Conservative attack adds

slowpoke said:
I think Dion got angry at Iggy's cheap shot remark and, BTW, he didn't cry like a baby. He was frustrated by Iggy's tactics and his heated response in English wasn't particularly coherent. English is not his native tongue so, IMHO, it was understandable that he couldn't find the right words quickly enough. I'd like to see how you handled yourself (arguing in French) under the same circumstances.

This is a weak excuse. The other candidates were able to debate effectively in the French debates (I was surprised at the quality of Bob Rae's French). It's also worth mentioning that Liberal policy is the reason Canada has 2 official languages.

Since the Liberals made this bed, their candidates for leadership should be fluent in both official languages or they run the risk of alienating a large section of the country.

I could be wrong, but I don't think pussylicker has aspirations of running the country.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
Harper would kick Dion's scrawny ass in a fist fight. :D

Have you not noticed how fat Harper's gut is? He'd be gasping for breath after about 10 seconds.

FWIW, the average 8 year-old girl could probably beat the crap out of Peter MacKay.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
Since you feel that way, I will respect your wishes and leave you alone.




Kelso on The 70's Show would call that a " Great Burn":)
 
LancsLad said:
Kelso on The 70's Show would call that a " Great Burn":)

The woman who plays Eric's mother on that show is a hoot.

OTB
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
This is a weak excuse. The other candidates were able to debate effectively in the French debates (I was surprised at the quality of Bob Rae's French). It's also worth mentioning that Liberal policy is the reason Canada has 2 official languages.

Since the Liberals made this bed, their candidates for leadership should be fluent in both official languages or they run the risk of alienating a large section of the country.

I could be wrong, but I don't think pussylicker has aspirations of running the country.
Re running the country, if I could find a few more good men like you, I just might.:D
 
Rub a Dub Dub, or 3 Blind Mice?

3 blind mice, 3 blind mice, see how they run, see how they run. They all run after the farmer's wife. She cuts off their tails with a carving knife. Have you ever seen such a sight in your life, as 3 blind mice
slowpoke said:
Dion inherited Kyoto quite late in the game and worked his tail off to make it happen so it pissed him off when Iggy, the siver spoon academic, pretended that it was Dion's fault that "we didn't get it done". Iggy had no idea what Dion went through as the environment minister - trying to sell Kyoto while the gov't sank under the weight of sponsorship. I honestly don't think it was possible for Dion to succeed under those circumstances and Iggy was out of line for exploiting that. I'd have been pissed too.
Are you certain it wasn't the farmers wife who cut off Dion's tail?:D So Dryden doesn't know what he is talking about either? Dryden wanted answers too. If the other idiots in the tub had kept their noses clean, it might not have sank.

slowpoke said:
I think Dion got angry at Iggy's cheap shot remark and, BTW, he didn't cry like a baby. He was frustrated by Iggy's tactics and his heated response in English wasn't particularly coherent. English is not his native tongue so, IMHO, it was understandable that he couldn't find the right words quickly enough. I'd like to see how you handled yourself (arguing in French) under the same circumstances.
Thankfully I went to school in Ontario, when the government didn't shove French down your throat.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
This is a weak excuse. The other candidates were able to debate effectively in the French debates (I was surprised at the quality of Bob Rae's French). It's also worth mentioning that Liberal policy is the reason Canada has 2 official languages.

Since the Liberals made this bed, their candidates for leadership should be fluent in both official languages or they run the risk of alienating a large section of the country.

I could be wrong, but I don't think pussylicker has aspirations of running the country.

It is also worth mentioning that bilingualism in Canada goes all the way back to 1867 and that the Mulroney gov't reaffirmed Canada's commitment to bilingualism when they passed the Official Languages Act in the 1988 parliament. So if the Liberals made this bed, the PC's didn't mind sleeping in it. Official bilingualism is just as much a PC policy as it is a Liberal one and it always has been.

http://www.canadianheritage.gc.ca/progs/lo-ol/biling/hist_e.cfm

"1988 The new Official Languages Act is adopted by Parliament. It repeats and qualifies the obligations under the 1982 Charter regarding the use of the two official languages in the provision of government services and throughout government institutions. The Act also states the government's commitment to promote linguistic duality within Canadian society and to support the development of official-language minority communities."

