is or is not PRIMARILY anthropogenic), there are some key details which you seem to prefer to ignore.

For example, the number of "Climate Scientists" who conspired to defraud the world by "adjusting" their data to support their pre-conceived conclusions - the focus of the article you cited.

It's most certainly not about casting aspersions on those who understand the facts and respect the scientific method.

http://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2009/11/24/the_fix_is_in_99280.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hockey_stick_controversy
http://wattsupwiththat.com/2009/11/...ently-been-hacked-hundreds-of-files-released/
 
Recognizing the causes

of environmental degradation, and factors leading to climate change are one form of environmental degradation, is fully taken into account then some very hard choices and real sacrifices inevitably result. This country is no longer about hard choices or any real sacrifice. The preference by voters for Ronald Reagan over Jimmy Carter (or Ralph Nader, for that matter) was a good example. The minimal commitment to substantive change recently announced is just another confirmation.:(
 
Check out Michael Crichton's "State of Fear"

Michael Crichton wrote an excellent novel called "State of Fear" which addresses these issues. At the back of the novel is a series of appendices which give his thinking on climate change, societal attitudes and "junk science". He also points out that at the turn of the century there were a lot of prominent people and scientists who absolutely believed in the idea of eugenics. We all know how that turned out.

My personal opinion: The past century is but a milli-second or less in the age of this planet. Those who say things are changing are using a VERY small sample in the life of this planet to base their conclusions on.

Crichton points out their is no such thing as a completely objective study in today's research world. I tend to agree.

I recently heard that all the hue and cry regarding the number of plastic bags going into landfills were less than .001% of all the OTHER shit (literally AND figuratively) that goes into landfills. So the government imposed a 5 cent levy per plastic bag - is that money actually going somewhere or is it another tax which will go into General Revenue for the government to decide which social program they are going to dole it out to?

There are a number of people who have talked about "The BIG Lie" as in if you say something outlandish long enough and loud enough people begin to wonder if there is something to it. While I applaud former US VP Al Gore, the reality is that "An Inconvienent Truth" shows you what the producer and director want you to see to support the point they are trying to make. It's easy to ignore the stuff that doesn't agree with you.

There should be a mandatory course taught in high school in this country call "Critical Thought". I know that it is part of may university and college programs, but it should be visited earlier. Maybe that way our future generations will take a good look at the message and then consider where the bias lays.
 
A topic like climate change completely defies human intuition.

We are hardwired to believe that whatever happened over and over again in the past will go on happening over and over again in the future. It is a stupid mental trick, but for every day life, surprisingly effective, so it's wired right into our brains to think that way.

Most people have learned to "trust their gut" and what their gut tells them is that tommorow will be more or less like yesterday and today and last year.

It takes mental effort to overcome that hardwired bias and look at data objectively.
 
Al Gore makes millions from this and will appreciate your efforts
 
Al Gore makes millions from this and will appreciate your efforts
Don't get me started on Al Gore again... :rolleyes:

I find it difficult to vote in this poll.

I don't think any reasonably intelligent/ educated person can truthfully say that climate change is NOT happening. It is the nature of things. The weather is affected by so many different factors it is nearly impossible to predict with any degree of accuracy. What is in question is why is it happening or more correctly, to what degree is man responsible, and what can we do now to try and change our course at this point.

What gets me is the utter FEAR mongering tactics that the "green movement" (Al gore, David Suzuki and the likes) use to promote their own agendas and personal gain. They have literally made a business out of it. And don't get me started on carbon credits... **rolls eyes**
 
Last edited:
Don't get me started on Al Gore again... :rolleyes:

I find it difficult to vote in this poll.

I don't think any reasonably intelligent/ educated person can truthfully say that climate change is NOT happening. It is the nature of things. The weather is affected by so many different factors it is nearly impossible to predict with any degree of accuracy. What is in question is why is it happening or more correctly, to what degree is man responsible, and what can we do now to try and now to change our course at this point.

What gets me is the utter FEAR mongering tactics that the "green movement" (Al gore, David Suzuki and the likes) use to promote their own agendas and personal gain. They have literally made a business out of it. And don't get me started on carbon credits... **rolls eyes**



Well put sir & very well written... That sums it up in the shortest space I've seen so far without leaving anything important out.
 
