Denying climate change: a psychological problem?

Climate change is caused by human industry?

  • Yep, I believe the climate change scientists

    Votes: 14 14.0%
  • Nope, we're just in a natural cycle of warming

    Votes: 26 26.0%
  • Yep, I say Option 1 AND deniers are psychologically attached to consumerism

    Votes: 4 4.0%
  • Nope, it's Option 2 AND saying otherwise is bad science

    Votes: 4 4.0%
  • Yep, but powerful economic interests are misleading the public

    Votes: 28 28.0%
  • Nope, but idealistic and opportunistic economic interests are duping publics

    Votes: 24 24.0%

  • Total voters
    100
Interesting, mover of mud (as nolabel might say), but quite wrong.

You get one thing correct in that theories are 'accepted' after peer review. What you get quite wrong is your belief that one 40 year paper disproves anything. If you follow your own logic you would have to read the most recent peer assessed work, such as the latest IPCC reports.

Its quite typical of deniers to quote one 'mistake' or one misquoted stolen email as proof that all work up to now has been incorrect. If you want to assess the present state of the science then you must criticize the most recent peer assessed, published works, again try the IPCC reports.

Follow your own logic, please.
 
Interesting, mover of mud (as nolabel might say), but quite wrong.

You get one thing correct in that theories are 'accepted' after peer review. What you get quite wrong is your belief that one 40 year paper disproves anything. If you follow your own logic you would have to read the most recent peer assessed work, such as the latest IPCC reports.

Its quite typical of deniers to quote one 'mistake' or one misquoted stolen email as proof that all work up to now has been incorrect. If you want to assess the present state of the science then you must criticize the most recent peer assessed, published works, again try the IPCC reports.

Follow your own logic, please.

I did not say one 40 years old paper disproves anything it does not. The original reference came up in the original post. The poster had several different theories and comingled them into a single omnibus global warming confluence. The reference was PART of the original rebuttal.

It is interesting that you use the phrase denier as a general term. It is typical of the proponants of the climate change/global warming theory that they denigrate anybody who does not imediatly agree with the " approved message" with a derogatory term selected purposley to be similar to the Holocaust Denier terminology.

You reference the IPCC reports as the most recent reports. In that you are correct and if you have followed my posts on this subject at all you would note that in fact I do discuss the latest reports from the IPCC. The interesting thing about most of those reports is that they fail the second part of the peer review process. The part where the conclusions are reproducable by independant researchers.

The fact that most of the original data is

a) Not available because they discarded it

b) Not available because the researcher refuses to release it

Causes a number of problems. First amoung them is no body really knows what the original data was and how it was adjusted prior to the conclusions being released.

Secondly given the release of the stolen e-mails and data, not a single e-mail from a disgruntled employee, but over a thousand of them from the principles in the research . Those same principles discussing ways to avoid FOI requests and adjust and remove data that did not conform. On how to stop publication of and a atrempt to stop researchers from submitting to periodicals that were/are critical of the stated goals of the research.

Just what are we supposed to believe? The research? It can not be reproduced without the original data, data that was apparantley discarded during a move.

Data that possibly confirmed what could be the most important research in the 20th/21st century. That data? Given that they want the developed world to spend trillions of dollars on carbon remediation why did they not ask for some money for storage of that very important data?

Presently there is a theory , that humans are causing climate change due to carbon dioxide and other gasses reflecting some of the reradiated heat from the earth back into the ecosphere. The data that was collected perported to show that , unfortunatly the data does not exist anymore due to the negligence of the party that is requiring us to believce in the theories that hte data supported.

We are supposed to take their word for the fact that the data is good, but then we have those e-mails describing how to adjust the data and the results to conform to the required theory.

The researchers who have not released their data for peer review should not be publishing at all. The point of peer review is to test the theories and reproduce the results. If you refuse to release your data what are you hideing?
 
