Conservative attack adds

slowpoke said:
It was this morning on the City news channel. I was in a bagel place getting my morning bagel and coffee. I watched the ad in the small window beside the live coverage from the traffic cameras. As I said, it was nothing to get excited about - just an innocent statement by Dion about the Liberals getting back to power. But the narration definitely tried to spin this by linking Dion's statement with a return to the corruption of sponsorship. I may be biased but I'm not blind. This was simple manipulation. Again, nothing extreme but certainly not the unvarnished little clips you alluded to. You obviously haven't seen the ad.
Nothing innocent about what Stephanie said. It shows Dion's desperation for the Lieberals to get back in power. Who wants a scared mouse/rat running the country?

Who ever said the Lieberals were the only governing party that can run Canada? Who ever said that only the Lieberals know what Canadians want? Who wants the Lieberals farking the country up more than it already is? DUH, the Lieberals. The Bloc, NDP and even the Green Party don't want the Lieberals running the country. The Conservative had the balls to let Canadians know what the majority of Canadians already know, and that is we don't want Stephanie Dion or the Lieberals "back in power".
 
someone said:
In the United States they allow utilities to trade pollution credits in the same manner and it has been estimated to have saved many 100s of millions (I don’t have the figures on my finger tips but I can get them when I have more time) over what direct regulation would have cost for the same reduction in pollution. That does not mean Kyoto is necessarily a good thing but it would be worse if it did not allow trading in pollution credits.
The problem with that, was that polluting companies forced a bunch of '70s Cheby 4X4s to the scrap yard so they themselves could continue polluting, without proper compensation to the owners. This is similar to what Kyoto will do. Pay someone else, without cleaning your own backyard up first.
 
johnhenrygalt said:
If true, it wouldn't be the first time a major Canadian federal political party violated copyright. Or does everyone forget the Liberal fuckup in the 2005-6 election campaign where their ads violated copyright?

I actually never noticed the Libs had done the same thing. Or maybe I've just forgotten. Whatever, it didn't do the Liberals any good because they got tossed out on their asses.
 
pussylicker said:
That's Mr Dithers for you.
I could respond as follows: how is it different than saying the reform party wouldn't change the trust laws and then quashing them after they get into power?


But really - have you never asked staff to do something and then the final product looks nothing like what you asked for?
 
johnhenrygalt said:
You can't please all of the people all of the time. The Liberals made a strategic decision over the last couple of elections not to give a shit about the Alberta seats (also about 10% of the electorate).


I am not sure thats true. They do run candidates and anne mclellan from calgary was in the cabinet. No-one from Toronto in harper's cabinet. yes no one elected but that did not stop him in montreal.
 
johnhenrygalt said:
If true, it wouldn't be the first time a major Canadian federal political party violated copyright. Or does everyone forget the Liberal fuckup in the 2005-6 election campaign where their ads violated copyright?


i don't remember hearing about this. Whose copyright did they violate? If they did then they should be held accountable just like if the reformers did they should be held accountable
 
pussylicker said:
And McGimpy hates Harper. With all the lies and farking McGimpy's done, he doesn't deserve any respect.


McGuinty is the premier of ontario and is representing the interests of 30% or more of the country. Harper has acted like a petulant child and had been disrespectful not just of the premier but of the whole province. If you don't care about your own province then I guess you would like this.

Can you tell me all the lies that McGuinty is attributed with. thanks
 
pussylicker said:
Nothing innocent about what Stephanie said. It shows Dion's desperation for the Lieberals to get back in power. Who wants a scared mouse/rat running the country?

