Blue Jays 2020

https://www.msn.com/en-ca/sports/ml...ted-in-ryu-keuchel/ar-BBXJiYN?ocid=spartanntp

Jays say they are interested in a couple of significant names, Ryu (ERA leader) and Keuchel. Are the Jays actually serious and sign a reasonably big name or two or do they let them all slide by and stick to their approach of the last 4 years which is pick up scrap heaps for cheap. If they are serious, then they will have to overpay. Or they can use that as an excuse to not sign. The Jays always have and will always have to overpay due to geography.

Actions (or lack thereof) will speak.
 
Last edited:
For who keep criticizing the moves Atkins keeps making, so far not one has really been bad. Aaron Sanchez non-tenerded by Houston.
 
For who keep criticizing the moves Atkins keeps making, so far not one has really been bad. Aaron Sanchez non-tenerded by Houston.

Do you think a decreasing win/loss record every single year from the 91-71 team they inherited to 67-95 last year shows that he is doing a good job by (arguably) not making bad trades? We should be thankful that their record wasn't worse?
 
In today's Star, Gregor Chisolm talks about Jays' lack of moves regarding their rotation.

https://www.thestar.com/sports/blue...-blue-jays-have-yet-to-make-a-major-move.html

It’s not immediately clear how deep into negotiations Toronto got with Wheeler, or whether a formal offer was made, but the result is another ideal fit who is no longer an option. The same situation applied earlier this off-season when Jake Odorizzi accepted Minnesota’s qualifying offer and Kyle Gibson signed a three-year deal with the Rangers.

Outside of trading for Chase Anderson, the Jays haven’t done anything to address their rotation needs. With guys like Dallas Keuchel, Hyun-Jin Ryu and Madison Bumgarner still available, all it will take is one phone call and a big cheque to alter the direction of this off-season. But the fan base should be forgiven if it’s feeling a bit skeptical, even as the front office maintains a positive front.]

Nobody should be questioning the desire to add talent but negotiating a deal and putting pen to paper are two very different things. This market has grown tired of hearing the Jays were close to adding someone who signed elsewhere. As Josh Donaldson once infamously said: “This isn’t the try league. This is the get-it-done league.” Fans want to see tangible results in free agency to complement what everyone agrees is a strong core of young position players.

A lot of organizations are looking for pitching, and with only so many guys to go around, at least a couple will be left on the outside looking in. Toronto might be one of them.
 
Do you think a decreasing win/loss record every single year from the 91-71 team they inherited to 67-95 last year shows that he is doing a good job by (arguably) not making bad trades? We should be thankful that their record wasn't worse?


yes I do.
 
Do you think a decreasing win/loss record every single year from the 91-71 team they inherited to 67-95 last year shows that he is doing a good job by (arguably) not making bad trades? We should be thankful that their record wasn't worse?

Yes.
 
Jays have to sign at least one ace starting pitcher who's a free aqent this winter.

If they dont we'll know they're not being serous about rebuilding
 
Jays have to sign at least one ace starting pitcher who's a free aqent this winter.

If they dont we'll know they're not being serous about rebuilding

But a #3 starter on most teams would be an "ace" with our rotation. Or are you talking about a legitimate ace.
 
Not yet. The time line still isn't right.

So they need to time acquisitions at exactly when they are ready to break out? How do we know when exactly that is. How do we know that the pieces they require will be available at that time?

If they are only, say, about 2 years away from competing, why not acquire a couple of needed pieces now and have them signed for 5 or 6 years? What if the core breaks out sooner than expected? Or do we sign 5 or 6 guys all at one time as you seem to be implying.
 
So they need to time acquisitions at exactly when they are ready to break out? How do we know when exactly that is. How do we know that the pieces they require will be available at that time?

If they are only, say, about 2 years away from competing, why not acquire a couple of needed pieces now and have them signed for 5 or 6 years? What if the core breaks out sooner than expected? Or do we sign 5 or 6 guys all at one time as you seem to be implying.

They are trying to create the biggest window they can where they can compete at a price within their budget. Signing a big FA right now could be a huge waste as the young core needs a bit more time. There are always moves that can be made at the trade deadline or when it's clear a few big FA will put them over the top. Right now it's not clear.
 
They are trying to create the biggest window they can where they can compete at a price within their budget. Signing a big FA right now could be a huge waste as the young core needs a bit more time
How do you know our youngsters (Biggio, Vlad, Gurriel, Bo, Jansen.....etc) wont have breakout years in 2020??

So they need to time acquisitions at exactly when they are ready to break out? How do we know when exactly that is. How do we know that the pieces they require will be available at that time?

If they are only, say, about 2 years away from competing, why not acquire a couple of needed pieces now and have them signed for 5 or 6 years? What if the core breaks out sooner than expected?
Exactly!