BTW, my argument is weak because it is impossible to really know WTF Dion was feeling when he responded to Iggy's comment. I have constructed what I consider to be a likely scenario but we'll never know if that is what was really happening. But your argument is equally weak. Dion's English is far better than Harper's French and there is no reason why Dion should be perfect in English. The only PC PM in the last 50 years who was really comfortable in both languages was Mulroney. The only Liberal PM who was really comfortable in both languages was Trudeau. All the other PMs in Canada's recent history have been far less than comfortable speaking in the opposite language and most of them really sucked. Turner's French was awful and I seem to recall you voted for him.
 
slowpoke said:
I think Dion got angry at Iggy's cheap shot remark
Stating a fact was a cheap shot?

slowpoke said:
and, BTW, he didn't cry like a baby. He was frustrated by Iggy's tactics and his heated response in English wasn't particularly coherent. English is not his native tongue so, IMHO, it was understandable that he couldn't find the right words quickly enough. I'd like to see how you handled yourself (arguing in French) under the same circumstances.

Given that most of Canada is English speaking, are you not just saying that he is not qualified to be PM of Canada?

slowpoke said:
Iggy, the siver spoon academic,

What do you think Dion’s background is? OK Iggy worked in a higher ranked university. Are you saying that because Dion worked in a lower ranked university, that makes him more qualified?:confused:

slowpoke said:
pretended that it was Dion's fault that "we didn't get it done". Iggy had no idea what Dion went through as the environment minister - trying to sell Kyoto while the gov't sank under the weight of sponsorship. I honestly don't think it was possible for Dion to succeed under those circumstances and Iggy was out of line for exploiting that. I'd have been pissed too.

So your saying that Dion’s defence was that since he was part of a corrupt government, he could not get anything done. I see. Interesting argument.
 
someone said:
Stating a fact was a cheap shot?

It was a cheap shot for Iggy to try to hang it all on Dion because Dion inherited Kyoto late in the game at a time when the Liberal minority gov't that was too weak to drive Kyoto forward. As a Liberal, I think Iggy should have left that alone because he was being critical of the Liberal party's performance from the earliest days of Kyoto and laying it all on Dion. Do you seriously think Dion could have pulled that off in such a short time and with so little support?

someone said:
Given that most of Canada is English speaking, are you not just saying that he is not qualified to be PM of Canada?

I think Stephane's English is adequate for the job and it will undoubtedly improve. He searches for words occasionally but I don't see that as much of a handicap. I am more concerned about how well he can think and manage people. I see no evidence that his English will impair his ability to lead. Do you seriously think his language skills disqualify him from leading Canada? If so, Chretien must have just been very lucky because he pulled it off for many years and nobody has suggested that the shortcomings of the Chretien Liberals had anything to do with Chretien's mangled English.

someone said:
What do you think Dion’s background is? OK Iggy worked in a higher ranked university. Are you saying that because Dion worked in a lower ranked university, that makes him more qualified?:confused:

Dion's immediate background was as our environment minister. He was also intergovernmental affairs minister before that (starting in Jan 1996). So Dion had about 10 years of government experience under his belt. He is also credited with formulating the Clarity Act. Iggy's immediate background was Harvard and he had never been in government. So he didn't know WTF he was talking about when he tried to blame Dion with the Liberal shortcomings on the environment.

someone said:
So your saying that Dion’s defence was that since he was part of a corrupt government, he could not get anything done. I see. Interesting argument.

