Conservative attack adds

When you get right down to it, I think that the conservatives are very lucky the liberals picked Dion as leader and not Iggy. Iggy was too close to the conservatives on many “wedge issues” like Afghanistan. Iggy likely would have taken votes away from the conservatives and have won the center. However, Dion is so far to the left that he may win NDP and BQ voters but I can’t see him getting many voters who voted conservative in the last election. That leaves the center open to Harper. With 3 parties going after the left wing voters, Harper might actually be able to get a majority.

BTW, it looks like the opposition may be forcing an election. They have a private members bill that would require the government to meet Kyoto targets and it looks likely to pass. Given the impossibility of still meeting the targets, I don’t see what choice the government would really have other than calling an election. Thus, we may find soon out soon how this all plays out.
 
someone said:
When you get right down to it, I think that the conservatives are very lucky the liberals picked Dion as leader and not Iggy. Iggy was too close to the conservatives on many “wedge issues” like Afghanistan. Iggy likely would have taken votes away from the conservatives and have won the center. However, Dion is so far to the left that he may win NDP and BQ voters but I can’t see him getting many voters who voted conservative in the last election. That leaves the center open to Harper. With 3 parties going after the left wing voters, Harper might actually be able to get a majority.

No one in the BQ would turn for Dion, he was part of the Liberal caucus during the referendum. He will always be seen as a federalist. Gilles Duceppe has do do something stupid for BQ supporters to turn to the Liberals, or a better leader has to come forward.

If an election is called today there will still be a minority government. Which will be fine because eveyone in parliment will be forced to work together until a true leader is discovered. I personally don't think that either Harper or Dion make a good leader.
 
Tungsten said:
No one in the BQ would turn for Dion, he was part of the Liberal caucus during the referendum. He will always be seen as a federalist. Gilles Duceppe has do do something stupid for BQ supporters to turn to the Liberals, or a better leader has to come forward.

I’m sure that is true of the hardcore separatists. However, I’m not sure about the soft core who may be voting for the BQ because it is a leftwing party. Remember, there is no significant NDP in Quebec for such voters.

Tungsten said:
If an election is called today there will still be a minority government.
You might turn out to be right about another minority. These things are hard to predict. However, the further the liberals move to the left, the better off Harper is. Thus, I’m not so sure.
 
someone said:
I’m sure that is true of the hardcore separatists. However, I’m not sure about the soft core who may be voting for the BQ because it is a leftwing party. Remember, there is no significant NDP in Quebec for such voters.

Are you sure they are a left wing party? Lucien Bouchard who was the first leader of the BQ party was actually a Progressive Conservative under the Mulroney government.
 
Tungsten said:
Are you sure they are a left wing party? Lucien Bouchard who was the first leader of the BQ party was actually a Progressive Conservative under the Mulroney government.
And Duceppe was a member of the communist party at one time. If you look at their voting record since he became leader, think it would be hard to argue that it is not a left wing party.
 
someone said:
When you get right down to it, I think that the conservatives are very lucky the liberals picked Dion as leader and not Iggy. Iggy was too close to the conservatives on many “wedge issues” like Afghanistan. Iggy likely would have taken votes away from the conservatives and have won the center. However, Dion is so far to the left that he may win NDP and BQ voters but I can’t see him getting many voters who voted conservative in the last election. That leaves the center open to Harper. With 3 parties going after the left wing voters, Harper might actually be able to get a majority.

BTW, it looks like the opposition may be forcing an election. They have a private members bill that would require the government to meet Kyoto targets and it looks likely to pass. Given the impossibility of still meeting the targets, I don’t see what choice the government would really have other than calling an election. Thus, we may find soon out soon how this all plays out.

Would the government be forced to dissolve parliament and call an election? That Kyoto resolution isn't exactly a major money bill so, IMHO, the gov't would not be required to throw in the towel. The gov't has said there is no way to meet the targets so the bill just puts more pressure on them to try harder over the next couple of years. No?

[Edit] I just dug this up. The CPOC are claiming the opposition motion carries no monetary provisions etc:

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20070209.wkyoto-battle0209/BNStory/National/home

The Tories say the bill, which easily survived a second-reading vote last fall, is by no means a confidence matter because it doesn't carry any monetary provisions.