Ok, take a look here and tell me what data is missing:
http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/data-sources/

There is no conspiracy to withhold data. If you can look through that list, tell me what data is missing that proves that we are not in the midst of anthropogenic climate change, you might have an argument.

The emails do not describe how to adjust data to prove existing theories, the 'trick' so often quoted is a method that better approximates the real world then a previous methodology.

And keep in mind that there are issues with data that comes from certain countries, ie some countries do not want climate data published. This is different from scientists not releasing their work.

And finally, what term do prefer to deniers?
 
And as a further note, Realclimate.org is a great reference site.

Here's what they have to say about peer assessed work:
http://www.realclimate.org/index.ph...iew-a-necessary-but-not-sufficient-condition/


On this site we emphasize conclusions that are supported by “peer-reviewed” climate research. That is, research that has been published by one or more scientists in a scholarly scientific journal after review by one or more experts in the scientists’ same field (’peers’) for accuracy and validity. What is so important about “Peer Review”? As Chris Mooney has lucidly put it:

[Peer Review] is an undisputed cornerstone of modern science. Central to the competitive clash of ideas that moves knowledge forward, peer review enjoys so much renown in the scientific community that studies lacking its imprimatur meet with automatic skepticism. Academic reputations hinge on an ability to get work through peer review and into leading journals; university presses employ peer review to decide which books they’re willing to publish; and federal agencies like the National Institutes of Health use peer review to weigh the merits of applications for federal research grants.


Put simply, peer review is supposed to weed out poor science. However, it is not foolproof — a deeply flawed paper can end up being published under a number of different potential circumstances: (i) the work is submitted to a journal outside the relevant field (e.g. a paper on paleoclimate submitted to a social science journal) where the reviewers are likely to be chosen from a pool of individuals lacking the expertise to properly review the paper, (ii) too few or too unqualified a set of reviewers are chosen by the editor, (iii) the reviewers or editor (or both) have agendas, and overlook flaws that invalidate the paper’s conclusions, and (iv) the journal may process and publish so many papers that individual manuscripts occasionally do not get the editorial attention they deserve.

and here's more from the same page on current scientific thinking:


The current thinking of scientists on climate change is based on thousands of studies (Google Scholar gives 19,000 scientific articles for the full search phrase “global climate change”). Any new study will be one small grain of evidence that adds to this big pile, and it will shift the thinking of scientists slightly. Science proceeds like this in a slow, incremental way. It is extremely unlikely that any new study will immediately overthrow all the past knowledge. So even if the conclusions of the Shaviv and Veizer (2003) study discussed earlier, for instance, had been correct, this would be one small piece of evidence pitted against hundreds of others which contradict it. Scientists would find the apparent contradiction interesting and worthy of further investigation, and would devote further study to isolating the source of the contradiction. They would not suddenly throw out all previous results. Yet, one often gets the impression that scientific progress consists of a series of revolutions where scientists discard all their past thinking each time a new result gets published. This is often because only a small handful of high-profile studies in a given field are known by the wider public and media, and thus unrealistic weight is attached to those studies. New results are often over-emphasised (sometimes by the authors, sometimes by lobby groups) to make them sound important enough to have news value. Thus “bombshells” usually end up being duds.

However, as demonstrated above, even when it initially breaks down, the process of peer-review does usually work in the end. But sometimes it can take a while. Observers would thus be well advised to be extremely skeptical of any claims in the media or elsewhere of some new “bombshell” or “revolution” that has not yet been fully vetted by the scientific community.
 
And finally, what term do prefer to deniers?

I don't know perhaps people with a different view point? The term is designed to cast people who disagree with the climate chenge orthodoxy in a pergerotive light.

The center whose articles you posted is an interesting choice.

Amoung its Directors/contributers

Dr Micheal Mann, noted for the hockey stick graph of temperatures and also for refuseing to release the date he used to produce his conclusion. Two Canadian statistisions redid all his work with the same data from teh same sources and destroyed his conclusions.

