Starts off with one falsehood "Now that ClimateGate has buried the fraudulent hockey stick for good," That's not been buried in the least. Maybe that one graph has been updated, but its still essentially in use in peer assessed work.
http://www.financialpost.com/opinion/story.html?id=2056988
Check thje link it is an opinion piece but is from a very reputable source, the attributions are available as well.
Ok so you have an e-mail that says in part change these values because we can not account for them in the theory, what does that actually say
What I meant to say was how can any of the data being used be trusted?
The reason being the only results available for inspection are results that have been changed by the people who are telling us to trust the data. Without the original raw data for auditing there is no way to tell if the adjustments of the data are reasonable or not. Do not get me wrong here data is adjusted on virtually every experiment, usually because of precision issues with the measuring equipment or issues with the methodology. Neither of these things will invalidate a result provided they are within the limits of the experiments error range.
The problem with the data from CRU is we do not have any idea what the error range was or what the data started out as . That brings in a question of what exactly did they do? That question is something we really need an answer for because the whole basis of the theory rests on that. If the data was corrupted for what ever reason the whole thesis is invalid.
The proponants of climate change/ global warming shot themselves in the foot by making everything a BIG SECRET. If the data and the peer review was done properly this would not have happened and the issue would be well on its way to conclusion.
Then your linked report goes off on confusing local temperature changes (ie the european little ice age) with global temperature change. I mean I'm not a scientist, just a musician who is curious about things, and I can poke holes in this paper in seconds. Its crap. Copy and pasted charts, stats out of context and illogical conclusions. If the author of that paper posted it anywhere where that was allowed criticism, it wouldn't last a second, in other words, its wouldn't stand the peer assessment process.
Do you believe it only because its what you want to believe?
Just to bring it back to the original article that started this link.
I could ask you the sme thing, do you belive that climate change as a result of human activity is going on? Or do you believe the people who tell you that? There is a big difference in the two things.
As to thinking I am an idiot feel free , trust me you are not the first,
Cycle Guy has the tickets for the line and assuming that you don't get barred for saying so by the mods who am I to argue with your assesment