"We're talking about a bill here that's very much an empty vessel," said Tory House Leader Peter Van Loan.

"It doesn't have any meaningful provisions in it. . . . It's a meaningless motion."

Bill C-288, which has the support of all three opposition parties, would require the government to table a climate-change plan within 60 days explaining how it would meet Kyoto's greenhouse gas targets.
 
slowpoke said:
Would the government be forced to dissolve parliament and call an election? That Kyoto resolution isn't exactly a major money bill so, IMHO, the gov't would not be required to throw in the towel. The gov't has said there is no way to meet the targets so the bill just puts more pressure on them to try harder over the next couple of years. No?
I had thought the same based on what I read previously but apparently there is a bill in question that would be legally binding on the government, according to Patrick Monahan, Dean of Osgoode Law school. However, as you know I’m no lawyer, I’m only going by what I’ve read recently.
 
someone said:
I had thought the same based on what I read previously but apparently there is a bill in question that would be legally binding on the government, according to Patrick Monahan, Dean of Osgoode Law school. However, as you know I’m no lawyer, I’m only going by what I’ve read recently.

It will get lots of analysis now that it is in the spotlight. Dion will try to pretend that it was binding to make the CPOC look like they are operating outside of the norms of parliament etc. But it will probably go nowhere fast. It is too soon for an election and most Canadians would rather let the minority gov't continue so this motion seems pointless or even counterproductive.
 
someone said:
When you get right down to it, I think that the conservatives are very lucky the liberals picked Dion as leader and not Iggy. Iggy was too close to the conservatives on many “wedge issues” like Afghanistan. Iggy likely would have taken votes away from the conservatives and have won the center. However, Dion is so far to the left that he may win NDP and BQ voters but I can’t see him getting many voters who voted conservative in the last election. That leaves the center open to Harper. With 3 parties going after the left wing voters, Harper might actually be able to get a majority.

Dion is definetaly better for the Conservatives than Ignatief would have been, but I doubt he will win any votes from the Bloc voters. Many in Quebec still despise him for his role in the Clarity Act and for his association with the sponsorship scandal.

Thanks to the Liberals choosing Dion as their leader, the Conservatives could pick up 5 more seats in Quebec.
 
danmand said:
No sir, it is you that do not like your own medicine. If it is ok for you to call me a liberal, I reckon it is ok for me to say that Rumsfeld is your hero.

I called you a Liberal because you are quick to jump to their defence when I critisize their politics. Based on this, logic would tell me you are Liberal. The proof is in the pudding.

If you can find evidence of me supporting Rumsfeld or jumping to his defence, you would have a legitimate basis for your claims. However, stating I support Rumsfeld without any evidence of it, is not giving me a taste of my own medicine.

Feel free to call me a Conservative if you want as most of my views tend to lean that way. If you labeled me as such, at least you would have evidence to back it up.

danmand said:
I agree it would be best if we both cease using this tactic.

I don't use tactics. I just call it the way I see it.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
I called you a Liberal because you are quick to jump to their defence when I critisize their politics. Based on this, logic would tell me you are Liberal. The proof is in the pudding.

If you can find evidence of me supporting Rumsfeld or jumping to his defence, you would have a legitimate reason for your claims. However, stating I support Rumsfeld without any evidence of it, is not giving me a taste of my own medicine.

You have no evidence that "I am quick to jump to the defence of the Liberals when you critisize their politics". Therefore you have no logic, and you have no pudding.

So I did give you a taste of your own medicine. And it appears that you did not like it.
 
danmand said:
You have no evidence that "I am quick to jump to the defence of the Liberals when you critisize their politics". Therefore you have no logic, and you have no pudding.

So I did give you a taste of your own medicine. And it appears that you did not like it.

All this talk about pudding is making me hungry.

So you are not a Liberal?
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
All this talk about pudding is making me hungry.

The pudding tastes like medicine.

lookingforitallthetime said:
So you are not a Liberal?

I dislike being labelled, and I am not likely to join a political party.