Perhaps a better choice of references would have helped.

I will get back to you after I review their articles and data might take a few days don't go away it should be interesting
 
Definitely, take a look dirt digger and get back to me.

Are you talking about this supposed 'controversy'?
(from the wikipedia ippc entry)

The third assessment report (TAR) prominently featured[71] a graph labeled "Millennial Northern Hemisphere temperature reconstruction" from a paper by Michael E. Mann, Raymond S. Bradley and Malcolm K. Hughes (MBH98[72]) often referred to as the "Hockey Stick Graph". This graph differed from a schematic in the first assessment report which depicted larger global temperature variations over the past 1000 years, and higher temperatures during the Medieval Warm Period than the present day. (The schematic was not an actual plot of data.) The appearance of MBH98 in the TAR was widely construed as demonstrating that the current warming period is exceptional in comparison to temperatures between 1000 and 1900. The methodology used to produce this graph was criticized in an article by Stephen McIntyre and Ross McKitrick.[73] In a 2006 letter to Nature, Bradley, Hughes and Mann pointed out that their original article had said that "more widespread high-resolution data are needed before more confident conclusions can be reached" and that the uncertainties were "the point of the article."[74]

I think your choice of words is a bit strong, and not backed up by any reputable papers.
There is some debate about his interpretation of data, but once again this in no way dimishes the results of the whole. Of course there are minor problems with some papers and theories but the gist of it is, there is no reputable scientists debating whether we are in the midst of anthropogenic climate change.

As I posted earlier, one of the 'people with different view points' tactics concern overemphasis on single minor points with single minor papers without any awareness of the size and depth of research on the matter. Its as if you can't get past looking at a wall without saying, well that one brick is not the right colour. Focus on the body of work, and there can be no real doubt where the science lays.
 
Of course there are minor problems with some papers and theories but the gist of it is, there is no reputable scientists debating whether we are in the midst of anthropogenic climate change.

Well, no, there are major problems with many papers and there are many reputable scientists debating whether we are in the midst of anthropogenic climate change.

And that was before we found several of the leading proponents of the side of such anthropogenic change caught falsifying their data and burying data which did not support their conclusions.

Science is about finding the conclusions from the data, NOT about finding the data which support your conclusion as this scientific community has done.
 
Well, no again, Anynym.

First off, what's the ratio scientists who believe we are in the midst of anthropogenic climate change to those who don't? I'd wager it to be close to 100:1.

Secondly, there is no proof of falsifying data, only misinterpreted, out of context stolen emails. The only people who seem to believe those emails prove anything are people who don't seem to understand what the emails are about.

Thirdly, where is the proof that the body of work represented by the IPCC has been done to support a forgone conclusion. Take a look at the history of climate change thread up earlier today, these conclusions are backed by close to 100 years of work by literally thousands of scientists. As posted earlier, the data is there for everyone to see. Seems to me that you might be the one defending a position without the data to back it up.
 
Ok, take a look here and tell me what data is missing:
http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/data-sources/

There is no conspiracy to withhold data. If you can look through that list, tell me what data is missing that proves that we are not in the midst of anthropogenic climate change, you might have an argument.

The emails do not describe how to adjust data to prove existing theories, the 'trick' so often quoted is a method that better approximates the real world then a previous methodology.

And keep in mind that there are issues with data that comes from certain countries, ie some countries do not want climate data published. This is different from scientists not releasing their work.

And finally, what term do prefer to deniers?

Definitely, take a look dirt digger and get back to me.

