Conservative attack adds

About those adds...

I personally think attacks are always the sure-fire sign of desperation, like the idiotic adds about Harper placing the army in our cities and the PC's add mocking Chretien's face back in the 90's.

What bothers me even more about these current adds is that we are not currently in an election! As a result the expenditures on these adds are not counted towards the spending limits - I think this is totally wrong - if one party put's out an add either promoting it's own policies or attacking an opposing party, the costs should be carryforward and included in the tally of the next election, period.

Now before anyone states that the Conservatives are using their own money I would like to point out that all the parties receive public money based on the percentage of the votes received in the last election(to compensate for the lowered limits on donations) and we the taxpayer finances a portion of each donation via a tax credit so in fact we are all paying a portion of these adds.
 
pussylicker said:
He didn't. I started the attack on Mr Dithers recently, and Red got involved. So flame me if you want.

It's nice to see that are others passionate enough to take up the ball and run with it.

OK! Why do you care how Martin ran his business? He's pretty much out of it all so it makes no difference.
 
slowpoke said:
OK! Why do you care how Martin ran his business? He's pretty much out of it all so it makes no difference.
Red and my debate has been about the rat Stephanie, Mean Jean and Mr Dithers. There was no leadership from the Lieberal camp, ie leading by example started the tax debate.

Rub a dub dub,
3 men in a tub.
The weiner,
The choker,
And the tax avoider.

Oops was that supposed to be whiner?
 
slowpoke said:
Show me where I said or implied anything about disavowing my country or that I consider that normal. I said: "If my accountant suggested I could legally save even more [taxes] by somehow registering my assets offshore, I'd probably say "let's do it".

Since I qualified my statement with "legally", that would mean that the laws of my beloved Canada allow all citizens to avail themselves of this particular tax benefit (loophole to you). Who am I to argue with the wise and honourable bright lights at Revenue Canada? And since when does legally registering one's ASSETS offshore become disavowing one's country. Did I say I would abandon Canada? Well....DID I?

I think you're getting a little too sensitive there slowpoke. I was referring to your pal Paul Martin, not you.

The bottom line, if Harper did the same thing, all the weenies would be crying foul. You can deny it if you want, but I know better.
 
slowpoke said:
BTW, just out of curiosity, why ARE you making an issue about how Martin ran his business. Just asking.

Like so many other threads, it evolved into a discussion over something else.

Sometimes that happens in here.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
I think you're getting a little too sensitive there slowpoke. I was referring to your pal Paul Martin, not you.

The bottom line, if Harper did the same thing, all the weenies would be crying foul. You can deny it if you want, but I know better.

Don't mistake exuberance on a Friday for sensitivity. I knew you weren't aiming at me. This whole thing is just fun and games. You can say anything you want about Martin and I won't bat an eye. For the record, I deny that it would bother me if Harper registered his business offshore to save taxes. If it was a profitable business in a sector where this type of behaviour was out of the ordinary, I'd probably wonder if it was really necessary to go to such extemes. But money saved (legally) is the same as money earned and it is hard to fault ANYONE for trying to maximize their income. Self interest is the driving force behind captitalism and we all know what happens to people who argue with capitalism.
 
bbking said:
... the ads you refer to about Harper occured between the time that NDP announced they would support sponser a non-confidence motion which everone knew Harper would support and an election thus being called - not the samething at all.

According to all parties there is no election in sight, so why the ads. The only other time was Liberals and Stockwell Day after his election to leadership and this was only in answer toAlliance ads about him - of course harper says the Alliance Party doesn't exist so this example little weight also.


bbk


ummmmm......this has absolutely nothing to do with what slowpoke and I were discussing.

Thanks for your input just the same. :rolleyes:
 
slowpoke said:
Don't mistake exuberance on a Friday for sensitivity. I knew you weren't aiming at me. This whole thing is just fun and games. You can say anything you want about Martin and I won't bat an eye. For the record, I deny that it would bother me if Harper registered his business offshore to save taxes. If it was a profitable business in a sector where this type of behaviour was out of the ordinary, I'd probably wonder if it was really necessary to go to such extemes. But money saved (legally) is the same as money earned and it is hard to fault ANYONE for trying to maximize their income. Self interest is the driving force behind captitalism and we all know what happens to people who argue with capitalism.


