Car question - car shakes when braking

newtohobby

New member
Jul 22, 2006
445
0
0
So I replaced the rotors and pads on my car. On highway speeds, when braking, the car shakes. I brought it in to get checked out and theres nothing wrong with the suspension or with the brakes that they can see. Any recommendations?
 
So I replaced the rotors and pads on my car. On highway speeds, when braking, the car shakes. I brought it in to get checked out and theres nothing wrong with the suspension or with the brakes that they can see. Any recommendations?
Just a guess, but maybe the new rotors are fucked up? Sounds like what happens when rotors are worn or re-machined poorly.
 
If your new rotors and set of brake pads are in perfect condition, then you should check that the rotors are seated properly. The new brake pads come with a synthetic grease that you have to apply to the edge of the pads so that they do not bind up. Check your instructions that came with the pads. Check 9:00 on the video

Question : Are the rotors new or machined? Very few places still machine rotors because they are so inexpensive these days.


 
Just a guess, but maybe the new rotors are fucked up? Sounds like what happens when rotors are worn or re-machined poorly.

I think you right. I had a same problem but it was my fault. After the break repair I used my new break very roughly and not giving a few days light using to work together properly. I fucked up my new rotors and I had to change again but it was my learning money. Since then I didn't have any problem.
 
Or it could be because it's brand new.

I've felt this before when I've changed the pads/rotors and it takes a bit to settle. After a week or so, shaking was gone.
 
brand new


If your new rotors and set of brake pads are in perfect condition, then you should check that the rotors are seated properly. The new brake pads come with a synthetic grease that you have to apply to the edge of the pads so that they do not bind up. Check your instructions that came with the pads. Check 9:00 on the video

Question : Are the rotors new or machined? Very few places still machine rotors because they are so inexpensive these days.


 
If the discs and pads are new I would check the seating of the discs and then put some brake lube on the edges of the brake pads. It could be just one edge of a brake pad binding up with old grease and dust.
 
Warped discs and that happens when your on the highway in stop and go traffic and you hit water or a downpour of rain. Worst thing for your rotors , it brings the heat down so drastically that it warps your discs!!
Nothing you can do about it especially on a highway.
 
Could be cheap parts. Many garages use the cheaper variety to get you back for more brake jobs. Water can get the rotors out of round in a hurry. If you use top quality parts, I found it made a huge difference. And someone you know putting them on.
 
Could be cheap parts. Many garages use the cheaper variety to get you back for more brake jobs. Water can get the rotors out of round in a hurry. If you use top quality parts, I found it made a huge difference. And someone you know putting them on.

Not true, unless there made of titanium. This happened to me on a brand new BMW with original parts. I had just come back from Florida and my discs were warped.
It was on warranty and they replaced them but the service mgr a good friend of mine, explained the reason why.
 
New rotors r nfg. No factory guarantee. Probably low cost Chinese. Get the rotors replaced with quality rotors. End of story.
 
New rotors r nfg. No factory guarantee. Probably low cost Chinese. Get the rotors replaced with quality rotors. End of story.
+1
Never buy the cheap stuff on eBay. They are so crap it's not funny, especially the slotted and dimpled ones, which may look nice but are even worse. The quality is so poor, you don't want to risk your safety and life on brakes and tires.

That being said, I did have one instance where I did have bad vibration on braking... after a poor winter wheel changeover. They didn't tighten the lug nuts properly, and when I went to inspect the wheels, one wheel was really about to fall off, it took only two or three turns before the lugs came off!!

Please retighten your wheels after driving 1-2 days after a change-over
 
I've had cheap Chinese brake drums on an older winter vehicle. On the test drive they almost took me off the road. They were new out of the box.
Buy original manufacturer. They used to be more expensive but not so much anymore.
If the problem started after the brake work that is probably the problem if they checked other components and found them to be OK.
On my Flex it turned out to be 2 of the tires had slightly shifted belts. Not easily seen but enough to act up at certain speeds and under harder braking.
New tires solved the whole problem. The originals had about 50% still left in the tread.
 
As many have said, best to bed in those new brakes and rotors easily and wait a couple of kms before doing anything else.

Lots of calipers get screwed up after winter due to the salt etc from winter but lately many have been having problems simply with the pistons within.

Hopefully it resolves. If not then maybe some new rotors again if mecahnic is sure it's not suspension(control arm, tie rods etc).

Replacing tires would be quite an expense and should be left as the last resort after alignments etc done.
 
New warped rotors are not impossible. Especially if they are the junk chinese ones as someone else mentioned. Always best to stay with OEM, orelse very high quality AM.

If you had your brakes done at a dealer, you got OEM. If you got them done at Midas, you got cheap.

Other possibilities are a loose wheel (been there done that).

Possibly a bad wheel bearing, (though they tend to make a whirring noise)

It is definitely not a pad seating issue, nor is it a requirement for anti-squeal lube (which gets applied to the back side of the pads by the way, not the edges), despite what others above have said.
 
I have news for you, the vast majority of brake disc and pads are Chinese manufactured. That is why the price today is lower than the price 25 years ago. There are high end, a wide range of middle end and low end pads and disc. The vast majority of these pads are sold dealer OEM, or at Canadian Tire. You get what you pay for. The lowest quality brake pads and disc are from small auto parts store jobber no name brands. They can not get the same quantity prices as dealer OEM or Canadian Tire so the quality is reflected in the price

The bad news is that you can get brake pads and disc ( OEM or better ) at Pepe Boys in the US at about half the price, any day of the week
 
Could be cheap parts. Many garages use the cheaper variety to get you back for more brake jobs. Water can get the rotors out of round in a hurry. If you use top quality parts, I found it made a huge difference. And someone you know putting them on.

Best brake job I ever had.... picked up the parts myself and a high school kid that was going into automotive did the work.
 
I've only ever purchased the following when needing to replace rotors ...for the driving enthusiast, and they never warp as they are put through a cryogenic treatment process. Smooth as silk when braking...awesome when braking hard:


http://www.frozenrotors.com/

Needless to say not cheap..but wtf..it's only your life at stake