Are you talking about this supposed 'controversy'?
(from the wikipedia ippc entry)

The third assessment report (TAR) prominently featured[71] a graph labeled "Millennial Northern Hemisphere temperature reconstruction" from a paper by Michael E. Mann, Raymond S. Bradley and Malcolm K. Hughes (MBH98[72]) often referred to as the "Hockey Stick Graph". This graph differed from a schematic in the first assessment report which depicted larger global temperature variations over the past 1000 years, and higher temperatures during the Medieval Warm Period than the present day. (The schematic was not an actual plot of data.) The appearance of MBH98 in the TAR was widely construed as demonstrating that the current warming period is exceptional in comparison to temperatures between 1000 and 1900. The methodology used to produce this graph was criticized in an article by Stephen McIntyre and Ross McKitrick.[73] In a 2006 letter to Nature, Bradley, Hughes and Mann pointed out that their original article had said that "more widespread high-resolution data are needed before more confident conclusions can be reached" and that the uncertainties were "the point of the article."[74]

I think your choice of words is a bit strong, and not backed up by any reputable papers.
There is some debate about his interpretation of data, but once again this in no way dimishes the results of the whole. Of course there are minor problems with some papers and theories but the gist of it is, there is no reputable scientists debating whether we are in the midst of anthropogenic climate change.

As I posted earlier, one of the 'people with different view points' tactics concern overemphasis on single minor points with single minor papers without any awareness of the size and depth of research on the matter. Its as if you can't get past looking at a wall without saying, well that one brick is not the right colour. Focus on the body of work, and there can be no real doubt where the science lays.

If we can get past the calling of names try this link

http://scienceandpublicpolicy.org/reprint/simple_proof.html

the authors are as reputable as the authors of the site you have recomended , the added bonus is they have never been accused of adjusting their data
 
And that was before we found several of the leading proponents of the side of such anthropogenic change caught falsifying their data and burying data which did not support their conclusions.

Science is about finding the conclusions from the data, NOT about finding the data which support your conclusion as this scientific community has done.

But gathering any data you can find that supports your conclusion is just what you have done. Pot calling the kettle black. Also, I did address your misinterpretation of the 'leaked email' saga, but as is typical in this debate, clim,ate change deniers sidestep anything that brings into doubt their credibility. Ultimately, the only people working in public on this are climate scientists citing anthropogenic change as a cause of warming. The deniers squirrel away in secret and public far less peer-reviewed work, but what they do is run websites and blogs - not peer reviewed - so that toms, dicks, and harry's can freely access what appears to be well founded claims. Everyone talks about greeny propoganda, but turns a blind eye to the source of denials of anthropogenic change.
 
First off, what's the ratio scientists who believe we are in the midst of anthropogenic climate change to those who don't? I'd wager it to be close to 100:1.

Well you might by surprised at teh actual numbers, but then this is not a numbers game, data and facts are data and facts, if they are correct however many people cheering for the wrong side does not matter.

Secondly, there is no proof of falsifying data, only misinterpreted, out of context stolen emails. The only people who seem to believe those emails prove anything are people who don't seem to understand what the emails are about.

Ok so you have an e-mail that says in part change these values because we can not account for them in the theory, what does that actually say?



Thirdly, where is the proof that the body of work represented by the IPCC has been done to support a forgone conclusion. Take a look at the history of climate change thread up earlier today, these conclusions are backed by close to 100 years of work by literally thousands of scientists. As posted earlier, the data is there for everyone to see. Seems to me that you might be the one defending a position without the data to back it up.

The history that you speak of is a selection of theories that are taken ( as much as I hate to use the phrase here) out of context.

The fact is the bulk of the green house gasses put into the atmosphere by human activity has happened since 1945 . I can get the accredited figures if you like.

If the bulk and by bulk I mean in excess of 75% total volume been deposited since 1945 why has the temperature been going up since the late 1800? The tempurature increase has leveled off if not actually decreased since about 1980.

Now even a stupid old fart like me can make an assumption that if I the gasses that humans are putting into the atmosphere are causeing the tempurature to go up would it not make sense that the tempurature change would follow the gas that is causing it rather than occuring before it hit the atmosphere.

