Captain Semaru trial

Your line now is that the allies followed the GC but the germans didn't, yet the allies won the war.

You are wrong, again. The allies did what they have to do to win the war. Actually, to give credit where credit is due, the Russians destroyed more German men and material than the Western allies ever did.
 
Well... there ya have it then buttercup... This is a nut shell is my whole problem with the "rights vs responsibilities" argument. I believe in taking responsibility for ones own actions OVER an individuals rights. You do the crime... you do the time.

By all means one should take responsibility for one's actions, just as you say.

But when it's the state, or worse, aprosecutorial part of it, passing judgment that you're responsible—and you may have serious and compelling grounds to differ—then your rights should prevail. As should mine, as should everyone's. That's why we have 'em and need to assure the least deserving that their's wil be protected.
 
Prosecutorial discretion undermines the rule of law, it's a much better idea to strike down and repeal laws that you don't really want to enforce most of the time.
Fortunately so far you are in a distinct minority. Hopefully you wont be in the position of having to defend yourself straight through trial because the Crown won't drop the charges because they "don't believe in Prosecutorial discretion."

Further what you would do is leave the police in charge of prosecutions: summons or arrest anyone for anything - after all the Crown "has to prosecute them".

The risk in having charges "dealt with outside of trial" is that they may be dealt with via a little quid pro quo: Stop publishing those critical articles in your newspaper and we'll make those irritating charges go away.
.
The last time you heard of this occurring in Canada or the U.S., Fuji was when?
 
Fortunately so far you are in a distinct minority. Hopefully you wont be in the position of having to defend yourself straight through trial because the Crown won't drop the charges because they "don't believe in Prosecutorial discretion."


I will start a thread on this topic in the politics forum, as it's polluting this one.
 
You are wrong, again. The allies did what they have to do to win the war. Actually, to give credit where credit is due, the Russians destroyed more German men and material than the Western allies ever did.

You haven't disputed the point: The allies won the war while largely adhering to the Geneva Conventions. The few, exceptional cases where some rogue unit failed to adhere to the GC in some specific situation were not consequential.
 
LORD FUCK A DUCK,
I can't be bothered to read this whole thread, but pieces of it are really putting a burr under my saddle.
So a few unrelated and disjointed comments.

There are probably very few people on this board that have killed another human with the legal authority of their respective government, even fewer where it was done up close and personal.

When you go to the shit-holes of this world and see how little human life is valued, in particular your own, your concepts of right versus wrong versus survival go through a surrealistic experience that would make Dali think he was on acid.

This is a thread where the opinion of the late DQ would have been highly valued and worth reading.

Once your ass is over there (where ever the hell there is) the basics;
Rule 1: Do everything in your power so your buddy goes home alive;
Rule 2; Do everything in your power so that you do home alive;
Rule 3; Do not kill or harm an innocent, but remember this is rule 3 not 1.

If a child points an AK at you - kill it.
If a pregnant woman has an IED - kill her.

What should have been reported was;
After returning fire from enemy combatants the Captain went to check on an injured combatant.
The Captain found that the combatant was already deceased.
The Captain saw other combatants in the distance and fired two shots at them.
The Captain returned to the unit and continued to lead them on the mission.

Everyone should have got in line with the story.
Is it a lie, yup.
Is it wrong, yup.
But you back your team, end of story.

Given the chance there is no doubt that the guy who is now dead would have tried to kill every man in that unit. He's dead, they're alive, welcome to war.

This was not the "My Lai Massacre", and that was not Lt. Calley leading the unit.
 
If a child points an AK at you - kill it.
If a pregnant woman has an IED - kill her.

I don't think anyone would disagree with this.

You haven't backed up why this would be appropriate:

What should have been reported was;
After returning fire from enemy combatants the Captain went to check on an injured combatant.
The Captain found that the combatant was already deceased.
The Captain saw other combatants in the distance and fired two shots at them.
The Captain returned to the unit and continued to lead them on the mission.

What happens when Canada makes this claim and then it's revealed to be a lie? How much damage does that do to our reputation? I suspect it puts the lives of our soldiers at risk, as they will fail to gain the trust of anyone. Enemies who might have surrendered will instead choose to fight to the death, taking down more Canadian soldiers than was necessary to win.

I suspect that in general prosecuting soldiers who overstep the line maintains the discipline and order without which we have a mob instead of a military.

Given that we were able to fight WW2 with GC violations being the exception rather than the rule I fail to see why any other conflict should be any different.
 
I was a fool for posting in this thread and the multiple similar threads.

The concept of placing the life of the man next to you before your own seems to defy comprehension in gentile society.

