David Miller and the Propane Explosion

Maybe Detroit and Toronto could swap mayors :p
 
tboy said:
Hey it's corey's fault, I suggest we find him and linch him!!! LOL I can't believe you actually admitted voting for this fool......

Sheik is right: people got what they wanted by voting for this tool.....


If you want to lynch me, you can find me at 100 Queen St. West on the second floor.

I'm the tall blond guy with a bunch of hangers on kissing my ass. :D
 
james t kirk said:
I think Miller would be VERY vulnerable to attacks on his ability as a leader (since he is a very poor leader and this propane explosion has clearly demonstrated how completely bankrupt he is in that regard.)

Next election, if there is a serious candidate running against Miller, he needs to target Miller's lack of character and lack of leadership and he could be successful. In short, make this a very personal election instead of sticking to the issues. Miller is vulnerable when it comes to his character.

All stupid policies that Miller has aside, at the end of the day, he's a whimp and a very poor leader and I think that is the angle to come at him from to which he won't be able to either respond, or recover.


You can go after Miller on everything from character, leadership, competence and to the issues.
 
From what i have read the propane facility was built in 2005, at that point the zoneing bylaws said they could put the plant there. In a real world scenario the zoning people would have said no you can not build it there in spite of the bylaws find somewhere else and if you disagree we will see you in court.

The public backlash from the people living in the area would have stopped the plant , or at the very least the provincial government could have used the not withstand clause in the constitution to overule the courts.

With the speed of the justice system here that plant still would not be built.
 
james t kirk said:
Next election, if there is a serious candidate running against Miller, he needs to target Miller's lack of character and lack of leadership and he could be successful. In short, make this a very personal election instead of sticking to the issues. Miller is vulnerable when it comes to his character.

That is just a recipe for electing another incompetent. You have to address the issues.
 
landscaper said:
From what i have read the propane facility was built in 2005, at that point the zoneing bylaws said they could put the plant there. In a real world scenario the zoning people would have said no you can not build it there in spite of the bylaws find somewhere else and if you disagree we will see you in court.

The public backlash from the people living in the area would have stopped the plant , or at the very least the provincial government could have used the not withstand clause in the constitution to overule the courts.

With the speed of the justice system here that plant still would not be built.

What world do you live in?

The site's zoning allowed it to be there. Zoning people at city hall are not in the position - nor should they be - to deny an application based on the type of facility. Is propane any more dangerous than a gas station? I think there is an equal chance of a major explosion at any gas station given the right circumstances.

The owner would have applied to move to this location. The application would be reviewed by city staff and when approved, the application would go to council in a more or less rubber stamp. Because the site was zoned properly, there would have not been any posted sign on the site about what is going there - you see those signs all the time listing a zoning change. Unless the general public was at council meetings, they probably would not have known the plans. By the time the shovels hit the ground, the public would then find out what is goin on and it is too late. The application has been approved and things are progressing.

As mentioned in the press and here, the Provincial Government regulates the industry. Anyone who is familiar with municipal/provincial politics knows that they do not overlap authourity. If the city zoned the property, they can move there and then the province inspects and regulates it after they move in.

If you really think that the province would use the Not Withstanding Clause for this you are dreaming in technicolor.

As much as I detest the Toronto Star, they had an interesting article about how many propane sites are in the GTA. Each of which has their own potential for disaster.
 
the city can in fact deny a building permit for any number of reasons correct zoning simply lets what ever use be used there.

If the city was determined to ensure the safety of the citizens it would indeed have denied the permits to build that facility there.

As for gas stations gasoline is a much more stable product when stored properly. A catstrophic failure such as we have seen here is very unlikely Hollywood to the contrary.
 
landscaper said:
... or at the very least the provincial government could have used the not withstand clause in the constitution to overule the courts.

A person could make the greatest argument in the world but when they end with a preposterous comment like this, it all goes flushing down the toilet. :p

The notwithstanding clause has been used, what, once? By Quebec over their language laws.
 
I can't say that I"m in the know on all the nuances of getting zoning changes or permit approvals but I have since discovered this:
1) If the city denies a zoning change for whatever reason, the builder/developer can then go to the OMD and since they don't give a rat's ass what goes on in the city, they will approve it. I seem to recall someone telling me recently that they have only denied 5 zoning changes in the last 5 yrs or something like that?
2) The can deny a building permit but unless they have legal grounds all it would take is a court order to abide by the city by-laws (if the site was actually zoned for propane storage/distribution whatever category that falls under).

