Charlottesville Car Death

Status
Not open for further replies.
No. You are just desperately looking for evidence that the woman wasn't killed by Fields.

What evidence have you seen that Heyer was killed by Fields? The fact that she was somewhere near the collision? I can find no statement by anyone, including her mother (who presumably spoke with both the police as well as those who attended the rally with her daughter) which claims she was actually struck by the car. The public information is that her proximate cause of death was heart failure. Of course, heart failure could be a result of trauma from a car collision, but where is the evidence that is what happened to her? There are many other plausible explanations for heart failure, including: 1) shock, 2) stress from overheating, 3) physical exhaustion, 4) physical trauma from a source other than the car (e.g. being pushed to the ground by the crowd who were either trying to avoid the car, or otherwise), etc. She was in terrible physical shape at the time of her death (contrary to the older photo of her circulated by the press when she died). How, exactly, have you been able to eliminate all these other possibilities?

It's the same absence of critical thinking that left so many in shock at the outcome of the Ghomeshi trial. You can say, like some, that you don't care exactly how it happened, because you're convinced that the car was driven into the protesters as intentional attempt to injure/kill others (another conclusion that we don't have enough facts to reach), but I guarantee you that the criminal court will care.
 
Why would the FBI know what they are talking about, especially in a thread about a right wing terror attack in the US?

Agreed,... why would the FBI know what they are talking about as far as universally accepted definitions of terrorism.
And so you are now a self proclaimed expert on the definition of terrorism,... ???

No. You are just desperately looking for evidence that the woman wasn't killed by Fields. I don't think you even have enough to qualify as a theory. Maybe I'll substitute "ramblings" for "theory".

I'm not "looking" for anything,... other than what the definition of a right wing terrorist is,...
And have no theory about the event.
But it seems that you have a "theory".

I haven't even commented on the event,... so maybe you should do some reading in the thread, before you make false comments.
 
What evidence have you seen that Heyer was killed by Fields?

The police charged him with murder.
They looked at the evidence and decided there was enough evidence to charge him with murder.

Fields, who is accused of killing one person and wounding 19 others, has already been charged with second-degree murder, three counts of malicious wounding and failure to stop in an accident that resulted in death. The five additional charges include two more counts of malicious wounding and three counts of aggravated malicious wounding, police said.
http://www.cnn.com/2017/08/18/us/charlottesville-james-alex-fields-charges/index.html

Chance are that they have access to more evidence then some neo-nazi wanna be trolling 4chan and stormcloud websites for 'evidence'.
 
The police charged him with murder.
They looked at the evidence and decided there was enough evidence to charge him with murder.


http://www.cnn.com/2017/08/18/us/charlottesville-james-alex-fields-charges/index.html

Chance are that they have access to more evidence then some neo-nazi wanna be trolling 4chan and stormcloud websites for 'evidence'.

Interesting article about 4chan and the type of fake news that they churn out, is even pummeling search sites like Google.

https://techcrunch.com/2017/10/02/h...gas-shooting-showed-up-on-google-top-stories/
 
What evidence have you seen that Heyer was killed by Fields? ....

Other than the police and District Attorney feeling they have enough evidence to convict Fields for her death and the injuries to the dozen or so others?

Sorry but I'll trust the US legal system far more than I trust some random youtube conspiracy nuts.
 
Other than the police and District Attorney feeling they have enough evidence to convict Fields for her death and the injuries to the dozen or so others?

Sorry but I'll trust the US legal system far more than I trust some random youtube conspiracy nuts.

Although an example of the Canadian system at work, did you also feel the police had enough evidence to convict Ghomeshi? What about the police that arrested and charged that black teenager in Whitby? How about Guy Paul Morin? For American examples, how about the police who investigated the cops who were charged in Baltimore? Or OJ Simpson?

Most police try to do their job, but there can be a lot of pressure to bring specific charges in some cases. Sometimes bringing charges, and then later having the crown either reduce them to what they should be or drop them altogether, is the only way to diffuse intense political pressure and avoid public unrest. That was certainly the case in Baltimore.

You really should learn what a conspiracy is if you're going to continue to use that term. Unless you're claiming that some of the videos that were posted are fraudulent or have been deceptively edited, they are just eyewitness accounts, incomplete in themselves, but part of the evidentiary foundation.
 
Last edited:
The police charged him with murder.
They looked at the evidence and decided there was enough evidence to charge him with murder.


http://www.cnn.com/2017/08/18/us/charlottesville-james-alex-fields-charges/index.html

Chance are that they have access to more evidence then some neo-nazi wanna be trolling 4chan and stormcloud websites for 'evidence'.

The police probably have more video evidence that they are not willing to release until after it has been provided as evidence in the court.
All the same this guy is a white supremacist, so I am not too sure why people are concerned about him.
 