Al Gore makes millions from this and will appreciate your efforts

So he is to be damned because he can see what's happening and invests his 'PRIVATE' money behind what he sees. Nothing like putting your money where your mouth is.

It might be good optics if he put a lot of this money into something like the Clinton Initiative. Even W. Buffit saw that you only need so much to live comfortably and gave nearly 36 billion to Bill Gats to use in his charity. Nice move.
 
Well put sir & very well written... That sums it up in the shortest space I've seen so far without leaving anything important out.

Almost a complete paragraph without a single hyperbole. You're getting old and slowing TM. It can be called fear mongering but there's a lot of solid science behind it. As I said before in long lost post, if you don't believe the science you'll never agree.

Remember the US government being told about the possibility of 'Hurricane Pam' destroying N'Orleans. The predictions were sloughed off by the powers in Washington and Katrina arrived within 12 months doing exactly what was predicted. Similar science, similar models, and bang on. They still didn't learn, as the Corps of Engineers are rebuilding the new stuff to a level that won't handle what can happen. The time spent walking through N'Orleans and looking a the 100 year high water marks 12 feet up the brick walls and realizing they were put there 125 years ago, made me cry and smirk simultaneously.

I have yet to return and I am in no hurry to see the damage never to be repaired.
 
Huh?

Nothing like putting your money where your mouth is.
On that note:

Let's take a look at Mr. Gore's own personal hypocrisy... The last image from his film (which I doubt very much was self financed, but that is just mere speculation on my part) states emphatically: "Are you ready to change the way you live?" Now, maybe I got his message wrong, but I believe he is implying that I should be making EVERY effort to reduce my family's "carbon dioxide output" by driving fuel efficient cars, changing my light bulbs, turn down (and even turn off) my air conditioner and even explore alternative ways of powering and heating my home...

So let's have a look at what Mr. Gore is willing to do... (assuming the numerous reports I've read are true), together, he and his wife Tipper own 3 homes:


  • a 10,000-square-foot, twenty room, eight bathroom home in the Belle Meade area Nashville, Tennessee (see below)
  • a 4,000-square-foot home in Arlington, Va.
  • By some reports, they own a third home in Carthage, Tennessee
His main residence, the 20 room mansion mentioned above (not including 8 bathrooms) heated by natural gas. Add on a pool (and a pool house) and a separate guest house, all heated by natural gas. In one month this residence consumes more energy than the average American household does in a year. The average bill for electricity and natural gas runs over $2,400. In natural gas alone, this property consumes more than 20 times the national average for an American home... and let's not forget- he reportedly has 2 additional homes, AND travels all around the globe using jet airplanes and gas guzzling limo's wherever he goes.

For someone rallying to save the planet by pursuing a path of extreme personal sacrifice, Gore demands very little sacrifice for himself. When asked about his environmentally (very) UNFRIENDLY ways, Mr. Gore's response is simple- he explains that he buys carbon credits to offset his and his family's lifestyle back to a zero footprint. WHAT??? He just totally negated the entire theme of his film and is admitting that he is diametrically opposed to the message he is preaching!!! He just spent almost 2 hours in his film telling me I had to REDUCE my carbon emissions! Is this not the very definition of hypocrite? :eek:
 
Last edited:

and in between, were there any reports of the polar caps getting thicker. These are just snap shot headlines, where the stories with them. It would be some interesting reading. We all know how flawed news headlines can be.

Remember "Dewey Defeats Truman!", or maybe not.

For someone to call David Suzuki agenda driven has never met the man. He is what you see.
 
Where I am sitting right now was once covered by a sheet of ice several miles thick. This was as recent as 10 to 15 thousand years ago, an eyeblink in geologic terms.
What happened to all that freakin' ice? It melted. Why? The planet warmed. And it did it without any assistance from my incandescent light bulbs or my brothers Chevy pick up.
Therefore, the planet can change its climate without human intervention.
Today, we see evidence of the planet warming once again, and the Ed Begley's of the world are trying to make everyone feel guilty for causing it.
Unless, and until, some resonable scientists, free of political agenda, can show me measurable data that my lifestyle, and not Mother Nature, is the root cause, then this is a battle I will view from the sidelines.
 
