Denis Potvin or Larry Robinson

shack

Nitpicker Extraordinaire
Oct 2, 2001
53,838
11,780
113
Toronto
Wow. If it wasn't for Bobby Orr, these two were easily the best two defensemen of that era and though built totally differently, they both brought similar skill sets to their games. Potvin was build like a tank (like Tim Horton) and Robinson all arms and legs. gangly.

Both were tough, very strong, leaders, nasty when needed, durable, skated well, not afraid to mix it up could rush the puck and were effective offensively. Both were the epitome of all-round defensemen.

People didn't mess with them. I loved the way Robinson dismantled a few of the Flyers in the playoffs who tried gooning it up. They didn't do much bullying after he got through with them.

I don't think I can find it, but I recall that Potvin had a streak that started as soon as he started playing and lasted more than a few years where he was on the ice for every single power play goal that the Islanders scored. Potvin put up much better offensive numbers than Bird, but then he didn't have to share time with Savard and Lapointe. I'd probably give the defensive advantage to Robinson, especially with that reach of his.

Seriously, to me it is an absolute tie. If I was forced to pick one, maybe because of character, I'd give the smallest edge to Robinson. Potvin was not always well-liked by his teammates and I think the small town western boy Robinson was just a genuine stand up guy. Aside from that, man, both those guys were all-time greats and played at the same time in what may have been the greatest era of hockey.
 
Ian Turnbull legend 5 goal game.
 
Biiiiiigggg Roooooobinsonnnnn....(the voice of Danny Gallivan dancing in my brain)
 
I would put Serge Savard ahead of Potvin and Robinson.

He didn't have the offensive numbers as those 2 because early in his career he had broken his legs, he decided to be more of a stay at home D-man.

He was a superb skater , he could go end to end with ease occasionally doing the spinarama like Orr did.

He was big , strong and tough: he man handled Dave Schultz:


He should have won at least one Norris IMO.

I would also put Salming ahead of Potvin and Robinson

Potvin was a big suck, he was very jealous of Orr when Orr won MVP of the 76 Canada Cup, he felt that he should have won it.
 
I would put Serge Savard ahead of Potvin and Robinson.

He didn't have the offensive numbers as those 2 because early in his career he had a back injury, he decided to be more of a stay at home D-man.

He was a superb skater , he could go end to end with ease occasionally doing the spinarama like Orr did.

He was big , strong and tough: he man handled Dave Schultz:


He should have won at least one Norris IMO.

I would also put Salming ahead of Potvin and Robinson

Potvin was a big suck, he was very jealous of Orr when Orr won MVP of the 76 Canada Cup, he felt that he should have won it.

No, he broke his leg twice, on the stationary goal posts, before the magnets were used. That stifled his mobility. Prior to that, he was a very fast rushing defenceman, the rival of Bobby Orr in the 1969 playoffs. One good thing about those stationary posts, the forwards did not rush the net and take liberties with the goalie.
 
No, he broke his leg twice, on the stationary goal posts, before the magnets were used. That stifled his mobility. Prior to that, he was a very fast rushing defenceman, the rival of Bobby Orr in the 1969 playoffs. One good thing about those stationary posts, the forwards did not rush the net and take liberties with the goalie.

Thanks
 
I'd take Potvin because of the offense. I think on defense they were pretty well equal. Big Bird had other great defense men on his team. Potvin was always out there against the other teams best
 
I'd take Potvin because of the offense. I think on defense they were pretty well equal. Big Bird had other great defense men on his team. Potvin was always out there against the other teams best

That's a tough one, but i think i would give the nod to Potvin also for the same reasons. As fundamentally sound a player as I've ever seen.
 
Seriously, to me it is an absolute tie. If I was forced to pick one, maybe because of character, I'd give the smallest edge to Robinson. Potvin was not always well-liked by his teammates and I think the small town western boy Robinson was just a genuine stand up guy. Aside from that, man, both those guys were all-time greats and played at the same time in what may have been the greatest era of hockey.

Robinson is from Winchester Ontario Eddie not far from Ottawa and also not to far from Hull where Potvin is from.

I saw Potvin play in junior with the 67's as a 15 year old so followed his career closely. As a #1 pick he was under the microscope not only through most of his junior career but coming into the NHL. And he never missed a beat. He's really the quintessential all around rear guard.

Robinson was a second round draft who played 1.5 tears in the AHL before making the Habs. So a little less pressure on him coming up. But once he did he was a juggernaut. His plus/minus stats are off the charts. He had a rating of plus 120 in 76/77. I mean that's just incredible.

