Captain Semaru trial

Probably the final update before the verdict:

Military ‘failed’ to prove case, Semrau’s lawyers say


Published On Wed Jul 7 2010
Allan Woods Ottawa Bureau


GATINEAU, QUE.— Shaky recall, sloppy investigators and conflicting accounts of what happened on an Afghan battlefield almost two years ago mean an army captain should not be convicted of killing a wounded, unarmed Taliban fighter, the officer’s defence team argued Wednesday.
Charged with second degree murder for what prosecutors say was a mercy killing along a dusty path in the southern province of Helmand, Capt. Robert Semrau now waits for his fate to be decided by a four-person panel of his military superiors.
A finding of guilt will send the married father of two young children to prison and likely result in his discharge from the Canadian Forces.
But Maj. Steve Turner, Semrau’s lead counsel, argued in the court martial Wednesday that the military has been unable to prove beyond a reasonable doubt the most crucial aspects of its case, namely that Semrau fired two shots into the gravely wounded insurgent to finish him off then admitted the deed to soldiers under his command, trusted colleagues and even an Afghan National Army officer who was at the scene.
“Our defence is that the prosecution, who can decide what charges to lay and what witnesses to call, has failed in its burden of proving to you that Capt. Semrau did all of these things,” Turner said in his closing arguments.
Semrau never testified in the three months of hearings and his lawyers never called any witnesses, believing that the case against the Moose Jaw, Sask. native was fraught with flimsy evidence.
There is Pte. Steven Fournier, portrayed by the defence as an out-of-shape soldier in his first firefight, who photographed what he described as a still-breathing insurgent before the deadly shots were allegedly fired.
He testified hearing Semrau make a series of admissions to his mentoring company after the incident that forms the crux of the mercy killing theory. Other soldiers testified that they didn’t recall hearing Semrau say any such thing.
The problems don’t stop there, Turner said. There is conflicting evidence about whether the insurgent was already dead after an American Apache gunship swooped in to stop an ambush on the Canadian soldiers, or whether he was near death’s door but still breathing.
The panel should also question whether there were one, two or more shots fired from Semrau’s C8 service rifle, as witnesses had different memories of what they heard, he said.
“Everybody saw things differently that day,” Turner said, arguing that if witnesses’ recall of some crucial details was suspect, most of their testimony should be called into question.
“We can’t just throw everything into a blender and think about what it tastes like in the end. We have to be very sure of what happened to be satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt.”
The defence took particular issue with the way a top secret mission back to the scene of the alleged crime was handled. Pte. Fournier led the way, but initially took military investigators to the wrong location. They had three hours in total to search for two 5.5-millimetre shell casings Semrau is alleged to have fired and they ended the mission as soon as they were located.
There were no proper evidence bags such as would be used in a normal police investigation, pieces of metal collected from the site were measured against a bayonet rather than a ruler and more than 20 items that may have been relevant were discarded.
“How do we know that the bullets and the shell casings have anything to do with this incident?” Turner asked, noting there was no DNA evidence, no blood and no real proof the bullets ever passed through a body which itself was never recovered by investigators.
“This wasn’t something you’d see in a CSI episode. This was them doing the best they could with what they had,” Turner said.
The prosecution, which also presented its closing arguments Wednesday, and anticipated the “reasonable doubt defence,” said there are few things that can be proven with certainty, but there is a preponderance of evidence that proves Semrau was in the wrong.
That evidence includes his apologies, explanations and admission of the shooting to an Afghan army officer, soldiers under his command and a colleague back at CFB Petawawa after the murder charges were laid, the prosecution said.
Was it an act of mercy? “Perhaps,” said Lt-Col Mario Leveillee. But that is no defence in a murder case.
“Canadian soldiers … do not have the right to decide that an injured (man) should be killed. No one does,” he said.
“An unarmed combatant is no longer an enemy … This means that he should have treated this man just as he would have expected a Canadian soldier to be treated that day.”
 
There are times when I wonder what it would be like to sit in judgement - this is not one of those times. I don't relish the decision the panel has to make.
 
The "lack of proof" argument is a standard one that defence counsel use in ALL criminal trials. Sounds like the prosecution have more than enough if Fournier is believed.
 
