Deadbeat dad in Ontario? Genius solution devised....

There's a simple way to prevent deadbeat dads.

Women need to stop fucking deadbeats.
 
Child support is really alimony.. lets face it.. it is often grossly in exess of what is really required for care of a child. Especially if you happen to be a high income earner.

Yeah, I never understood when male celebrities are sentenced to pay child support of something insane like $50k/mth. There's single moms out there trying to do on $40k/yr. There should be a maximum yearly amount that a judge can sentence.
 
The family support system needs to be merged with the income tax system. The support requests need to become realistic. The system minimizes earning potential, reducing the funds available to support the kids. The system is rife with inequalities, and actively discourages men from becoming responsible fathers.

Examples:
- Each kid should be treated equally. The kids I am living with should not get worse treatment than kids living with an ex.
- Spouses should be encouraged to work and to provide for the family. As a parent, your best option is to spend all day at home with your kids, and the legal system encourages this.
- Fathers should be encouraged to look after kids. As the system currently is, if you meet a mother with kids, you may undertake long-standing financial obligations, even if the mother leaves you. This discourages willing fathers from looking after kids, and minimizes the average mother's family income.
- The father has minimal ability to do proper financial planning, this includes planning for both his retirement and for his kids university education.
- Legally fathers are assumed to have a constant income supply, and invulnerable to future expensive illnesses. Even the FRO realizes how incredibly unrealistic this is, and limits maximum deductions to 50% of income. The courts don't. The result is bad debts.
- Bad debts. Family law is one of the few bad debts that you cannot discharge in bankruptcy. You are bankrupt. WTF???
- If you are a father, and have a new business, it is way better for it to be in the underground economy. I vividly remember calculating that between my wife's requests for alimony and income tax payments, alimony+tax could be 110% of my income. Child support would be on top of that. Even the FRO will not enforce any payroll deduction in excess of 50% of the take home income. Keep in mind that just because your spouse wants money, and your kids need money, it does not mean that any other legal organization including the CRA and IRS recognize their interpretations.
- The system has no ability to cope with changing international regulations and income tax.
- Why are support payments based on income and not a fixed amount for needs?

If we ran the income tax system the way we ran the child support system, very few people would pay income tax. The court does not become involved in 99% of people's income tax decisions. Why does the child support need to go to court? For income tax, if your income changes, your tax changes. For child support, if your income changes, you go to court. What part of this makes sense?

The income tax system was designed to maximize aggregate revenue for the government while minimizing expenses. We should adopt similar approaches with the child-support system. The system is supposed to be about maximising support for the kids. Why don't we focus on an economic system to designed to maximize support for the kids?
 
I too have lived this scenario.Love my kids and was fortunate to have them 2 of 4 weeks a month.I split all camps,sports etc and still paid her support.When my income took a major dive my lawyer told me if I fell behind I would have to start cashing rrsp's or get a second job...I missed a couple months and after 10 years of paying directly started my FRO nightmare.I'll spare the details but it is nothing short of a miracle I survived my current relationship and still kept the kids in the activities they were involved.They are now in their 20's ,well adjusted and I have great relationships with them.As for my ex ,she made more money for 14 of the 16 years I paid ,holidays 2-3 times a year and finally married the goof I caught her fucking so many years ago.My father was a deadbeat dad in the 60's and 70's and every time a freind asks me how I thought my situation was justified I reply "My dad and guys like him ,are responsible for the one sided situations that are so prevalent today"Just my two cents
As someone who has lived through (almost) precisely what JohnLarue discribes, I can tell you it's not based on fantasy. I fully agree with the need for child support, and certainly agree that there should be penalties, severe penalties, for those who don't pay. But, things are very much in the mother's favor these days.

For decades, fathers could just walk away from a marriage, paying all but nothing to help raise the kids. As often as not, they also walked out on the kids, leaving the mother doing the bulk of the child rearing, and earning money to support the children. Because of the magnitude of this problem, the courts pulled up their socks, and legislated more appropriate support requirements, so that mothers and children were no longer getting screwed by poor fathers. But, in the effort to "fix" the problem, they've gone too far.

Now, fathers are more involved with their kids than ever, and many of those of us who are divorced are very heavily involved in our childrens lives. We get them for 1/2 of the time, yet are required to pay large sums to the mother, with little to no no accountability on how she spends the money. I agree that the kids/mother should receive support to pay for food, home, clothes, etc.. but the amounts need to be realistic. There's absolutely no reason that I should have to live in a 2br apartment, have 2nd hand furniture, shop at discount stores, and drive a beat-up car, simply because our relationship didn't work and it is best for everyone that the marriage end.

In my case, she's rewarded with an extra $1500/mo child support for the next 15 years, which is almost 1/2 of my montly income.. makes it a bit hard to swallow when she goes on trips, has a new vehicle, a large house, and new clothes, while the kids come over and are wearing socks with holes and ripped jeans.
 
