Conservative attack adds

Anyone remember the Kim Campbell attack ad on Chretien's facial paralysis?That one actually ran for two days before Campbell pulled it. So what if it was 1988? It was the absolute worst kind of ad because it was a personal attack, unrelated to the actual politics of the day or the character of the subject.

http://www.cbc.ca/canadavotes/analysiscommentary/negativeads.html

Even the most infamous attack ad in Canadian history was beginning to sway voters to the Progressive Conservatives when then leader Kim Campbell abruptly pulled it from the airwaves during the 1993 campaign, says one of the men responsible for it.

The spot, conceived by Allan Gregg and Tom Scott, showed photos of Jean Chrétien's distorted face while voices said, "Does this look like a prime minister?" and "I personally would be very embarrassed if he were to become prime minister of Canada."

Gregg insists in Warren Kinsella's book Kicking Ass in Canadian Politics that Tories who had seen the ad before it aired somehow missed the fact that it could be seen as a slur against a physical deformity caused by facial paralysis Chrétien suffered in his youth. The firestorm the ad created led to Campbell ordering it off the air within two days.
 
slowpoke said:
I may be biased but I'm not blind.

I did not mean to imply that.

BTW, it seems that a liberal admits that the Tories are copying their methods:

"As negative ads go, even Liberals concede they may be effective. One former high-ranking Grit said the Tories have taken a page from the Liberal handbook by running images of their opponents' leader and superimposing his own words at the bottom of the screen against him. "
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20070130.wxanalysis30/BNStory/National/home

I'll withhold further comment until I've seen an entire ad.
 
tip said:
I find it funny that almost everyone I meet who's committed to the environment and has suddenly bought into the Kyoto thing knows virtually nothing about how Kyoto works. When I explain to them that buying credits from China and former Soviet blocks countries is the only way Canada will ever meet it's targets and how much that may cost and that pollution in Canada doesn't even have to go down at all, they're flabbergasted.

What I've noticed is that the Liberals have been better at communicating their message than the Conservatives, at least in Toronto. Does anyone else sense a disconnect between Toronto and the rest of the country? I don't think there's anything the conservatives could do to win one seat in the GTA.

.

I agree with you. People generally aren't that bright when it comes to complex agreements that politicians try to sell with pictures of baby animals. It's a stupid agreement and if we had had a colder than average winter, such as in 2003/4, there wouldn't be the level of silly rhetoric that the press is currently spewing. Politicians can't evaluate and plot the right long term course of action when the sheep:)are bleeting in their ear. They get distracted easily and all they want to do is count the sheep.

I think that Toronto is different because it is a greater melting pot than any other Canadian city ( except Vancouver maybe?) and the Conservatives have a reputation ( encouraged by the Liberals) of catering to a waspish membership.Until they have been in power long enough so that people see that they aren't actually going to put on hooded robes with GWB on the back there will be this uneasiness here.
 
tip said:
I find it funny that almost everyone I meet who's committed to the environment and has suddenly bought into the Kyoto thing knows virtually nothing about how Kyoto works. When I explain to them that buying credits from China and former Soviet blocks countries is the only way Canada will ever meet it's targets and how much that may cost and that pollution in Canada doesn't even have to go down at all, they're flabbergasted.

I'm always amazed at how little people know about Kyoto. Generally speaking, the ones who know the least are the most supportive.

tip said:
What I've noticed is that the Liberals have been better at communicating their message than the Conservatives, at least in Toronto. Does anyone else sense a disconnect between Toronto and the rest of the country? I don't think there's anything the conservatives could do to win one seat in the GTA.

The Conservatives have won seats in the GTA, just not in the city itself. Toronto votes the way it votes and it has nothing to do with how messages are communicated.

Since Toronto is far from a representation of the rest of Canada, I doubt Harper or the Conservatives care one way or the other.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
Since Toronto is far from a representation of the rest of Canada, I doubt Harper or the Conservatives care one way or the other.


thats why they don't get elected. they don't like toronto.
 
red said:
thats why they don't get elected. they don't like toronto.

....and Toronto doesn't like them. The Liberals and NDP will continue to get the lion share of seats in the city no matter what they do (or do not do).

With that in mind, the opinion of the Toronto voters causes little concern to Harper, the Conservatives or the rest of Canada.
 
tip said:
I find it funny that almost everyone I meet who's committed to the environment and has suddenly bought into the Kyoto thing knows virtually nothing about how Kyoto works. When I explain to them that buying credits from China and former Soviet blocks countries is the only way Canada will ever meet it's targets and how much that may cost and that pollution in Canada doesn't even have to go down at all, they're flabbergasted.

Yes! I actually have to stop myself short of calling people idiots for hating the Tories cause they pulled out of Kyoto. We should be kissing their asses, thanking them (especially Rona's...meeeooow;) )--not only have they saved Canada money, but they stood up for the truth. There have been at least two independent studies from North American universities (on out of Guelph) that tore to shreds the original research that Kyoto was based on.