Who ever said the Lieberals were the only governing party that can run Canada? Who ever said that only the Lieberals know what Canadians want? Who wants the Lieberals farking the country up more than it already is? DUH, the Lieberals. The Bloc, NDP and even the Green Party don't want the Lieberals running the country. The Conservative had the balls to let Canadians know what the majority of Canadians already know, and that is we don't want Stephanie Dion or the Lieberals "back in power".


well according to the recent polls the liberals are tied or ahead of the conservatives- so a majority don't want the conservatives in power either. did Harper have the balls to say that or does he keep talking about how much he would like a majority and how much has enjoyed being the PM during the past year. all politicians seek to form the gov't- this is the whole point.
 
pussylicker said:
Nothing innocent about what Stephanie said. It shows Dion's desperation for the Lieberals to get back in power. Who wants a scared mouse/rat running the country?

Who ever said the Lieberals were the only governing party that can run Canada? Who ever said that only the Lieberals know what Canadians want? Who wants the Lieberals farking the country up more than it already is? DUH, the Lieberals. The Bloc, NDP and even the Green Party don't want the Lieberals running the country. The Conservative had the balls to let Canadians know what the majority of Canadians already know, and that is we don't want Stephanie Dion or the Lieberals "back in power".

I don't know who said the Liberals were the only governing party and I don't care. People say all kinds of crazy stuff. The governing party is the one who gets the votes. Full stop.

As far as Dion saying "we have to get back in power", I'd be pretty worried about him if he said he DIDN'T want to get back into power. WTF kind of a leader would ever say that? Think about it....
 
someone said:
I did not mean to imply that.

BTW, it seems that a liberal admits that the Tories are copying their methods:

"As negative ads go, even Liberals concede they may be effective. One former high-ranking Grit said the Tories have taken a page from the Liberal handbook by running images of their opponents' leader and superimposing his own words at the bottom of the screen against him. "
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20070130.wxanalysis30/BNStory/National/home

I'll withhold further comment until I've seen an entire ad.

Your article also points out the risks inherent in these attack ads. IMHO, these risks are unwarranted at this stage because Harper has plenty of time to put forward sound environmental strategies that would diminish Dion's slight advantage in the polls. The ads make Harper appear desperate which validates Dion's stature as the one to beat. Here is the part of your article I'm talking about:

..."But there are those who say that there are also a couple of significant risks in the Conservative strategy.

On one level, the Tories may be elevating Mr. Dion's stature by focusing their attacks so heavily on him. That's bad news for Mr. Harper's potential ally, NDP Leader Jack Layton, whose efforts have been to make the Liberals irrelevant.

On another and perhaps more significant level, the ads may leave the Tories open to criticism that they are simply being opportunistic.

One former Conservative ad executive suggested that the approach may be dangerous for the Tories because it risks making them look more intent on winning a spin war than on fixing what may turn out to be this generation's most significant public-policy difficulty.

"They show the Conservatives are worried about Dion but more importantly, they'll simply reinforce Canadians' perception that the government isn't serious about the environment and views it as a PR battle to be won," the executive said.

If the Conservatives really believe they've lost the battle on the environment, then they may also believe there's little risk in this approach. Invalidate the Liberal advantage, goes the theory, because you can't make up the ground anyway.

But if the Tories start looking like all they care about is taking down Mr. Dion, then they better hope it works. Because if he somehow survives the assault intact, the next debate may be about how much the Tories themselves care about what may be the most significant issue of our day."
 
i think its kind of like retailers putting up christmas decorations in september.
 
red said:
I am not sure thats true. They do run candidates and anne mclellan from calgary was in the cabinet.

Perhaps one reason the liberals have problems in Alberta is that they and their supporters don’t even know the difference between Calgary and Edmonton. Given the historic rivalry between the two cities, I would recommend that you not make the same mistake if you are ever in an Albertan spots bar when their two teams meet. No offense, but I do think that is one reason Toronto is disliked in the rest of the country.

Slowpoke, I never meant to say the strategy would work, only that the advertisements are no more negative then those the liberals use. I saw one on T.V. this morning and it wasn't so bad. BTW, you might be interested in the editorial the Globe had on the advertisements yesterday (Unfortunately, there are no free links).
 
someone said:
.....Slowpoke, I never meant to say the strategy would work, only that the advertisements are no more negative then those the liberals us. I saw one on T.V. this morning and it wasn't so bad. BTW, you might be interested in the editorial the Globe had on the advertisements yesterday (Unfortunately, there are not free links).

