Denying climate change: a psychological problem?

Climate change is caused by human industry?

  • Yep, I believe the climate change scientists

    Votes: 14 14.0%
  • Nope, we're just in a natural cycle of warming

    Votes: 26 26.0%
  • Yep, I say Option 1 AND deniers are psychologically attached to consumerism

    Votes: 4 4.0%
  • Nope, it's Option 2 AND saying otherwise is bad science

    Votes: 4 4.0%
  • Yep, but powerful economic interests are misleading the public

    Votes: 28 28.0%
  • Nope, but idealistic and opportunistic economic interests are duping publics

    Votes: 24 24.0%

  • Total voters
    100
It gets quite tiring, but ok, one more shot.

And one more quick quip, landscaper. I took the time to read your link, have you looked at any of the links I've posted?

nolabel is quite right, the magnifying lense on climate change science is only pointed one way. The science is a work in progress, there is a vast body of work and there will always be studies that will have errors. But finding single errors in single studies does not in any way disprove the general consensus.

The McIntyre/Mann pissing match doesn't disprove anything. If you, at the very minimum, read the wiki page on Hockey Stick Controversy you can see that McIntyre had some valid criticisms which Mann answered and that Mann's work was subjected to incredible criticism, that Mann himself said in the original 1998 article "more widespread high-resolution data are needed before more confident conclusions can be reached and that the uncertainties were the point of the article." Mann has since released a paper in 2008 that refines the previous study and continues his work, meanwhile McIntyre has now resorted to bizarre claims of upside down use of data.

None of this debate on methodology of this one study disproved the general point that we are now in a warming period on this planet that is quite probably unprecedented in the last 1000 years and is man made.
 
If they were single studies I would agree, they are not, there are discrepancies in the later tree ring work as well enough so that the work can be and is questioned.
As for Mann's work he has never released the source data he used Mcintyre redid the work fro scratch to find the problems.

The question of who is correct can be easily solved by the complete auditing of all teh data.

Peer review also includes a section that basically says the work needs to be able to be replicated independantly.

This has never been done .

This whole issue needs to be aired out by that I mean a complete audit of all the science the data and the methodolgies invloved. If the data science and methodology stand up to an independant audit I don't have a problem with the science, but until then the onus is on the people who are saying this is right to prove it.

As of yet they have not done so.

Note , Dr Jones at East Anglia has for 10 years or so refused to release the data sets and used any number of excuses not to do so in spite of court orders etc. Just recently he announced that the data had been lost during a move, yesterday he claims the dsata was destroyed by his predecesor.

Now science is basically a reputation based system. You are only as good as your last published work. Given the discrepancies in the stories that have been released, on what basis are we supposed to believe anything coming from this source?

That is the problem in a nutshell. There has been so much screaming and shouting there is no basis for any level of trust.

If you disagree with anything related to climate change you are a "DENIER" and sumarily dismissed.

The whole situation needs to be cleared up before we put the developed world into the toilet and flush it.
 
Wrong again, landscaper.

Again, a quick wiki search of hockey stick controversy shows that Mann did release all his data. Please back up your assertion that the data was not released with something credible.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hockey_stick_controversy

One point of contention relates to McIntyre's requests for Mann to provide him with the data, methods and source code McIntyre needed to "audit" MBH98.[20] Mann provided some data and then stopped. After a long process - in which the National Science Foundation supported Mann - the code was made publicly available [21]. It happened because Congress investigated after an article in the Wall Street Journal [22] detailed criticisms raised by McIntyre.[23] Congress was especially concerned about Mann’s reported refusal to provide data. In June 2005, Congress asked Mann to testify before a special subcommittee. The chairman of the committee (Joe Barton, a prominent global warming skeptic) wrote a letter to Mann requesting he provide his data, including his source code, archives of all data for all of Mann's scientific publications, identities of his present and past scientific collaborators, and details of all funding for any of Mann's ongoing or prior research, including all of the supporting forms and agreements.[22] The American Association for the Advancement of Science viewed this as "a search for some basis on which to discredit these particular scientists and findings, rather than a search for understanding."[24] When Mann complied, all of the data was available for McIntyre. Congress also requested that third party science panels review the criticisms by McIntyre and McKitrick.
 