You may think the city is all powerful to stop what they don't want here but they really aren't. They can delay, attempt to modify, but unless they have a legal leg to stand on, they are powerless. (even if they change the zoning after the company is set up and running the company would be exempt from the re-zoning under the "grandfather" clause).

As for the idiots who "didn't know how dangerous" it was....They ought to be smacked upside the head. To live next to a tank that is holding the equivolent of 10000 lbs of TNT and say "I didn't know it was dangerous" is no different than saying "I didn't know murder was against the law....".

Rexdale is a good example. Like Downsview, it used to be a major industrial area and was probably zoned as such. The "re-zoning" was probably applied for by developers and had the area changed to residential.

THis is another example of how home purchasers have to wake up and know what they're getting into before signing the paper......(this kind of reminds me of people who live by the airport and when they put in a new runway, they whined like crazy but if they had done some research they'd have known the airport had the right to put it in).
 
chiller_boy said:
I don't remember the great accomplishments of Mel Lastman. .

Sheppard Subway.

They were going to build 4 lines.

Then the gov't cut the funding and they were going to build 0 lines.

Only Mel stepped up to the plate and did what it took to build the first leg of that line. (Sure, it's not that well used, but someday, it will be - bank on that.)

He also was behind North York's transformation.

Miller's been in power for 5 years and has built sweet fuck all. His lasting legacy will be "getting to the root causes" of everything and cacelling the building of one bridge to the Island but paying for it anyway.
 
Larry_Fyne said:
What world do you live in?

The site's zoning allowed it to be there. Zoning people at city hall are not in the position - nor should they be - to deny an application based on the type of facility. Is propane any more dangerous than a gas station? I think there is an equal chance of a major explosion at any gas station given the right circumstances.

The owner would have applied to move to this location. The application would be reviewed by city staff and when approved, the application would go to council in a more or less rubber stamp. Because the site was zoned properly, there would have not been any posted sign on the site about what is going there - you see those signs all the time listing a zoning change. Unless the general public was at council meetings, they probably would not have known the plans. By the time the shovels hit the ground, the public would then find out what is goin on and it is too late. The application has been approved and things are progressing.

As mentioned in the press and here, the Provincial Government regulates the industry. Anyone who is familiar with municipal/provincial politics knows that they do not overlap authourity. If the city zoned the property, they can move there and then the province inspects and regulates it after they move in.

If you really think that the province would use the Not Withstanding Clause for this you are dreaming in technicolor.

As much as I detest the Toronto Star, they had an interesting article about how many propane sites are in the GTA. Each of which has their own potential for disaster.

The Province regulates the operation of a propane facility, however, the City regulates the zoning.

The construction of the facility should have gone through an environmental assessment at the very least at which time I am sure that the public would have had a chance to voice their opinions.

From what I saw on the news the other night, the local residents were very much opposed to this facility and yet it was still built because the local politicians ignored them.

I remember in my area (Ward 13 - Parkdale High Park) there was a LOT of opposition to a new condo development. The local residents all came out in force to oppose the oversized and out of character condo development. Our useless councillor - Saundercook basically did his usual disappearing trick. The entire issue came before council at which time Saundercook stuck his political finger into the political breeze and voted against it, HOWEVER, he never took the issue to task with the other councillors and they all voted for it for the most part.

Why?

Because they want the money.

That's how it works. At the end of the day, Saundercook could stand back and say that he voted against it, but democracy sucks and the vote was carried. (I would argue that he is therefore impotent to do anything to help his local residents.)


My point is that even if the local residents oppose the construction of the propane facility, the other councillors only see the development fees and property taxes and they figure, "not in my backyard"

So yes, the city is responsible for the facility being constructed. They could have stopped it during the EA process but the fact of the matter is - they didn't want to.

Now, imagine if said facilty was going to be built at the corner of Davenport and McPherson - just north of Dupont in the southern end of Forrest Hill. I know for a fact that that tract of land is zoned industrial as there is a large Toronto Hydro Facility there, Ontario Hydro, Gas Stations and there used to be a Steel Fabrication shop on the corner.

Do you really think that they would have EVER built such a facility there?

Never in a million years of Sundays.
 