I'm glad that the Canuck military has the stones to follow the rule of law. Most countries and most militaries don't.
 
Even if the courts martial board should find Capt. Semrau guilty, the case is automatically reviewed by an appeals panel and could be quashed at that point. I find it hard to believe that with the absence of a body, forensic evidence and reliable witnesses, the board could have any other finding then not quilty.

On the other hand, this is a military process and is fraught with chain of command meddling. If the senior commander wants him found guilty, that is what will happen with the board. Thank God for the appeals panel who will review the case, as they are held to a different standard then the jury on the board.
 
Article by Toronto criminal Lawyer Edward Prutschi (meaning he practices Criminal Law, not that he is criminal AND a lawyer.........or maybe he is!!!)

WHEN BAD LAW HAPPENS TO GOOD PEOPLE
Many of you are likely already familiar with the alleged facts in the disturbing and complicated case of Captain Robert Semrau. For those who are not, here’s a quick refresher.
Capt. Semrau was serving a tour of duty with the Canadian military in Afghanistan. He was assigned to a small Operational Mentor and Liason Team (OMLT) tasked with working hand-in-hand with a larger force of Afghani military assisting them in becoming a self-sufficient fighting force capable of challenging the Taliban militia on their own when Canada’s mission comes to a close. On Oct. 19, 2008 his orders were to troll Helmand Province for Taliban and engage with deadly force. Capt. Semrau and his team found exactly what they were looking for and were soon engaged in a firefight. Back-up was called and a pair of U.S. Apache attack choppers sprayed the area with 30mm cannon fire. Pressing forward, the solidiers came upon two of the victims of that fire. One was clearly dead. The other was described as lying in a pool of blood with a gaping hole in his back “the size of a dinner plate”, one leg pock-marked by shrapnel tenuously attached to what remained of his foot, and “a fist-sized laceration to his stomach”. The OMLT soldiers and their Afghan counterparts were still in the field with little knowledge of how many Taliban remained in the area. Medical evacuation was not available.
What happened next is the subject of great scrutiny at Capt. Semrau’s military trial on charges of murder. Prosecution witnesses differ on a number of salient points but all seem to suggest that Capt. Semrau then fired two shots at the fallen Taliban, ending what little was left of his life. These same witnesses are equally unanimous in their explanations for Capt. Semrau’s alleged actions: mercy killing.
As a criminal lawyer, a quick review of this case’s outline reveals many of the usual defences that can arise in criminal trials: no body was ever recovered leaving a serious absence of forensic evidence and witnesses appear to rely heavily on uncorroborated hearsay while conflicting with each other’s statements. However, in the unique facts of Capt. Semrau’s case, the greatest challenge faced by the prosecution may not be in proving its case beyond a reasonable doubt, but in maintaining moral legitimacy when imposing the obligatory life sentence for murder upon a decorated soldier who, if found guilty, would be responsible for an apparent mercy killing of an enemy combatant.
The lead prosecutor in the case, Lieutenant –Colonel Mario Leveillé, has been quoted as saying, “It is shockingly unacceptable and it is the type of behaviour we could not accept in Canada.” Although referring to the conduct of Capt. Semrau, one could be forgiven for thinking that the same could be said for a legal system that would sentence a soldier in these circumstances to life imprisonment.
The case has a chillingly personal dimension for me. As I have written before in this space, one of my associates is Mr. Jason Morische, who, these days, is more commonly referred to as Captain Morische. Capt. Morische is right now serving in Afghanistan in the very same capacity as Capt. Semrau was — deployed in a Canadian OMLT.