I've spent way too much time reading on this issue today, but I continue to learn a lot.

Here's a very good page debunking all your arguments, with credible links to peer assessed papers, Landscaper. They shred all your arguments.

Basically, Mann's work was valid, Mann's work has been verified by other studies and McIntyre doesn't know what he's talking about.

Please, please read this link.

http://www.logicalscience.com/skeptic_arguments/fakeddata.html
 
And please note, that the link includes direct links to the data you claim Mann won't release.

How about an apology or at least admitting that you are wrong?
 
The point of peer review,at least the part where the independant reviewers reproduce the results does require independant. Wahl and Ammaan are hardly independant, the data you refer to is the adjusted data not the raw data.

Mcintyres work has been independantly review and audited by peers who are not part of the same group and found to stand the test.
 
Again, no.

McIntyre published one peer reviewed paper, which has been contested.
His other attempts have been refused.
McIntyres work has only been reviewed by statisticians who said his original work had one valid point, but that it did not change the merit or results of Mann's work.

Please show proof that the data is not the raw data.

Again, Mann's work has been verified by numerous studies using different methods and models. Even assuming there are minor problems in Mann's 1998 paper, since corrected, it doesn't provide enough proof that therefore all scientists are crooked and climate change is not happening.

Do you deny that we now have 387 ppm of CO2 in the atmosphere?
Do you deny that we are in a period of warming?
Do you deny that glaciers the world are thawing?
Do you deny that the north pole is losing permament ice?

I regret spending so much time on one minor point when there is such a vast amount of proof and you can't seem to honestly read both sides of the argument.
 
No more snow tires.

First, climate change means no more winters ever again.

Second, peak oil means you won't be able to afford gas in a few years.

Third, 2012 is coming and then we're all doomed.

Fourth, the heat alone from this thread has significantly warmed the planet, and is nearing the melting point whereupon the 'H' word will be used, thus ending all arguments.
 
The point of peer review,at least the part where the independant reviewers reproduce the results does require independant. Wahl and Ammaan are hardly independant, the data you refer to is the adjusted data not the raw data.

Mcintyres work has been independantly review and audited by peers who are not part of the same group and found to stand the test.

You're not responding to anything Flubadub is saying, you're just shifting ground whenever there is a problem with your argument. Gee, pot calling the kettle black on that one, huh? It doesn't take a genius to see complete evasiveness on show.
 
I have an important rule in life: Don't trust the experts. whether the expert is a carpenter or a doctor. Get several opinions and do some research and think for yourself.
 
I have an important rule in life: Don't trust the experts. whether the expert is a carpenter or a doctor. Get several opinions and do some research and think for yourself.

You must spend a lot of time looking over the shoulders of other people. It drive you crazy when you can't see your car at the your dealer when work need to be done. so when the doctor says your arms broken what do you do, walk out and go to another doctor?

Interesting general comment, but full of holes.
 
I have an important rule in life: Don't trust the experts. whether the expert is a carpenter or a doctor. Get several opinions and do some research and think for yourself.

I have an important rule in life, too. It's called don't trust sloppy thinkers.

You must spend a lot of time looking over the shoulders of other people.

As Unlucky Rock correctly notes, lurkerjoe has adoped about the worst possible life strategy. Ever heard of the benefits of a division of labour? I am sure lurkerjoe is one of those micro-managers everyone hates!


But then, oops, lurkerjoe completely contradicts himself. This looks very much like trusting what some experts told him, in this case not to trust the conclusions of some others.

And just to put this stupid story in perspective, from the very article lurkerjoe and you conspiracy nuts are talking about . . .

"Independent scientists are quick to point out that the actions described in the e-mails do not describe anything like a fabrication of global-warming evidence, and that two other major sets of historical data drawn from the same sources, both held by NASA institutions in the United States, also show a historical warming trend."