How feasible was it for Dion to take on the provinces and industry without a strong government behind him? Not very! And it is a bit of a stretch to paint the Martin Liberals as a corrupt government when the corruption had occurred many years before and the guilty had been exposed in the Gomery inquiry. The simple fact is that Martin had a weak minority gov't because of previous corruption and it was that weakness that hindered Dion. We've been over this already.
 
slowpoke said:
It was a cheap shot for Iggy to try to hang it all on Dion because Dion inherited Kyoto late in the game and also as part of a minority gov't that was too weak to drive Kyoto forward. As a Liberal, I think Iggy should have left that alone because he was being critical of the Liberal party's performance from the earliest days of Kyoto and laying it all on Dion. Do you seriously think Dion could have pulled that off in such a short time and with so little support?

Iggy’s words were “we”, meaning the liberal party and a Cabinet Dion was part of the time. Besides, Dion is trying to frame himself as a one issue candidate and was in cabinate the whole time. We are talking about a guy who seems to be basing his whole campaign on a lie. I.e. that Canada could still meet its Kyoto targets.

slowpoke said:
I think Stephane's English is adequate for the job and it will undoubtedly improve. He searches for words occasionally but I don't see that as much of a handicap. I am more concerned about how well he can think and manage people. I see no evidence that his English will impair his ability to lead. Do you seriously think his language skills disqualify him from leading Canada? If so, Chretien must have just been very lucky because he pulled it off for many years and nobody has suggested that the shortcomings of the Chretien Liberals had anything to do with Chretien's mangled English.

What got Chrétien elected was the fact that the conservative party split into three after Mulroney’s second election. It is something people commonly call the first past the post system.

slowpoke said:
Dion's immediate background was as our environment minister. He was also intergovernmental affairs minister (starting in Jan 1996). So Dion had about 10 years of government experience under his belt. He is also credited with formulating the Clarity Act. Iggy's immediate background was Harvard and he had never been in government. So he didn't know WTF he was talking about when he tried to blame Dion with the Liberal shortcomings on the environment.
I think this is one of the most foolish arguments you have mad so far. You're saying that Dion had become a career politician. That gives him expertise on playing politics and getting elected. It does not give him any real expertise on issues. For that, ministers have briefs. Breifs that are informed in part by people at places like Harvard. Being smart is not a bad thing and I woudl not hold the fact that iggy is the smarter of the two, against him.



slowpoke said:
How feasible was it for Dion to take on the provinces and industry without a strong government behind him? Not very! And it is a bit of a stretch to paint the Martin Liberals as a corrupt government when the corruption had occurred many
years before and the guilty had been exposed in the Gomery inquiry. The simple fact is that Martin had a weak minority gov't because of previous corruption and it was that weakness that hindered Dion. We've been over this already.
We’ve been there already and you are still trying to deny reality. Look, I know that you believe the liberal leaders can do no wrong but you should note a few things. First, we are not taking about “many years before”. Moreover, we are talking about Dion lying both during the leadership campaign and now about the possibility of Canada meeting its Kyoto targets. Blaming it on Gomery is not going to work.
 
If I may be allowed to give my gratuitous opinion, I think that your discussion is a bit over the top. Dion is a politician just like Martin, Harper, Mulrooney, Clark and Cretien. wWhy would you expect him to be any better or worse than Harper for example. Dion is trying to use the environment to be elected, just like Harper is. They have both through polls discovered that canadians care about the environment.
 
danmand said:
If I may be allowed to give my gratuitous opinion, I think that your discussion is a bit over the top. Dion is a politician just like Martin, Harper, Mulrooney, Clark and Cretien. wWhy would you expect him to be any better or worse than Harper for example. Dion is trying to use the environment to be elected, just like Harper is. They have both through polls discovered that canadians care about the environment.
I don’t really disagree. In fact, I think that to some extent Dion is just digging a hole for himself. IF there is a Spring election and if he somehow forms a government, he will have a hard time getting people to forget his rhetoric. Moreover, the more Canadians become informed about the costs of meeting Kyoto at this late stage of the game, the more credibility he loses. However, although all politicians lie, I think it is worse when it is the central part of the campaign and they know they will not be able to keep the promise. That being said, I can’t see it really helping him. I think that if he were smart, he would be focusing on things like the conservatives' policies regarding the justice system or Isreal (which I really disagree with). The BQ and NDP can get away with impossible Kyoto promises as people know they will never form government. I have a hard time seeing it working for the liberals. However, it would not be the first time I overestimate the intelligence of the average voter, so I could be wrong.
 
someone said:
Iggy’s words were “we”, meaning the liberal party and a Cabinet Dion was part of the time. Besides, Dion is trying to frame himself as a one issue candidate and was in cabinate the whole time. We are talking about a guy who seems to be basing his whole campaign on a lie. I.e. that Canada could still meet its Kyoto targets.