When my income took a major dive my lawyer told me if I fell behind I would have to start cashing rrsp's or get a second job...I missed a couple months and after 10 years of paying directly started my FRO nightmare.I'll spare the details but it is nothing short of a miracle I survived my current relationship and still kept the kids in the activities they were involved.

The system makes no allowance for drops in income. Statistically, it will happen to almost everyone.
 
No. It is not grossly in excess of what is required for the care of a child. The figures are taken from a chart which is published by the government and is based on several months of research by a team of economists and social workers as to how much it genuinely takes to support a child.

Honestly, where do you get your information from?

Perhaps from actual experience with the system? My son's mother deliberately* gets pregnant by different guys (five kids, five fathers) because that way she gets more money. She's got $3500 a month coming in per month in child support and since it doesn't count as income she pays no tax on it. Great job if you can get it.

*when I say deliberately I mean she puts a hole in the condom so it will break. Did the same thing to all of us
 
[Rant on]

By the time you get to court and get a judge to decide anything it can be six months, a year, or more. In the mean time they take your driver's license and your car. Yeah, that's fair.

Or the judge just decides that you're making more than you do. No evidence required but you better start paying or else.

Or the judge decides that you can work when a team of doctors say you can't. Doesn't matter pay up or else.

Haven't seen you kids in two years because your ex doesn't let them. Well too bad, better put aside a couple of hundred thousand if you want to ever see them again.

Anyone with any serious experience of our family law courts knows it's that bad and worse.

As for the men's rights movement being "90%rhetoric" pardon me but, WTF are you talking about? The system is so biased in favour of women that it's a joke. Any family law lawyer will tell you about it. A mother could do things to a child that would put a father in jail and nothing happens. Physical abuse, drug use, it just doesn't matter.

That is the reality of our family law courts. At it's the children who suffer.

So we have an FRO for father's who don't pay. Where is the equivalent for mother's who prevent their children from seeing their father? When are the courts going to start taking seriously the damage done to children by mother's who alienate their children from their fathers? Where are the automatic fines, license suspensions and other penalties?

[Rant off]

Yeah, I am pissed off with our system. It really is biased in favour of the mothers. But the reality is in being that way it is biased against the well being of the children.


People who haven't been through it really don't know how bad it is.
 
I hate to say it, but I regard divorced parents as TRASH. Maybe one person is not to blame for the split up, but even then it was THEY that made a bad choice of partner to have kids with. And it's a fair bet both sides showed selfishness and inability to PUT THEIR CHILDREN FIRST.

The result is the kids grow up in a fragmented family, and are more likely to repeat the cycle in the next generation.

I have zero respect for any Dad (or Mom) who does not place the interest of their Kids first and foremost.

Agreed.
 
this is probably too much for me to respond to time-wise, but I will try and counter some of the points. First, most Family court judges try very hard to be fair to guys and to be realistic in assessing what a guy should or could be earning. That means reading carefully through the guy's medical reports and seeing if they are realistic. The number of guys who suddenly develop "back pains" the day after they leave their wife and kids is pretty notorious.

No reputable family law lawyer will agree that the system is biased against men.

If a woman uses physical abuse against her kids or uses drugs in front of them, I can GUARANTEE that the Children's Aid will be on her right away and she runs a good chance of losing those kids.

Re women who block dads from having access, all judges and lawyers know this goes on and try to prevent it. Once in a while, such a mom is plunked in jail. It takes a LOT for a judge to do that and the mom is given a number of lesses sanctions and second chances before she gets hit hard. Usually as well, a guy who doesn't pay is given a number of second chances before being jailed.

The courts take parental alienation very seriously, but it is a more complicated problem than whether a guy does or doesn't pay a child support order and takes longer to investigate and resolve.

There are a lot of "men's rights" myths, but they are not borne out by the reality of the court system.
 
The system makes no allowance for drops in income. Statistically, it will happen to almost everyone.

Of course, it does. A support payor can move to vary child support whenever his income drops.
 
Perhaps from actual experience with the system? My son's mother deliberately* gets pregnant by different guys (five kids, five fathers) because that way she gets more money. She's got $3500 a month coming in per month in child support and since it doesn't count as income she pays no tax on it. Great job if you can get it.

*when I say deliberately I mean she puts a hole in the condom so it will break. Did the same thing to all of us

congratulations to your ex. Mathematically, she will make more by having 5 different dads pay child support for 5 kids, than having 1 dad pay child support for 5 kids. But she's a pretty extreme case. Child support law is pretty simplistic because a legislative decision was taken to make it so and avoid protracted litigation over a more complex child support calculation system. Your ex found one of the little loop holes, but how many women are going to have 5 different kids by 5 different dads?
 