Kyoto is like busy work at the office. It's like having that Microsoft Word document up on the screen so if anyone looks in, it looks like you're working on something. Kyoto does absolutely no good for the environment whatsoever, but if you pull the line and say you're part of it, well, it looks like you're doing something so people are happy.
 
i have never read the kyoto agreement but I see from this thread that a number of the members have. can they summarize the agreement?
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
....

With that in mind, the opinion of the Toronto voters causes little concern to Harper, the Conservatives or the rest of Canada.


what a nice sentiment. the opinions of 10% (or more?) of Canadians don't matter to Harper and the conservatives.
 
tip said:
When I explain to them that buying credits from China and former Soviet blocks countries is the only way Canada will ever meet it's targets and how much that may cost and that pollution in Canada doesn't even have to go down at all, they're flabbergasted.
:

I’m not really a fan of Kyoto but, in principle, there is nothing wrong with what you describe. If China and the former Soviet Union can reduce pollution at a lower cost than Canada, it makes since to pay them to do so. In the United States they allow utilities to trade pollution credits in the same manner and it has been estimated to have saved many 100s of millions (I don’t have the figures on my finger tips but I can get them when I have more time) over what direct regulation would have cost for the same reduction in pollution. That does not mean Kyoto is necessarily a good thing but it would be worse if it did not allow trading in pollution credits.

Of course part of the problem with Kyoto is that some of the Russian reduction would have happened anyway due to their economic collapse since the signing of Kyoto. Thus, buying from them is not necessarily creating an overall reduction that would not have happenned anyway. However, that is not so much a problem with the idea of tradeable permits as the fact that no one expected the decline in the Russian economy after Kyoto was signed.
 
red said:
what a nice sentiment. the opinions of 10% (or more?) of Canadians don't matter to Harper and the conservatives.

You can't please all of the people all of the time. The Liberals made a strategic decision over the last couple of elections not to give a shit about the Alberta seats (also about 10% of the electorate).
 
slowpoke said:
This could be interesting. Harper doesn't seem to have permission to use that footage. The CPOC won't even say how they got their hands on it. If the CPOC are in copyright violation with these ads, they'll look like assholes who can't even do a good smear without spilling most of the shit on themselves. Talk about blowback!

If true, it wouldn't be the first time a major Canadian federal political party violated copyright. Or does everyone forget the Liberal fuckup in the 2005-6 election campaign where their ads violated copyright?
 
tip said:
...
What I've noticed is that the Liberals have been better at communicating their message than the Conservatives, at least in Toronto. Does anyone else sense a disconnect between Toronto and the rest of the country? I don't think there's anything the conservatives could do to win one seat in the GTA.
...
Travel and discussion anywhere in TROC (the rest of Canada) produces regular dispassion to all things Toronto.

The GTA has returned Liberals and NDP for a long time due to the particular residential demographic of several decades. With the huge bulding boom, all occupied by young and middle aged reasonably affluent voters, the GTA residential demographic is greatly changing. I suspect that conservative MP's will be elected in GTA ridings very soon.
 
red said:
without getting into a whole liberal/conservative thing- the ad about weapons in the street was never broadcast.
Wha cha talkin bout Willis? I saw da ad on TV
 
slowpoke said:
Canadian Press

OTTAWA --The television ads, which began airing Monday, use footage from last fall's Liberal leadership debates to deliver the message that the new Grit leader is weak, indecisive and an environmental failure. But that footage belongs to a consortium of TV networks which pooled their resources to provide live coverage of the debates. The Cable Public Affairs Channel provided the pool camera for each debate.

CPAC anchor Peter Van Dusen said Monday that any outside use of debate video would have to be approved by all pool members. Moreover, he said such video is traditionally never authorized for use by political parties.
First of all, I knew about it saturday night, and saw them on sunday, so CTV is dead wrong about first airtime. And I'm sure Jack and Gilles went up the hill and discussed it and approve it, as it helps out both the NDP and Bloc. At least they didn't put words in Stephanies mouth. Dryden and Iggy both went after Stephanie. Whether the rat is weak, indecisive or a failure, he and only he left no imagination, as Stephanie said what Stephanie said.

Besides Stephanie is just power hungry. See the job has already gone to his head. He wants to be back in the drivers seat as bad as Mr Dithers wanted to win a majority. Oops, I guess Mr Dithers was a failure too. Couldn't fill the boots of Mean Jean, and only got a minority.
 
someone said:
red said:
someone said:
I doubt that you could make a legal arguement that there are economic gains. I think that you're pretty free to quote what other people have said. Don't forget, the liberals have done the same thing in the past, even when they had argreed not to. Thus, if they got away with it, I can't see the problem here.
True. On the other hand, there were economic gains to be made by the Lieberals if they had stayed in power, and kept picking the pockets of taxpayers to line their own. But that was based on TV ads saying "Harper is 'evil', and we (meaning the Lieberals) can't trust him".
 
red said:
3. the conservatives could treat the premier of ontario with a little bit of respect- whether they agree with him or not. the conservatives and the reform members who control the party hate toronto. they blame toronto for every grievance they have going back to the crow rates and for every societal vice they despise (at least publicly). if they want to win over toronto- they could but you have to try.
And McGimpy hates Harper. With all the lies and farking McGimpy's done, he doesn't deserve any respect.