The original question was about my use of "cheap shot". I gave a reason why I considered it a cheap shot and I still think it was a cheap shot because the question was directed at Dion and the implication was that the failure to implement Kyoto was Dion's fault. Iggy may have used "we" but he was talking to Dion. As far as Dion having been in the cabinet the whole time or how he frames himself or whether or not he lied saying Canada could still meet Kyoto, those are all interesting questions but I don't see how they have a helluva lot to do with the reason I chose "cheap shot".

someone said:
What got Chrétien elected was the fact that the conservative party split into three after Mulroney’s second election. It is something people commonly call the first past the post system.

That may be true but I was referring to the fact that Chretien survived as the PM even though his English is terrible and that the shortcomings of the Liberals weren't caused by Chretiens language skills. How Chretien got elected is another matter.

someone said:
I think this is one of the most foolish arguments you have mad so far. You're saying that Dion had become a career politician. That gives him expertise on playing politics and getting elected. It does not give him any real expertise on issues. For that, ministers have briefs. Breifs that are informed in part by people at places like Harvard. Being smart is not a bad thing and I woudl not hold the fact that iggy is the smarter of the two, against him.

I simply said that Dion had 10 years experience in gov't and that Iggy had zero years in gov't. That's all I said. I didn't say Iggy wasn't smart because we both know damned well that he is VERY smart. I said he didn't know WTF he was talking about because he had never been in gov't. And I have never once held Iggy's intelligence against him. Nor have I given a second thought to his maybe being smarter than Dion. I could care less because they are both smart enough to be PM.

As far as expertise is concerned, I think Dion probably aquired considerable expertise on the issues he has addressed such as Kyoto and the referendum (Clarity Act). And so what if Dion was briefed by those with an even greater expertise? The point remains that briefed-to-the-tits-Dion WAS extremely familiar with Kyoto and the obstacles to implementing it while Iggy was not. So Iggy was in no position to be lecturing Dion about his performance as environment minister, briefs or no briefs.

someone said:
We’ve been there already and you are still trying to deny reality. Look, I know that you believe the liberal leaders can do no wrong but you should note a few things. First, we are not taking about “many years before”. Moreover, we are talking about Dion lying both during the leadership campaign and now about the possibility of Canada meeting its Kyoto targets. Blaming it on Gomery is not going to work.

The sponsorship program was initiated in 1996 and Chuch Guite retired in 1999. So most of the actual corruption occurred quite a while ago. Many is an exaggeration. It only seems like many.

You may be talking about Dion lying during the leadership campaign and since but I was talking about what had happened before that to prevent Kyoto from being implemented. And where did I blame Gomery? I've repeated time and again, that the WEAKNESS of the minority Liberals during Dion's tenure was ONE of the reasons why driving Kyoto was virtually impossible. How is that "blaming" Gomery? I blame those crooked Liberals who caused the whole sponsorship mess in the first place. Since Dion isn't one of those crooked Liberals, I have simply tried to evaluate the obstacles that confronted him as environment minister. One of those obstacles was being part of a weak minority gov't. Here's what I said:

"Dion inherited Kyoto quite late in the game and worked his tail off to make it happen so it pissed him off when Iggy, the siver spoon academic, pretended that it was Dion's fault that "we didn't get it done". Iggy had no idea what Dion went through as the environment minister - trying to sell Kyoto while the gov't sank under the weight of sponsorship. I honestly don't think it was possible for Dion to succeed under those circumstances and Iggy was out of line for exploiting that. I'd have been pissed too."
 
