Blue Jays 2020

I do wanna say in Shitkin's defense, very few marquee pitchers will wanna come to Toronto if they feel we wont be a contending team for the next 2 to 3 years. So its not easy convincing guys like Keuchel or Hyun-jin Ryu to come here, regardless of how much money you throw at them
 
Then Shack I really don't know what your complaining about. Your always griping that the don't spend money. What do you want them to do? Throw big money at guys like Justin Smoak??

P.S, the reasonable time frame is the next two years. If these kids get off to a hot start, don't be surprised to see this administration get super aggressive at the trade dead line.


Like I don't know why your so against these guys. You realize this team had shitty GM's for 21 years before them right?? If you want to deduct AA's years from there, that's fine, but he didn't accomplish anything until his 5th year, when he was on the final year of his contract and went all in to save his ass and look good.


At least these guys have been somewhat clear with their plan (if you can read between the lines, which apparently most people can't) and if it works it works. If it doesn't, they'll be out.
I am complaining that the team is not getting better other than by possibly miniscule increments this off season. The record has worsened on a yearly basis. They have cleared the payroll. They talk about financial flexibility but are not using it. They said they were going to explore all possibilities from the most expensive to the cheapest. They said that, not I. Well, we know what they have done so far.

Why can't they pick up a piece here or a piece there that are solid players and sign them for 5 years. Even if you are willing to wait 8 years for the regime, they will still be here for when the time is right. The way I read you they should do nothing significant until the time is "right". What then, sign 10 free agents all at once?

A contender does not happen overnight. It takes some time. Please tell me what they have done acquisition wise to start building a contender, other than bring up a solid core of 4-6 players and wait for them to all mature to their potential. There are 20 more positions to fill. The outfield is weak both offensively and defensively. Rotation and bullpen are mediocre at best but probably worse. The infield has offensive potential (!st base is weak), but the defense is suspect. There is insufficient power at first base. Is all that going to get addressed in one fell swoop? Or is 8 or 9 years reasonable for an experienced executive of the year who has a rich owner and a huge fan base. "Toto, I don't think we're in Cleveland anymore."

As for AA he was a young pup and a rookie. He made big splashes every year and once he got more experience, he got us a 2 time playoff team. He was coveted enough by the Dodgers to be part of their team, and after a short while was coveted by at least the Braves, where they have made the playoffs both years under him. Notice that he inherited a respectable team but he built on it and didn't fuck it up. shapeero inherited a very serious contender, did nothing to improve it, and even if the minor league roster was weak, he mismanaged the significant assets he had here. He did not capitalize on the stars that were here. AA has outperformed shappero to this point, both on the field and getting asses in the seats for for Rogers, and generating enthusiasm (which translates to revenue) with the fan base. shapeero has lost most of the goodwill that AA developed. You cannot deny that.

BTW, Smoak is a journeyman with a career .230 average, good glove, inconsistent pop. Never been a fan.

OK, maybe there is still time this off-season to put a couple of good players in place for more than 2 years, and maybe you are right that they will make big moves at the deadline. BTW, what assets do they have to dangle to get contender worthy players, who can help now. It is too late for prospects and wait another 3 years for them to develop. And how many of these assets are there to make several mid-long term acquisitions. You say 2 more years is reasonable. How are they going to get 15-20 contending worthy players at the trade deadline and next off-season, because this off-season is slipping away. That is a huge task and seeing as their feet are going to be at the fire, management cannot afford to make a mistake with any of them.

Have you had a chance to find those posts about "all us guys" clamoring for Strasburg and Cole, or is that just hyperbole on your part, which if that's the case, detracts from your argument.

Waiting for George to rip me a new one, but aside from some impatience, I think there is reasonable merit to my points.
 
Justin Smoak signs with the Milwaukee Brewers.
Smoak will receive $4 million for 2020 with a team option for $5.5 million in 2021 that includes a $1 million buyout.
Which is apparently the going rate for a journeyman.
By the by, Justin Smoak had an on base percentage in 2019 of .342
Vlad Jr.'s OBP was .339
Gleyber Torres .337
Manny Machado .334
Jose Abreu .330
Mike Moustakas .329

Damn fine defensive 1st baseman as well, but okay.
 
Loved watching Smoak play first base. The Jays visit Milwaukee in 2020, but I don't think they come here. Too bad.
 