Of course, it does. A support payor can move to vary child support whenever his income drops.

In theory, it does. As such, when the recession hit, my divorce lawyers practice was backlogged with support variation requests. However, it takes a long while for those requests to clear. You can also be held liable for underpayment when times where good.

However, if you have truly uneven income, you can't go to court everytime your circumstances change. There is no equivalent to the income tax system where income is based on income. In fact, family court does not recognize the CRA's definition of income as income.

The system is a bureaucratic nightmare.
 
I guarantee that you have spent zero time in any Family court. I also guarantee you that oagre has likely represented as many dads as he has mothers and he still has formed the opinions he has, which I share whole heartedly, based not on what "more than a few" have told me, but based on five years of practice. The scenario you have described above is nothing more than a fantasy that emerges from the bitterness that fuels the "men's rights" movement.

I guarantee you do not know what you are talking about
As I described it, this is the scenario that several people I know are currently in

I know both the Moms and the Dads and I was objective when weighing the facts
(The interest of the Kids is first and for most)

So much for your "fantasy"

Are you sure extensive practice (5 years -so you have seen it all ?????) as a shyster does not cloud your objectivity here?

You have every right to disagree with my opinion, however there are much better ways of delivery than stating what I describe is a fantasy.
Please explain how it you are so 100% sure that such an abuse its not possible, given an extremely high divorce rate and the infallibilities of a government run system

"OH yes, it could never happen"
Because you say it can't ????

Well I am telling you it does happen
 
i hear what oagre says but I thinks it better to have the guy out of jail and in his car and working than the taking away his car and putting him in jail for what is really a civil dispute.

Again, strict penalties on deadbeat dads not only force deadbeats to cough up funds, but also deter guys from fathering kids they have no intention to support. Spend some time talking to single mothers in countries that have no legal apparatus to force support payment and hear about their life experiences.

It is just fucking incredible what some guys will do if they can get away with it with impunity.
 
Impounding a deadbeat parents car to encourage them to go to work to pay their support is like freezing their bank account and ordering them to write a cheque.
Lets face it, the support system and FRO are corrupt. How else could one organization turn 600,000 Ontario men into criminals who have never committed another crime elsewhere?
Just another lame duck system that attacks the impoverished. Tries to rip the golden goose open to get all the eggs at once. The real deadbeats are not the men too poor to live in a courtroom, hire representation they cannot afford or pay 100% of their unemployment benefits to satisfy a court ordered solution while they destabalize their lives. The real deadbeats are the parents who pay no attention to the physical, emotional, and spiritual needs of their children. There are kids with intact families, nice houses, every toy and gadget they could ever want, and their parents are still deadbeats.
 
So much for your "fantasy"

Are you sure extensive practice (5 years -so you have seen it all ?????) as a shyster does not cloud your objectivity here?

Well I am telling you it does happen

An endearing comment. Actually, my shyster-ism covers over 2 decades and every other family court lawyer - oops, I mean "shyster" - would echo my position. But we're all shysters and you clearly know more than we do.
 
I guarantee that you have spent zero time in any Family court. I also guarantee you that oagre has likely represented as many dads as he has mothers and he still has formed the opinions he has, which I share whole heartedly, based not on what "more than a few" have told me, but based on five years of practice. The scenario you have described above is nothing more than a fantasy that emerges from the bitterness that fuels the "men's rights" movement.

Ya, that makes lots of sense; you are surely correct. Thanks for coming out, oagre's duplicate handle.
 
I agree with OAGRE!!!

Although the courts should somehow change how value is exchanged.......In other words...40% of payments could come via purchases...ie: Hockey sticks, winter coats, jeans, enrollment fees in activities. The other 60% cash.

That way a Father actually gets to spend cash with and on his kid..in his presence. Otherwise a FAther often pays all cash.....And then pays tons more to be seen to spend on child.....trips, entertainment etc!! I agree the chart exists...but what it does not take into account is the fact Dad hands over his share ..ALL HIS SHARE..in cash...but then spends more on his child for other things. I know he shoudl do it...but this spending should be part of the TOTAL..and all verifiable....

AS FOR SEIZING THE CAR.......I suspect the time will come...rightly...when the car is sold (Its an asset) and proceeds go to Mom to catch up on arrears!!
 
Great! If I lose my job and cant pay they take my car so that means I con`t go look for work no less get to work. Dose anyone else think that this double talking, totally detatched from reality weasel of a premier has worn out is welcome
 
Great! If I lose my job and cant pay they take my car so that means I con`t go look for work no less get to work. Dose anyone else think that this double talking, totally detatched from reality weasel of a premier has worn out is welcome

do you guys ever READ my posts about the legal system? Even if they interfere with your good times ranting about politics?

Have a good thread, fellows. I've done my duty and shall depart.