You know for a fact all the kids were wearing PFD's,...???
So the teachers and TDSB only have a "legal" responsibility,...wow,...does explain the attitude of teachers though.
The parents,...especially the ones in this case,...expected the teachers to be responsible for their kids safety,...but as has been posted here numerous times,...we shouldn't have expected that.
He didn't say all kids were wearing PFDs. I can't find quotes to support how many were/weren't wearing one.
He also didn't say that TDSB and its teachers ONLY have legal responsibilities here.
You seem to suggest that this "attitude", which in this case appears to be one of negligence if not gross negligence, is the attitude of "teachers" towards the duty of care expected of them when acting in their role(s) as teachers. I feel if this were the case, that this type of tragedy would be more frequently reported. There were over 2 million students enrolled in Ontario schools last year, and to my knowledge this is the only death under investigation. But I could be wrong...
In no way am I trying to shift all of the deserved blame here away from this teacher/these teachers, but suggesting that the 120,000 "teachers" in this province are as irresponsible as those being investigated here is utter nonsense. I don't have a ton of love for teachers, but that's ridiculous.
Just to clarify, I don't think the one or two teachers here are blameless, they're going down and very likely deserve it.
When I was in high school, a 15 year old student in our school died on a school ski trip. I know it would be different expectations around the level of direct teacher supervision on that ski trip compared to this canoe trip, but I assume the poor parents of the ski accident kid, like the swimming accident kid, "expected" a level of safety that was impossible to guarantee.
Skiing, and swimming, are inherently dangerous activities without adequate training and/or equipment (the ski accident happened before helmets were a thing). You can make it more safe for yourself as a 15 year old by sticking to bunny hills as was recommended by the instructor who administered the ski test, or wearing the PFD this 15 year old student was provided with. Or you can make it very unsafe for yourself by forgetting/ignoring the instruction. But assuming/expecting that just because your kid is on a trip supervised by a teacher that their safety in the water is somehow guaranteed, is a bit daft.
Did the parents know he couldn't swim? I'd be a bit surprised if they were totally unaware. This seems like something that as a parent you'd ordinarily know. The new TDSB policy will solve this potential pitfall if the parents were indeed (somehow) totally blissfully unaware of their child's competency in the water and the dangers this might create on a canoe trip.
I personally don't think I'd be comfortable sending my (hypothetical) 15 year old child on a trip like this if I had ANY concerns over his safety in terms of ability to self-rescue in the water. And if I couldn't see the dangers of not being able to swim and how this could potentially play out in an emergency situation on a canoe trip, I feel I'd deserve at-least some of the blame myself as a parent for choosing to sign the waivers and permission slips that ultimately led to the tragedy.
And as stated before, this wasn't a 4 year old who jumped into a part of the pool they shouldn't have, this was a 15 year old. They may not be legally responsible as an adult by that age in this country, but he made some very poor choices that day, IMHO was old enough to think for himself, and absolutely deserves some of the blame.
...Unless of course you think 15 year olds shouldn't be in any way responsible for their actions... Based on previous posts, I'm pretty sure that you (FAST) believe the opposite.
It appears based on the recent articles that TDSB and the principal will be justifiably targeted for some of the blame here as well.
I'm glad to see that TDSB and the Ministry are re-evaluating these policies. It doesn't hurt to be overly cautious when it comes to water safety, and maybe this is the wake up call the MOE needed. Tragically late, but better late than never.