Conservative attack adds

someone said:
If that happens it will really make the double standard regarding “attack ads” even more obvious. The Conservatives and T.V. people tried using the same copyright arguments when the liberals used similar footage in the 1988 election and it didn’t work. However, I have noticed that “attack ads” are usually only bad when the Conservatives use them and not when the liberals us them.

Edit: I don’t know about broadcasts but I know that for books you can do a fair amount of copying legality if you acknowledge the source and limit it to something like 10%. I’m not sure why broadcasts would be different.

I don't like attack ads in general and, FWIW, I didn't think much of Martin's attack ads on Harper during the last election. These are probably worse because they are clearly intended to ridicule Dion's personality which goes beyond attacking his record on the environment. If Martin was in copyright violation for footage he used against Harper in the last election, I didn't hear anything about it. I'm not disputing that it happened but it didn't make much of a splash. Also, Martin's ads were intended to generate fear of what Harper might actually DO if he became PM. These attack ads are more about Dion the weakling with the funny accent. Not quite the same.
 
someone said:
Edit: I don’t know about broadcasts but I know that for books you can do a fair amount of copying legality if you acknowledge the source and limit it to something like 10%. I’m not sure why broadcasts would be different.

is this true? can you photocopy 10% of a book and then distribute that 10%?
 
red said:
someone said:
Edit: I don’t know about broadcasts but I know that for books you can do a fair amount of copying legality if you acknowledge the source and limit it to something like 10%. I’m not sure why broadcasts would be different.

is this true? can you photocopy 10% of a book and then distribute that 10%?
I'm not sure that you can distibute it for profit but you can put it on library reserves for students to photocopy as part of course reading as opposed to having to buy the whole book. 10% or one chapter is the rule of thumb I've usually been givin for this type of thing. I would think that this would be similar as no one is reselling the broadcast. However, DQ is the lawyer on the board, so prehaps he has an opinion on this (although American copyright laws may be different).
 
someone said:
red said:
someone said:
Edit: I don’t know about broadcasts but I know that for books you can do a fair amount of copying legality if you acknowledge the source and limit it to something like 10%. I’m not sure why broadcasts would be different.


I'm not sure that you can distibute it for profit but you can put it on library reserves for students to photocopy as part of course reading as opposed to having to buy the whole book. 10% or one chapter is the rule of thumb I've usually been givin for this type of thing. I would think that this would be similar as no one is reselling the broadcast.

maybe not selling the broadcast- but there is an intent to make economic gains- i.e. market share/votes- also broadcasting something on free airwaves is certainly different than making an excerpt available to students.
 
slowpoke said:
I don't like attack ads in general and, FWIW, I didn't think much of Martin's attack ads on Harper during the last election. These are probably worse because they are clearly intended to ridicule Dion's personality which goes beyond attacking his record on the environment.
I’ve only seen clips of the advertisements on the news but they don’t seem bad. Just footage from the leadership convention.

slowpoke said:
If Martin was in copyright violation for footage he used against Harper in the last election, I didn't hear anything about it. I'm not disputing that it happened but it didn't make much of a splash.
First, if you read my post, you will see that it referred to the 1988 election when the liberals (along with the other parties) had agreed that footage from the debates could not be used and then went back on their word. In this case, I doubt very much if the conservatives made any such agreement as they were not involved in the debates.

slowpoke said:
Also, Martin's ads were intended to generate fear of what Harper might actually DO if he became PM. These attack ads are more about Dion the weakling with the funny accent. Not quite the same.
Unless you are naive enough to believe that the liberals really thought there would be troops with guns on the streets threatening people if Harper got elected, you can’t say they were about “what Harper might actually DO if he became PM”. Thus, the main difference is the liberal ads were lies while the conservative ads seem to just be clips of what other liberals had to say about Dion during leadership debates.

Edit: BTW, I do not mean to imply that you are "naive". I just used the word to imply what someone would have to be to beleive to troops in the streets stuff.
 
red said:
someone said:
red said:
maybe not selling the broadcast- but there is an intent to make economic gains- i.e. market share/votes- also broadcasting something on free airwaves is certainly different than making an excerpt available to students.
I doubt that you could make a legal arguement that there are economic gains. I think that you're pretty free to quote what other people have said. Don't forget, the liberals have done the same thing in the past, even when they had argreed not to. Thus, if they got away with it, I can't see the problem here.
 
Last edited:
someone said:
Unless you are naive enough to believe that the liberals really thought there would be troops with guns on the streets threatening people if Harper got elected, you can’t say they were about “what Harper might actually DO if he became PM”. Thus, the main difference is the liberal ads were lies while the conservative ads seem to just be clips of what other liberals had to say about Dion during leadership debates.

without getting into a whole liberal/conservative thing- the ad about weapons in the street was never broadcast.

both sides are grasping-looking-out-for-themselves-lying-political-weasels
 
The Liberals set the bar last year with their ad of soldiers marching into cities when Harper suggested shoring up the emergency military forces near the cities. This ad is at least real footage. Nothing's made up. I think it speaks for itself.