Like other scribes who have written on this tragic story, I am reminded of the sardonic words of Frances Ford Coppola’s Captain Willard in the Vietnam opus, Apocalypse Now, when he opines “Charging a man with murder in a place like this is like handing out speeding tickets at the Indy 500.” Are we asking the five-member military jury in Capt. Semrau’s case to play the proverbial speed-trap cop at an Afghani Indy 500 race? When the American helicopters opened fire on the Taliban position, their intention was clear; their goal indisputable. Kill. This goal was achieved in the case of the first insurgent and, based upon the evidence available, appears to have been well on its way to succeeding in the case of Capt. Semrau’s insurgent. Wherever one falls on the ultimate question of whether mercy killing a dying enemy in theatre constitutes murder, even those most disturbed by the alleged actions of Capt. Semrau find themselves nauseated by the thought that this 36 year old soldier could spend a minimum of ten years in a federal penitentiary awaiting his earliest parole eligibility while his two daughters grow up without him. Canadians have grown sadly accustomed to seeing young children weeping graveside as caskets draped in the maple leaf return too often from Afghanistan. Watching a once-proud father through the grill of a prison’s bars is a fate arguably worse than death. It attaches a level of opprobrium and a stench of stigma that ought never to apply to someone found guilty of the facts in this case.
Ivory tower academics and arm-chair writers (like myself) can debate for eons whether Capt. Semrau’s alleged conduct is a heinous crime, a moral failing, or a brave act of mercy towards a foe on death’s door-step. Regardless of where you fall on the question of whether ‘mercy killings’ are criminal, the lack of flexibility in the sentencing of this offence highlights important lessons that can be applied to a broader spectrum of criminal law policy.
First, recent Tory amendments whittling away at judicial discretion in sentencing by increasing the number of offences subject to mandatory minimum penalties will only create new and more tragic examples of cases where a manifestly unjust sentence is required by statute. Capt. Semrau’s case is but one example of the disproportionate effect mandatory minimums can have in mercy killing cases (the circumstances of Robert Latimer and his severely disabled daughter also come to mind).
Second, the rarely discussed spectre of jury nullification has the potential to nudge its way into the Semrau case. Simply put, jury nullification refers to the phenomenon of jurors flatly refusing to apply a law in circumstances where society’s view of criminality differs from that of our Criminal Code. The most famous example of this oft unspoken jury behaviour dates back to the numerous abortion prosecutions against Dr. Henry Morgentaler. It was undeniable on the face of the evidence that Morgentaler was brazenly and repeatedly violating Canada’s anti-abortion law (since repealed) yet jury after jury refused to register a conviction.
The dynamics of the potential for jury nullification in the Semrau case are particularly intriguing as a number of factors mingle together making it very difficult to accurately predict what may happen. In a charge of murder, the jury is painfully aware of the only sentence that can follow a guilty verdict. This adds a tremendous pressure upon the jury who cannot take comfort in thinking that their verdict will be tempered by a merciful sentence. However, it is difficult to conceive how a five-member military jury (contrasted with the normative twelve-person civilian juries) would be prepared to deviate from the letter of the law. After all, being themselves career military men and women, these jurors are deeply inculcated in a culture of precise application of orders through their chain of command. To knowingly thwart the application of a law, even where that law may run afoul of blurry concepts of justice, may well be beyond their scope.
And so, legal observers are left to watch as the trial continues. When soldiers are sent to war with orders to kill, the line between a job well done and murder can become easily obscured by the Afghan sand blowing across the valleys of Helmand Province.
 