But that ability, to be willing to die for someone else, is what drives the focus and endurance of physical extremes.

Almost no man will not stay awake for 48 hours, be cold, wet, hungry, and drive forward for their own pleasure (threesomes with some of the ladies here being an exception).

Some men will do it because mentally they know that the man next to them depends on them. His life is in their hands and they will never betray that, and they are willing to die for him.

Until that last sentence in completely ingrained in your psyche, you just won't get it. And that's o.k., you don't need to get it, someone else will, and someone else will deal with the bad people (you hope).

Just don't bitch and moan about the manner in which they killed someone when that is what they were put there to do. Find the enemy and kill them.

So continue your discussion in a free and open manner. No thought need be paid to the blood spent to allow that freedom. And if you think that the Geneva Convention is not violated on a regular basis by all armed forces of the world but simply not reported, then you live a fool's paradise and not reality.

"Good people sleep peacefully in their bed's at night because rough men stand ready to do violence on their behalf."

Done with this thread.
 
I am naive about the legality of killing enemies in the battlefield and this
a question by virtue of my ignorance.

Had we policed and investigated our soldiers in WWI and WWII
the way we do now applying similar morals and ethics how many
of them would have been charged like captain Semrau?

Canadian POWs in WWI got a very hard time from the Germans early on because they'd gotten the reputation, perhaps deserved, of being 'take no prisoners' soldiers. Investigations of alleged crimes by Germans against our troops often heard the claim that belief had inspired reprisal. And we had our own Hun atrocity stories, like the crucified seregant on the cathedral door.

But the current case has nothing really to do with such stuff from the dirty darkest side of war. Essentially, as has been said, it's a mercy killing issue, when seen one way, and a murder when seen the other.
 
You haven't disputed the point: The allies won the war while largely adhering to the Geneva Conventions.

Why do you keep beating a dead horse? Revisit your own posts (number 96 and 99) in this thread. In your own words, you said the GC was ignored in the PACIFIC and on the EASTERN FRONT. That means that over 85% of the civilian and non-civilian combatants in WW II ignored the GC and the GC was ignored on many occasions even on the Western Front. The Allies won WW II because our forebearers had the brains to ignore the GC in the PACIFIC and on the EASTERN FRONT and on the WESTERN FRONT when necessary.

Rock: Why oh why, didn't you listen to Capital Guy (post 90)?
 
The Allies won WW II because our forebearers had the brains to ignore the GC in the PACIFIC and on the EASTERN FRONT and on the WESTERN FRONT when necessary.

What a load of bull. Go read some history books why don't you? Of all the ridiculous things you've posted over the years, this one takes the cake.

Violations of the GC were not consequential to allied victory.
 
What a load of bull. Go read some history books why don't you? Of all the ridiculous things you've posted over the years, this one takes the cake.
Violations of the GC were not consequential to allied victory.

I am going to listen to Capital Guy this time. We should put his post 90 on this thread as a sticky.
 
As previously mentioned, it was a tactical decision (and IMO the right one).

Canadian soldier thought Taliban fighter was already dead, court hears
By Andrew Duffy, Ottawa CitizenApril 21, 2010

GATINEAU, Que. — The injured Taliban fighter that Capt. Robert Semrau is accused of killing had one leg blown off, another foot severed and was bleeding heavily from a wound in his torso, a court martial has heard.

Warrant Officer Merlin Longaphie was the first Canadian soldier to see the Taliban fighter, who had been shot out of a tree by a U.S. Apache helicopter on Oct. 19, 2008.

The Apache had been called in when Longaphie, and the Afghan National Army soldiers he was mentoring, came under fire during a sweep-and-clear operation in Helmand Province.

Longaphie told the court martial that he assumed the downed Taliban fighter had been the one who had ambushed them. He didn't offer the insurgent first aid because he thought he was already dead.

"I came to a quick conclusion in that I didn't observe any movement and the ANA (Afghan National Army) didn't seem to have any concerns," Longaphie testified. "My natural instinct was to say, 'This is a dead guy.'"

The prosecution must establish that the Taliban fighter Semrau is alleged to have shot and killed was still alive at the time.

Semrau, 36, of CFB Petawawa, faces four charges, including second degree murder, in connection with the incident, which prosecutors have characterized as a battlefield mercy killing.

Longaphie told the court martial that the Taliban fighter was one of four dead insurgents that he saw during the operation's chaotic first day.

The operation was led by the Afghan National Army, but included police officers, border police and small numbers of Canadian, U.S. and British soldiers.