Just wondering
 
I just got this its worth a read


Surely there must have been serious men and women in the hard sciences who at some point worried that their colleagues in the global warming movement were putting at risk the credibility of everyone in science. The nature of that risk has been twofold: First, that the claims of the climate scientists might buckle beneath the weight of their breathtaking complexity. Second, that the crudeness of modern politics, once in motion, would trample the traditions and culture of science to achieve its own policy goals. With the scandal at the East Anglia Climate Research Unit, both have happened at once.

I don't think most scientists appreciate what has hit them. This isn't only about the credibility of global warming. For years, global warming and its advocates have been the public face of hard science. Most people could not name three other subjects they would associate with the work of serious scientists. This was it. The public was told repeatedly that something called "the scientific community" had affirmed the science beneath this inquiry. A Nobel Prize was bestowed (on a politician).


Daniel Henninger discusses how Climategate is undermining the objectivity of science.
.•Podcast .Global warming enlisted the collective reputation of science. Because "science" said so, all the world was about to undertake a vast reordering of human behavior at almost unimaginable financial cost. Not every day does the work of scientists lead to galactic events simply called Kyoto or Copenhagen. At least not since the Manhattan Project.

What is happening at East Anglia is an epochal event. As the hard sciences—physics, biology, chemistry, electrical engineering—came to dominate intellectual life in the last century, some academics in the humanities devised the theory of postmodernism, which liberated them from their colleagues in the sciences. Postmodernism, a self-consciously "unprovable" theory, replaced formal structures with subjectivity. With the revelations of East Anglia, this slippery and variable intellectual world has crossed into the hard sciences.


.This has harsh implications for the credibility of science generally. Hard science, alongside medicine, was one of the few things left accorded automatic stature and respect by most untrained lay persons. But the average person reading accounts of the East Anglia emails will conclude that hard science has become just another faction, as politicized and "messy" as, say, gender studies. The New England Journal of Medicine has turned into a weird weekly amalgam of straight medical-research and propaganda for the Obama redesign of U.S. medicine.

The East Anglians' mistreatment of scientists who challenged global warming's claims—plotting to shut them up and shut down their ability to publish—evokes the attempt to silence Galileo. The exchanges between Penn State's Michael Mann and East Anglia CRU director Phil Jones sound like Father Firenzuola, the Commissary-General of the Inquisition.

For three centuries Galileo has symbolized dissent in science. In our time, most scientists outside this circle have kept silent as their climatologist fellows, helped by the cardinals of the press, mocked and ostracized scientists who questioned this grand theory of global doom. Even a doubter as eminent as Princeton's Freeman Dyson was dismissed as an aging crank.

Beneath this dispute is a relatively new, very postmodern environmental idea known as "the precautionary principle." As defined by one official version: "When an activity raises threats of harm to the environment or human health, precautionary measures should be taken even if some cause and effect relationships are not fully established scientifically." The global-warming establishment says we know "enough" to impose new rules on the world's use of carbon fuels. The dissenters say this demotes science's traditional standards of evidence.



What would Galileo do?
.The Environmental Protection Agency's dramatic Endangerment Finding in April that greenhouse gas emissions qualify as an air pollutant—with implications for a vast new regulatory regime—used what the agency called a precautionary approach. The EPA admitted "varying degrees of uncertainty across many of these scientific issues." Again, this puts hard science in the new position of saying, close enough is good enough. One hopes civil engineers never build bridges under this theory.

The Obama administration's new head of policy at EPA, Lisa Heinzerling, is an advocate of turning precaution into standard policy. In a law-review article titled "Law and Economics for a Warming World," Ms. Heinzerling wrote, "Policy formation based on prediction and calculation of expected harm is no longer relevant; the only coherent response to a situation of chaotically worsening outcomes is a precautionary policy. . . ."

If the new ethos is that "close-enough" science is now sufficient to achieve political goals, serious scientists should be under no illusion that politicians will press-gang them into service for future agendas. Everyone working in science, no matter their politics, has an stake in cleaning up the mess revealed by the East Anglia emails. Science is on the credibility bubble. If it pops, centuries of what we understand to be the role of science go with it.
 