I think his lawyers could have pursued a more aggressive defense, rather than just relying on the prosecution to be unable to prove theirs beyond a reasonable doubt, but I for one am glad that the "not guilty" to murder verdict was reached. The application of Canadian law on its citizens under normal Canadian conditions isn't an easy template to transfer onto its citizens in situations such as what the Captain was under. Hopefully their will be some consideration to this in sentencing for the disgraceful conduct decision. IMO prison time for this man would not be in the best interest of the Canadian public.

Here's my edit: It looks like I'm not the only one to think so!!!



<H2 sizset="132" sizcache="0">Mercy killings rare: ex army major-general



By BRYN WEESE, Parliamentary Bureau
Last Updated: July 19, 2010 8:35pm

  • OTTAWA - Capt. Robert Semrau's decision to put a fatally wounded Taliban fighter out of his misery after a gun battle in Afghanistan was “appropriate,” a retired army major-general says.

Such occasions do happen - albeit very rarely - and will continue regardless of Semrau's court martial.
"I think the occasions are so rare you can count them on one finger,” said Lewis MacKenzie, a 35-year veteran of the Canadian Forces who headed up the UN mission in Sarajevo during the Balkans War. “It's not something that anybody would even think about ahead of time. It's just a situation develops and then it happens. I would suggest in the nine years we've been in Afghanistan, this is probably the only one."
But MacKenzie said complicated battlefield context makes them all extremely difficult to judge - especially in a peaceful Canadian court - and they are best left unreported.
"Some people will interpret that as being cavalier. It's not,” MacKenzie said. “People have to understand the battlefield. Shit happens.
“There was a judgment call that was made at the time that, in my estimation, was appropriate, and it's taken three years to clean it up and come to a conclusion."
On Oct. 19, 2008, Semrau was part of a team of Canadian Forces mentoring members of Afghanistan's National Army when they were ambushed by Taliban insurgents.
Following an intense firefight - in which a U.S. Apache attack helicopter was called in - one of the insurgents had been shot out of a tree by helicopter cannon fire.
Court heard one of his legs had been severed at the hip, the other held together only by flesh.
He also had a gaping hole in his abdomen.
Court had also heard Semrau told fellow officers after the shooting he wanted to put the dying Taliban insurgent out of his misery.
In Monday's dramatic verdict, Semrau was found not guilty of second-degree murder, attempted murder and negligence to perform his military duty.
He was convicted of disgraceful conduct, which carries a maximum five-year prison sentence.
“I'm just hoping the mitigating circumstances mean the punishment for that will be modest to the extreme," MacKenzie said, adding he's “disappointed” the one conviction stuck.
But he warned legislators and bureaucrats not to “cover” Semrau's case with a new rule banning mercy killings. No such rule officially exists.
“Quite frankly, every incident is going to be so different,” he said. “I mean those guys are lugging around enough pages of rules of engagement now to all of a sudden insult their intelligence by saying 'We don't want you to mercy kill.'"
Semrau's sentence hearing begins Monday in Gatineau.


</H2>
 
Last edited:
"A warrior’s honour is a slender hope, but it may be all there is to
separate war from savagery. And a corollary hope is that men can
be trained to fight with honour. Armies train people to kill, but they
also teach restraint and discipline."

By the strict definition of "Duty With Honour" the Captain may not have done what he should have done. But as most of us know there are rules and then there is what you do when stuff happens.
If the Captain hadn't said anything after the fact I wonder if any of this would have been know.

BTW - Bonus points to anyone that can identify the source for the opening quote.
 
I was hoping he would beat all of the charges but given the law and the prosecution's case, I suppose this is a reasonable compromise and gives much more leeway in the sentencing guidelines.

I'm actually pleasantly surprised by this verdict as I can't imagine why the star witness would lie about it.
I would think it was a very difficult thing to do to come forward about this.
As much as I am in favour of mercy killings in some situations, the reality is that the law does not permit soldiers, or anybody else, the discretion to make these decisions.
 
Sounds like the defence did just fine. There was no real defence on the facts, just the feeling in most people that he should not have been prosecuted. The verdict sounds like the jury reached a compromise in their minds.

They did not feel that they should let him walk away, given the strength of the prosecution's case. But the did not want to send him to jail.
 
As I've posted before this prosecution should have never been approved. That said at least Captain Semrau's Counsel avoided him being convicted of murder and that is no small thing.
 
So he was found guilty on the military's favourite catch-all. The convicition may still be overturned by the appeal's panel.

Thank God I was never in Capt. Semrau's position.
 
So he was found guilty on the military's favourite catch-all. The convicition may still be overturned by the appeal's panel.

Thank God I was never in Capt. Semrau's position.

I suppose what he should have done is load the poor guy up with morphine instead...then he would have been "rendering assistance". But they should really have medivaced the guy....
 
I suppose what he should have done is load the poor guy up with morphine instead...then he would have been "rendering assistance". But they should really have medivaced the guy....

You would have needed several copters for the various body parts.

AS has been noted shit happens and occasionally shit happens to you. The guy was shot out of a tree by a 30mm rotary cannon I am surprised he was alive when he hit the ground.
 
Barring yet another delay, sentencing for the disgraceful conduct decision is to be announced later today (Oct 5th).
I've said it before, IMO prison time for this man would not be in the best interest of the Canadian public.
 
But, don't we need to send this man to hard time to demonstrate to our enemies that we are "morally superior"?

At this point he's presumed to be innocent of murder. There's no evidence he actually killed anybody. You know my opinion is that if he was found guilty of murder he should rot in jail, but he was NOT found guilty of murder.

He'll get whatever the suitable punishment is for being a disgrace.