For example: I admire Mulrooney for having kept the death penalty out of Canada against the will of his caucus . Does that make me a liberal or a conservative?
 
danmand said:
The pudding tastes like medicine.

I think you're giving yourself too much credit.


danmand said:
I dislike being labelled, and I am not likely to join a political party.

For example: I admire Mulrooney for having kept the death penalty out of Canada against the will of his caucus . Does that make me a liberal or a conservative?

That would make you a Liberal. Since I agree with you on this issue, that would make me a Liberal too I guess.

Therfore, your point concerning labels is noted.
 
The theme of the Conservative attack ads are that the Liberals were in power for 13 years and got nothing done.

The issue du jour is the environment (It seems like only yesterday that the issue was hospital wait times), and I agree that the Liberals were mistaken to sign the Kyoto Accord without honouring the targets. With regards to this accord, the Liberals got little done, and so they lack credibility in attacks (however deserved) on the Conservatives' environment programme.

However, I disagree that the Liberals got nothing done during the past 13 years. Under the Liberals, the federal budget went from deficit to surplus with about $10B per year being applied to the debt toward the end of Liberal rule. I remember when the debt was the issue du jour, and it is still very important to me. Some people accuse of the Liberals of downloading expenses to the provinces and municipalities, but I prefer to think that the Liberals made difficult decisions to cut services that were no longer affordable.

The problem I have with the Liberals is that they did not share the suffering of the people during the service cuts. Hundreds of millions went missing from Human Resources Development Canada and the Sponsorship Programme while people were on waiting lists for medical care, housing, etc. Paul Matrin's appointment of Art Eggleton to the Senate, after the Liberals’ own ethics commissioner exposed him for giving a consulting contract to his girlfriend, was especially galling.

However, the thing that made me want to hold my nose and vote Liberal were those $10B per year debt payments, which represent the hope of not passing onto future generations the consequences of decades of financial mismanagement. Still, I would have liked to have seen Allan Cutler (Sponsorship whistleblower running for the Conservatives) win over David McGuinty (who so far has shown himself to be as big a political weasel as his brother by heckling Rona Ambrose and then trying to make political hay out of the rise he got out of Peter McKay, losers all around in that farce).

I would have preferred that the Conservatives beat the Liberals last election on the scandal issue alone, without promising the GST cut. The impact of that cut (about $6B per year loss of revenue) will be felt this coming budget when the debt payment for the year will likely come in at under $4B.

My advice to the Conservatives is to continue $10B per year debt payments and show the people that you too will make sacrifices. Stephen Harper is setting a good example by not participating in the gold-plated government pension plan, but much more could be done (Eliminate all gold-plated pensions, the Senate, the Governor General, etc.).

As for the attack ads, they remind me of the Liberal attack ads. The Conservatives are in power now and should be trying to distinguish themselves from their predecessors. The Conservatives should show that they can provide the same prudent debt management of the Liberals minus the scandals.
 
Last edited:
markvee said:
the federal budget went from deficit to surplus with about $10B per year being applied to the debt toward the end of Liberal rule. I remember when the debt was the issue du jour, and it is still very important to me. Some people accuse of the Liberals of downloading expenses to the provinces and municipalities, but I prefer to think that the Liberals made difficult decisions to cut services that were no longer affordable.

The problem I have with the Liberals is that they did not share the suffering of the people during the service cuts. Hundreds of millions went missing from Human Resources Development Canada and the Sponsorship Programme while people were on waiting lists for medical care, housing, etc. Paul Matrin's appointment of Art Eggleton to the Senate, after the Liberals’ own ethics commissioner exposed him for giving a consulting contract to his girlfriend, was especially galling.

However, the thing that made me want to hold my nose and vote Liberal were those $10B per year debt payments, which represent the hope of not passing onto future generations the consequences of decades of financial mismanagement. Still, I would have liked to have seen Allan Cutler (Sponsorship whistleblower running for the Conservatives) win over David McGuinty (who so far has shown himself to be as big a political weasel as his brother by heckling Rona Ambrose and then trying to make political hay out of the rise he got out of Peter McKay, losers all around in that farce).