Alright, a little exuberance is a good thing, just don't get sensitive on us.

I believe there is something wrong with a Prime Minister's company registering assets in another country to avoid taxes. I would feel the same way if Harper did it too.

I may be wrong to feel that way, but it's how I feel.
 
The other great thing about Martin is that a lot of their ships, the lakers, were built in Collingwood with heavy taxpayer subsidy. Its the Cdn way .

But then why would he be any different than all the other qwebec libs. Gotta have that subsidy.
 
Desperation was my first impression as well. The ads I saw today had nothing in them that I'd classify as clever or convincing me to vote Conservative to stop Dion.

Many Conservatives have skeletons in the closet too.

mindingmyownbusiness said:
I personally think attacks are always the sure-fire sign of desperation, like the idiotic adds about Harper placing the army in our cities and the PC's add mocking Chretien's face back in the 90's.

What bothers me even more about these current adds is that we are not currently in an election! As a result the expenditures on these adds are not counted towards the spending limits - I think this is totally wrong - if one party put's out an add either promoting it's own policies or attacking an opposing party, the costs should be carryforward and included in the tally of the next election, period.

Now before anyone states that the Conservatives are using their own money I would like to point out that all the parties receive public money based on the percentage of the votes received in the last election(to compensate for the lowered limits on donations) and we the taxpayer finances a portion of each donation via a tax credit so in fact we are all paying a portion of these adds.
 
Most find anti-Dion Tory ads unfair: poll

Harper may have planted a seed of doubt about Dion's environmental credentials or his leadership qualities with those attack ads but they were perceived as unfair by almost 60% of the Canadians who'd seen them. So the downside of the attack ads is that Harper looks like he's playing dirty politics. IMHO, Harper lost more in perceived integrity than he gained by smearing Dion.

http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/20070207/dion_ads_070207/20070207?hub=Politics

OTTAWA -- A new poll suggests Canadians are not impressed by Conservative party TV ads that attempt to discredit new Liberal Leader Stephane Dion.

The survey by Decima Research found that 38 per cent of respondents -- out of a sample of more than 1,000 -- recalled seeing the attack ads.

But among the 388 Canadians who remember watching the unusual, non-election-period political advertising, 59 per cent said the ads were not fair in how they described Dion. Only 22 per cent felt the ads were fair.

Fully two thirds of the respondents said the information in the ads was not relevant to their choice in the next federal election, compared with 26 per cent who said it was relevant.

Among the subset of respondents who said they remembered seeing the ads, the margin of error is plus or minus five percentage points, 19 times in 20.

Almost a third of those who recalled seeing the Conservative ads said they saw them only in the news media, and not as paid TV spots.
 
slowpoke said:
Among the subset of respondents who said they remembered seeing the ads, the margin of error is plus or minus five percentage points, 19 times in 20.

Almost a third of those who recalled seeing the Conservative ads said they saw them only in the news media, and not as paid TV spots.
Polls don't mean sh!t, and you know what I think of polls. So that means an actual 52% or was it 60.6%? :D
 
slowpoke said:
Harper may have planted a seed of doubt about Dion's environmental credentials or his leadership qualities with those attack ads but they were perceived as unfair by almost 60% of the Canadians who'd seen them. So the downside of the attack ads is that Harper looks like he's playing dirty politics. IMHO, Harper lost more in perceived integrity than he gained by smearing Dion.

.

I actually think that it was a smart move. Yes people generally don't like attack ads . What it has done though is cut the feet out from under the Liberals who wanted to call an election and campaign on their environmental record.

I have seen the add where Iggy Pop turns to Dion during the Liberal leadership campaign and says (talking about the Dion's performance on environmental matters) "Stephan , we simply didn't get it done" .

Bingo. I think people will remember that long after they forget the nastiness of the ads.
 
train said:
I actually think that it was a smart move. Yes people generally don't like attack ads . What it has done though is cut the feet out from under the Liberals who wanted to call an election and campaign on their environmental record.