Then Shack I really don't know what your complaining about. Your always griping that the don't spend money. What do you want them to do? Throw big money at guys like Justin Smoak??

Who suggested throwing coin at Smoak?

If these kids get off to a hot start, don't be surprised to see this administration get super aggressive at the trade dead line.

The "kids" can get off to a great start, but if the pitching is shit, their numbers mean nothing. We will sit and look at the stats and say man, these kids are killing it...and we are 32 and 40...if only we had pitching. And at that moment, the trade deadline means fuck all.

BBL, I admire your optimism and support of Shakins, I just wish I shared it as much as you do.
 
Justin Smoak signs with the Milwaukee Brewers.
Smoak will receive $4 million for 2020 with a team option for $5.5 million in 2021 that includes a $1 million buyout.
Which is apparently the going rate for a journeyman.
By the by, Justin Smoak had an on base percentage in 2019 of .342
Vlad Jr.'s OBP was .339
Gleyber Torres .337
Manny Machado .334
Jose Abreu .330
Mike Moustakas .329

Damn fine defensive 1st baseman as well, but okay.

Defensively one of the best 1st basemen playing the game today, switch hitter, excellent team player, all around good guy. Hope he does well with the Brewers!
 
Defensively one of the best 1st basemen playing the game today, switch hitter, excellent team player, all around good guy. Hope he does well with the Brewers!

This.
All of this.
 
Who suggested throwing coin at Smoak?



The "kids" can get off to a great start, but if the pitching is shit, their numbers mean nothing. We will sit and look at the stats and say man, these kids are killing it...and we are 32 and 40...if only we had pitching. And at that moment, the trade deadline means fuck all.

BBL, I admire your optimism and support of Shakins, I just wish I shared it as much as you do.


It's not that I'm optimistic, I'm simply telling what there plan is, and where they're at with it. They'll have about an extra 100 million or more per year to spend over the next 12-24 months. Lets hope they spend it right.
 
Who suggested throwing coin at Smoak?



The "kids" can get off to a great start, but if the pitching is shit, their numbers mean nothing. We will sit and look at the stats and say man, these kids are killing it...and we are 32 and 40...if only we had pitching. And at that moment, the trade deadline means fuck all.
.

No it doesn't at all..lol, and they don't have to wait until the trade deadline.
 
https://www.sportsnet.ca/baseball/mlb/tao-stieb-notable-addition-help-blue-jays-fans-believe/

This is simply an opinion of a single reporter/analyst. He may be right. He may be wrong. But he is voicing the sentiment of a segment of the Jays' fan base and admittedly much more measured and eloquent than my rants. LOL

This is a line right at the end:

This is likely an argument for why teams shouldn't wait until the perfect moment to begin adding substantively all at once when they are "ready", and why they should always be looking to make their team better.
 
Defensively one of the best 1st basemen playing the game today, switch hitter, excellent team player, all around good guy. Hope he does well with the Brewers!
Can't argue with any of that.

But his OPS of .748 in 2019 ranked him 17th among 1st basemen in just the AL. Rowdy Tellez was 18th at .742. !B is one of the premier power positions and despite his defense and other qualities Smoak's performance at the plate was not good enough.
 
Can't argue with any of that.

But his OPS of .748 in 2019 ranked him 17th among 1st basemen in just the AL. Rowdy Tellez was 18th at .742. !B is one of the premier power positions and despite his defense and other qualities Smoak's performance at the plate was not good enough.

Wasn't suggesting they should resign just pointing out his good points. As far his bat went, it wasn't what you expect or want from a first baseman, but he had no protection in the line up either and it was easy to pitch around him. Brewers might be a real good fit for him.
 
Wasn't suggesting they should resign just pointing out his good points. As far his bat went, it wasn't what you expect or want from a first baseman, but he had no protection in the line up either and it was easy to pitch around him. Brewers might be a real good fit for him.

I understood your post. Aside from one very good half season (his all-star year), I was never overly impressed and stated so. I think some other people were overstating his contributions.
 
I understood your post. Aside from one very good half season (his all-star year), I was never overly impressed and stated so. I think some other people were overstating his contribution.
By Blue Jays standards he was adequate though.

By big market team standards he would be a very useful bench player/switch hitter ;)