After reading this thread, I have to totally agree with all of Sheik's posts....
Our Mayor, being a lawyer himself, knows only too well how to evade Qs and convert fact into fiction and vice versa. He is supposed to be mayor of all the people, but shows his political bias on every issue and at Prov/Fed elections. He appears to be a control freak in running affairs at 'Silly Hall' and does not like to have his judgement questioned....
As for the Propane Explosion, the actual cause of the tragedy has yet to be determined, thus it is not appropriate to point fingers at anyone until this is determined, or until all the FACTS come to light.
Meanwhile, I was appalled to watch the CTV News tonight and see a City Counciller scream at a resident to 'shut up'!!! These poor people have been barred from their homes for 4 days and cannot get straight honest answers from anyone, hence their frustration. All these moronic politicians just want to score brownie points by getting on a soapbox in front of the cameras......shades of Mayor Miller after every shooting tragedy.
God, 3 more years.........
 
kbluejayk said:
God, 3 more years.........

There are several people working very hard to shorten the wait. ;)
 
Sheik said:
Obviously you love Mr Miller, so tell me what he has done that has benefited the city?

He has done a great job of dealing with the 'homeless industry', sorry I meant homeless issue. I believe some clients even use city hall as their mailing address to receive their monthly cheques.
 
vsailor said:
1 question....are they going to demolish the homes that are structurally inhabitable and rebuild them?.....what a frickin mess!!!

Who is "they"???

The city will inspect the houses and if they are deemed unsafe the city will condemn them.

Then the insurance company who covered Superior Propane will have to pay out a claim to whomever's house was condemned and any auxillary costs (like lodging etc). I read yesterday someone was complaining that they "were still in the bathrobe and slippers" they were wearing when they evacuated. LOL I guess they never heard of bank machines and clothing stores!

Anyhow, it will probably be up to each individual homeowner to put in a claim agianst the insurance company to rebuild or buy another home.

I would even hazard a guess that each individual homeowner should have been in contact with their insurance company on Monday to see about coverage. I know many policies have contingency funds available for situations like this.
 
bbking said:
I have no love for Miller also, however City of Toronto Act that enabled the City to raise it's own revenue through tax increases is being abused both on the Federal and Provincial level.

Toronto needs investment from those two levels of Government and routinely what we hear, especially from the Feds is ... raise taxes.

I do agree that Miller has a propensity to concentrate power within his own group of lackeys but frankly most of his opposition are just loony ... maybe more so than the leftists he controls.



bbk
To your last point. The right leaning members of council would be Ford, Holyday, Minnan-Wong, Thompson, Stintz, Nunziata, Ootes, Shiner and Feldman. Not one of these members is on Miller's executive committee. Why? Because they don't want to be lackeys.
Ford's antics aside I think any one of these members would be better than anyone Miller has, including himself.
Giambrone at TTC is an utter disaster.
Moscoe at anything is a joke.
Shelly Carroll as budget chief? That's like having Lindsay Lohan in charge of the bar.
 
james t kirk said:
Sheppard Subway.

They were going to build 4 lines.

Then the gov't cut the funding and they were going to build 0 lines.

Only Mel stepped up to the plate and did what it took to build the first leg of that line. (Sure, it's not that well used, but someday, it will be - bank on that.)

He also was behind North York's transformation.

Miller's been in power for 5 years and has built sweet fuck all. His lasting legacy will be "getting to the root causes" of everything and cacelling the building of one bridge to the Island but paying for it anyway.

The Shepherd subway loses thousands for the city every day. The TTC even considered 'mothballing; it and using the money for areas that had real transit needs. It is an Icon to political power and the meglomania of Mel Lastman.

To use Mel Lastman as an example of what we need in a mayor is idiotic.
 
City Councillor tells Toronto resident to shut up

http://ca.news.yahoo.com/s/capress/080814/national/toronto_explosions_anger

TORONTO - A media briefing at the site of a massive propane explosion in Toronto degenerated into a shouting match between a public official and residents Wednesday.


City Coun. Maria Augimeri was there to address concerns about asbestos after the hazardous material was found in the neighbourhood. But she was confronted by several angry residents. Augimeri accused one man of using the death of a firefighter for partisan purposes and told him to "shut up."


Sunday morning's blasts at Sunrise Propane Industrial Gases sent orange fireballs into the sky and displaced thousands of residents.


One firefighter died at the scene, and another body was found at the explosion site Monday night.