I find it funny that almost everyone I meet who's committed to the environment and has suddenly bought into the Kyoto thing knows virtually nothing about how Kyoto works. When I explain to them that buying credits from China and former Soviet blocks countries is the only way Canada will ever meet it's targets and how much that may cost and that pollution in Canada doesn't even have to go down at all, they're flabbergasted.

What I've noticed is that the Liberals have been better at communicating their message than the Conservatives, at least in Toronto. Does anyone else sense a disconnect between Toronto and the rest of the country? I don't think there's anything the conservatives could do to win one seat in the GTA.

And this is sad because I grew up thinking it was simply a choice between two management teams with slightly different views. As long as you changed teams every once in awhile, you get relatively scandal and corruption free government and didn't let anything drift too far right or left. And even sadder is the lost openess I used to associate with the liberal party. My nieces and nephews ask me why everyone hates Harper so much and I don't know what to tell them. No one wants to debate policy pros and cons anymore. If he represents the conservatives, then by definition, he can be no good. Just what exactly has he done to deserve this in Toronto? Jean Chretien took Toronto for granted for more than ten years and never delivered anything meaningful yet Toronto thinks he's a god.
 
someone said:
red said:
someone said:
I doubt that you could make a legal arguement that there are economic gains. I think that you're pretty free to quote what other people has said. Don't forget, the liberals have done the same thing in the past, even when they had argreed not to. Thus, if they got away with it, I can't see the problem here.

i am only asking questions. I don't know what the legal answer is.

the "whether someone did it before and shouldn't have, but they got away with it- so I am going to do it now" - this is the kind of argument that earned my kids a grounding.

I do find it interesting that many people today do not believe that copyright laws apply anymore. the quote in the thread was from a group of broadcasters who held the copyright for the broadcast- not from the Liberal party. so whether the liberals, NDP or mahatma ghandi did it in the past is irrelevant. whether they had permission from those who owned the copyright is relevant.
 
red said:
without getting into a whole liberal/conservative thing- the ad about weapons in the street was never broadcast.s

But it was freely available on the internet until it was pulled so I don’t think there is a substantive difference.

red said:
both sides are grasping-looking-out-for-themselves-lying-political-weasels

That’s the type that gets attracted to politics. As a friend of mine used to like saying “shit floats”. I think her saying is much more accurate than “cream rises to the top”

red said:
someone said:
red said:
i am only asking questions. I don't know what the legal answer is.

the "whether someone did it before and shouldn't have, but they got away with it- so I am going to do it now" - this is the kind of argument that earned my kids a grounding.

I do find it interesting that many people today do not believe that copyright laws apply anymore. the quote in the thread was from a group of broadcasters who held the copyright for the broadcast- not from the Liberal party. so whether the liberals, NDP or mahatma ghandi did it in the past is irrelevant. whether they had permission from those who owned the copyright is relevant.
But whether the liberals got away with it in the past is a good sign that it is not necessarily illegal. Anyway, prehaps the best thing to do is wait and see how the legal side plays out if and when it gets to court.
 
someone said:
But it was freely available on the internet until it was pulled so I don’t think there is a substantive difference.


well I think there is a difference. one is approved for broadcast, the other is inadvertently on a website for a few hours before it is noticed and then yanked.
 
someone said:
...Unless you are naive enough to believe that the liberals really thought there would be troops with guns on the streets threatening people if Harper got elected, you can’t say they were about “what Harper might actually DO if he became PM”. Thus, the main difference is the liberal ads were lies while the conservative ads seem to just be clips of what other liberals had to say about Dion during leadership debates.

There is a rather convoluted commentary in one of the Harper attack ads where Dion says "we have to return to power" or something similar and suddenly they've twisted that around and the narrator is asking us why we'd want to return to those days of corruption. Since Dion said nothing about returning to corruption, the CPOC attack ad is also an attempt to sell us a lie. Nothing to get excited about but a pretty fair example that these attack ads are NEVER the innocent little clips you're making them out to be.
 
tip said:
What I've noticed is that the Liberals have been better at communicating their message than the Conservatives, at least in Toronto. Does anyone else sense a disconnect between Toronto and the rest of the country? I don't think there's anything the conservatives could do to win one seat in the GTA.

And this is sad because I grew up thinking it was simply a choice between two management teams with slightly different views. As long as you changed teams every once in awhile, you get relatively scandal and corruption free government and didn't let anything drift too far right or left. And even sadder is the lost openess I used to associate with the liberal party. My nieces and nephews ask me why everyone hates Harper so much and I don't know what to tell them. No one wants to debate policy pros and cons anymore. If he represents the conservatives, then by definition, he can be no good. Just what exactly has he done to deserve this in Toronto? Jean Chretien took Toronto for granted for more than ten years and never delivered anything meaningful yet Toronto thinks he's a god.


1. Jean Chretien is a god? this is the first I have heard of this. many in toronto were tired of chretien.
2. If someone is conservative they are automatically bad? not sure I agree with this, but there is certainly an unease with the social agenda that the reform party has. Harper is a reform party guy, whatever he calls himself now. so it doesn't play well in toronto. there are plenty of fiscally conservative people in toronto, but they don't want any one telling them how to live their lives or with who(m?).

