Boy Drowned On School Outing

You know for a fact all the kids were wearing PFD's,...???

I don't have the fantastical imagination you have so I base it solely on what's been reported. And yes. At least one kid was repeatedly in the news stating that he was swimming at the same time with a PFD.



...The parents,...especially the ones in this case,...expected the teachers to be responsible for their kids safety,...but as has been posted here numerous times,...we shouldn't have expected that.
Would you send your kid on a canoe trip if you knew he couldn't swim?
 
You know for a fact all the kids were wearing PFD's,...???

So the teachers and TDSB only have a "legal" responsibility,...wow,...does explain the attitude of teachers though.

The parents,...especially the ones in this case,...expected the teachers to be responsible for their kids safety,...but as has been posted here numerous times,...we shouldn't have expected that.

giphy.gif


He didn't say all kids were wearing PFDs. I can't find quotes to support how many were/weren't wearing one.

He also didn't say that TDSB and its teachers ONLY have legal responsibilities here.

You seem to suggest that this "attitude", which in this case appears to be one of negligence if not gross negligence, is the attitude of "teachers" towards the duty of care expected of them when acting in their role(s) as teachers. I feel if this were the case, that this type of tragedy would be more frequently reported. There were over 2 million students enrolled in Ontario schools last year, and to my knowledge this is the only death under investigation. But I could be wrong...

In no way am I trying to shift all of the deserved blame here away from this teacher/these teachers, but suggesting that the 120,000 "teachers" in this province are as irresponsible as those being investigated here is utter nonsense. I don't have a ton of love for teachers, but that's ridiculous.

Just to clarify, I don't think the one or two teachers here are blameless, they're going down and very likely deserve it.

When I was in high school, a 15 year old student in our school died on a school ski trip. I know it would be different expectations around the level of direct teacher supervision on that ski trip compared to this canoe trip, but I assume the poor parents of the ski accident kid, like the swimming accident kid, "expected" a level of safety that was impossible to guarantee.

Skiing, and swimming, are inherently dangerous activities without adequate training and/or equipment (the ski accident happened before helmets were a thing). You can make it more safe for yourself as a 15 year old by sticking to bunny hills as was recommended by the instructor who administered the ski test, or wearing the PFD this 15 year old student was provided with. Or you can make it very unsafe for yourself by forgetting/ignoring the instruction. But assuming/expecting that just because your kid is on a trip supervised by a teacher that their safety in the water is somehow guaranteed, is a bit daft.

Did the parents know he couldn't swim? I'd be a bit surprised if they were totally unaware. This seems like something that as a parent you'd ordinarily know. The new TDSB policy will solve this potential pitfall if the parents were indeed (somehow) totally blissfully unaware of their child's competency in the water and the dangers this might create on a canoe trip.

I personally don't think I'd be comfortable sending my (hypothetical) 15 year old child on a trip like this if I had ANY concerns over his safety in terms of ability to self-rescue in the water. And if I couldn't see the dangers of not being able to swim and how this could potentially play out in an emergency situation on a canoe trip, I feel I'd deserve at-least some of the blame myself as a parent for choosing to sign the waivers and permission slips that ultimately led to the tragedy.

And as stated before, this wasn't a 4 year old who jumped into a part of the pool they shouldn't have, this was a 15 year old. They may not be legally responsible as an adult by that age in this country, but he made some very poor choices that day, IMHO was old enough to think for himself, and absolutely deserves some of the blame.

...Unless of course you think 15 year olds shouldn't be in any way responsible for their actions... Based on previous posts, I'm pretty sure that you (FAST) believe the opposite.

It appears based on the recent articles that TDSB and the principal will be justifiably targeted for some of the blame here as well.

I'm glad to see that TDSB and the Ministry are re-evaluating these policies. It doesn't hurt to be overly cautious when it comes to water safety, and maybe this is the wake up call the MOE needed. Tragically late, but better late than never.
 
I don't have the fantastical imagination you have so I base it solely on what's been reported. And yes. At least one kid was repeatedly in the news stating that he was swimming at the same time with a PFD.

WOW,...one kid,...
And I did NOT state how many kids were wearing PFDs, or were not...that's you assuming.



Would you send your kid on a canoe trip if you knew he couldn't swim?

Believe it or not basketcase,...there was other activities besides canoeing.