And This

In contemplating the purloined University of East Anglia emails (L. Gordon Crovitz's "The Web Discloses Inconvenient Climate Truths," Information Age, Nov. 30), an illuminating and contrasting backdrop is this description of scientific conduct, given in 1974 by that scientist's scientist, Nobel laureate physicist Richard P. Feynman: "There is one feature I notice that is generally missing in "cargo cult science." . . . It's a kind of scientific integrity, a principle of scientific thought that corresponds to a kind of utter honesty—a kind of leaning over backwards. For example, if you're doing an experiment, you should report everything that you think might make it invalid—not only what you think is right about it: other causes that could possibly explain your results; and things you thought of that you've eliminated by some other experiment, and how they worked . . . Details that could throw doubt on your interpretation must be given, if you know them. . . . If you make a theory, for example, and advertise it, or put it out, then you must also put down all the facts that disagree with it, as well as those that agree with it."
 
I just got this its worth a read

Followed by a long post by a moron. That blog mixes in talk of postmodernism in the social sciences with some controversy in the natural sciences without ever saying what one has to do with the other. Then there's some references to Galileo, which draw on the long-held image of Galileo the dissenter, without having the foggiest historical idea that Galileo was a serious player in the 'Noble Courts' of the early 1600's in Italy. Basically, it was Galileo's JOB to provide entertainment for wealthy merchants and aristocrats, and Galileo sought the title of 'Philosopher' because that title came with a hefty pay packet. Ironically, the blogger's equating of climate deniers with Galileo, both apparently dissenters who are persecuted, actually thus harms the case of the climate deniers.

Historically, Galileo dissented because it made him MONEY. This is a totally true historical fact. Moreover, Galileo's theory proving the motion of the earth is in fact scientifically WRONG (Galileo made observations of planets with a telescope, and formulated physical theories similar to today's inertia, but neither of these were his preferred theories for why the earth revolved around the sun). Galileo ran afoul of Cardinal Bellarmine (the blogger does not even know the relevant authorities, so why trust a moron blogger?) because Galileo's theory of the tides, meant to prove the earth's motion, literally failed to predict actual tides as readily observable. If climate deniers want to hitch their wagon to Galileo, go ahead, because they are hitching their fortunes to a dude who both got paid to dissent and who was wrong.
 
an illuminating and contrasting backdrop is this description of scientific conduct, given in 1974 by Nobel laureate physicist Richard P. Feynman: " . . . Details that could throw doubt on your interpretation must be given . . . you must also put down all the facts that disagree with it, as well as those that agree with it."

All good. The problem is that if you communicate openly and honestly with the public, then most in the public do not have the faintest idea how to evaluate uncertainties in science, and most hold a very distorted image of science in which everything is magically without any doubt at all. Basically, many in the public think of science as like religion, a field without significant dissent and in which no legitimate differences can exist. When differences are revealed, the public lacks a brain, and runs straight from "differences" to "no knowledge at all". Feynman was actually aiming this message at scientists. He was telling them to be honest with each other. He was saying scientists should argue amongst themselves.

But that's not what is happening in climate change. Every idiot who breathes air thinks they can evaluate scientific research. This is simply not true, and too many people are flattering themsleves. Here's quotes from Feynman and Galileo, which in each case suggest that the public should really learn to let scientists haggle something out rather than presume they can evaluate research. Remember, if you put this issue to a vote, the number of scientists claiming anthropogenic causes account for the increase in warming vastly outweigh those who dissent. I am not claiming that we should farm the issue out for referendum. I am saying we should listen to knowledgeable researchers. Those numbers mean something, and all you monday morning quarterbacks are stroking yourselves. I know you dissenters have no truck with me, but it doesn't concern me that I am not flattering you, because you flatter yourselves enough for any lifetime.

http://www.edwardtufte.com/bboard/q-and-a-fetch-msg?msg_id=0002gi
 
Last edited:
I'm having a tough time here with your arguments as well, landscaper.