3. the conservatives could take plenty of actions to win over toronto- but they don't want to. they could get rid of the harbour commission and give the authority to the city's elected officials where it belongs. they could provide funding for the transportation system and not just a credit for TTC riders- many of which don't make enough to pay taxes. they could appoint someone from toronto to cabinet as they did for montreal. they could treat the premier of ontario with a little bit of respect- whether they agree with him or not. the conservatives and the reform members who control the party hate toronto. they blame toronto for every grievance they have going back to the crow rates and for every societal vice they despise (at least publicly). if they want to win over toronto- they could but you have to try.
 
slowpoke said:
There is a rather convoluted commentary in one of the Harper attack ads where Dion says "we have to return to power" or something similar and suddenly they've twisted that around and the narrator is asking us why we'd want to return to those days of corruption. Since Dion said nothing about returning to corruption, the CPOC attack ad is also an attempt to sell us a lie. Nothing to get excited about but a pretty fair example that these attack ads are NEVER the innocent little clips you're making them out to be.
Perhaps I should wait until I see the whole advertisements. But I'm assuming the news would have shown the worse parts so I can't see how the whole ads would be worse. As I say, I think they are pretty mild compared to what the liberals have done in the past. I suspect that you're just showing your bias when you imply otherwise. BTW, what channel did you see them on?
 
red said:
well I think there is a difference. one is approved for broadcast, the other is inadvertently on a website for a few hours before it is noticed and then yanked.
You mean it was placed on the website to see what the reaction was and then pulled when it was negative. Don't forget, Martin approved of producting the advertisement. Are you saying that he was spending money on it without reason?
 
tip said:
The Liberals set the bar last year with their ad of soldiers marching into cities when Harper suggested shoring up the emergency military forces near the cities. This ad is at least real footage. Nothing's made up. I think it speaks for itself.

I find it funny that almost everyone I meet who's committed to the environment and has suddenly bought into the Kyoto thing knows virtually nothing about how Kyoto works. When I explain to them that buying credits from China and former Soviet blocks countries is the only way Canada will ever meet it's targets and how much that may cost and that pollution in Canada doesn't even have to go down at all, they're flabbergasted.

What I've noticed is that the Liberals have been better at communicating their message than the Conservatives, at least in Toronto. Does anyone else sense a disconnect between Toronto and the rest of the country? I don't think there's anything the conservatives could do to win one seat in the GTA.

And this is sad because I grew up thinking it was simply a choice between two management teams with slightly different views. As long as you changed teams every once in awhile, you get relatively scandal and corruption free government and didn't let anything drift too far right or left. And even sadder is the lost openess I used to associate with the liberal party. My nieces and nephews ask me why everyone hates Harper so much and I don't know what to tell them. No one wants to debate policy pros and cons anymore. If he represents the conservatives, then by definition, he can be no good. Just what exactly has he done to deserve this in Toronto? Jean Chretien took Toronto for granted for more than ten years and never delivered anything meaningful yet Toronto thinks he's a god.

If Harper surrounded himself with a credible management team, he'd sell in Toronto. But there are too many Stockwells simmering on the back burner and too many Ronas doing whatever Harper tells them to do.

Also, you complain about a lack of open debate etc. Harper absolutely hates the Liberals so it is all about politics of opportunity and winning. Harper wants nothing whatever to do with legitimate debate.
 
someone said:
You mean it was placed on the website to see what the reaction was and then pulled when it was negative. Don't forget, Martin approved of producting the advertisement. Are you saying that he was spending money on it without reason?


he did? how do you know?
 
red said:
he did? how do you know?
It was reported at the time that he had signed off on the production of all four ads (or whatever the number of attack ads was, I think it was four). He claimed that that was not the same as approving them for air (which technically is true but if you don't intend to air them, why spend money on them).
 
someone said:
Perhaps I should wait until I see the whole advertisements. But I'm assuming the news would have shown the worse parts so I can't see how the whole ads would be worse. As I say, I think they are pretty mild compared to what the liberals have done in the past. I suspect that you're just showing your bias when you imply otherwise. BTW, what channel did you see them on?

It was this morning on the City news channel. I was in a bagel place getting my morning bagel and coffee. I watched the ad in the small window beside the live coverage from the traffic cameras. As I said, it was nothing to get excited about - just an innocent statement by Dion about the Liberals getting back to power. But the narration definitely tried to spin this by linking Dion's statement with a return to the corruption of sponsorship. I may be biased but I'm not blind. This was simple manipulation. Again, nothing extreme but certainly not the unvarnished little clips you alluded to. You obviously haven't seen the ad.
 
someone said:
It was reported at the time that he had signed off on the production of all four ads (or whatever the number of attack ads was, I think it was four). He claimed that that was not the same as approving them for air (which technically is true but if you don't intend to air them, why spend money on them).


well one could approve a concept and then not approve the final product.