Some of the police officers and soldiers were smoking drugs before the operation began, he said. Then, one hour into the sweep, the shooting began and continued at regular intervals for the next 12 hours, Longaphie said. Some of it was friendly fire.

Semrau's lawyer, Maj. Steve Turner, asked Longaphie if it was the most confusing operation he had ever experienced in his 25 year career.

"Up until that point, yes sir," he said.

Earlier Wednesday, Longaphie testified that he had been taught never to jeopardize the success of a mission by administering first aid on a battlefield.

Longaphie said the instructors at his advanced first aid course at CFB Petawawa stressed that in war "tactical realities" trumped all other concerns.

The instructors suggested, he said, that it was sometimes necessary to sacrifice the lives of injured combatants to ensure the success of a mission.

"I remember one of the opening statements was that the best way to administer first aid is to win the firefight," Longaphie testified.

Soldiers learned how to apply tourniquets, create an emergency airway and administer drugs for blood-clots in the seven-day course. Longaphie was part of a four-man mentoring team led by Semrau; the team was embedded with the ANA at a forward operating base west of Kandahar City.

Longaphie will be re-examined Thursday by military prosecutors.
 
Update on this case:

OTTAWA — The second-degree murder trial of a Canadian soldier will move to the scene of the alleged crime — Afghanistan — next month.
Testimony is scheduled to resume at Kandahar Airfield, where Afghan soldiers and interpreters are to give evidence about the events of Oct. 19, 2008.
Military prosecutors contend that, during an Afghan-led military operation that day in Helmand Province, Capt. Robert Semrau, 36, of Canadian Forces Base Petawawa in Ontario fired two tracer rounds into the chest of a severely wounded, disarmed Taliban insurgent.
Semrau faces four charges, including second-degree murder, in connection with what has been described as a battlefield mercy killing. Semrau has pleaded not guilty to all counts.
His general court martial, which began two months ago, has been marked by repeated delays as lawyers argue over how the unusual case should proceed.
Military prosecutors recently concluded the “Canadian” portion of their case.
The court martial will now go into hiatus as the Office of the Chief Military Judge co-ordinates the court’s move to Afghanistan.
Since the judge, court reporter, prosecutors, defence lawyers and five-member jury are military personnel, they must all be qualified to perform first aid, fire a C-8 rifle and respond to a chemical or biological attack in order to travel to Kandahar Airfield.
In Afghanistan, the court martial is expected to hear from an Afghan interpreter, known as Max, who was with Semrau, and his fire team partner, Cpl. Steven Fournier, on the day of the alleged shooting.
Military prosecutor, Capt. Tom Fitzgerald, has told court that the interpreter saw Semrau fire the second shot into the wounded Taliban fighter, who had been left to die by the Afghan National Army. The insurgent had been blasted from a tree by an Apache helicopter.
Fournier has testified that Semrau told him and the interpreter to walk away from the wounded man. After he turned to go, Fournier said, he heard two shots in quick succession and turned with his rifle raised, fearing an ambush. Fournier said he saw Semrau standing over the insurgent with his rifle pointed at his chest.
Semrau was leader of a four-man Canadian mentoring unit embedded with an Afghan rifle company.
Fournier has testified Semrau admitted to a “mercy killing” when the mentoring team gathered on the battlefield a few minutes after the shooting.
That version of events, however, has not squared with the testimony of other team members.
Former Cpl. Tony Haraszta, testified that Semrau spoke to the team that night and told them he shot the Taliban to “put him out of his misery.”
The third team member, Warrant Officer Merlin Longaphie, testified that Semrau made no such admissions any time that day.
Semrau’s lawyers have yet to present a defence in the case, but their cross-examinations have served to highlight the inconsistencies between witnesses.
The defence has also established that it would have been next-to-impossible for Semrau to call in a helicopter to remove the injured man since the area had not been secured.
​
It will also be open to the defence to argue that the Taliban fighter had already died by the time Semrau is alleged to have shot him. In a cellphone video, entered into evidence by the prosecution, the insurgent lies motionless on the ground and shows no signs of life.
There are no autopsy results in the case, since the insurgent’s body was never recovered.
The court martial has also heard that Canadian soldiers were taught that a military operation should never be compromised by the administration of first aid on a battlefield. Longaphie said his battlefield first-aid course instructors stressed that, in war, “tactical realities” trump all other concerns.
The instructors, he said, suggested it was sometimes necessary to sacrifice the lives of injured combatants to ensure the success of a mission.
​
​
​

​
 
As previously mentioned, it was a tactical decision (and IMO the right one).

The defense that the guy was already dead is a legitimate defense. You can't kill someone who is not alive, obviously. It will be up to the court to judge factual questions like that.