The summary of yesterday's Globe editorial seems to downplay these so-called attack ads which is fine. But I have to disagree with the Globe's assertion that these ads contain "no distortion and barely a touch of innuendo". That is just plain bullshit. They contain a hefty dollop of both (innuendo and distortion). Anyone who claims otherwise is either biased beyond redemption or simply lying through his teeth. Also, where is this guy getting this "suggestion that Canadians are too namby-pamby to tolerate political leaders who point out the weaknesses, real or otherwise, of their opponents?" Canadians love to see their leaders savage each other. That's half the fun of politics. This guy must get paid by the word. This is the Globe's summary:

Attack ads? Hardly
These are attack ads? The Conservative Party's paid television commercials challenge Liberal Leader Stephane Dion on his party's environmental record, on being part of a scandal-plagued party and on (allegedly) being a poor leader. There is no distortion and barely a touch of innuendo. Yet some voices have criticized these as attack ads. Is the suggestion that Canadians are too namby-pamby to tolerate political leaders who point out the weaknesses, real or otherwise, of their opponents?
 
slowpoke said:
The summary of yesterday's Globe editorial seems to downplay these so-called attack ads which is fine. But I have to disagree with the Globe's assertion that these ads contain "no distortion and barely a touch of innuendo". That is just plain bullshit. They contain a hefty dollop of both (innuendo and distortion). Anyone who claims otherwise is either biased beyond redemption or simply lying through his teeth. Also, where is this guy getting this "suggestion that Canadians are too namby-pamby to tolerate political leaders who point out the weaknesses, real or otherwise, of their opponents?" Canadians love to see their leaders savage each other. That's half the fun of politics. This guy must get paid by the word. This is the Globe's summary:

Attack ads? Hardly
These are attack ads? The Conservative Party's paid television commercials challenge Liberal Leader Stephane Dion on his party's environmental record, on being part of a scandal-plagued party and on (allegedly) being a poor leader. There is no distortion and barely a touch of innuendo. Yet some voices have criticized these as attack ads. Is the suggestion that Canadians are too namby-pamby to tolerate political leaders who point out the weaknesses, real or otherwise, of their opponents?

Slowpoke, I would take you much more seriously if you had complained about the liberal attack ads in the past which were much worse on all counts. The ad I saw was tame by comparison to the liberal ads of the last few elections which told outright lies. Furthermore, I would say that "anyone who claims otherwise is either biased beyond redemption or simply lying through his teeth". I think your response is just sour grapes over your party getting a partial taste of its own medicine.
 
red said:
I could respond as follows: how is it different than saying the reform party wouldn't change the trust laws and then quashing them after they get into power?


But really - have you never asked staff to do something and then the final product looks nothing like what you asked for?
I know what you are saying, but Mr Dithers never governed with a consistant or clear mind. All he was concerned about was the flags flying on his little boats while avoiding paying Canadian taxes. Avoidance without getting caught was the only thing he didn't waiver on.

As far as the income trust laws go, reality forced a decision to tax or you and I would continue to pay high amounts of taxes unnecessarily. Why should corps be allowed to run like lemmings to convert their companies so they could defer income to shareholders to avoid taxes while the shareholders don't pay until they take the final win or loss? Oops, you don't pay if it is a loss.
 
red said:
McGuinty is the premier of ontario and is representing the interests of 30% or more of the country. Harper has acted like a petulant child and had been disrespectful not just of the premier but of the whole province. If you don't care about your own province then I guess you would like this.

Can you tell me all the lies that McGuinty is attributed with. thanks
With only 25% of the actual eligable voters voting for him, McGimpy isn't truly representing 30% of Canada. He has broken just as many promises as the Federal Lieberals and their Red Book BS. He talks out of the side of his mouth just as much as Mean Jean did.