And you keep on ignoring the fact that this was an immigrant family thinking that things like this would be handled somewhat better than some third world country,...little did they know our education system is staffed by irresponsible civil servants.

And a few other parents of non swimmers thought the same way.

And now we hear that the TDSB and the Ministry are re-evaluating these policies,...there was nothing wrong with the current policies,...people just had to do their fricken jobs.,...and over their god complex.
 
again you didn't read the article .... he drowned in the afternoon sometime. it was not until everyone got out of the water and gathered with the teachers that they noticed he was missing. quit trolling. lol
Read the article? I must remind you that Trump is the President.... it is now ok to not read the article and just make stuff up...isn't it?
 
little did they know our education system is staffed by irresponsible civil servants.

Little did they know, consenting to their 15 year old boy's attendance on a canoe trip, would put him at risk of drowning if the 15 year old didn't wear his provided PFD in and around the water, since he can't swim and water causes drowning for non-swimmers.

As I hinted at above, Omar Khadr was 15 when he was captured. Remind me, how responsible are 15 year olds for their own actions?

And now we hear that the TDSB and the Ministry are re-evaluating these policies,...there was nothing wrong with the current policies,...people just had to do their fricken jobs.,...and over their god complex.

We don't even know if the teachers are responsible, as they have intelligently declined to comment, and TDSS has only said they're on leave (they haven't said it's disciplinary). I'm not saying they aren't in any way responsible or liable, but if they weren't certified NLS, they wouldn't be responsible for supervision during the swim. For all we know it was the non-teacher trippers who were the certified lifeguards on duty.

Regardless, the policies very clearly need to change. If TDSB had a functional set of safety protocols for canoe trips, or any activity involving open water, this very likely wouldn't have happened. This teacher (or these teachers) seemed to do enough stupid things leading up to the actual drowning that the principal should have had at-least a passing interest in oversight. Since it's his job.

Personally, even when I was in lifeguard shape, I would have declined supervising 15 (or 17) non-swimmers, and 15 swimmers in a healthy Algonquin lake deeper than 4 feet. This was VERY dangerous, and no one person is necessarily to blame. Even with 2 sets of trained and responsible eyes on the activity, if a kid jumped into a lake and sank without surface panic, they're probably going to die. You would have had to somehow have eyes on him at the exact moment he hit the water and kept eyes on him after he didn't surface. There were up to 17 other kids that need that same attention simultaneously. I'm most surprised that this hasn't happened before.

Many things went wrong here. But if a kid doesn't meet minimum requirements to do an activity safely, they shouldn't be able to participate. Bottom-line.

Particularly if the activity is completely extracurricular.
 
I agree with you on everything your saying . Everyone is to blame in this situation...

The boy is to blame if he wasn't wearing a PDF ( however from reading the article sounds like every student was). In this case he should have known not to go on the trip if he couldn't swim.
The teachers are to blame because they should have been watching more carefully and hired more supervisors to help assist them with the amount of students on the trip.
The parents are to blame because like previous posts have stated it is impossible they wouldn't know such a thing.
The board/ school is to blame because they say they conducted a swim test before going on the trip which fifteen of those thirty students failed which means they risked fifteen students drowning. In this case only one of them drowned but could you imagine if it was more than one? That would be even more devastating. The board should have not allowed those students to attend the trip at all . Don't pass swim test = Don't go on trip. That simple. Just like if you cant ski you don't go on ski trips. Its self explanatory.

Obviously there was something wrong with the board policies if they allowed the students that failed to go on the trip. When parents sign permission forms they are trusting that the school is going to bring their kids back safely and have the proper procedures in place to do just that. Again that wasn't the outcome in this case. A student died on SCHOOL TIME . Which means they are absolutely responsible. With that being said I am sure that if this goes to court many people are going to be facing the consequences and it isn't going to pretty.

The teachers who were supposed to be "supervising" are probably going to be fired for having their family on the trip which as we know can be a MAJOR distraction. There is no reason to EVER bring your family on a trip even if the school says its ok for whatever reason. To me totally unacceptable and outrageous behavior on the schools part.

I guess we will just have to wait and see how it all plays out..
Little did they know, consenting to their 15 year old boy's attendance on a canoe trip, would put him at risk of drowning if the 15 year old didn't wear his provided PFD in and around the water, since he can't swim and water causes drowning for non-swimmers.