I would have preferred that the Conservatives beat the Liberals last election on the scandal issue alone, without promising the GST cut. The impact of that cut (about $6B per year loss of revenue) will be felt this coming budget when the debt payment for the year will likely come in at under $4B.

My advice to the Conservatives is to continue $10B per year debt payments and show the people that you too will make sacrifices. Stephen Harper is setting a good example by not participating in the gold-plated government pension plan, but much more could be done (Eliminate all gold-plated pensions, the Senate, the Governor General, etc.).The Conservatives should show that they can provide the same prudent debt management of the Liberals minus the scandals.

Hehehehe, thanks for the laugh.

Who do you think paid down the debt? The mighty Liberal party? It was the people who were overtaxed doing it.

As for the Liberals downloading expenses, this again was another way to pay down the debt. Pass it on to the next level of government and let them figure out how to pay for it! Talk about mismanagement. But thank god Mike Harris was there, the sheep of Ontario were led to believe the evils of the country were because of him!

All the while the silent abuse of funds continued, the accountability of federal government controls was forgotten due to the spin-doctoring of the Liberal machine.

I have seen the inner workings of the massive accounting mechanism in the federal government and it is a nasty mix of bullshit and creative accounting. It will never be held accountable due to the multitude of programs and departments that have no internal controls.

Are the conservatives any better? Only time will tell, but at least we have rid ourselves of a Liberal government that had become corrupt and used to feeding at the trough of public expense. Change was needed because the "Old Guard" was content on ruling the roost and pointing fingers at everyone but themselves for the problems in the country.

Because if you step back and look at the big picture, the federal Liberals may have looked good from a federal standpoint, but their actions certainly fucked up most all provincial and municpal governmental operations. And that my friend, was not a good deal for the taxpayer and for the country!

Federal Liberals = Reduce the federal debt, but increase the provincial and municpal debts. Thanks for the ass fucking!
 
I think these ads are brilliant, and good timing because the time the election comes around it won't be in the front of people's minds but will be in their psyche. Hey the Conservative Party has the $$$ might as well spend it. Its not like they are telling any untruths, its all quotes from the Liberal leaders. Man Dion looks and sounds like a bumbling idiot in those ads...how he won the leadership is beyond comprehension.
 
bbking said:
As a Liberal, I was very eager for a spring election - but now think Dion needs a little more time to grow into the job - I think the bbq summer circuit will do him a world of good, since he seems to be more comfortable in that role than he seems to be in question period. In this sense I think the ads worked in that it may have given us Liberals some pause about being over eager to replace Harper right after the convention.

I have no doubt that the NDP vote move in the recent polls will move back to the Liberals in the next election and assure a Liberal minority but I now think it would be better to go next fall or Winter and be in a better position to get a majority.



bbk

Youll never be happy until there some left wing quebecer in charge will you?
Heres a guy (Dion) whos English is as bad as Chretiens, is a citizen of France,was involved in the Adscam thing and wants to bring LIEberal members back in who were kicked out because of that,pretty much would devastate our economy by his zeal over Kyoto and you think that the people of this country are stupid enough to fall for all that again??
Id like to see the LIEberals reduced to about 2 members like Muldoons Quebec liberal PCs and hopefully take Jack Layton and his commie wife along with them!
I liked this board a lot more when we talked about what SC's we could go to for the best mileage!
 
Dancerfan said:
Youll never be happy until there some left wing quebecer in charge will you?
Heres a guy (Dion) whos English is as bad as Chretiens, is a citizen of France,was involved in the Adscam thing and wants to bring LIEberal members back in who were kicked out because of that,pretty much would devastate our economy by his zeal over Kyoto and you think that the people of this country are stupid enough to fall for all that again??
Id like to see the LIEberals reduced to about 2 members like Muldoons Quebec liberal PCs and hopefully take Jack Layton and his commie wife along with them!

You have to excuse BBKing. He's just another blind Liberal living in the past and assumes the majority of Canadians are as dim as he is.


Dancerfan said:
I liked this board a lot more when we talked about what SC's we could go to for the best mileage!

In the political section?
 
lol yeah and good luck to all of us if that fucking Dion and his gang of liberal liars and thiefs take over!