Child support is really alimony.. lets face it.. it is often grossly in exess of what is really required for care of a child. Especially if you happen to be a high income earner.
As someone who has lived through (almost) precisely what JohnLarue discribes, I can tell you it's not based on fantasy. I fully agree with the need for child support, and certainly agree that there should be penalties, severe penalties, for those who don't pay. But, things are very much in the mother's favor these days.
For decades, fathers could just walk away from a marriage, paying all but nothing to help raise the kids. As often as not, they also walked out on the kids, leaving the mother doing the bulk of the child rearing, and earning money to support the children. Because of the magnitude of this problem, the courts pulled up their socks, and legislated more appropriate support requirements, so that mothers and children were no longer getting screwed by poor fathers. But, in the effort to "fix" the problem, they've gone too far.
Now, fathers are more involved with their kids than ever, and many of those of us who are divorced are very heavily involved in our childrens lives. We get them for 1/2 of the time, yet are required to pay large sums to the mother, with little to no no accountability on how she spends the money. I agree that the kids/mother should receive support to pay for food, home, clothes, etc.. but the amounts need to be realistic. There's absolutely no reason that I should have to live in a 2br apartment, have 2nd hand furniture, shop at discount stores, and drive a beat-up car, simply because our relationship didn't work and it is best for everyone that the marriage end.
In my case, she's rewarded with an extra $1500/mo child support for the next 15 years, which is almost 1/2 of my montly income.. makes it a bit hard to swallow when she goes on trips, has a new vehicle, a large house, and new clothes, while the kids come over and are wearing socks with holes and ripped jeans.
When my income took a major dive my lawyer told me if I fell behind I would have to start cashing rrsp's or get a second job...I missed a couple months and after 10 years of paying directly started my FRO nightmare.I'll spare the details but it is nothing short of a miracle I survived my current relationship and still kept the kids in the activities they were involved.
No. It is not grossly in excess of what is required for the care of a child. The figures are taken from a chart which is published by the government and is based on several months of research by a team of economists and social workers as to how much it genuinely takes to support a child.
Honestly, where do you get your information from?
I have zero respect for any Dad (or Mom) who does not place the interest of their Kids first and foremost.
The system makes no allowance for drops in income. Statistically, it will happen to almost everyone.
Perhaps from actual experience with the system? My son's mother deliberately* gets pregnant by different guys (five kids, five fathers) because that way she gets more money. She's got $3500 a month coming in per month in child support and since it doesn't count as income she pays no tax on it. Great job if you can get it.
*when I say deliberately I mean she puts a hole in the condom so it will break. Did the same thing to all of us
Of course, it does. A support payor can move to vary child support whenever his income drops.
I guarantee that you have spent zero time in any Family court. I also guarantee you that oagre has likely represented as many dads as he has mothers and he still has formed the opinions he has, which I share whole heartedly, based not on what "more than a few" have told me, but based on five years of practice. The scenario you have described above is nothing more than a fantasy that emerges from the bitterness that fuels the "men's rights" movement.
i hear what oagre says but I thinks it better to have the guy out of jail and in his car and working than the taking away his car and putting him in jail for what is really a civil dispute.
So much for your "fantasy"
Are you sure extensive practice (5 years -so you have seen it all ?????) as a shyster does not cloud your objectivity here?
Well I am telling you it does happen
I guarantee that you have spent zero time in any Family court. I also guarantee you that oagre has likely represented as many dads as he has mothers and he still has formed the opinions he has, which I share whole heartedly, based not on what "more than a few" have told me, but based on five years of practice. The scenario you have described above is nothing more than a fantasy that emerges from the bitterness that fuels the "men's rights" movement.
Great! If I lose my job and cant pay they take my car so that means I con`t go look for work no less get to work. Dose anyone else think that this double talking, totally detatched from reality weasel of a premier has worn out is welcome