As I hinted at above, Omar Khadr was 15 when he was captured. Remind me, how responsible are 15 year olds for their own actions?



We don't even know if the teachers are responsible, as they have intelligently declined to comment, and TDSS has only said they're on leave (they haven't said it's disciplinary). I'm not saying they aren't in any way responsible or liable, but if they weren't certified NLS, they wouldn't be responsible for supervision during the swim. For all we know it was the non-teacher trippers who were the certified lifeguards on duty.

Regardless, the policies very clearly need to change. If TDSB had a functional set of safety protocols for canoe trips, or any activity involving open water, this very likely wouldn't have happened. This teacher (or these teachers) seemed to do enough stupid things leading up to the actual drowning that the principal should have had at-least a passing interest in oversight. Since it's his job.

Personally, even when I was in lifeguard shape, I would have declined supervising 15 (or 17) non-swimmers, and 15 swimmers in a healthy Algonquin lake deeper than 4 feet. This was VERY dangerous, and no one person is necessarily to blame. Even with 2 sets of trained and responsible eyes on the activity, if a kid jumped into a lake and sank without surface panic, they're probably going to die. You would have had to somehow have eyes on him at the exact moment he hit the water and kept eyes on him after he didn't surface. There were up to 17 other kids that need that same attention simultaneously. I'm most surprised that this hasn't happened before.

Many things went wrong here. But if a kid doesn't meet minimum requirements to do an activity safely, they shouldn't be able to participate. Bottom-line.

Particularly if the activity is completely extracurricular.
 
Everyone is to blame in this situation...

The organizers, teachers and school board are the ones holding themselves out as the experts on this trip, the students and parents know little or nothing about canoe trips to northern Canada and were relying on the organizers expertise. Whoever overlooked the swimming test failures is screwed. Will be interesting to see if there were other tests like endurance and health with overlooked failures.
 
WOW,...one kid,...


You really like just being a troll. I stated other kids were wearing PFDs and we have evidence that other kids were wearing PFDs. But you just want to argue.

And as I said before, Ayn Rand would shed tears at you attempts to deny personal responsibility and place it all on the nanny state.
 
The organizers, teachers and school board are the ones holding themselves out as the experts on this trip, the students and parents know little or nothing about canoe trips to northern Canada and were relying on the organizers expertise. Whoever overlooked the swimming test failures is screwed. Will be interesting to see if there were other tests like endurance and health with overlooked failures.

I asked a friend today whose daughter went on a grade 11 outdoor education trip last year. His daughter doesn't attend a Toronto school.

He said there was at-least 1 parents information session at his daughter's school before parents were expected to sign what ended up being very clear permission forms. He also received a pretty extensive information packet. He remembers there was more than 1 information session offered but he only attended the one. He's new here, from mainland China, his English is still pretty weak and was very concerned about the trip as a parent. He said the session was before the swim testing. He didn't remember finding out if she passed or failed the swim test, but did get a persmission slip which he assumed was only sent home with kids who passed the test.

He also said it was pretty expensive, like $350 or $400, but I remember reading it was free at CW Jeffries.

At both schools, participation on the trip is totally extracurricular (not for course credit) and occurred outside of regular school time. Not that it matters, but the teachers would also be volunteering their time.

---

This is tragic, but if you actually don't want kids to drown on canoe trips:
a) Cancel all canoe trips, which I think would be pretty sad.

b) Prevent kids from participating on a trip like this who can't swim. Which I think is a MOE or even OHRC thing, since everyone has a right to participate on trips offered through a school.

or
c) Teach all kids to swim.

I doubt anyone here thinks teachers, let alone this teacher/these teachers, never make mistakes or act negligently towards their jobs. If this happened once, it can happen again regardless of the policy changes around paperwork tracking.

---

I'm obviously struggling to agree with anyone who thinks the 15 year old victim and his parents bear little to no responsibility for what happened here.
 
The parents of students at C.W. Jeffrey(sp) don't have money. Taxpayer money funded the outing.

Good. I'm glad that less affluent and especially those new to the country have the chance to learn about and enjoy what Canada has to offer.
 
BLM is to blame. It the school said no BLDM would have protested shut down the entire park. It was best the school let the kid go on a canoe trip and hope he didn't encounter any deep lakes and drown. The lakes in the park are only 100' feet deep at most. Rapids are fast enough that if you fall in you will only be pulled under for a few minutes - young people can easily hold their breath for 10 minutes.
 