The police probably have more video evidence that they are not willing to release until after it has been provided as evidence in the court.
All the same this guy is a white supremacist, so I am not too sure why people are concerned about him.

Not only that but I'm sure they interviewed all the eyewitnesses separately, and can check if anyone's stories doesn't match the others.

But bud plug does have the power of stormcloud and youtube behind him.
 
Why would the FBI know what they are talking about, especially in a thread about a right wing terror attack in the US?

So according to you, that was an act of terrorism,... but the killing of 58 in Vegas,... "and the FBI further confirmed that "no evidence at this point to say it was an act of domestic terrorism.",... was NOT,...???

And you still want to stand by your FBI's definition of terrorism,...???

If I was you,... I would look else where for your sources.
 
The police probably have more video evidence that they are not willing to release until after it has been provided as evidence in the court.
All the same this guy is a white supremacist, so I am not too sure why people are concerned about him.

That's interesting. You're operating on the theory that the police had their own surveillance trained on this particular intersection at the exact time of the incident? Why would they be doing that? Or do you believe that the police can prevent witnesses who made videos from releasing them to the internet because they will be later relied upon at the trial?

Here's a revelation for you, the police can only control the release of evidence which they create through their own interviews or forensic analysis. They don't control the distribution of videos shot by citizens, even if they want to rely upon them as evidence. In this day and age, it would be extremely rare for someone who shot critical video of this sort of event not to upload/publish it (whether to monetize it, or for other reasons). They also cannot prevent witnesses from giving interviews to the media about what they saw, even if they will be later called upon to testify at the trial.
 
That's interesting. You're operating on the theory that the police had their own surveillance trained on this particular intersection at the exact time of the incident? Why would they be doing that? Or do you believe that the police can prevent witnesses who made videos from releasing them to the internet because they will be later relied upon at the trial?

Here's a revelation for you, the police can only control the release of evidence which they create through their own interviews or forensic analysis. They don't control the distribution of videos shot by citizens, even if they want to rely upon them as evidence. In this day and age, it would be extremely rare for someone who shot critical video of this sort of event not to upload/publish it (whether to monetize it, or for other reasons). They also cannot prevent witnesses from giving interviews to the media about what they saw, even if they will be later called upon to testify at the trial.

And a revelation for you.
Police will have access to security cameras from businesses in the area as well as any traffic or other cameras installed by the city.
And if police interview people and seize their phones as evidence, with video, how do you expect witnesses to post it?
 
And a revelation for you.
Police will have access to security cameras from businesses in the area as well as any traffic or other cameras installed by the city.
And if police interview people and seize their phones as evidence, with video, how do you expect witnesses to post it?
Butt Plug obfuscation aka utter noise-nonsense masquerading as scholarly legal genius.
 
Butt Plug obfuscation aka utter noise-nonsense masquerading as scholarly legal genius.

Anbarandy, haven't seen you in a while!

It's always a mistake to jump on Frank's tattered coat tails, as he'll normally just drag you into the logical ditch with him. I'm normally spared the waste of time it is to read his posts, since I have him on perma-ignore. However, since you've chosen to quote him and refer to me, I guess I should say something about it in order to respond to you.

Frank's point is, once again, a silly one. Guess how the police find citizen videos related to crime investigations? They find them on the internet, like everyone else! In fact, a number of the videos related to this incident were live streams. As to private security cameras, these usually are focused on a customer's property, not the middle of a public intersection, but to indulge that possibility, normal (and good) practice is to copy the company video before surrendering the original recording to the police (in fact, most systems have built in backups that create copies automatically). The City of Charlottesville might have traffic cameras at this intersection or they might not. It's only a small city of 45,000 people, so it seems unlikely that they have many such expensive cameras at many of their intersections. Did you know that a city the size of Toronto only has approximately 150 red light cameras and only had 77 up until this year?

And of course, all of which begs the question of what more videos could possibly show us that we haven't already seen in relation to Heyer? No video is going to show us Heyer getting hit by the car at it moved forward to impact. At most, there might be some chain reaction between the car collision and her collapsing on the sidewalk. Or not.

It is odd how Frank keeps posting in a style that makes it appear that we are engaged in a discussion with one another, when he knows we are not. Figuring that behaviour out, however, is well outside of my field of expertise.
 
Frank's point is, once again, a silly one. Guess how the police find citizen videos related to crime investigations? They find them on the internet, like everyone else! In fact, a number of the videos related to this incident were live streams. As to private security cameras, these usually are focused on a customer's property, not the middle of a public intersection, but to indulge that possibility, normal (and good) practice is to copy the company video before surrendering the original recording to the police (in fact, most systems have built in backups that create copies automatically). The City of Charlottesville might have traffic cameras at this intersection or they might not. It's only a small city of 45,000 people, so it seems unlikely that they have many such expensive cameras at many of their intersections. Did you know that a city the size of Toronto only has approximately 150 red light cameras and only had 77 up until this year?

