someone said:
Slowpoke, I would take you much more seriously if you had complained about the liberal attack ads in the past which were much worse on all counts. The ad I saw was tame by comparison to the liberal ads of the last few elections which told outright lies. Furthermore, I would say that "anyone who claims otherwise is either biased beyond redemption or simply lying through his teeth". I think your response is just sour grapes over your party getting a partial taste of its own medicine.
You're right that I didn't complain about the Lib attack ads. I was supporting Martin so it never crossed my mind. I still didn't like Martin's approach with those ads, or his overall campaign for that matter. But I didn't necessarily see the ads as the gross distortions you apparently did. Harper was a little known western Reform religious conservative (borderline redneck) to many of us here in ON so many of the questions and fears expressed in those Liberal attack ads didn't seem all that far-fetched. Thinking back, I can still see Stockwell twitching away in the background and I still recall how Bush-like Harper seemed in his support for the Iraq war, his denial of the science behind global warming, his Kyoto bashing, his opposition to gay marriage, abortion, and gun control. Never mind that Harper was a former VP of the National Citizen's Coalition who actually said many of the things he is purported to have said. I thought Martin was doing us all a favour by exposing Harper's neocon hidden agenda. Seriously. I've linked to an article describing what the Liberals said about Harper. Much of that stuff was straight from the record so, even now, I don't quite see how you can characterize these as outright lies any more than the Harper ad I'd described earlier in this thread.
BTW, when you refer to Harpers attack ads as "your [my Liberal] party getting a partial taste of its own medicine", you're implying that the Liberals have some kind of patent on attack ads. I'm not saying the Liberals did or didn't invent attack ads but both parties have used them for so many years that we'll probably never know who actually started them or who has been the biggest offender. So, IMHO, it is not strictly correct to suggest the Liberals deserve to be on the receiving end of personal attack ads any more than the CPOC or their PC predecessors. IMHO they're both equally guilty.
I'd said earlier that Harper's ads were "nothing to get excited about" so your sour grapes characterization is a bit unfair. I really don't mind them that much. In fact I was practically sleepwalking through this entire debate until you said: "Thus, the main difference is the liberal ads were lies while the conservative ads seem to just be clips of what other liberals had to say about Dion during leadership debates." I'd seen one of Harper's attack ads that morning so I pointed out that I didn't think it was fair to call the ad I'd seen "just a clip". I still don't but it doesn't mean I found the ad particularly upsetting.
http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNe...attackads_060110/20060110?s_name=election2006
The new ads each feature unflattering close-ups of Harper's face, are accompanied by war-like drumming, and end with the newly-minted Liberal campaign slogan, "Choose Your Canada."
A female announcer challenges his credibility in a number of areas. Perhaps the most far-flung of the ads suggests conservative U.S. donors played a key role in Harper's career.
"Who paid for Stephen Harper's rise to the head of the party?" asks the voice. "We don't know. He refuses to reveal his donors. What do you suppose he's hiding? We do know he's very popular with right wingers in the U.S. They have money, maybe they helped him. We just don't know. He just won't say."
The ads also attack Harper's position on Atlantic Canada. One ad quotes Harper as saying "unfortunately many people in Atlantic Canada feel that it's only through government favours there will be economic progress."
Another closely compares Harper to former Ontario premier Mike Harris.
"Like Stephen Harper, Mike Harris had a right wing agenda. Remember the Common Sense Revolution? Remember the environmental neglect, the shattered social programs, the crumbling schools and hospitals, the huge deficits? Yeah, that Common Sense Revolution. Do we really want to go down that road again?"
The ads also:
Attack Harper's comments to an American think-tank in Montreal when he called the U.S. a light and inspiration to Canadians and the world;
Claim Harper will either have to raise taxes or run a deficit to pay for his campaign promises;
Claim Harper and Bloc Quebecois Leader Gilles Duceppe have a close relationship that will not benefit national unity;
Claim that Harper once said Liberal ridings in the west of Canada are either dominated by recent Asian immigrants or recent migrants from eastern Canada;
Report comments Harper made to an American audience, advising them not to feel bad for Canada's unemployed, who receive "generous social assistance and unemployment assistance," and that Canada is content to become a second-tier social country;
Quote a U.S. newspaper editorial that described Harper as the most pro-U.S. leader in the western world.