I likely should have waited until I had may morning coffee before responding. I'm sorry if I was grumpy. You response was much more polite.

slowpoke said:
The original question was about my use of "cheap shot". I gave a reason why I considered it a cheap shot and I still think it was a cheap shot because the question was directed at Dion and the implication was that the failure to implement Kyoto was Dion's fault. Iggy may have used "we" but he was talking to Dion. As far as Dion having been in the cabinet the whole time or how he frames himself or whether or not he lied saying Canada could still meet Kyoto, those are all interesting questions but I don't see how they have a helluva lot to do with the reason I chose "cheap shot".

I do think the two are related as he was promising Canada would meet Kyoto if he became PM. I think Iggy was right when he said the liberals had a chance and didn’t get it done. Thus, it was too late for Dion’s promise. Whether there may or may not have been an excuse for not getting it done is another (related) thing.

slowpoke said:
That may be true but I was referring to the fact that Chretien survived as the PM even though his English is terrible and that the shortcomings of the Liberals weren't caused by Chretiens language skills. How Chretien got elected is another matter.
I think the two are related as I don’t think he would have survived as PM if he didn’t get elected. I don’t see how you can say you were referring the fact he survived as PM when you have to get elected to survive as PM. Moreover, the liberals tend to dumb their leaders when they don’t get elected so I don’t even think he would have survived as leader if he had not gotten elected..

slowpoke said:
I simply said that Dion had 10 years experience in gov't and that Iggy had zero years in gov't. That's all I said. I didn't say Iggy wasn't smart because we both know damned well that he is VERY smart. I said he didn't know WTF he was talking about because he had never been in gov't. And I have never once held Iggy's intelligence against him nor have I given a second thought to his maybe being smarter than Dion. I could care less because they are both smart enough to be PM.

As far as expertise is concerned, I think Dion probably aquired considerable expertise on the issues he has addressed such as Kyoto and the referendum (Clarity Act). And so what if Dion was briefed by those with an even greater expertise? The point remains that briefed-to-the-tits-Dion WAS extremely familiar with Kyoto and the obstacles to implementing it while Iggy was not. So Iggy was in no position to be lecturing Dion about his performance as environment minister, briefs or no briefs.

When it comes to the clarity Act, I would agree that Dion likely has some expertise. However, I don’t see any evidence that he has any expertise on Kyoto. If he does, it is worse as that means he really knows he is lying when he says Canada can still meet the target. I guess that might be true (or even likely) that he knows this, but as I say, I see not evidence of this knowledge on Kyoto. Also, what evidence do yo hae that Iggy is not familar with Kyto and the impossiblity of Canada meeting its targets?
 
slowpoke said:
How feasible was it for Dion to take on the provinces and industry without a strong government behind him? Not very! And it is a bit of a stretch to paint the Martin Liberals as a corrupt government when the corruption had occurred many years before and the guilty had been exposed in the Gomery inquiry. The simple fact is that Martin had a weak minority gov't because of previous corruption and it was that weakness that hindered Dion. We've been over this already.
So the Lieberals did nothing. Point taken. We get that, and now the Harper Gov't is in the same boat, yet you all want Harper to buckle under, accept Kyoto, and implement it while he has a minority gov't. Kyoto should never have be signed onto by Mean Jean. Period. Harper has done more on other fronts in less time than Mr Dithers did, so who was the more affective minority gov't?

As far as the Lieberals go, we are talking about the old boys club, a dinosaur at best, slow moving, and sinking into extinction, and it still exists. Since so many of you want to drag Harper's history into the picture as being Reform, and not really Conservative and definately not Progressive Conservative, then fair is fair. Iggy, Kennedy nor Rae were part of the Lieberals, so they do have a chance of steering the Lieberals in a new direction. Stephanie was part of the old boys club, so the stink should stay with him. Stephanie is trying to be a leopard who's changed his spots, and it doesn't wash.