It can be called fear mongering

but there's a lot of solid science behind it.


As I said before in long lost post, if you don't believe the science you'll never agree.

I believe in science when it is done objectively & properly.... What I DON'T believe in is the "scientists" that have now been revealed as perpetrating fraud by their own emails... In addition the fact that we the people are being asked to give up an enormous amount of freedom AND huge gobs of money makes me very suspicious....

Govenments tend to use this amount of spin & scare mongering ONLY when there is no truth to it & they are looking for unearned benefits at the expense of their citizens. It's a tactic as old as time: Create a panic, then "solve" the problem in exchange for more $ & power.

It's always the same message: "don't Think about what we're saying there is not time....... FEEL the threat... let go of your reason & let us take care of you"

& with the track record that governments have I think it's VERY fair to demand that they Conclusively PROVE every goddamned thing they claim...

Very sorry but there are far more elements to consider beyond just the "science" here... And the "science" isn't that convincing even With all the pushing & spin... Truth is pretty self evident & it can stand openly on it's own & face all challengers. Peer review might have meant something once but it's basically devolved to cronyism, dogma & orthodoxy as of late.

& with the track record that governments have I think it's VERY fair to demand that they Conclusively PROVE every goddamned thing they claim BEFORE we give them anything else...

If it's really so important they could divert all the resources necessary to fund a comprehensive research effort that was completely transparent & indisputable... But they haven't.. They have mostly pushed it on us. It's all very murky & full of dirty tricks & it STINKS.

How is that not reasonable? Demanding indisputable proof this time citing their track record of lies?
 
Al Gore's net worth went from $2m in 2000, to about $100m today. I wish I could "believe" in global warming as strongly as he does!
 
Where I am sitting right now was once covered by a sheet of ice several miles thick. This was as recent as 10 to 15 thousand years ago, an eyeblink in geologic terms.
What happened to all that freakin' ice? It melted. Why? The planet warmed. And it did it without any assistance from my incandescent light bulbs or my brothers Chevy pick up.
Therefore, the planet can change its climate without human intervention.
Today, we see evidence of the planet warming once again, and the Ed Begley's of the world are trying to make everyone feel guilty for causing it.
Unless, and until, some resonable scientists, free of political agenda, can show me measurable data that my lifestyle, and not Mother Nature, is the root cause, then this is a battle I will view from the sidelines.


Dinasaurs lived in a really warm time too..... Guess they all drove SUVs......

:)
 
Where I am sitting right now was once covered by a sheet of ice several miles thick. This was as recent as 10 to 15 thousand years ago, an eyeblink in geologic terms.
What happened to all that freakin' ice? It melted. Why? The planet warmed. And it did it without any assistance from my incandescent light bulbs or my brothers Chevy pick up.
Therefore, the planet can change its climate without human intervention.
Today, we see evidence of the planet warming once again, and the Ed Begley's of the world are trying to make everyone feel guilty for causing it.
Unless, and until, some resonable scientists, free of political agenda, can show me measurable data that my lifestyle, and not Mother Nature, is the root cause, then this is a battle I will view from the sidelines.

Yes. Climate change happens naturally but the human activity speeds up so fast to a point nature (including human!) does not have enough time to adjust. There will be never 100% proof but you just don't want to the on the problem side if the scientist are right.
 
On that note:


]His main residence, the 20 room mansion mentioned above (not including 8 bathrooms) heated by natural gas. Add on a pool (and a pool house) and a separate guest house, all heated by natural gas. In one month this residence consumes more energy than the average American household does in a year. The average bill for electricity and natural gas runs over $2,400. In natural gas alone, this property consumes more than 20 times the national average for an American home... and let's not forget- he reportedly has 2 additional homes, AND travels all around the globe using jet airplanes and gas guzzling limo's wherever he goes.[/FONT]

eek:[/FONT]

how on earth are his gas/electricity bills at $2,400 per month? my house is about the same size and my monthly bill no where close to that. what is the source of the $2,400 figure?
 
So where do these carbon credits come from?


Does he pay a bunch of bicycle riding nuts (just pulling your chain CG:D) to offset his energy intensive lifestyle?? If the credits come from productive businesses that have cut their own emissions, doesn't using the "credits" for something besides other productive businesses defeat the purpose of the whole thing?