And of course, all of which begs the question of what more videos could possibly show us that we haven't already seen in relation to Heyer? No video is going to show us Heyer getting hit by the car at it moved forward to impact. At most, there might be some chain reaction between the car collision and her collapsing on the sidewalk. Or not.

It is odd how Frank keeps posting in a style that makes it appear that we are engaged in a discussion with one another, when he knows we are not. Figuring that behaviour out, however, is well outside of my field of expertise.

Just because Bud Plug won't see these responses doesn't mean its not worth posting for the board.

Bud sounds particularly silly trying to claim that police only get video evidence off of youtube, by the way. What next, all criminal investigations will now be run through facebook only?
Just as he sounds silly claiming that nobody posts a security camera that monitors the doors or outside of their business.
 
And a revelation for you.
Police will have access to security cameras from businesses in the area as well as any traffic or other cameras installed by the city.
And if police interview people and seize their phones as evidence, with video, how do you expect witnesses to post it?

Absolutely 100% correct. In almost all cases, these particular security camera videos are not posted online at the request of the FBI and the investigation units.
If that piece of thrash did not kill Heather Heyer as the right wing groups are implying, why are there NO PROTESTS from the KKK, White supremacists and other alt right groups. Again, there is enough of evidence to convict him of attempted murder with intent. Wonder why Bad Plug is feeling so sorry that he is in prison, as he is considered to have committed acts of terrorism.
 
Anbarandy, haven't seen you in a while!

It's always a mistake to jump on Frank's tattered coat tails, as he'll normally just drag you into the logical ditch with him. I'm normally spared the waste of time it is to read his posts, since I have him on perma-ignore. However, since you've chosen to quote him and refer to me, I guess I should say something about it in order to respond to you.

Frank's point is, once again, a silly one. Guess how the police find citizen videos related to crime investigations? They find them on the internet, like everyone else! In fact, a number of the videos related to this incident were live streams. As to private security cameras, these usually are focused on a customer's property, not the middle of a public intersection, but to indulge that possibility, normal (and good) practice is to copy the company video before surrendering the original recording to the police (in fact, most systems have built in backups that create copies automatically). The City of Charlottesville might have traffic cameras at this intersection or they might not. It's only a small city of 45,000 people, so it seems unlikely that they have many such expensive cameras at many of their intersections. Did you know that a city the size of Toronto only has approximately 150 red light cameras and only had 77 up until this year?

And of course, all of which begs the question of what more videos could possibly show us that we haven't already seen in relation to Heyer? No video is going to show us Heyer getting hit by the car at it moved forward to impact. At most, there might be some chain reaction between the car collision and her collapsing on the sidewalk. Or not.

It is odd how Frank keeps posting in a style that makes it appear that we are engaged in a discussion with one another, when he knows we are not. Figuring that behaviour out, however, is well outside of my field of expertise.

BUD,... you have to understand that people do exist with absolutely no personal credibility & integrity, a complete lack of character,... and think their behaviour is normal and acceptable,... can actually look at themselves in a mirror,... and feel just fine about themselves.

But never turn your back on them.

Thankfully,... they are few and far between.
 
Although an example of the Canadian system at work, ....

So this whole post is you pretending that you have more evidence than the police and district attorney.

If the DA decides that the evidence doesn't support the charges they will drop them. They haven't.
 
So according to you, that was an act of terrorism,... but the killing of 58 in Vegas,... "and the FBI further confirmed that "no evidence at this point to say it was an act of domestic terrorism.",... was NOT,...???...

According to the FBI, not me. But of course you know better.


And the commonly accepted definition of terrorism is an attack on civilians meant to promote a political cause. As of yet we have no idea if there was a cause or if he was just a violent nut.
 
According to the FBI, not me. But of course you know better.

So you don't have an opinion on what constitutes terrorism,... only what you read some US agency stated,... best to stay out of the discussion then backetcase.


And the commonly accepted definition of terrorism is an attack on civilians meant to promote a political cause. As of yet we have no idea if there was a cause or if he was just a violent nut.

Which confirms nobody has a fricken clue.
 
So you don't have an opinion on what constitutes terrorism,... only what you read some US agency stated,... best to stay out of the discussion then backetcase.




Which confirms nobody has a fricken clue.

????

Do you realize how stupid it is to argue against the definitions of the FBI when it comes to terrorism in the US?


p.s. If you had the ability to read a full two sentences, you would see my definition of terrorism in the post you quoted.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.