Wow. If it wasn't for Bobby Orr, these two were easily the best two defensemen of that era and though built totally differently, they both brought similar skill sets to their games. Potvin was build like a tank (like Tim Horton) and Robinson all arms and legs. gangly.
Both were tough, very strong, leaders, nasty when needed, durable, skated well, not afraid to mix it up could rush the puck and were effective offensively. Both were the epitome of all-round defensemen.
People didn't mess with them. I loved the way Robinson dismantled a few of the Flyers in the playoffs who tried gooning it up. They didn't do much bullying after he got through with them.
I don't think I can find it, but I recall that Potvin had a streak that started as soon as he started playing and lasted more than a few years where he was on the ice for every single power play goal that the Islanders scored. Potvin put up much better offensive numbers than Bird, but then he didn't have to share time with Savard and Lapointe. I'd probably give the defensive advantage to Robinson, especially with that reach of his.
Seriously, to me it is an absolute tie. If I was forced to pick one, maybe because of character, I'd give the smallest edge to Robinson. Potvin was not always well-liked by his teammates and I think the small town western boy Robinson was just a genuine stand up guy. Aside from that, man, both those guys were all-time greats and played at the same time in what may have been the greatest era of hockey.
Both were tough, very strong, leaders, nasty when needed, durable, skated well, not afraid to mix it up could rush the puck and were effective offensively. Both were the epitome of all-round defensemen.
People didn't mess with them. I loved the way Robinson dismantled a few of the Flyers in the playoffs who tried gooning it up. They didn't do much bullying after he got through with them.
I don't think I can find it, but I recall that Potvin had a streak that started as soon as he started playing and lasted more than a few years where he was on the ice for every single power play goal that the Islanders scored. Potvin put up much better offensive numbers than Bird, but then he didn't have to share time with Savard and Lapointe. I'd probably give the defensive advantage to Robinson, especially with that reach of his.
Seriously, to me it is an absolute tie. If I was forced to pick one, maybe because of character, I'd give the smallest edge to Robinson. Potvin was not always well-liked by his teammates and I think the small town western boy Robinson was just a genuine stand up guy. Aside from that, man, both those guys were all-time greats and played at the same time in what may have been the greatest era of hockey.