The notion that it was "tactical" does not sit well: Why not just leave him there? There is a big difference between "due to tactical realities we could not take him with us" and "due to tactical realities I shot a wounded prisoner".

I think if the "tactical realities" line is going to be used it's going to be necessary to show that he would have been treated no differently had he been a wounded Canadian.
 
I just noticed this thread as I was in the Dominican Republic when it was happening but I must say that this is very troubling to me.

Personally, I am all for mercy killings in some instances.
Sure this will create some grey areas for debates and trials but I don't buy the claim that it will automatically open up the flood gates for indiscriminate murders without scrutiny and repercussions.
Each case must be weighed on it's own and judged by our peers.

Unfortunately, the sad reality is that there is no discretion allowed for mercy killings in Canada at this time.
I would think that all of our soldiers know this basic law and they do not have the authority to make judgment calls which break the law without facing the consequences.

Laws do not change over night and in the mean time I think judges should have the discretion to go outside of the sentencing guidelines for some cases like Latimer and Semrau.

The judge in the Latimer case sentenced him to 1 year in prison and 1 year house arrest even though the minimum is life and 10 years for parole.
The Crown appealed and he got 10 years.

Sadly, I fear the same fate awaits Semrau but I hope that massive public outrage by a vast majority of Canadians will call for amendments which I believe our society desires and hopefully demands.

http://www2.macleans.ca/2010/05/18/a-soldiers-choice/
 
Update.....

Comrades attend court martial of Semrau, charged in shooting death of insurgent

Wed, 2010-06-16 21:03.
By: Tara Brautigam, The Canadian Press
KANDAHAR, Afghanistan - A small group of comrades from the regiment of Capt. Robert Semrau attended his court martial Wednesday at Kandahar Airfield in what his lawyer described as a show of support.
Semrau, charged in the battlefield shooting death of a wounded Afghan insurgent, chatted briefly with the soldiers from the Royal Canadian Regiment, occasionally smiling.
His second-degree murder case resumed inside a tent that has been converted into a makeshift military courtroom at the sprawling military base.
"He certainly has a lot of peers who are here at this time, so obviously he's not without supporters," Maj. Steve Turner, Semrau's lawyer, said outside court.
"The Canadian Forces are a fairly small and tight-knit crew, and pretty much all of us find friends and colleagues when we go to other bases or on deployment."
Turner said Semrau would have preferred returning to the war-torn country serving alongside his military brethren.
"Obviously the circumstances of coming back for trial are different than coming back for a deployment," Turner said. "He'd much rather be serving in a different capacity than here as the subject of this proceeding."
The court martial, which began in Canada in March, is the first in Afghanistan since the mission began in 2002.
Preparations for the case are unlike those for civilian or military trials back home. Soldiers checked their guns at the door. Court officials had to undergo training similar to that given to deployed troops, such as first aid and weapons proficiency.
The day's proceedings were dominated by procedural discussions which are the subject of a publication ban.
Semrau, 36, has pleaded not guilty to four charges, including second-degree murder, following the October 2008 fatal shooting of an injured militant in neighbouring Helmand province, west of Kandahar. No body was ever recovered.
Semrau was part of a four-member Operation Mentor Liaison Team assigned to an Afghan National Army company while on a foot patrol when they encountered a series of ambushes and called in an Apache helicopter strike.
The company soon came across a badly injured insurgent, whom the ANA soldiers disarmed and began verbally and physically abusing, including kicking sand and spitting on him, according to military court testimony.
The ANA commander allegedly said medical care would not be provided, leaving Semrau's team to make a decision. They agreed not to call in an evacuation helicopter, although such support was available through the British, the court has heard.
Soon after, a second insurgent was found about 50 metres away, already dead. It was decided to photograph the two insurgents, because they were unidentified and the intelligence could prove worthwhile.
Semrau and an interpreter nicknamed Max returned to the injured man. Another soldier, Cpl. Steven Fournier, took photos. Semrau allegedly then told the other two to "turn around" and that "you do not or should not have to see this."
The prosecution has said Max, who is scheduled to take the witness stand in Kandahar, will testify that he heard two distinct shots and turned around in time to see Semrau firing the second shot, the barrel of his assault rifle pointed at the wounded man.
The defence has not put forth its case as it's not obliged to, according to court martial rules.
Semrau wasn't charged until two months after the incident as details began leaking out, the court has heard. A military team went back to Helmand province and found two .56 mm shell casings, but no body.
Semrau had a previously spotless record in stints with both the British and Canadian Forces and is based at Canadian Forces Base Petawawa.
The case continues Thursday.