Lines such as: "Ok so you have an e-mail that says in part change these values because we can not account for them in the theory, what does that actually say?"
That doesn't make any sense to me, I mean your quoted comment. I can't parse it.

I checked the link you posted.
Starts off with one falsehood "Now that ClimateGate has buried the fraudulent hockey stick for good," That's not been buried in the least. Maybe that one graph has been updated, but its still essentially in use in peer assessed work.

Then your linked report goes off on confusing local temperature changes (ie the european little ice age) with global temperature change. I mean I'm not a scientist, just a musician who is curious about things, and I can poke holes in this paper in seconds. Its crap. Copy and pasted charts, stats out of context and illogical conclusions. If the author of that paper posted it anywhere where that was allowed criticism, it wouldn't last a second, in other words, its wouldn't stand the peer assessment process.

Do you believe it only because its what you want to believe?
Just to bring it back to the original article that started this link.

Personally, considering the typos, bad logic, repeated talking points without the vaguest understanding and general lack of wit in your previous posts I'd have to say you must be an idiot.

There.

I've done it, I better go get the flame suit out.
Nolabel, can you pass me the fire extinguisher?
 
Starts off with one falsehood "Now that ClimateGate has buried the fraudulent hockey stick for good," That's not been buried in the least. Maybe that one graph has been updated, but its still essentially in use in peer assessed work.

http://www.financialpost.com/opinion/story.html?id=2056988
Check thje link it is an opinion piece but is from a very reputable source, the attributions are available as well.

Ok so you have an e-mail that says in part change these values because we can not account for them in the theory, what does that actually say

What I meant to say was how can any of the data being used be trusted?

The reason being the only results available for inspection are results that have been changed by the people who are telling us to trust the data. Without the original raw data for auditing there is no way to tell if the adjustments of the data are reasonable or not. Do not get me wrong here data is adjusted on virtually every experiment, usually because of precision issues with the measuring equipment or issues with the methodology. Neither of these things will invalidate a result provided they are within the limits of the experiments error range.

The problem with the data from CRU is we do not have any idea what the error range was or what the data started out as . That brings in a question of what exactly did they do? That question is something we really need an answer for because the whole basis of the theory rests on that. If the data was corrupted for what ever reason the whole thesis is invalid.

The proponants of climate change/ global warming shot themselves in the foot by making everything a BIG SECRET. If the data and the peer review was done properly this would not have happened and the issue would be well on its way to conclusion.

Then your linked report goes off on confusing local temperature changes (ie the european little ice age) with global temperature change. I mean I'm not a scientist, just a musician who is curious about things, and I can poke holes in this paper in seconds. Its crap. Copy and pasted charts, stats out of context and illogical conclusions. If the author of that paper posted it anywhere where that was allowed criticism, it wouldn't last a second, in other words, its wouldn't stand the peer assessment process.

Do you believe it only because its what you want to believe?
Just to bring it back to the original article that started this link.

I could ask you the sme thing, do you belive that climate change as a result of human activity is going on? Or do you believe the people who tell you that? There is a big difference in the two things.

As to thinking I am an idiot feel free , trust me you are not the first,
Cycle Guy has the tickets for the line and assuming that you don't get barred for saying so by the mods who am I to argue with your assesment
 
Followed by a long post by a moron. That blog mixes in talk of postmodernism in the social sciences with some controversy in the natural sciences without ever saying what one has to do with the other. Then there's some references to Galileo, which draw on the long-held image of Galileo the dissenter, without having the foggiest historical idea that Galileo was a serious player in the 'Noble Courts' of the early 1600's in Italy. Basically, it was Galileo's JOB to provide entertainment for wealthy merchants and aristocrats, and Galileo sought the title of 'Philosopher' because that title came with a hefty pay packet. Ironically, the blogger's equating of climate deniers with Galileo, both apparently dissenters who are persecuted, actually thus harms the case of the climate deniers.

