slowpoke said:
How feasible was it for Dion to take on the provinces and industry without a strong government behind him? Not very! And it is a bit of a stretch to paint the Martin Liberals as a corrupt government when the corruption had occurred many years before and the guilty had been exposed in the Gomery inquiry. The simple fact is that Martin had a weak minority gov't because of previous corruption and it was that weakness that hindered Dion. We've been over this already.
So the Lieberals did nothing. Point taken. We get that, and now the Harper Gov't is in the same boat, yet you all want Harper to buckle under, accept Kyoto, and implement it while he has a minority gov't. Kyoto should never have be signed onto by Mean Jean. Period. Harper has done more on other fronts in less time than Mr Dithers did, so who was the more affective minority gov't?
As far as the Lieberals go, we are talking about the old boys club, a dinosaur at best, slow moving, and sinking into extinction, and it still exists. Since so many of you want to drag Harper's history into the picture as being Reform, and not really Conservative and definately not Progressive Conservative, then fair is fair. Iggy, Kennedy nor Rae were part of the Lieberals, so they do have a chance of steering the Lieberals in a new direction. Stephanie was part of the old boys club, so the stink should stay with him. Stephanie is trying to be a leopard who's changed his spots, and it doesn't wash.
slowpoke said:
It was a cheap shot for Iggy to try to hang it all on Dion because Dion inherited Kyoto late in the game at a time when the Liberal minority gov't that was too weak to drive Kyoto forward. As a Liberal, I think Iggy should have left that alone because he was being critical of the Liberal party's performance from the earliest days of Kyoto and laying it all on Dion. Do you seriously think Dion could have pulled that off in such a short time and with so little support?
But, Iggy, Kennedy and Rae weren't part of the Lieberals, so they do have a chance of steering the Lieberals in a new direction. They don't stink of the Mean Jean/Mr Dithers era.
slowpoke said:
I think Stephane's English is adequate for the job and it will undoubtedly improve. He searches for words occasionally but I don't see that as much of a handicap. I am more concerned about how well he can think and manage people. I see no evidence that his English will impair his ability to lead. Do you seriously think his language skills disqualify him from leading Canada? If so, Chretien must have just been very lucky because he pulled it off for many years and nobody has suggested that the shortcomings of the Chretien Liberals had anything to do with Chretien's mangled English.
Better get the little blue parking sign out for Dion.
Mean Jean had his problems, but he was more of a bumbling idiot. Choking a bystander was a hoot. BTW, I didn't see any flaw with Mr Dither's French.