someone said:If that happens it will really make the double standard regarding “attack ads” even more obvious. The Conservatives and T.V. people tried using the same copyright arguments when the liberals used similar footage in the 1988 election and it didn’t work. However, I have noticed that “attack ads” are usually only bad when the Conservatives use them and not when the liberals us them.
Edit: I don’t know about broadcasts but I know that for books you can do a fair amount of copying legality if you acknowledge the source and limit it to something like 10%. I’m not sure why broadcasts would be different.
I don't like attack ads in general and, FWIW, I didn't think much of Martin's attack ads on Harper during the last election. These are probably worse because they are clearly intended to ridicule Dion's personality which goes beyond attacking his record on the environment. If Martin was in copyright violation for footage he used against Harper in the last election, I didn't hear anything about it. I'm not disputing that it happened but it didn't make much of a splash. Also, Martin's ads were intended to generate fear of what Harper might actually DO if he became PM. These attack ads are more about Dion the weakling with the funny accent. Not quite the same.