Historically, Galileo dissented because it made him MONEY. This is a totally true historical fact. Moreover, Galileo's theory proving the motion of the earth is in fact scientifically WRONG (Galileo made observations of planets with a telescope, and formulated physical theories similar to today's inertia, but neither of these were his preferred theories for why the earth revolved around the sun). Galileo ran afoul of Cardinal Bellarmine (the blogger does not even know the relevant authorities, so why trust a moron blogger?) because Galileo's theory of the tides, meant to prove the earth's motion, literally failed to predict actual tides as readily observable. If climate deniers want to hitch their wagon to Galileo, go ahead, because they are hitching their fortunes to a dude who both got paid to dissent and who was wrong.

I see so gettting the Pope and the church to label him an heretic and place him under house arrest was a money making plot, ok.

Cardinal Bellarmine officiated over the first trial of Gallileo ordered him not to hold or maintain any teachings not in line with the church. The second trial was in Rome before a Papal heresy trial and he was ordered confined and publication of his work was ordered stopped. The confinement was changed to house arrest after the trial.

All that aside the point of the column was to point out that science has a responsibility to maintain its impartiality and to report what was found not what was wanted.

Gallileo was placed under house arrest for his beliefs the current crop of scientists would do well to take a look and think about what he did.

Some ethics would be a good about now.
 
Just noting the poll results:

- The number of people making claims for/against the question, based on a political/economic claim, outnumber those with opinions stemming from an assessment of the science, by two to one.

My cautionary word is not to confuse the two (pol/econ claims and scientific claims). That is, whatever your politics, do not confuse it with knowing the science.

Also, I note that, while alot of posters want to refer to isolated instances of questions about data, they do so in an imbalanced fashion. There's very little effort to interrogate the claims of the natural cycle crowd, but a magnifying glass is placed on the anthropogenic crowd. Just so it's clear, the more you place a magnifying glass on ANY scientific theory or set of data, the more you will confront the real nature of science: it is provisional, depends upon argumentative peer review to arrive at conclusions (truth is not self evident), relies on diverse arrays of funding, individual sets of researchers can make mistakes, theories are approximations, there are always anomalies to any theory, and so on. I note that too many find an instance of this reality, among the anthropogenic crowd, and think they have unearthed falsit or deception. That kind of reasoning just displays the sheer depth of your incomprehension of science. But as I noted, it also lacks abalance, because the same could be said for the Big Oil natural cycle folk, but you leave them along (mysteriously).
 
Just noting the poll results:

- The number of people making claims for/against the question, based on a political/economic claim, outnumber those with opinions stemming from an assessment of the science, by two to one.

My cautionary word is not to confuse the two (pol/econ claims and scientific claims). That is, whatever your politics, do not confuse it with knowing the science.

Also, I note that, while alot of posters want to refer to isolated instances of questions about data, they do so in an imbalanced fashion. There's very little effort to interrogate the claims of the natural cycle cloud, but a magnifying glass is placed on the anthropogenic crowd. Just so it's clear, the more you place a magnifying glass on ANY scientific theory or set of data, the more you will confront the real nature of science: it is provisional, depends upon argumentative peer review to arrive at conclusions (truth is not self evident), relies on diverse arrays of funding, individual sets of researchers can make mistakes, theories are approximations, there are always anomalies to any theory, and so on. I note that too many find an instance of this reality, among the anthropogenic crowd, and think they have unearthed falsit or deception. That kind of reasoning just displays the sheer depth of your incomprehension of science. But as I noted, it also lacks abalance, because the same could be said for the Big Oil natural cycle folk, but you leave them along (mysteriously).

The posts have not been about the Big oil natural cycle they have been about global warming.

When the next subject comes up I am sure we will discuss it to death as well