I will give the slight nod to Robinson here just because I think his shut down ability was a tad better than Potvin but this comparison is about as close as it gets. Salming, Park, Lidstrom are excellent defenders but not in the same conversation.
 
This is a thread about Larry Robinson. Why are members throwing in names like Orr, Turnbull, Savard, Salming, Park, Lidstrom, etc.? I saw "Big Bird" played in real life and real time at the Forum in Westmount before the Canadiens moved to the Bell Centre. I have to give the edge to Robinson. (Savard is also on the list of the top 100.)

Wayne Gretzky
Bobby Orr
Gordie Howe
Mario Lemieux[10]
Maurice Richard
Doug Harvey
Jean Beliveau
Bobby Hull
Terry Sawchuk[11]
Eddie Shore
Guy Lafleur
Mark Messier
Jacques Plante
Ray Bourque
Howie Morenz
Glenn Hall
Stan Mikita[12] Slovakia
Phil Esposito
Denis Potvin
Mike Bossy
Ted Lindsay
Patrick Roy
Red Kelly
Bobby Clarke
Larry Robinson
Ken Dryden
 
This is a thread about Larry Robinson. Why are members throwing in names like Orr, Turnbull, Savard, Salming, Park, Lidstrom, etc.? I saw "Big Bird" played in real life and real time at the Forum in Westmount before the Canadiens moved to the Bell Centre. I have to give the edge to Robinson. (Savard is also on the list of the top 100.)

This is a thread about Larry Robinson AND Dennis Potvin.
I don't get the list, especially non D.
 
Originally Posted by The Oracle
Robinson is from Winchester Ontario Eddie not far from Ottawa .

I thought that he was a Saskatchewan guy. Even more impressive that an Ontario guy could be so solid.

As The Oracle pointed out "The Big Bird" is from the Ottawa Valley. I am pretty sure that Robinson grew up on a farm outside of Winchester - with that background and his raw boned toughness - I could see why you thought he was a Saskatchewan guy.

As far as choosing between the two while I think Potvin probably had more natural talent and athleticism I would pick Robinson as I believe he was more of a character guy and was obviously no slouch both offensively, defensively and in the physical aspects of the game (also as a Habs fan I am biased)
 
LOL. Join the crowd of people who do not understand what goes on in the world of Darts' unique mind.

Indeed.

Didn't attempted hijackings go out of style in the 1970's?
 
This is a thread about Larry Robinson AND Dennis Potvin.
I don't get the list, especially non D.

I was curious to see where Potvin and Robinson ranked on the list of the NHL's top 100 players. So, I extracted only that part of the list that included Potvin and Robinson and highlighted only those two. It was simpler to just leave those other names rather than edit them out. Maybe, or maybe not, there are other lists that rank Robinson higher than Potvin.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hockey_News#All-time_NHL_player_rankings

Robinson’s career plus/minus rating of plus-730 ranks as the best ever recorded. Robinson posted a miraculous plus/minus rating of plus-120 in 1976-77, which is second only to Bobby Orr’s plus-124 in 1970-71.

Robinson earned a career 958 points (208 goals, 750 assists) ranking him ninth all-time amongst NHL defensemen.

At 6’4” and 225 pounds, Robinson was huge for his era. Not known as a fighter per say, Robinson had no trouble dropping the gloves when needed, as witnessed by his battle with legendary tough guy Dave “The Hammer” Schultz in which Robinson got the better of Schultz who was one of the best fighters in NHL history.

Like many of the great players, Robinson could do it all— skate, pass, score, hit and fight— and he exhibited great leadership which helped earn him six Stanley Cup Championships.

https://thehockeywriters.com/best-nhl-defensemen-ever/
 
At 6’4” and 225 pounds, Robinson was huge for his era. Not known as a fighter per say, Robinson had no trouble dropping the gloves when needed, as witnessed by his battle with legendary tough guy Dave “The Hammer” Schultz in which Robinson got the better of Schultz who was one of the best fighters in NHL history.
A Sunday afternoon game, I remember watching it with my dad.
My dad hated fighting and goonery but he was on the edge of his seat when Robinson gave Schultz the beats.
Robinson was gangly but he was strong as hell.
 
No, he broke his leg twice, on the stationary goal posts, before the magnets were used. That stifled his mobility. Prior to that, he was a very fast rushing defenceman, the rival of Bobby Orr in the 1969 playoffs. One good thing about those stationary posts, the forwards did not rush the net and take liberties with the goalie.

Holy smokes, I didn't know he had that in him.
Very impressive.