I have seen the add where Iggy Pop turns to Dion during the Liberal leadership campaign and says (talking about the Dion's performance on environmental matters) "Stephan , we simply didn't get it done" .

Bingo. I think people will remember that long after they forget the nastiness of the ads.

Time will tell if this was a smart move or not. I'm not convinced it was.

I realize I may not represent the average Canadian as I didn't need a Conservative ad to tell me the Liberal record on the environment was abysmal.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
Time will tell if this was a smart move or not. I'm not convinced it was.

I realize I may not represent the average Canadian as I didn't need a Conservative ad to tell me the Liberal record on the environment was abysmal.

True, but the Liberals were going to use it against the Conservatives, the Conservatives got a head start and now the Liberals have to re-think their position and their agenda.
 
I can imagine that the liberals can dig up some nice tidbits from the leadership campaigns in the conservative party.

Do the conservatives really think that any voters will be swayed by watching old clips from past elction campaigns?
 
danmand said:
I can imagine that the liberals can dig up some nice tidbits from the leadership campaigns in the conservative party.

That could be interesting.

Although, they may have a tough time avoiding their new wonder girl, Belinda Stronach.
 
bbking said:
Actually they have some great comments from Jim Prentice about how difficult it was for Harper to get along with others - that one will get air-play and ring a little truer for voters than the current anti-Dion ads.


bbk

Iggy was right. The Liberals had 13 years to do something about the environment and chose to do nothing. I don't know what could ring truer than that.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
Iggy was right. The Liberals had 13 years to do something about the environment and chose to do nothing. I don't know what could ring truer than that.

How about Harper proposing to do even less about global warming for even longer - ie: consulting about emission targets until 2020 or 2025? HMMM? You seem to have forgotten about that little gem from BEFORE the polls alerted Harper to the fact that his attempted negligence on climate change would not be tolerated. Canadians aren't utterly stupid so they'll remember that Harper first tried to do even less than the Liberals and was forced to flip flop on climate change once he finally twigged to the fact that Canadians want to be led by someone who cares.

Furthermore, with all the noise Harper and the oil lobby made about the Liberals signing us up for Kyoto and the subsequent Liberal-brokered deal with the auto industry to cut emissions by 5.3 megatonnes by 2010, I doubt that any normal Canadian actually believes that the Liberals "chose to do nothing" for 13 years. That is one of the reasons why 59% of Canadians who've seen the attack ads think they are unfair. It is because they are utter bullshit.

http://www.cbc.ca/news/background/kyoto/timeline.html

March 23:[2005] The federal government and Canada's car makers reach an agreement on emissions standards. Automakers agree that its new vehicles will cut emissions by 5.3 megatonnes by 2010 as part of Ottawa's Kyoto plan.
 
slowpoke said:
How about Harper proposing to do even less about global warming for even longer - ie: consulting about emission targets until 2020 or 2025? HMMM? You seem to have forgotten about that little gem from BEFORE the polls alerted Harper to the fact that his attempted negligence on climate change would not be tolerated. Canadians aren't utterly stupid so they'll remember that Harper first tried to do even less than the Liberals and was forced to flip flop on climate change once he finally twigged to the fact that Canadians want to be led by someone who cares.

Furthermore, with all the noise Harper and the oil lobby made about the Liberals signing us up for Kyoto and the subsequent Liberal-brokered deal with the auto industry to cut emissions by 5.3 megatonnes by 2010, I doubt that any normal Canadian actually believes that the Liberals "chose to do nothing" for 13 years. That is one of the reasons why 59% of Canadians who've seen the attack ads think they are unfair. It is because they are utter bullshit.

http://www.cbc.ca/news/background/kyoto/timeline.html

March 23:[2005] The federal government and Canada's car makers reach an agreement on emissions standards. Automakers agree that its new vehicles will cut emissions by 5.3 megatonnes by 2010 as part of Ottawa's Kyoto plan.

For God's sake slopoke, give it a rest. You sound like a broken record.

I'm going to be honest. I stopped reading the above after the first sentence. I've heard it all form you before, a 100 times.