OPP has opened a criminal investigation.

What for,...it was the parents and the dead kids fault,...???

OH wait,...maybe they ARE charging the parents and the dead kid,...got to put blame were it belongs.

And maybe all 15 kids who failed the swimming test,...because it can't be possibly the responsibility of the TDSB and teachers.
 
Mother says she felt pressured to send daughter on trip where Toronto student died
https://www.theglobeandmail.com/new...after-toronto-students-death/article36013059/

A mother says she felt pressured by a teacher at a Toronto school to send her daughter, who cannot swim, on a camping trip ... she knew vaguely about the trip and what it would entail. ... “They never told her [my daughter] if she failed or passed, but she knew she failed, because when she was in the water, she didn’t do anything.

Teachers were excited to see the trip happen, but the parents and students showed little interest in learning about and preparing for this trip.
 
Mother says she felt pressured to send daughter on trip where Toronto student died
https://www.theglobeandmail.com/new...after-toronto-students-death/article36013059/

A mother says she felt pressured by a teacher at a Toronto school to send her daughter, who cannot swim, on a camping trip ... she knew vaguely about the trip and what it would entail. ... “They never told her [my daughter] if she failed or passed, but she knew she failed, because when she was in the water, she didn’t do anything.

Teachers were excited to see the trip happen, but the parents and students showed little interest in learning about and preparing for this trip.

Thanks for the link.

The teachers are on home assignment, which is a clarification from the Star article.

I'm confused how this could be a credit bearing trip.

Regardless, I'm not convinced by what Ms. De Freitas said:

"I'm really disappointed in the school, and I feel we were deceived as parents because I know my kid couldn't swim," Ms. De Freitas said. "Had I known that it was one of the requirements, my kid would have not been on that trip, I guarantee that, 100 per cent."

So, you know your kid couldn't swim, but didn't know that might be a requirement on a canoe trip?

I mean, you don't necessarily need to know how to portage or what a j-stroke is to know that a canoe trip would probably require your non-swimming child to be exposed to water in some way. If she was confused by any of it, simple Google searches like "canoe" or "Algonquin" would have effectively countered the teacher's 'deception' in an absolute way. Canoeing, almost without exception, happens in and around water.

How pressured could she have been? It's a teacher... I didn't listen to them when I was a teenager...

Ignoring whether or not schools should allow students without prerequisite skills to ensure their own safety on a trip like this, a huge part of the Perry tragedy still goes back to improper use of prescribed safety equipment.

If De Freitas' daughter made good choices, she would have worn her lifejacket at all times while in, on or around water. As a result, her risk of drowning would be almost nonexistent.

So was De Freitas' daughter just lucky that the teacher(s) negligence in letting her on the trip didn't cause her to drown? Or did De Freitas' 15-year-old daughter survive this trip because she, like the other 13 non-swimmers who survived this trip, took reasonable and adequate precautions to ensure her own safety when in and around water, like wearing a PFD.

I wasn't there, but I'd bet a testicle that the swimming activity that Perry drowned during was optional for the kids. Perry chose to go swimming, and chose to go swimming without a PFD. Two major safety risks a 15 year old with limited swimming skills is old enough to have made his own decisions on.

At 15, when I made a poor decision, it wasn't teacher or parent that got in trouble for my mistake.
 
The parents of students at C.W. Jeffrey(sp) don't have money. Taxpayer money funded the outing.

why shouldnt poor schools get more funding?

what is wrong with giving kids life experiences?

can you prove that fund raising and donations were absent?

did you know all school have some money in their budget for discretionary items and or activies?
 
LMAO...really, LMAO.

see if you can get a hold of a copy of the monthly publication Professionally Speaking you'll find teachers getting fired every month for reasons ranging from improper handling of IEPs to theft to inappropriate comments to physically discipling kids and of course sex charges..... if they are responsible for the drowning they will be fired too


you cant teach with a criminal record so depending on hiw this plays out

i just googled back issues are available online for you to read the disciplanary stuff is near the back of each issue
 
were the teachers aware that the boy took off his pfd?

To me the key is what did the teacher know?

I mean if a kid losses their eye in shop class because they werent wearing glasses the teacher i not automatically responsible because there are instances when a kid could remove glasses without the teachers knowledge.