A bit of selective reporting by you all, really.
 
Isn't it funny how we used to say, "Global warming"

Since over the last decade, the temperatures have been falling slightly, now it's, "Climate change."

lol. 30 years ago, they were warning us about another ice age.

Over the 4 billion or so years that this planet has existed, the climate has always been changing. We are foolish to believe that we are the sole cause of it.
 
You either did not read any of the other posts, or cannot recall their content. There's enough in there to suggest you are being extremely simplistic in your understanding of the technical claims about climate change. Just so you know, the claim is about global increase in the mean temperature (no, that doesn't imply the temperature is angry), so that there will always be both seasonal variations and geographical variations. Your post just shows that you completly lack an understanding about something you otherwise dismiss.
 
I have an important rule in life, too. It's called don't trust sloppy thinkers.

As Unlucky Rock correctly notes, lurkerjoe has adoped about the worst possible life strategy. Ever heard of the benefits of a division of labour? I am sure lurkerjoe is one of those micro-managers everyone hates!

But then, oops, lurkerjoe completely contradicts himself. This looks very much like trusting what some experts told him, in this case not to trust the conclusions of some others.

And just to put this stupid story in perspective, from the very article lurkerjoe and you conspiracy nuts are talking about . . .

"Independent scientists are quick to point out that the actions described in the e-mails do not describe anything like a fabrication of global-warming evidence, and that two other major sets of historical data drawn from the same sources, both held by NASA institutions in the United States, also show a historical warming trend."

A bit of selective reporting by you all, really.

No, I'm the type that micro-managers hate because I can think for myself. Nice assumption though, fits in with the proponents of climate change who like to put down everybody who don't subscribe to their views. Next I'll be heretic.

BTW: Division of labour was first developed to facilitate the manufacturing of goods so that goods once made by skilled artisans can be made by unskilled people for a fraction of the cost. Win: big business. Lose: independent artisans. Outside manufacturing its called an integrated, cross-functional team or some other Dilbert-babble.

Evidently, you think that the G&M is an "expert?" You really are a dumbass. I'd like to sell you some land high up in the rockies. It's a good deal, it'll be waterfront property if the experts have it right. And 20 years from now when the experts revise their findings it'll be your own personal island.
 
You must spend a lot of time looking over the shoulders of other people. It drive you crazy when you can't see your car at the your dealer when work need to be done. so when the doctor says your arms broken what do you do, walk out and go to another doctor?

Interesting general comment, but full of holes.

Uh, huh. And you must be the kind of person who'll agree to every single repair that a dealer recommends, like a complete engine flush without a) knowing what the fuck it is and b) checking to see if it even does anything (it doesn't).

For the record, if my arm is bent is a weird angle then clearly it's broken, doesn't take an expert to know that. If my arm doesn't exhibit the usual signs of a broken arm but the doctor says my arm's broken I would kindly ask him to point it out on the x-ray "because I'm curious to see it" but I'd really be checking to make sure my name is on the x-ray and having him double check. Medical errors are prevalent enough that millions are spent improving lab and diagnostic procedures to avoid them.

I'm not saying I don't believe anything an expert tells me, I'm just not a sheeple.
 
ok, lurkerjoe.

So you don't believe experts, but do believe evidence like a weirdly bent arm.

So what do you make of (sorry to repeat this, but no denier has a reasonable answer yet):
Increase in CO2 to 387 ppm.
Melting of glaciers.
Melting of permanent ice in arctic.
The fact that 9 of the hottest years on record have taken place within the last 25 years.
Spring comes earlier than it used to.
You don't need snow tires anymore (joke)
Depletion of commercial fishing species (tied to overfishing and change in ocean temperature)
Thousands of studies confirming these observations and tying it to 90% probability it is human caused (IPCC).

There you have numerous real world examples, backed by numerous studies.
Or are you a sheeple who believes a handful of people who tell you what you want to believe (back to original article for thread).


So, is your arm broken?