slowpoke said:
It was a cheap shot for Iggy to try to hang it all on Dion because Dion inherited Kyoto late in the game at a time when the Liberal minority gov't that was too weak to drive Kyoto forward. As a Liberal, I think Iggy should have left that alone because he was being critical of the Liberal party's performance from the earliest days of Kyoto and laying it all on Dion. Do you seriously think Dion could have pulled that off in such a short time and with so little support?
But, Iggy, Kennedy and Rae weren't part of the Lieberals, so they do have a chance of steering the Lieberals in a new direction. They don't stink of the Mean Jean/Mr Dithers era.

slowpoke said:
I think Stephane's English is adequate for the job and it will undoubtedly improve. He searches for words occasionally but I don't see that as much of a handicap. I am more concerned about how well he can think and manage people. I see no evidence that his English will impair his ability to lead. Do you seriously think his language skills disqualify him from leading Canada? If so, Chretien must have just been very lucky because he pulled it off for many years and nobody has suggested that the shortcomings of the Chretien Liberals had anything to do with Chretien's mangled English.
Better get the little blue parking sign out for Dion.:D
Mean Jean had his problems, but he was more of a bumbling idiot. Choking a bystander was a hoot. BTW, I didn't see any flaw with Mr Dither's French.
 
someone said:
Iggy’s words were “we”, meaning the liberal party and a Cabinet Dion was part of the time. Besides, Dion is trying to frame himself as a one issue candidate and was in cabinate the whole time. We are talking about a guy who seems to be basing his whole campaign on a lie. I.e. that Canada could still meet its Kyoto targets.
To add to your point, Iggy is including himself in the WE, even though he wasn't part of the Liberal Party, so good on him. Iggy was willing to take on the Lieberal stink.
 
someone said:
I likely should have waited until I had may morning coffee before responding. I'm sorry if I was grumpy. You response was much more polite.

You weren't grumpy. You were actually quite civilized relative to other CPOC supporters.:D

someone said:
I do think the two are related as he was promising Canada would meet Kyoto if he became PM. I think Iggy was right when he said the liberals had a chance and didn’t get it done. Thus, it was too late for Dion’s promise. Whether there may or may not have been an excuse for not getting it done is another (related) thing.

I don't remember that debate so I was basing my assessment on Dion's response to Iggy's question in the recent attack ad. Dion became angry and semi-coherent so he obviously was stung by Iggy's remark as if he thought Iggy was blaming him for the whole sorry mess. Iggy may have been alluding to the Liberal party's continued failure to launch Kyoto or he may have been alluding to the impossibility of Dion's promise to meet the targets. I'd have to see the debate again.

someone said:
I think the two are related as I don’t think he would have survived as PM if he didn’t get elected. I don’t see how you can say you were referring the fact he survived as PM when you have to get elected to survive as PM. Moreover, the liberals tend to dumb their leaders when they don’t get elected so I don’t even think he would have survived as leader if he had not gotten elected.

I started off asking myself if Dion would be handicapped by his English. I was thinking strictly in terms of his ability to do the job because your question was whether Dion was qualified to be PM with his English. That's where the comparison with Chretien's terrible English came into the equation. But if I feel Dion can do the job well enough with his current command of the English language, then I would vote for him to be the next PM. And if I would vote for him, why wouldn't lots of other people?? So it all comes down to the ability to do the job. That what drives the votes, IMHO.

someone said:
When it comes to the clarity Act, I would agree that Dion likely has some expertise. However, I don’t see any evidence that he has any expertise on Kyoto. If he does, it is worse as that means he really knows he is lying when he says Canada can still meet the target. I guess that might be true (or even likely) that he knows this, but as I say, I see not evidence of this knowledge on Kyoto. Also, what evidence do yo hae that Iggy is not familar with Kyto and the impossiblity of Canada meeting its targets?

Given that he chaired the Montreal Kyoto Summit or whatever it was called, I assume he knows all about Kyoto. I agree that the likelihood of us meeting those commitments now is quite low so he is probably lying about that. He is thinking he'll get us as close as possible to minimize the carbon credits we'll have to buy but he must know we won't really make it.